Parental decisional regret and views about optimal timing of female genital restoration surgery in congenital adrenal hyperplasia

Experiences and preferences of women with CAH and parents about disclosure of childhood surgery

INTRODUCTION

Complete disclosure of childhood genital surgery to patients with congenital adrenal hyperplasia (CAH) is a critical part of CAH care. There are no guidelines or uniform recommendations on the timing and content of surgical disclosure discussions.

OBJECTIVE

Our objective was to describe the experiences and preferences of females with CAH and parents of females with CAH who underwent childhood genital surgery regarding surgical disclosure.

METHODS

We conducted an anonymous cross-sectional online survey of females with CAH (46XX, ≥16 years [y] old) and parents of females with CAH who underwent genital surgery before age 4y in North America. Participants reported experiences, preferences, and advice about initial ("first time you were told") and complete disclosure ("told all details"). Non-parametric statistics and qualitative analysis were used.

RESULTS

Participants included 59 females with CAH (median age: 37y, 92% White, 93% non-Hispanic) and 41 parents (median: 36y, 85% White, 93% non-Hispanic, daughter median: 26y). The 76% of females who received complete disclosure were younger (median age: 33y) and underwent surgery more recently (median decade: 1980s) than the 14% who received only initial disclosure (median: 47y, 1970s) and the 10% who did not receive any disclosure (median: 60y, 1960s, p = 0.0003, Summary Figure). Females reported median ages of initial and complete disclosure as 7-10y and 11-13y, respectively. Disclosure was preferred by 98% of females with initial disclosure by age 14y and complete disclosure by 18y. Parents reported similar findings. Most disclosures were by mothers (initial: 82%, complete: 64%). Doctors were more involved in complete vs. initial disclosures (complete: 47%, initial: 13%, p < 0.001). Qualitative analysis of advice about surgical disclosure revealed 8 themes.

CONCLUSIONS

Disclosure of childhood genital surgery to women with CAH has increased over time. Although timing of disclosure varied, women preferred disclosure, and that it be initiated before age 14y and completed by age 18y.

Parental regret following decision for sons to undergo elective post-neonatal circumcision

INTRODUCTION

The reasons for performing a circumcision among males after the neonatal period are usually cultural or medical. We aimed to evaluate parental regret for providing consent and to identify factors associated with such regret.

METHODS

Included were the parents of males aged 6 months to 18 years who underwent circumcision under general anesthesia at a single center between 2/2017 and 01/2023. Those who underwent additional surgical procedures during the same session were excluded. Parents responded telephonically to the Decision Regret Scale (DRS) questionnaire. Regret was classified as none (0 points), mild (1-25) or moderate-to-strong (26-100). Surgical and demographic data were retrieved for comparison to DRS scores and identification of predictors of parental regret.

RESULTS

In total, 201 of the 265 suitable patients met the inclusion criteria. Parents of 130 patients (65% response rate) whose average age was 5.06 (IQR 1.58,7.53) years completed the DRS questionnaire (study group). The average time since surgery was 41.8 (IQR 25.4,59.3) months. Forty surgeries were undertaken for cultural reasons and 90 for medical considerations. Eighteen parents reported regret (15 mild and 3 moderate-to-strong) for their decision to consent to their son's circumcision. The time from responding since surgery was the only significant variable in the DRS scores, with a 33-month gap predicting no regret (p = 0.02 compared to shorter gaps). The reasons for circumcision did not significantly differ between the "regret" and "no-regret" groups (p = 0.23).

DISCUSSION

Our current investigation revealed a lower incidence of parental regret when compared to previous reports following distal hypospadias repair, likely attributable to the lower complication rate associated with circumcision. Our data reflect the experience of a single center in a country where neonatal male circumcision is routinely performed for cultural and religious reasons, thus precluding the generalization of our findings to places where post-natal circumcision is less commonplace.

CONCLUSION

Consent to their son's post-neonatal circumcision was regretted by 13.8% of parents. Time since surgery significantly influenced the reduction of their negative attitudes.

