Primary vs. salvage liver transplantation for biliary atresia: A retrospective cohort study

Primary Liver Transplant in Biliary Atresia: The Case for and Against

The role of liver transplantation as a primary procedure in biliary atresia has been argued over for at least 40 years, indeed since the coming of age of safe liver transplantation during the 1980s. Yet, it is not a common option in most series (usually ≤5%) and typically reserved for those with late presentations (arguably >100 days) with established cirrhosis. This review presents the pros and cons of primary liver transplant. The pros are based upon the observation that at best a Kasai portoenterostomy (KPE) is simply palliative in most, and at worse has no effect whatsoever on restoration of bile flow and is therefore pointless. Set against this are the cons: there is a dearth of prognostic tests (clinical, biochemical, or histological) at the time of presentation which may predict inevitable failure; the possibility of long-term native liver survival to adulthood in a proportion (albeit a minority); and the implied increased need for donor organs suitable for infants - a stressor for an already overstressed system. Improving results from KPE in terms of increasing the proportions clearing their jaundice and minimizing the effects of chronic liver fibrosis and cirrhosis would surely limit the siren calls for primary transplants but the key must be better discrimination at presentation with the use of biomarkers (circulatory or histological, individually or together) to enable better decision making.

Biliary atresia

Biliary atresia (BA) is a progressive inflammatory fibrosclerosing disease of the biliary system and a major cause of neonatal cholestasis. It affects 1:5,000-20,000 live births, with the highest incidence in Asia. The pathogenesis is still unknown, but emerging research suggests a role for ciliary dysfunction, redox stress and hypoxia. The study of the underlying mechanisms can be conceptualized along the likely prenatal timing of an initial insult and the distinction between the injury and prenatal and postnatal responses to injury. Although still speculative, these emerging concepts, new diagnostic tools and early diagnosis might enable neoadjuvant therapy (possibly aimed at oxidative stress) before a Kasai portoenterostomy (KPE). This is particularly important, as timely KPE restores bile flow in only 50-75% of patients of whom many subsequently develop cholangitis, portal hypertension and progressive fibrosis; 60-75% of patients require liver transplantation by the age of 18 years. Early diagnosis, multidisciplinary management, centralization of surgery and optimized interventions for complications after KPE lead to better survival. Postoperative corticosteroid use has shown benefits, whereas the role of other adjuvant therapies remains to be evaluated. Continued research to better understand disease mechanisms is necessary to develop innovative treatments, including adjuvant therapies targeting the immune response, regenerative medicine approaches and new clinical tests to improve patient outcomes.

Galectin-3 in biliary atresia and other pediatric cholestatic liver diseases

AIMS

Biliary atresia (BA) is characterized by intrahepatic inflammation and rapid progression of liver fibrosis. Galectin-3, a beta-galactoside binding protein, is a key regulator of inflammation and fibrosis. The aim of this study was to characterize circulating and hepatic Galectin-3 levels in children with BA.

METHODS

Plasma and liver samples were obtained from children with early BA at time of Kasai hepatoportoenterostomy, late BA at time of transplant, early and late other cholestatic liver diseases (CLD), and controls. Plasma Galectin-3 was measured using standard enzyme-linked immunoassay. Liver tissue was analyzed with multiplex immunohistochemistry and quantified using whole slide analysis. Statistical comparisons were made using nonparametric testing.

RESULTS

Plasma Galectin-3 in late BA was significantly higher than in early BA (20.82 [12.45-30.46] vs. 11.30 [8.74-16.83] ng/mL, p = 0.0096). Galectin-3 levels correlated with markers of disease severity and interleukin-6. There were significantly more Galectin-3+ M2 macrophages in late BA in comparison to late other CLD (162 [157-233] vs. 49 [33-59] cells/mm2, p = 0.03). The number of Galectin-3+ M2 macrophages correlated with the number of activated hepatic stellate cells and bile duct proliferation.

CONCLUSIONS

Plasma Galectin-3 is higher in late BA at time of transplant in comparison to early BA at time of Kasai. The number of Galectin-3 expressing M2 macrophages in late BA is elevated relative to late other CLD and was associated with other prognostic histological findings. Galectin-3 targeted therapy may be beneficial in slowing disease progression to cirrhosis in children with BA.

