Diagnostic utility of core needle biopsy versus open wedge biopsy for pediatric intraabdominal solid tumors: Results of a prospective clinical study

A Comparison of Commonly Utilized Diagnostic Biopsy Techniques for Pediatric Patients With Cancer: A Systematic Review by the APSA Cancer Committee

BACKGROUND

Historically, surgical biopsy (SB) for diagnosis of pediatric solid tumors was considered necessary to provide adequate tissue for histologic and molecular analysis. Less invasive biopsy techniques such as image-guided core needle biopsy (CNB), have shown comparable accuracy with decreased morbidity in some adult studies. However, data regarding the safety and efficacy of CNB in pediatric tumors is limited. This study's aim was to assess the overall rate of successful diagnosis and safety of CNB compared to SB in children with malignancies.

METHODS

A PRISMA compliant systematic review was performed in MEDLINE via PubMed, Embase and CINAHL Plus database searches from 2010 to 2023. Studies were included with relevance to the following clinical question: For children with concern for malignancy requiring biopsy for diagnosis, how does CNB compare to open or laparoscopic/thoracoscopic SB in terms of safety and diagnostic efficacy? Data for patients ≤21 years requiring biopsy for diagnosis of liver tumors, neuroblastoma (NB), soft tissue sarcoma (STS), and lymphoma were included.

RESULTS

Twenty-seven studies including 2477 patients met inclusion criteria, with 2065 undergoing CNB and 412 SB. Of the 2477 patients, 820 patients had NB, 307 liver tumors, 96 STS, 151 lymphoma, and 1103 patients were from studies that included multiple diagnoses. The average complication rate for CNB was 2.9% compared to 21.4% for SB (p < 0.001). Bleeding was the most common complication in both groups, but significantly higher after SB (22.1% vs 2.3%) (p < 0.001). CNB was diagnostic in 90.8% of patients compared to 98.8% who underwent SB (p < 0.001).

CONCLUSIONS

Rates of successful diagnosis were greater than 90% for both CNB and SB, though significantly higher for SB. Conversely, complication rates were close to ten times higher after SB compared to CNB. Given its relatively lower risk profile, CNB can be a safe and useful diagnostic tool for children with solid malignancies. Research focused on enhancing CNB's diagnostic accuracy while maintaining low morbidity should be further explored.

LEVEL OF EVIDENCE

Treatment study, Level III.

Efficacy of core needle biopsy in the diagnosis of pediatric extracranial solid malignancies: A 10-year study

Introduction:

Core needle biopsies of solid masses in children are a minimally invasive technique. It guides to a definitive diagnosis and facilitates management.

Aims and Objectives:

To determine the accuracy, sensitivity, and specificity of core needle biopsies in diagnosing pediatric solid masses.

Materials and Methods:

A retrospective analysis of 430 children, who underwent core needle biopsy for solid masses between January 2007 and December 2016 at CMC Vellore, was done.

Results:

Retroperitoneal and intra-abdominal masses constituted 66% of cases. Real-time image guidance was used in 44% of cases. An accurate diagnosis was obtained in 93.6% of cases, while results did not correlate with the final diagnosis in 3.4%. Three percent had inadequate or necrotic tissue. None of the children had postprocedure complications.

Conclusion:

Core needle biopsies serve as good diagnostic modality, with minimal risks, in making a conclusive diagnosis and deciding on the line of management.

The utility of core-needle tumor biopsy for pediatric patients

BACKGROUND

Core-needle biopsy (CNB) is used less frequently for the diagnosis of tumors in pediatric patients. In this report, the utility and safety of CNB for pediatric patients are described.

METHODS

The medical records of patients who underwent CNB at the Department of Pediatric Surgery, Kyushu University Hospital from April 2020 to November 2021 were retrospectively reviewed. A 14 G or 16 G BARDMISSION Disposable Needle Instrument was used. For the diagnosis of neuroblastoma, a 14 G needle was selected; for the diagnosis of other tumors a 16 G needle was selected.

RESULTS

During the above period 17 CNBs were performed in 17 patients, and the median patient age was 8 years (range, 15 days-19 years). The pathological diagnoses of the tumors were as follows: neuroblastoma, n = 6; lymphoma, n = 3; hepatoblastoma, n = 2; and others, n = 6. The quantity and quality of all tumor samples obtained by CNB was sufficient to make a diagnosis. The postoperative course after CNB was uneventful in most cases, with the exception of one case of hepatoblastoma (pseudoaneurysm).

CONCLUSIONS

Core-needle biopsy is useful for pediatric patients. Sufficient tumor specimens were able to be obtained in all cases, irrespective of the type of tumor, and an accurate diagnosis could be made.

