Synchronous bilateral Wilm's tumor with complete radiographic response managed without surgical resection: a report from the National Wilm's Tumor Study 4

Unwrapping Nephrogenic Rests and Nephroblastomatosis for Pediatric Surgeons: A Systematic Review Utilizing the PICO Model by the APSA Cancer Committee

BACKGROUND

Nephrogenic rests (NR) may represent precursor lesions for Wilms tumor (WT), but their clinical course is not fully understood and no guidelines for treatment exist. This study sought to evaluate the outcomes of pediatric patients with NRs related to traditional chemotherapy and surgery.

METHODS

A PRISMA-P-compliant literature search was conducted in MEDLINE, Embase, CINAHL, Web of Science, COCHRANE, and SCOPUS from inception to June 2021. Clinical questions regarding the treatment of NRs, including chemotherapy and surgery, were developed in the population, intervention, comparison, and outcome format.

RESULTS

Twenty-five studies including 1445 patients met inclusion criteria for evaluating chemotherapy compared to observation for NRs. Eighteen studies including 1392 patients met inclusion criteria for evaluating the role of surgery for NRs. Patients with isolated NRs who underwent observation progressed to WT 33% of the time; chemotherapy reduced the rate of WT to 3.9%. Observation of multiple NRs and diffuse hyperplastic perilobar nephroblastomatosis (DHPLN) led to progression to WT 50% and 100% of the time, respectively. Chemotherapy reduced the rate of WT to 34% for multiple NRs and 46% for DHPLN. Surgery for isolated NRs reduced the risk of WT development from 23.7% in patients with incomplete excision to 3.3% with complete excision; however, 96% of patients with incompletely excised NRs had bilateral disease.

CONCLUSIONS

Observation with close surveillance for isolated NRs is safe. Treatment with chemotherapy is recommended for patients with multiple NRs and DHPLN. Surgical management of NRs should focus on renal function preservation.

LEVEL OF EVIDENCE

Treatment study, Level III.

Management of bilateral Wilms tumor over three decades: The perspective of a single center

INTRODUCTION

Outcomes of Wilms tumor improved in last 50 years and excellent survival rates can be achieved especially in case of non-metastatic disease and favorable histology. Nevertheless, bilateral cases still stand as a therapeutic challenge. Prognosis of bilateral Wilms tumor (BWT) is not as good as the unilateral tumors of similar stage and histology in terms of survival and renal function.

OBJECTIVE

Management of BWT is constantly evolving and still stands as a therapeutic challenge. This study is designed to review and share our experiences on this topic from a surgical standpoint.

STUDY DESIGN

The records of patients treated in our clinic between 1980 and 2013 according to Turkish Pediatric Group of Oncology protocol were analyzed retrospectively and clinical data, surgical details, pathology results, long term outcomes were analyzed.

RESULTS

Thirteen girls and 7 boys with a mean age of 2,5 years were treated. There were 2 patients with Wilms tumor-Aniridia-Growth Retardation complex and one with isolated hemihypertrophy. Metastasis were detected in lungs of 4 patients; liver of 2 and in the cranium of one. All patients except one with the presumptive diagnosis of unilateral Wilms tumor were given preoperative chemotherapy. To sum up; 19 nephroureterectomies, 8 partial nephrectomies and 13 enucleations were performed to 36 kidneys without any major early or late postoperative complications. Pathologic results revealed positive surgical margins in 2 lesions with enucleation and in 2 with partial nephrectomies and anaplasia in 4 patients. Two patients were not operated due to parental disapproval. Two patients had the need of dialysis; one was anephric and the others' renal functions recovered over a year. Seven patients received radiotherapy for pulmonary metastasis, positive surgical margins or local recurrences. Overall, 13 patients survived and 7 died due to metastasis, recurrences, and complication of dialysis and refusal of surgical treatment. Survival among all patients was 65% and 72.2% among operated ones. Of the 7 patients with the partial nephrectomy, 2 died and 5 survived. Among enucleation group, 8 out of 10 survived and 2 died. Survival was slightly higher among enucleation group (80% vs 71.4%). Median time of follow-up for survivors of disease is 5.8 years (min: 6 months and max: 14 years).