Parental decision regret after pediatric urologic surgeries compared to decisions of everyday life

INTRODUCTION

Parents are at risk of decision regret (DR) for decisions affecting their children. The Decision Regret Scale (DRS) measures medical DR but lacks context outside of healthcare.

OBJECTIVE

To compare parental DR 1) between common pediatric urologic surgeries and everyday decisions and 2) with preference to make a different choice.

METHODS

We conducted a cross-sectional online survey of randomly selected parents >1year (y) after their children underwent: orchiopexy (males ≤10y), open ureteral reimplant (OUR, females 2-6y), open pyeloplasty (OP, ≤2y), or robotic pyeloplasty (RP, 5-17y) (2017-2021). Higher DRS scores indicate increased DR (none: 0, mild: 1-25, moderate: 30-50, strong: 55-75, very strong: 80-100). Parents completed DRS on four decisions: their child's surgery, most recent/current romantic relationship, most recent leased/purchased car, and most recent purchased meal. Parents reported if they would make the same choice (yes/no). Nonparametric statistics were used.

RESULTS

We surveyed 191 parents (orchiopexy n = 52, OUR n = 50, OP n = 51, RP n = 38). The median parent age was 36y (mothers: 86%). Some DR was reported for all decisions, but with significant differences in DR severity. The lowest median DRS score was seen with surgery (orchiopexy 0 [IQR 0-10], OUR 0 [IQR 0-5], OP 0 [IQR 0-0], RP 0 [IQR 0-0]), with no difference between surgery groups (p = 0.78). This was followed by relationship (0, IQR 0-20), car (15, IQR 0-25), and meal (20, IQR 0-30, p < 0.001). Most parents did not report any DR regarding surgery (orchiopexy 69%, OUR 74%, OP 76%, RP 76%, with no difference between surgery groups p = 0.85, Summary Figure). Comparatively, 59% of parents did not have any regret about their relationship, 37% their car, and 28% their meal (p < 0.001). All surgical DR was mild or moderate. No parent (0%) would have chosen differently for their child's surgery versus 4-12% for non-surgical decisions (p < 0.001). Overall, increasing DR corresponded to increasing desire to have made a different choice (DRS≤10: 0%, DRS 45-50: 32%, DRS 55-60: 66%, DRS≥75: 100%, p < 0.001).

CONCLUSION

Parental DR varied between urological surgical and non-surgical decisions. It was lowest after surgery. Some regret was reported after every decision, but the subset of parents with regret was smallest after surgical decisions. Positive DRS scores do not necessarily correspond to parents wishing they made a different choice.

Differences of Sex Development: Current Issues and Controversies

Differences of sex development (DSD) encompass a broad range of conditions in which the development of chromosomal, gonadal, or anatomic sex is not typically male or female. Terms used to describe DSD are controversial, and continuously evolving. An individualized, multidisciplinary approach is key to both the diagnosis and management of DSD. Recent advances in DSD care include expanded genetic testing options, a more nuanced approach to gonadal management, and an emphasis on shared decision-making, particularly related to external genital surgical procedures. The timing of DSD surgery is currently being questioned and debated in both medical and advocacy/activism spheres.

Decisional Regret Among Caregivers of Infants with Differences of Sex Development Reared as Male

OBJECTIVE

Differences of sex development (DSD) are congenital conditions in which individuals are discordant in their chromosomal, phenotypic, and/or gonadal sex. Treatment of DSD can involve surgical intervention to external genitalia to make anatomy seem male-typical (i.e., male genitoplasty). Caregiver-perceived decisional regret regarding young boys with DSD was explored quantitatively and qualitatively.

METHOD

Participants (N = 39) were caregivers of infants (N = 23) diagnosed with DSD (mean age = 8.9 months, standard deviation = 5.9 months) reared male participating in a longitudinal investigation of psychosocial outcomes. Qualitative data were collected at 6 to 12 months after baseline enrollment to evaluate caregiver decision-making corresponding to levels of regret concerning their child's treatment. All but one infant received genital surgery before caregiver reporting on their decisional regret. Quantitative exploratory analyses evaluated longitudinal predictors of decisional regret at 6 to 12 months.

