Heterotaxy syndrome and malrotation: does isomerism influence risk and decision to treat

Which side are they on? Diagnosing primary ciliary dyskinesias in low- or middle-income countries: A review and case series

Background

Primary ciliary dyskinesia (PCD) is a rare genetic condition with a variable clinical presentation, making its diagnosis a challenge. We describe two unrelated sibling pairs with PCD: adult siblings in the first and perinatal/neonatal in the second. Both families highlight the more common and rarer clinical manifestations of PCD. We use these cases to highlight: (i) current understanding of the underlying genetic and pathophysiological mechanisms of PCD; (ii) the diversity of cardiac and respiratory features of PCD across a wide age range; (iii) aspects of the history and clinical examination that should raise suspicion of PCD; and (iv) the role of next-generation sequencing gene panel testing in confirmation of the diagnosis. We note genomic evidence predicting that PCD is relatively common in black African populations.

Study synopsis

What the study adds. This review of two sibling pairs illustrates the variable histories, presentations, diagnostic processes and clinical courses of primary ciliary dyskinesia (PCD) in low- or middle-income countries (LMICs), highlighting the diagnostic challenges faced when encountering such patients in settings where there may not be access to specialised resources. Possible diagnostic tools that can be used are discussed, weighing up their pros and cons in an LMIC setting, and a potential diagnostic approach that can be adapted to the treating clinician's own context is provided.Implications of the findings. Confirmation of the diagnosis of primary ciliary dyskinesia is no longer limited to well-resourced institutions, but can be done in less specialised environments using novel, highly accurate next-generation sequencing gene panel testing, reducing the need to transport patients as well as the overall cost to the healthcare system. Well-resourced institutions that see high volumes of patients with PCD can invest in new highly sensitive diagnostic tools such as high-speed video microscopy. There is a need for research investigating the validity of tools such as ciliary immunofluorescence in the South African population.

Malrotation and Fibroblast Growth Factor Receptor-2-Associated Craniosynostosis: An Underrecognized Association and Management Pathway

INTRODUCTION

Feeding difficulties are common and multifactorial in children with Fibroblast Growth Factor Receptor-2 (FGFR-2) mutations. Intestinal rotation anomalies have been demonstrated to occur more frequently in animals with FGFR-2 mutations. This study aims to describe intestinal rotation anomalies, surgical management, and feeding assistance in children with FGFR-2 mutations who have undergone upper gastrointestinal (UGI) contrast studies.

METHODS

Retrospective data were collected of children born between 1988 and 2020 in a UK quaternary craniofacial unit with FGFR-2-associated craniosynostosis. A consultant survey of approach to malrotation was undertaken.

RESULTS

Thirty-four children were included, 17 (50%) female. Six (18%) had UGI symptoms, which included bilious vomiting (n=2), nonbilious vomiting (n=5), retching (n=1), feed intolerance (n=3), and failure to thrive (n=3). Nine had a gastrostomy in situ. Intestinal rotation anomalies occurred in 4 (12%) children, 3 of whom underwent a Ladd procedure and two third required gastrojejunal feeding postoperatively. Consultants agreed that all children with FGFR-2 mutation and UGI symptoms should undergo UGI contrast study, as should children requiring a gastrostomy.

DISCUSSION

Intestinal rotation anomalies in children with FGFR-2 mutations occur more frequently than the general population. Prompt consideration of UGI contrast in symptomatic children with FGFR-2 mutation is recommended to enable early surgical management of children with malrotation.

Splenic Torsion in Heterotaxy Syndrome with Left Isomerism: A Case Report and Literature Review

Splenic torsion is an unusual condition that results in congenital abnormality, especially in the visceral abnormal arrangement. We report the case of an 8.5-year-old boy with features in the right upper quadrant. Radiological investigations revealed heterotaxy syndrome with polysplenia and a hypodense tumor in the right upper quadrant adjacent to several spleens. We initially treated it as an intra-abdominal tumor. Laparoscopy was performed to check the tumor condition and revealed a congestive tumor located in the abdomen of the right upper quadrant below the central liver, which was suspected to be a torsion spleen without attaching ligaments. Laparoscopic splenectomy was successfully carried out without complications. The pathological report shows splenic tissue with hemorrhagic infarction. Physicians should be vigilant of the differential diagnosis of the acute abdomen in adolescents.