Predicting Cirrhosis and Poor Outcomes of Bile Drainage Surgery for Biliary Atresia: A Multicentric Observational Study in Japan

OBJECTIVE

To identify patients with biliary atresia (BA) with extremely poor outcomes of bile drainage surgery using the infant BA liver fibrosis (iBALF) score, a liver fibrosis marker based on standard blood analysis.

BACKGROUND

Although primary liver transplantation is beginning to be considered as an alternative to bile drainage surgery in patients with BA, those most likely to benefit from this procedure have not yet been identified.

METHODS

The medical records of 380 patients with BA with bile drainage surgery between 2015 and 2019 were collected for retrospective analysis from 60 participating hospitals. To predict native liver survival at age 1 year, a receiver operating characteristic curve was drawn for the iBALF score. The cutoff value was determined as the point indicating >99% sensitivity.

RESULTS

The median age at surgery was 56 days (range: 4-183 days), and native liver survival at age 1 year was achieved in 258 (67.9%) patients. An iBALF score of 5.27 was chosen as the cutoff, and 18 patients (4.7%) were found to have an iBALF score >5.27; of these, only 2 (95% CI: 1.4%-34.7%) had native liver survival at age 1 year, indicating a significantly poorer outcome than in the other patients (95% CI: 65.7%-75.4%). Moreover, patients with an iBALF score >5.27 had significantly higher mortality and younger age at salvage liver transplantation.

CONCLUSIONS

Patients with BA having a preoperative iBALF score >5.27 had extremely poor outcomes of bile drainage surgery and may be considered candidates for primary LTx.

Primary liver transplantation vs transplant after Kasai portoenterostomy in children with biliary atresia: A retrospective Brazilian single-center cohort

BACKGROUND

Biliary atresia (BA) is the most common indication for pediatric liver trans plantation, although portoenterostomy is usually performed first. However, due to the high failure rate of portoenterostomy, liver transplantation has been advocated as the primary procedure for patients with BA. It is still unclear if a previous portoenterostomy has a negative impact on liver transplantation outcomes.

AIM

To investigate the effect of prior portoenterostomy in infants un dergoing liver transplantation for BA.

METHODS

This was a retrospective cohort study of 42 pediatric patients with BA who underwent primary liver transplantation from 2013 to 2023 at a single tertiary center in Brazil. Patients with BA were divided into two groups: Those under going primary liver transplantation without portoenterostomy and those undergoing liver transplantation with prior portoenterostomy. Continuous variables were compared using the Student's t-test or the Kruskal-Wallis test, and categorical variables were compared using the χ2 or Fisher's exact test, as appropriate. Multivariable Cox regression analysis was performed to determine risk factors for portal vein thrombosis. Patient and graft survival analyses were conducted with the Kaplan-Meier product-limit estimator, and patient subgroups were compared using the two-sided log-rank test.

RESULTS

Forty-two patients were included in the study (25 [60%] girls), 23 undergoing liver transplantation without prior portoenterostomy, and 19 undergoing liver transplantation with prior portoenterostomy. Patients with prior portoenterostomy were older (12 vs 8 months; P = 0.02) at the time of liver transplantation and had lower Pediatric End-Stage Liver Disease scores (13.2 vs 21.4; P = 0.01). The majority of the patients (35/42, 83%) underwent living-donor liver transplantation. The group of patients without prior portoenterostomy appeared to have a higher incidence of portal vein thrombosis (39 vs 11%), but this result did not reach statistical significance. Prior portoenterostomy was not a protective factor against portal vein thrombosis in the multivariable analysis after adjusting for age at liver transplantation, graft-to-recipient weight ratio, and use of vascular grafts. Finally, the groups did not significantly differ in terms of post-transplant survival.

CONCLUSION

In our study, prior portoenterostomy did not significantly affect the outcomes of liver transplantation.