RESULTS

When completing a write-in item inquiring about decision-making and potential regret, most caregivers (n = 16, 76%) reported that their child's genital surgery was their first medical decision. Two caregivers referenced gender assignment as a decision point. One-third of caregivers reported some level of decisional regret (33%), with 67% reporting no regret. No hypothesized predictors of decisional regret were statistically significant.

CONCLUSION

Many caregivers of infants with DSD reared male view genital surgery as a first health care decision. Approximately one-third of caregivers reported some level of decisional regret. Further research is warranted to explore long-term decisional regret; it will be particularly important to investigate the decisional regret of patients with DSD.

Reviewing next of kin regrets in surgical decision-making: cross-sectional analysis of systematically searched literature

BACKGROUND

Decision-making concerning relatives undergoing surgery is challenging. It remains unclear to what extent implicated next of kin eventually regret their decisions and how this regret is assessed. Our aim was to systematically review the literature on decisional regret of next of kin and to describe the assessment tools used and the surgical populations studied.

METHODS

We included interventional or observational, quantitative or qualitative studies reporting the measurement of decisional regret of next of kin concerning relatives undergoing surgery. We searched a variety of databases without restriction on publication year. We assessed the quality of reporting of quantitative studies using the NIH Quality Assessment Tool for Observational Cohort and Cross-Sectional Studies and of qualitative studies using the Critical Appraisal Skills Program Checklist.

RESULTS

Thirteen cross-sectional, five prospective cohorts and five qualitative studies matched our inclusion criteria. In 18 studies (78%), patients were children, in five (22%), young or middle-aged adults. No study included elderly or frail patients. Thirteen studies (57%) used the original Decision Regret Scale which was validated for patients, but not for next of kin. Only 3 of the 18 (17%) quantitative studies and only one of the 4 (25%) qualitative studies were rated as "good" in the quality assessment.

CONCLUSION

None of the retrieved studies used validated tools to assess the decisional regret of next of kin and none of them examined this issue in elderly or frail surgical patients.

Decisional regret about surgical and non-surgical issues after genitoplasty among caregivers of female infants with CAH

INTRODUCTION

Caregivers of female infants with congenital adrenal hyperplasia (CAH) often confront complex medical decision-making (e.g., early feminizing genitoplasty).

OBJECTIVE

This study aimed to evaluate the relevant medical decisions and subsequent decisional regret of caregivers following their child's genitoplasty.

STUDY DESIGN

Caregivers (N = 55) were recruited from multidisciplinary treatment programs for participation in a longitudinal study. Qualitative data was collected at 6-12 months following feminizing genitoplasty to evaluate caregiver-reported decision points across their child's treatment. Quantitative exploratory analysis evaluated pre-operative predictors of subsequent decisional regret.

DISCUSSION

When prompted about their decision-making and potential regret, most caregivers (n = 32, 80%) reported that their daughter's genital surgery was their primary medical decision. Specific themes regarding genital surgery included the timing and type of surgery. Most caregivers reported no decisional regret (62%), with 38% reporting some level of regret. Greater pre-operative illness uncertainty predicted heightened decisional regret at follow-up, p = .001.

CONCLUSION

Two-thirds of caregivers of female infants with CAH reported not regretting their decision-making. Nevertheless, over one-third of caregivers reported some level of regret, suggesting the need for improvements in shared decision-making processes. Many, but not all, families reported that this regret was related to surgical decision-making. Reducing caregiver illness uncertainty (e.g., providing clear information to families) may increase their satisfaction with decision-making. Further research is needed to determine how the evolving care practices surrounding early genitoplasty will impact families.