Impact of gastrointestinal comorbidities in patients with right and left atrial isomerism

BACKGROUND AND AIM

Heterotaxy syndrome, being right atrial isomerism (RAI) or left atrial isomerism (LAI), often presents with Congenital Heart Disease (CHD). Intestinal abnormalities, including malrotation are common. We assessed the spectrum of gut abnormalities and their impact on medium-term outcome in a cohort of patients with fetal and postnatal diagnoses of heterotaxy syndrome.

METHODS

We reviewed the cardiology records of heterotaxy syndrome patients from two centres, regarding the presence of CHD, time for cardiac intervention, presence of gastrointestinal abnormalities, and type/time of surgery. A questionnaire about gastrointestinal status was sent to patients <18 years old. Kaplan-Meier curves were derived for survival data and freedom from intervention.

RESULTS

Data were included for 182 patients (49 RAI and 133 LAI) of 247 identified. Questionnaires were sent to 77 families and 47 replied. CHD was present in all RAI and 61.7% of LAI cases. Thirty-eight patients had abdominal surgery (20.9%), similar for RAI and LAI (20.4% versus 21%, p> 0.99): Ladd procedure in 17 (44.7%), non-Ladd in 12 (31.5%), and both procedures in 9 (23.7%). Ten-year freedom from Ladd procedure for all was 86% for the whole cohort (RAI = 87%; LAI = 85%, p = 0.98). Freedom from any gastrointestinal surgery at 10 years was 79% for the whole cohort (RAI = 77%; LAI = 80%, p = 0.54). Ten-year freedom from cardiac surgery was 31% for the whole cohort (RAI = 6%; LAI = 43%, p < 0.0001).

CONCLUSIONS

In our cohort, one in five patients required abdominal surgery, mostly in their first year of life, similar for RAI and LAI. Between 1 and 10 years of follow-up, the impact of gastrointestinal abnormalities on outcome was minimal. Medium term survival was related to CHD.

[Isomorfismo cardiaco: Una perspectiva multidisciplinaria]

Atrial isomerism describes complex anatomical findings with defects in the determination of lateralization; being a rare situation, with a prevalence of 1 in every 10.000 to 20.000 live births, with an incidence of up to 4% of all cardiac malformations. The diagnosis can be made in the neonatal age; however, clinical presentation is nonspecific. Depending on the spectrum of malformations, complex and invasive diagnostic tools may be required. Treatment is varied and can range from palliative surgery in view of univentricular physiology to total correction surgery for biventricular repair.

Lateral Heterotaxy Syndrome in a Newborn Caucasian Male

Heterotaxy syndrome is a varied spectrum of rearrangements of thoracic and abdominal organs that present many unique complications. Among all congenital deformities, heterotaxy syndrome is rare although this is likely an underestimate without routine imaging due to the benign nature of some defects. Numerous genes have been identified that play a role in its pathogenesis, and it has been hypothesized that heterotaxy syndrome is a consequence of both genetic and environmental impacts on the body axis. This case report also demonstrates the fundamental role of cardiac catheterization and imaging in further specifying the subtype of heterotaxy. Furthermore, it highlights the inconsistency of laterality with functional asplenia, visceral situs ambiguus, double-outlet right ventricle, and a left-sided inferior vena cava apart from other anomalies in a newborn male. 

Concurrent right atrial isomerism, complete atrioventricular septal defect, and single ventricle in an L-transposition of great arteries patient complicated by brain abscess

We present a case of an 11-year-old Indonesian female who was referred to our facility after surgical excision of brain abscess. The patient has been previously diagnosed with right atrial isomerism, complete atrioventricular septal defect, and L-Transposition of great arteries. Multiple staged surgeries are required for the management of this condition.