A convenient nomogram for predicting early death or liver transplantation after the Kasai procedure in patients with biliary atresia

PURPOSE

Many patients with biliary atresia (BA) after the Kasai procedure (KP) progress to death or require liver transplantation to achieve long-term survival; however, most cases of death/liver transplantation (D/LT) occur in the early period after KP (usually within 1 year). This study was designed to construct a convenient nomogram for predicting early D/LT in patients with BA after KP.

METHODS

A BA cohort was established in May 2017, and up to May 2023, 112 patients with 1-5 years of follow-up were enrolled in the study and randomly (ratio, 3:1) divided into a training cohort for constructing a nomogram (n = 84) and a validation cohort (n = 28) for externally validating the discrimination and calibration. The training cohort was divided into two groups: the early D/LT group (patients who died or had undergone LT within 1 year after KP [n = 35]) and the control group (patients who survived through the native liver more than 1 year after KP [n = 49]). Multivariate logistic regression and stepwise regression were applied to detect variables with the best predictive ability for the construction of the nomogram. The discrimination and calibration of the nomogram were internally and externally validated.

RESULTS

The Kaplan-Meier (K-M) curve showed an actual 1-year native liver transplantation (NLS) rate of 57.1% and an estimated 2-year NLS rate of 55.2%. By multivariate regression and stepwise regression, age at KP, jaundice clearance (JC) speed 1 month after KP, early-onset PC (initial time < 36.5 days) after KP, sex, aspartate aminotransferase-to-platelet ratio index (APRI), and weight at KP were identified as the independent variables with the best ability to predict early D/LT and were used to construct a nomogram. The developed nomogram based on these independent variables showed relatively good discrimination and calibration according to internal and external validation.

CONCLUSION

Most D/LTs were early D/LTs that occurred within 1 year after KP. The established nomogram based on predictors, including sex, weight at the KP, the APRI, age at the KP, JC speed 1 month after the KP, and early PC, may be useful for predicting early D/LT and may be helpful for counseling BA patients about patient prognosis after KP. This study was retrospectively registered at ClinicalTrials.gov (NCT05909033) in June 2023.

Are the Post-transplant Outcomes of Kasai's Early Failure and Late Failure Comparable to the Primary Liver Transplantation?

It is uncertain whether prior Kasai procedures negatively impact the outcomes of liver transplantation (LT). The prior meta-analysis did not distinguish between Kasai early failure (K-EF) and late failure (K-LF). Numerous studies have been recently published; therefore, we perform a systematic review and meta-analysis. We searched PubMed and Embase databases to identify studies comparing the outcomes of biliary atresia (BA) patients undergoing primary LT versus patients with prior Kasai procedures. Subgroup analysis was done at the time of Kasai failure (early vs. late). Twenty-five studies comprising 6,408 patients receiving LT were included in the analysis. We found a statistically significant increase in one-year graft survival in K-LF versus primary liver transplant (pLT) (P = 0.0003). One-year patient survival was also increased in K-LF, although not statistically significant (P = 0.09). No difference in the one- and five-year graft and patient survival, reoperation rate, infection, and biliary complication was seen in pLT vs overall prior Kasai (K-EF and K-LF). These results suggest that prior kasai procedure does not negatively impact the outcome of LT. In addition, BA patients with prior Kasai undergoing LT later in life tend to perform better than primary liver transplants.

Cost-effectiveness analysis of liver transplantation in biliary atresia according to the severity of end-stage liver disease

BACKGROUND

Timing for liver transplantation (LT) in biliary atresia (BA) children with end-stage liver disease (ESLD) is associated with all-cause mortality. The cut-off value of pediatric end-stage liver disease (PELD) score for LT consideration varies across institutions. We aimed to determine the cost-effectiveness of LT to prevent death among BA children registered on the waiting list with different severities of ESLD.

METHODS

Subjects were BA children aged < 12 years at a transplant center between 2010 and 2021. A decision tree was developed for cost-effectiveness analysis from a hospital perspective to compare all-cause death between patients initially registered with a low PELD score (< 15) and a high PELD score (≥ 15). Each patient's direct medical cost was retrieved from the beginning of registration until 5 years after LT, adjusted with an inflation rate to 2022 Thai Baht (THB).