The morbidity of open tumor biopsy for intraabdominal neoplasms in pediatric patients

PURPOSE

Tumor biopsy is often essential for diagnosis and management of intraabdominal neoplasms found in children. Open surgical biopsy is the traditional approach used to obtain an adequate tissue sample to guide further therapy, but image-guided percutaneous core-needle biopsy is being used more often due to concerns about the morbidity of open biopsy. We used a national database to evaluate the morbidity associated with open intraabdominal tumor biopsy.

METHODS

We identified all patients undergoing laparotomy with tumor biopsy in the National Surgical Quality Improvement Project-Pediatric (NSQIP-P) database from 2012 to 2018 and measured the frequency of complications in the 30 days postoperatively. We tested associations between patient characteristics and outcomes to identify risk factors for complications.

RESULTS

We identified 454 patients undergoing laparotomy for biopsy of an intraabdominal neoplasm. Median postoperative hospital stay was 7 days (IQR 4-12) and operative time was 117 min (IQR 84-172). The overall complication rate was 12.1%, with post-operative infection (6%) and bleeding (4.2%) being the most common complications. Several patient characteristics were associated with bleeding, but the only significant association on multivariable analysis was underlying hematologic disorder.

CONCLUSION

Open abdominal surgery for pediatric intraabdominal tumor biopsy is accompanied by significant morbidity. Postoperative infection was the most common complication, which can delay initiation of further therapy, especially chemotherapy. These findings support the need to prospectively compare percutaneous image-guided core-needle biopsy to open biopsy as a way to minimize risk and optimize outcomes for this vulnerable population.

Diagnostic accuracy of image-guided core needle biopsy of non-central nervous system tumors in children

BACKGROUND AND AIMS

Core needle biopsies (CNB) are less invasive, cause less morbidity, and have lower costs than open biopsies (OB). However, the number of studies reporting CNB accuracy in pediatric tumors is limited and series are small. The aim of this study is to investigate if CNB diagnosis is concordant with the final diagnosis in pediatric solid non-central nervous system (CNS) tumors.

METHODS

Data from all patients treated in a single center between November 2014 and December 2019 were collected from the national pathology database and from local medical records. Data collection included age, sex, CNB diagnosis, final diagnosis, number of cores obtained, number of cores used for histology, cumulative core length, greatest dimension of the lesion, lesion volume, and complications.

RESULTS

Out of 361 CNB, 95.6% (345/361) provided a diagnosis. A resection or follow-up biopsy was performed in 201 cases. The final diagnosis was concordant with the CNB in 100% (201/201) of cases. The age, number of cores used for histology, and the greatest dimension of the lesion did not significantly differ between diagnostic and nondiagnostic CNB. The cumulative core length of diagnostic CNB was significantly higher than in the nondiagnostic group (24.72 mm vs. 13.37 mm, p-value .022). Complications occurred in 2.1% (7/337) of CNB procedures. Molecular analysis was successful in 228/233 (98%) of cases in which it was performed.

CONCLUSIONS

CNB diagnosis is highly concordant with the final diagnosis and the diagnostic rate is high. The complication rate in CNB is low.

Laparoscopic approach for abdominal neuroblastoma in Japan: results from nationwide multicenter survey

BACKGROUND

Some neuroblastoma (NB) cases are suitable for minimally invasive surgery (MIS), but indication and technical issue are unclear. We assessed the current status of MIS for abdominal NB after mass screening period in Japan.

METHODS

Preliminary questionnaires requesting the numbers of NB cases that underwent MIS from 2004 to 2016 were sent to 159 Japanese institutes of pediatric surgery. The secondary questionnaires were then sent to the institutions that reported MIS cases of NB in order to collect detailed data.

RESULTS

One hundred and thirty-four (84.2%) institutions responded to the preliminary questionnaires, and 83 (52.2%) reported managing operative cases. The total number of operative cases was 1496. MIS was performed for 175 (11.6%) cases, of which the completed forms of 140 patients were returned, including 100 abdominal NB cases. The male/female ratio was 51/49. Forty-seven cases underwent a laparoscopic biopsy, and 2 (4.3%) cases were converted to laparotomy due to bleeding. Sixty-five cases underwent MIS for radical resection, and 7 (10.8%) were converted to laparotomy. The reasons for open conversion were bleeding and severe adhesion. Regarding open conversion, there were no significant relationships between conversion and neo-adjuvant chemotherapy, biopsies, stage, size, or MYCN amplification. We found no relationship between resectability and vascular encasement in this study. There was relationship between the resected tumor size and the patients' height, which was expressed using the following formula: [Formula: see text] (x, patients height, y, tumor size; p = 0.004219, SE: 1.55566). Postoperative complications after radical resection were recognized in 7 (10.8%) cases.