Noncardiac surgery in the congenital heart patient

More children with congenital heart disease are surviving and require noncardiac surgery. A high-yield summary of congenital heart anatomy and pathophysiology is presented to contextualize these patients for surgeons. Preoperative planning including risk stratification, anesthetic management and timing of elective surgery are discussed. Specific intraoperative considerations for particular cases, such as the use of laparoscopy and thoracic surgery, are reviewed. Postoperative outcomes and recommended management required to mitigate complications are summarized.

Heterotaxy Syndrome and Intestinal Rotation Abnormalities

BACKGROUND

Infants with heterotaxy syndrome (HS) have abnormal lateralization of organs along the right-left body axis. Intestinal rotation abnormalities (IRAs) are a potential source of morbidity and mortality. For this study, our objective was to prospectively observe a cohort of infants with HS and determine the incidence and natural history of IRA.

METHODS

Infants ≤6 months of age with HS were enrolled in this prospective observational study. Exclusion criteria were other congenital abnormalities that necessitated abdominal surgery. HS was defined as any arrangement of organs that was not situs solitus or situs inversus along with associated congenital heart disease. The investigation for IRA was at the discretion of each participating center.

RESULTS

Infants were recruited from January 2012 to December 2016. Thirty-eight infants from 7 institutions were included; 22 infants had right isomerism and 16 infants had left isomerism. Twenty-nine infants (76%) were evaluated for IRAs; 21 of 29 evaluations (72%) were abnormal. Eight infants were investigated because of symptoms, and 21 infants were evaluated routinely. The median age at symptom presentation was 46 days (range: 5-171 days). Seven infants had a Ladd procedure; 4 were prophylactic, with 3 as part of a combined procedure, and 3 were emergent. No child suffered acute midgut volvulus over a median follow-up of 1.6 years (range: 0.06-4.93 years).

CONCLUSIONS

IRAs are common in infants with HS. Infants with symptoms presented by 6 months of age. There was no failure of expectant management resulting in midgut volvulus during a median follow-up of 1.6 years.

Is isomerism a risk factor for intestinal volvulus?

INTRODUCTION

Isomerism, or heterotaxy syndrome, affects many organ systems anatomically and functionally. Intestinal malrotation is common in patients with isomerism. Despite a low reported risk of volvulus, some physicians perform routine screening and prophylactic Ladd procedures on asymptomatic patients with isomerism who are found to have intestinal malrotation. The primary aim of this study was to determine if isomerism is an independent risk factor for volvulus.

METHODS

Kid's Inpatient Database data from 1997 to 2012 was utilized for this study. Characteristics of admissions with and without isomerism were compared with a particular focus on intestinal malrotation, volvulus, and Ladd procedure. A logistic regression was conducted to determine independent risk factors for volvulus with respect to isomerism.

RESULTS

15,962,403 inpatient admissions were included in the analysis, of which 7970 (0.05%) patients had isomerism, and 6 patients (0.1%) developed volvulus. Isomerism was associated with a 52-fold increase in the odds of intestinal malrotation by univariate analysis. Of 251 with isomerism and intestinal malrotation, only 2.4% experienced volvulus. Logistic regression demonstrated that isomerism was not an independent risk factor for volvulus.

CONCLUSION

Isomerism is associated with an increased risk of intestinal malrotation but is not an independent risk factor for volvulus.

TYPE OF STUDY

Prognosis study.

LEVEL OF EVIDENCE

Level III.

Is Screening of Intestinal Foregut Anatomy in Heterotaxy Patients Really Necessary?: A Systematic Review in Search of the Evidence

OBJECTIVE

(1) Is screening of intestinal rotational anatomy obligatory in "asymptomatic" patients with heterotaxy? (2) Does detection of an anomaly warrant surgical correction?