RESULTS

Among 176 children, 138 (78.4%) were initially registered with the high PELD score. The cost and mortality rate of the low PELD score group (THB1,413,424 or USD41,904 per patient and 31.6% mortality) were less than the high PELD score group (THB1,781,180 or USD52,807 per patient and 47.9% mortality), demonstrating the incremental cost-effectiveness ratio (ICER) of THB2,259,717 or USD66,994 per death prevented. The cost of early post-operative admission had the highest effect on the ICER. Considering the break-even analysis, cost among children initially registered at the low PELD score was also less expensive over time.

CONCLUSIONS

Registration for LT at PELD score < 15 was more cost-effective to prevent death among BA children with ESLD.

Early life growth and developmental trajectory in children with biliary atresia undergoing primary liver transplantation

Objective

To clarify the early growth and developmental characteristics of children with biliary atresia (BA) undergoing primary liver transplantation (pLT).

Methods

A prospective cohort study, which specifically focused on BA-pLT children, was conducted after the diagnosis of BA by following the children at the time of pLT and 1, 3, 5, 7 months and 1 year after pLT for growth and developmental monitoring. The growth parameters were calculated according to the WHO standard, and the developmental status was assessed using Denver Developmental Screening Tests.

Results

A total of 48 BA children who received pLT at the age of 5.00 ± 0.94 months were analyzed. The weight-for-age Z-value (Z_W) and length-for-age Z-value (Z_L) were higher than the head circumference-for-age Z-value (Z_HC) at pLT (P = 0.002 and 0.02), but they were all lower than the WHO growth standard (Z = 0) (P < 0.001). The Z_W and Z_HC decreased first and then returned to the population level at 1 year after pLT, while the Z_L only returned to the preoperative status and was lower than the Z_W and Z_HC (P < 0.001). Developmental screening showed that 35% (17/48) of the children were defined as suspicious and 15% (7/48) were abnormal at 1-4 months after pLT, the most likely time to be suspected of developmental delay. At 1 year after pLT, gross motor skill delay still existed (12/45, 27%), and language skill delay began to appear (4/45, 9%).

Conclusions

BA-pLT children suffer from growth and developmental problems. Low Z_HC is the main growth problem before pLT, while low Z_L is the problem after pLT. Developmental delays are significant after pLT, especially in motor and language skills. The current study suggested that further studies are warranted to clarify the long-term growth and developmental outcomes of BA-pLT children, to compare them with children undergoing the Kasai procedure and to explore their influencing factors and possible mechanisms.

Role of galectin-3 in the pathogenesis and progression of biliary atresia

Content available: Audio Recording.

Exploratory application of indocyanine green quantification in biliary atresia observational study

BACKGROUND

Indocyanine green (ICG) is known to facilitate real-time imaging of the bile outflow during the Kasai procedure. This study explored more possibilities for applying ICG quantification in biliary atresia (BA).

METHODS

We enrolled nine BA patients in this study. All patients received intravenous ICG injections before surgery and underwent Kasai operation. With a fluorescence imaging system (Nanjing Nuoyuan, REAL-IGS FLI-108) to observe the ICG and quantify the ICG fluorescence intensity (ICG-FI) changes of the hepatic portal fibrous tissue and the liver during the operation. As a short-term prognosis assessment, we monitored the postoperative ICG metabolism time in stool and used the jaundice-free (TBIL < 2 mg/dl) at 1-3 months after the operation.

RESULTS

The average age of the patients at the time of surgery was 73 days. There were no adverse reactions after ICG injection. All patients were observed ICG-FI increased after the dissection of hepatic portal fibrous tissue, and the ICG-FI of the liver decreased during the operation. They all received standardized treatment after surgery. Four patients completely metabolized ICG within about two weeks (no fluorescence detected in stool), and the other five were longer than two weeks. Five patients achieved a jaundice-free outcome in the short-term postoperatively, and the other four did not.

CONCLUSIONS

It is feasible to quantify ICG-FI in real-time to evaluate the anatomical degree of hepatic portal fibrous tissue in BA. The variations of ICG-FI in the liver and postoperative ICG metabolism time may be related to prognosis.