DISCUSSION

Outcomes of BWT management have changed dramatically during the last few decades from only survival, to a long life expectancy without the need of renal replacement therapy owing to improvements in treatment options. We argue that positive surgical margins do not necessarily lead to local recurrence. For this reason it may be wiser to favor on more nephron sparing surgery than to achieve negative surgical margins. Adjuvant chemotherapy and radiotherapy may be adequate to prevent local recurrence. Also, survival did not differ significantly between different ways of nephron sparing surgeries, so it may be wiser to choose enucleation over partial nephrectomy which preserves more nephrons. Nephron-sparing surgery should have utmost importance despite the risk of positive margins. On the other hand, there is not enough data to interpret if positive surgical margins have role on distant metastases or not. Presence of metastasis and recurrence seems to be an important determinant of prognosis given the fact that none of the survivors had any metastasis or recurrence.

CONCLUSION

Nephron preservation should be the aim while taking positive surgical margin risk on nephron sparing surgery side relying on postoperative chemotherapy and carefully planned radiotherapy to avoid recurrence. However, there is significant diversity on the management BWT in different centers and a certain validated guideline or protocol to provide the optimal treatment is still lacking.

Childhood renal tumor: a report from a Chinese Children's Cancer Group

Here we investigated the establishment of multicenter cooperative treatment groups in China, as well as radiotherapy compliance and effectiveness among children with renal tumors. Medical records were reviewed for 316 children with renal tumors diagnosed by a multicenter cooperative group from 14 hospitals in China from 1998 to 2012. Median patient age was 29.5 months (range, 2–173 months old), and male-to-female ratio was 1.4 : 1. After a median follow-up of 22 months (range, 1–177 months), five-year event-free survival rates were 72% overall; 76.1% for favorable histology (251 cases); 59% for unfavorable histology (27 cases); and 91%, 75%, 71%, 53%, and 48.5%, respectively for Stages I, II, III, IV, and V. Following standardized criteria, radiation therapy was indicated for 153 patients, among whom five-year event-free survival was 72.8% for the 95 who received radiation and 24% for the 58 patients who did not. Our results are reasonable but can be further improved and show the feasibility of a multicenter cooperative group model for childhood renal tumor treatment in China. Radiation therapy is important for stage III and IV patients but remains difficult to implement in some parts of China. Government management departments and medical professionals must pay attention to this situation. This clinical trial is registered with ChiCTR-PRCH-14004372.

Nephron-sparing partial nephrectomy for bilateral Wilms' tumor

PURPOSE

Partial nephrectomy is increasingly used in children with bilateral Wilms' tumor (BWT) or contralateral recurrence. Nephron-sparing surgery seeks to achieve complete tumor removal while preserving functional renal parenchyma. Previous series have documented high rates of complications, recurrence, and mortality.

METHODS

Twelve patients (4 boys and 8 girls aged 9-42 months) with BWT or contralateral recurrence were treated at our institution with unilateral or bilateral partial nephrectomy. Preoperative imaging, operative notes, and pathology reports were reviewed. Outcomes analyzed included complications, recurrence, readmission rate, postoperative glomerular filtration rate (GFR), and survival.

RESULTS

All patients underwent successful nephron-sparing resection using standard techniques, with only 2 patients requiring unilateral nephrectomy. Median length of stay was 3 days. There were no major complications or urine leaks. Two patients were lost to follow-up. The remaining 10 were followed up for a median of 36 months (range, 3-79 months). There have been no recurrences or unplanned readmissions. Mean GFR is 107.7 (± 32.8) mL/min per 1.73 m(2), with no patient having a GFR below the lower limit of normal for age.

CONCLUSION

Nephron-sparing resection is a safe and effective approach for children with BWT or contralateral recurrence and should be part of the multimodality therapeutic approach to this disease.

Bilateral Wilms' tumor: Mansoura multi-centers 15 years experience

Purpose. Bilateral Wilms' tumor (WT) is a challenge. Aggressive surgical resection is needed to prevent recurrence. We revised the clinico-epidemiological criteria of bilateral WT patients in our locality and relation to outcome.

Subjects and methods. 462 WT patients were registered in three medical centers at Mansoura, Egypt. Twenty five patients had bilateral WT whose medical records were revised for all clinico-epidemiologic data plus treatment details, toxicity, and outcome.

Results. The mean age was 34.5 months; 64% of cases were female. Abdominal mass was the commonest presentation (72%). Congenital anomalies were reported in two cases (one case showed hemihypertrophy and the other showed aniridia). About 60% had favorable pathology. Nineteen cases had synchronous bilateral WT (76%) and the remaining (six cases) had metachronous tumors. For the synchronous cases, the response rate to preoperative chemotherapy was 79% and nephron sparing surgery for the least involved kidney was possible in all. Survival rate was 74%. Metachronous tumor management included nephrectomy followed by chemotherapy for the initially diagnosed tumors. However, nephron sparing surgery of the contralateral tumors following preoperative chemotherapy was possible in two cases and the survival rate was 33%. No renal failure or any therapy-related complications were reported.