SUMMARY OF BACKGROUND DATA

Heterotaxy is an abnormal arrangement of thoraco-abdominal viscera across a left-to-right axis. Intestinal rotational anomalies are frequent among patients with heterotaxy, but debate exists as to whether they are benign in nature, requiring careful observation alone, or if surgical correction is warranted to prevent obstruction or midgut volvulus.

METHODS

A systematic review [according to PRISMA guidelines] was conducted using CINAHL, EMBASE, Medline, and Cochrane Databases. Article quality was assessed using MINORS criteria. Conference proceedings and unpublished data were screened additionally.

RESULTS

Nineteen studies met the eligibility criteria but reporting was adequate for 9. All were observational studies. These included a total of 414 patients managed expectantly, that is, "asymptomatic patients" in whom no intestinal rotation screening was undertaken (group A), 191 cases in whom screening was performed routinely (group B), and 92 patients considered "symptomatic" of potential rotational anomalies and therefore underwent imaging or laparotomy (group C). In group A, 1 patient developed symptoms attributable to malrotation in whom laparotomy confirmed the diagnosis (0.24%). Among groups B and C, 151 had Ladd's operations (53%) and 14 cases of malrotation with obstruction or volvulus were described (4.9%), of which 2 "symptomatic patients" died before laparotomy. Overall surgical complication rate was 17% with 30-day mortality rate of 2.6% to 4.6%.

CONCLUSION

The evidence base for screening "asymptomatic" patients is weak especially considering the life-limiting comorbidities.

The impact of cardiac risk factors on short-term outcomes for children undergoing a Ladd procedure

BACKGROUND/PURPOSE

The purpose of this study was to describe the outcomes of children with and without congenital heart disease who undergo a Ladd procedure.

METHODS

The 2012-2014 National Surgical Quality Improvement Program Pediatric (NSQIP-P) data were queried for patients undergoing a Ladd procedure. Utilizing NSQIP-P definitions, patients were categorized into four cardiac risk groups (none, minor, major, severe) based on severity of cardiac anomalies, previous cardiac procedure(s), and ongoing cardiac dysfunction. Ladd procedures were elective/non-elective. Outcomes included length of stay, adverse events, and mortality.

RESULTS

878 patients underwent Ladd procedures. 633 (72%) patients had no cardiac risk factors and 84 (10%), 109 (12%), and 52 (6%) had minor, major, and severe cardiac risk factors, respectively. Children with congenital heart disease experienced increased morbidity and mortality and longer hospital stays (all p<0.05). Elective Ladd procedures were associated with similar morbidity but shorter length of stay and lower mortality than non-elective procedures. Older age at time of operation was associated with fewer adverse events.

CONCLUSIONS

Although overall mortality remains low, children with higher risk cardiac disease experience increased morbidity and mortality when undergoing a Ladd procedure. Older age at the time of the Ladd procedure was associated with improved outcomes in children.

Characteristics of Hospitalizations for the Glenn Procedure in Those With Isomerism Compared to Those Without

Isomerism, also known as heterotaxy, is a unique clinical entity in which there are mirror imaged findings in the thoracic. In the abdomen, the arrangement of organs can be random. The anatomic findings also have functional consequences. Isomerism has been known to increase morbidity and mortality in those with functionally univentricular hearts. The aim of this study was to determine the impact of isomerism on the Glenn hospitalization. Data from the 1997 to 2012 Kids' Inpatient Database were utilized for this cross-sectional study. Admissions during which a Glenn procedure was done were identified. Next, these admissions were separated into those with and without isomerism. Admission characteristics were then compared in a univariate fashion as well as by regression analysis. Length of hospitalization, cost of hospitalization, extracorporeal membrane oxygenation, and inpatient mortality were the outcomes of interest. A total of 4959 admissions with a Glenn procedure were identified. Of these, 450 were associated with isomerism. The median age at which the Glenn procedure was done was 10 and 13 months in those without and with isomerism, respectively. Neither univariate nor regression analysis demonstrated any significant difference in length of hospitalization, cost of hospitalization, need for extracorporeal membrane oxygenation, and inpatient mortality between those with and without isomerism. Isomerism does not impact the characteristics of the Glenn hospitalization. Those with isomerism did tend to be older when they underwent the Glenn procedure.