CONCLUSIONS

MIS was performed in limited cases of abdominal NB. A laparoscopic biopsy with careful attention to bleeding is feasible. The resected tumor size was shown to correlate with the patients' height. Tumor size within 6 cm of maximum diameter can be resected safely.

Ultrasound-Guided Core Biopsy for Tissue Diagnosis in Pediatric Oncology: 16-Year Experience With 597 Biopsies

OBJECTIVE. Percutaneous imaging-guided core needle biopsies (CNBs) for cancer diagnosis in pediatric patients are gaining interest because of their availability, lower rate of complications, and high diagnostic power compared with traditional surgical biopsies. Nevertheless, their precise role in the diagnostic algorithm of pediatric oncology is still unknown. The purpose of this study was to report our accumulated 16-year experience with CNB; discuss the availability, safety, and diagnostic accuracy of the procedure and the adequacy of ancillary testing; and compare our findings with the available literature. MATERIALS AND METHODS. Pediatric ultrasound-guided CNBs performed in our hospital between November 2003 and December 2019 were retrospectively studied. Data collection included demographics, clinical and procedural parameters, complications, and final diagnosis. RESULTS. A total of 597 biopsies were performed in 531 patients (132 performed in known oncologic patients and 465 performed to establish diagnosis). The median time between the biopsy request and the procedure was 1 day. Of 432 biopsies performed in patients with malignancies, 12 (2.8%) had false-negative results. In 165 cases of benign pathologic findings, all had true-negative results. Ancillary testing was adequate in all malignant cases. Overall sensitivity, specificity, and accuracy rates were 97.2%, 100%, and 98.0%, respectively. Five biopsies (0.8%) resulted in complications, including one major bleed and one track seeding. CONCLUSION. Our experience shows that ultrasound-guided CNB for suspected malignancy in pediatric patients has a high safety profile, availability, and accuracy rate compared with surgical biopsy. Our fast-track strategy enables early initiation of designated therapy and has the potential to become the procedure of choice.

New Prognostic Indicators in Pediatric Adrenal Tumors: Neuroblastoma and Adrenal Cortical Tumors, Can We Predict When These Will Behave Badly?

Pediatric adrenal tumors are unique entities with specific diagnostic, prognostic, and therapeutic challenges. The adrenal medulla gives rise to peripheral neuroblastic tumors (pNTs), pathologically defined by their architecture, stromal content, degree of differentiation, and mitotic-karyorrhectic index. Successful risk stratification of pNTs uses patient age, stage, tumor histology, and molecular/genetic aberrations. The adrenal cortex gives rise to adrenocortical tumors (ACTs), which present diagnostic and prognostic challenges. Histologic features that signify poor prognosis in adults can be meaningless in children, who have superior outcomes. The key clinical, pathologic, and molecular findings of pediatric ACTs have yet to be completely identified.

Diagnostic ultrasound-guided cutting needle biopsies in neuroblastoma: A safe and efficient procedure

BACKGROUND

Neuroblastoma (NB) is the most common extracranial solid tumor of childhood and accounts for 15% of deaths in pediatric oncology. Apart from the clinical stage at diagnosis, molecular factors are important for the characterization of the tumor and for decision on adequate treatment. Pretreatment diagnosis and molecular profiling are based on analysis of a tumor sample, obtained either by fine needle aspiration cytology (FNAC), cutting needle biopsy or open surgical biopsy. The method used depends on local tradition and routines. Ultrasound-guided cutting needle biopsy (UCNB) has been used at the Uppsala University Hospital since 1988 for diagnosis of pediatric solid tumors.

PROCEDURES

Medical records of 29 patients with NB who underwent pretreatment, diagnostic, ultrasound-guided needle biopsy were reviewed. Information extracted from the patients' records included: age at diagnosis, gender, tumor site, clinical stage, molecular profiling made on biopsies (e.g. MYCN status, ploidy and chromosomal aberrations), and UCNB complications (i.e. bleeding, pain, or anesthesiologic complications).

RESULTS

A total of 34 UCNBs were performed in the 29 patients. Repeated biopsies were done in three patients. UCNB was diagnostic in 90% (26/29). A complete molecular profiling was obtained in all UCNBs after 2008. Two patients (7%) developed a significant bleeding and two (7%) needed analgesics following UCNB. Neither infection nor tumor growth in the needle tract was observed. There were no anesthesiologic complications.

CONCLUSIONS

UCNB is reasonably safe in patients with NB and usually gives a sufficient amount of tumor tissue for a histological diagnosis, molecular profiling, and biobank storage.