Conclusions. Bilateral WT is predominantly synchronous with favorable histology, with female predilection and possibly congenital anomalies. Preoperative chemotherapy followed by nephron sparing surgery has a favorable outcome with preserved renal function especially in patients with synchronous WT. Response to preoperative chemotherapy had a statistically significant prognostic impact.

Risk factors for end stage renal disease in non-WT1-syndromic Wilms tumor

PURPOSE

We assessed risk factors for end stage renal disease in patients with Wilms tumor without known WT1 related syndromes. We hypothesized that patients with characteristics suggestive of a WT1 etiology (early onset, stromal predominant histology, intralobar nephrogenic rests) would have a higher risk of end stage renal disease due to chronic renal failure. We predicted a high risk of end stage renal disease due to progressive bilateral Wilms tumor in patients with metachronous bilateral disease.

MATERIALS AND METHODS

End stage renal disease was ascertained in 100 of 7,950 nonsyndromic patients enrolled in a National Wilms Tumor Study during 1969 to 2002. Risk factors were evaluated with cumulative incidence curves and proportional hazard regressions.

RESULTS

The cumulative incidence of end stage renal disease due to chronic renal failure 20 years after Wilms tumor diagnosis was 0.7%. For end stage renal disease due to progressive bilateral Wilms tumor the incidence was 4.0% at 3 years after diagnosis in patients with synchronous bilateral Wilms tumor and 19.3% in those with metachronous bilateral Wilms tumor. For end stage renal disease due to chronic renal failure stromal predominant histology had a HR of 6.4 relative to mixed (95% CI 3.4, 11.9; p<0.001), intralobar rests had a HR of 5.9 relative to no rests (95% CI 2.0, 17.3; p=0.001), and Wilms tumor diagnosis at less than 24 months had a HR of 1.7 relative to 24 to 48 months and 2.8 relative to greater than 48 months (p=0.003 for trend).

CONCLUSIONS

Metachronous bilateral Wilms tumor is associated with high rates of end stage renal disease due to surgery for progressive Wilms tumor. Characteristics associated with a WT1 etiology markedly increased the risk of end stage renal disease due to chronic renal failure despite the low risk in non-WT1 syndromic cases overall.

Laparoscopic nephron-sparing resection of synchronous Wilms tumors in a case of hyperplastic perilobar nephroblastomatosis

Diffuse hyperplastic perilobar nephroblastomatosis (DHPLN) is a rare precursor lesion of Wilms tumor (WT). Because of the increased risk to develop WT in either kidney, current management algorithms of DHPLN merit nephron-sparing strategies, beginning with chemotherapy and close radiographic monitoring into late childhood. After resolution of DHPLN, subsequent detection of a renal nodule mandates resection to exclude WT. Here, we report the case of a 4-year-old girl who developed 2 synchronous nodules in the right kidney more than 2 years after completion of therapy for DHPLN. Because of the early detection and peripheral location of these 2 nodules, laparoscopic nephron-sparing resection of each was performed using ultrasonic dissection. Both nodules were determined on pathology to be favorable histology WT with negative surgical margins. The child was placed on vincristine and actinomycin D therapy for 18 weeks.

Current management of wilms' tumor

Wilms' tumor is the most common malignant renal tumor in children. Survival has improved dramatically over time as a result of prospective randomized clinical trials conducted by the pediatric cooperative cancer groups. Current research is directed toward identifying low-risk patients for whom a reduction in treatment intensity would decrease long-term morbidity. This article reviews the most recent advances in the biology and treatment of children with Wilms' tumor.

Malignant tumours of the kidney: imaging strategy

Primitive malignant renal tumours comprise 6% of all childhood cancers. Wilms tumour (WT) or nephroblastoma is the most frequent type accounting for more than 90%. Imaging alone cannot differentiate between these tumours with certainty but it plays an important role in screening, diagnostic workup, assessment of therapy response, preoperative evaluation and follow-up. The outcome of WT after therapy is excellent with an overall survival around 90%. In tumours such as those where the outcome is extremely good, focus can be shifted to a risk-based stratification to maintain excellent outcome in children with low risk tumours while improving quality of life and decreasing toxicity and costs. This review will discuss the imaging issues for WT from the European perspective and briefly discuss the characteristics of other malignant renal tumours occurring in children and new imaging techniques with potential in this matter.