Screening and Treatment of Intestinal Rotational Abnormalities in Heterotaxy: A Systematic Review and Meta-Analysis

OBJECTIVE

To assess the role of screening and prophylactic surgery for intestinal rotational abnormalities (IRAs) in asymptomatic patients with heterotaxy.

STUDY DESIGN

PubMed, Embase, and Cinahl were searched electronically to determine the overall incidence of IRAs in heterotaxy; the detection rate of IRAs associated with screening; the incidence of midgut volvulus in patients without screening; and the incidence of morbidity and mortality after prophylactic and emergency Ladd procedures. Relevant data were computed with a meta-analysis of proportions. Between-study heterogeneity was assessed with the I(2) statistic.

RESULTS

From 276 papers identified, 24 studies with a total of 1433 patients with heterotaxy were included for systematic review. No randomized study was identified. True incidence of IRA in heterotaxy could not be ascertained through meta-analysis. In patients who underwent screening, the incidence of IRA was 58%. Acute midgut volvulus occurred in 5.8% of those who did not undergo screening. Postoperative mortality after Ladd procedure mainly was associated with cardiac insufficiency, and overall it was significantly greater in the emergency group compared with the prophylactic group (18% vs 5.6%). The complication rate also was greater in case of emergency vs prophylactic abdominal surgery (27% vs 16%); adhesional small bowel obstruction was the most common complication overall (6%).

CONCLUSION

The screen-detected incidences of IRA and acute midgut volvulus were significantly greater in heterotaxy than the normal population. Prophylactic Ladd procedure was associated with less morbidity and mortality compared with emergency surgery. A long-term prospective randomized trial is needed to define the indication for screening and prophylactic treatment of IRA in heterotaxy.

Antenatally diagnosed right-sided stomach (dextrogastria): A rare rotational anomaly

AIM

Antenatal detection of right-sided stomach (dextrogastria) is rare, and its significance in regards to intestinal rotation is unclear. We aimed to review all cases of antenatally-diagnosed dextrogastria in our regional fetal medicine unit over 10years.

METHODS

A retrospective case-note review of patients identified from a prospectively-maintained database was performed.

RESULTS

Twenty cases of antenatally-diagnosed dextrogastria were identified from 2004 to 2014. There were 8 terminations and 1 intra-uterine death. One patient has no post-natal information obtainable. Ten infants were live-born, and 2 died secondary to cardiac disease in the neonatal period. All had significant cardiac/vascular anomaly on postnatal assessment, including the 3 neonates in whom dextrogastria was the only antenatal finding. Two neonates developed bilious vomiting and underwent Ladd's procedure. Operative findings were dextrogastria/malrotation in both. A third child had gastro-oesophageal reflux, and contrast demonstrated stable duodenal/midgut position. This child has not developed symptoms attributable to malrotation and not undergone surgery. All 3 of these infants had asplenia or polysplenia and were managed with antibiotic prophylaxis/immunisation. Five children in the series were not investigated for malrotation and have not come to surgical attention (one is known to be asplenic).

CONCLUSION

Antenatally-detected dextrogastria, even if apparently isolated, was always associated with postnatal significant cardiovascular anomaly, splenic abnormality or situs inversus. This may be important for antenatal counselling. We currently recommend postnatal echocardiography and splenic assessment, but reserve GI investigation/intervention for symptomatic malrotation owing to potential significant cardiac comorbidity.

Manifestations of bodily isomerism

We report the findings present in 49 postmortem specimens from patients with so-called heterotaxy, concentrating on those found in the extracardiac systems of organs. Also known as bodily isomerism, we suggest that it is important to segregate the syndromes into their isomeric subtypes to be able to make inferences regarding likely extracardiac and intracardiac findings to allow for proper surveillance. We demonstrate that this is best done on the basis of the atrial appendages, which were isomeric in all the hearts obtained from the specimens available for our inspection. The abdominal organs do not demonstrate isomerism, and they show variable features when compared to the isomeric atrial appendages.

Heterotaxy and intestinal rotation anomalies: 20 years experience at a UK regional paediatric surgery centre

BACKGROUND

The association of heterotaxy with intestinal rotation anomalies is well described. However debate exists with regard optimal management notably should 'asymptomatic' bowel rotation anomalies undergo operation? The present study therefore sought to determine: (1) the risk(s) of volvulus in patients diagnosed with heterotaxy and (2) define morbidity associated with operation for 'asymptomatic' anomalies in a fragile patient cohort with co-existent congenital heart disease.

METHODS

Medical case record reviews of ALL heterotaxy patients born during January 1993-December 2013 and attending a UK paediatric centre were analyzed.

RESULTS

Of a total of 92 patients, 16 (17.4%) cases underwent foregut imaging studies. Three examinations were performed in 'symptomatic' patients. Twelve studies reported 'abnormal anatomy' with only five patients undergoing surgical correction. No complication(s) were recorded after Ladd's operation to correct defects. A single fatality occurred within 30 days postoperatively from cardiac failure. In 87 patients in whom Ladd's operation was not undertaken, no single patient developed intestinal volvulus (median length of follow-up 27.2 months, total 446.1 person years).

CONCLUSION

This study strongly supports a 'watchful waiting' policy for heterotaxy patients. Many children who ultimately die from heart disease may avoid unnecessary abdominal surgery.

Observation versus prophylactic Ladd procedure for asymptomatic intestinal rotational abnormalities in heterotaxy syndrome: A systematic review

BACKGROUND

The management of intestinal rotational abnormalities (IRA) in heterotaxy syndrome (HS) remains inconsistent. Because of the high incidence of malrotation in HS, screening of asymptomatic patients is standard of care in some institutions. The Ladd procedure is the treatment for malrotation, and has been reported to have high complication rates in HS patients.

METHODS

We performed a systematic review of publications describing IRA in pediatric HS patients from January 1993 to present. The incidence of volvulus on surgical exploration was determined. Perioperative and long-term outcomes were analyzed to determine complication and mortality rates.

RESULTS

Eleven retrospective studies describing 649 HS patients were identified. Of all patients with HS, 27% (176/649) underwent Ladd procedure. Only 1.2% (8/649) of HS patients included had volvulus. Postoperative complications occurred in 25 patients (14%), including a 10% incidence of small bowel obstruction. Perioperative and overall mortality rates after Ladd procedure were 3% and 21%, respectively. Six studies described mesenteric width, reporting 43% to have narrow mesentery.

CONCLUSION

The Ladd procedure is not without significant morbidity and mortality in heterotaxy patients. Further prospective studies should investigate predictors of mesenteric width to spare the unnecessary morbidity of surgery in patients who are at low risk for volvulus.

Fetal Magnetic Resonance Imaging of Malformations Associated with Heterotaxy

Magnetic resonance imaging (MRI) is increasingly used as an investigation during fetal life, particularly for assessment of intracranial masses, congenital diaphragmatic hernia, myelomeningocele, and abdominal masses. As the number of scans increases, so is the variety of congenital malformations being recognized. It is axiomatic that interpretation of the findings is enhanced when attention is paid to the likely findings in the setting of known syndromes, this information then dictating the need for additional acquisition of images. One such syndrome is so-called "visceral heterotaxy", in which there is typically an isomeric, rather than a lateralized, arrangement of the thoracic and abdominal organs. Typically associated with complex congenital cardiac malformations, heterotaxy can also involve the central nervous system, and produce pulmonary, gastrointestinal, immunologic, and genitourinary malformations. In this review, we discuss how these findings can be demonstrated using fetal MRI.