Parental Regret Following Decision to Revise Circumcision

PURPOSE

Revision surgery for the removal of excess foreskin after circumcision is a common procedure. The decision regret scale (DRS) is a validated questionnaire which assesses regret after medical decision making. The aim was to evaluate parental regret by means of the DRS and querying about factors associated with regret about deciding to revise their child's circumcision.

PATIENTS AND METHODS

Included were all pediatric patients who underwent revision of neonatal circumcision in a single center between 2010 and 2016. Excluded were children who underwent revision for reasons other than excess foreskin, those who underwent additional surgical procedures during the same anesthetic session, and those who had undergone previous penile surgery other than circumcision. Response to the DRS questionnaire was by a telephone call with the patient's parent. Regret was classified as none (a score of 0), mild (1-25), or moderate-to-strong (26-100). Surgical and baseline demographic data were obtained from the departmental database and compared between the no regret and regret groups.

RESULTS

Of the 115 revisions of circumcisions performed during the study period, 52 fulfilled the inclusion criteria, and the parents of 40 (77%) completed the DRS questionnaire. Regret was reported by 11/40 [28%: nine as mild (23%) and two as moderate-to-strong (5%)]. The average age of the child in the regret group was 17 months compared to 18 months in the no regret group (p = 0.27). The median weight percentile was 43% in both groups. Surgical variables, including anesthesia type (caudal vs. no block, p = 0.65), suture type (polyglactin vs. poliglecaprone, p = 0.29), operation time (28 vs. 25 min, p = 0.59), and anesthesia time (55 vs. 54 min, p = 0.57) were not significantly different between the groups.

CONCLUSIONS

Regret for deciding upon revision surgery for removal of excess foreskin post-circumcision was reported by 27.5% of parents of children who underwent revision. No clinical, surgical, or demographic characteristics predicted parental decisional regret.

Complete corporeal preservation clitoroplasty: new insights into feminizing genitoplasty

INTRODUCTION

46,XX Congenital adrenal hyperplasia (CAH) remains the first cause of genital virilization and current surgical techniques aim to restore female aspect of genitalia while preserving dorsal neurovascular bundle but not at the expense of not preserving erectile tissue. We aim to report our experience with a new surgical technique for clitoroplasty, completely preserving corporeal bodies, neurovascular bundles without dismembering the clitoris, in four patients with over a year follow up.

MATERIALS AND METHODS

After IRB approval four patients with 46,XX CAH and Prader 5 and 3 external genitalia, underwent feminizing genitoplasty. Complete preservation of erectile tissue was accomplished without a need to dissect dorsal neurovascular bundle. Glans size allowed no need for glanular reduction and there was no need to dismember the corporeal bodies.

RESULTS

Four patients 12 to 24-months-old underwent complete corporeal preservation clitoroplasty (CCPC), mean age was 18.5 months, mean follow up was 10.25 months. Vaginoplasty was performed in all patients with partial urogenital mobilization (PUM) and Urogenital Sinus flap (UF), only one severely virilized patient required a parasagittal pre-rectal approach to mobilize the vagina. We had no complications until last follow up.

CONCLUSION

To our knowledge, we are introducing the concept of CCPC without the need of disassembling the corporeal bodies, neurovascular bundle and glans. It stands as a new alternative for feminizing genitoplasty with complete preservation of erectile tissue and no dissection of neurovascular bundle. Although there is still lacking long-term follow-up, it represents a new step in conservative reconfiguration of the external virilized female genitalia.

Illness Uncertainty Longitudinally Predicts Distress Among Caregivers of Children Born With DSD

OBJECTIVE

A subset of parents of children with disorders/differences of sex development (DSD) including ambiguous genitalia experience clinically elevated levels of anxious and depressive symptoms. Research indicates that uncertainty about their child's DSD is associated with parent psychosocial distress; however, previous studies have been cross-sectional or correlational in nature. The current study is the first to examine the longitudinal trajectory of the relationship between caregiver-perceived uncertainty about their child's DSD and caregiver anxious and depressive symptoms across the first 12 months following genital surgery in young children, or if surgery was not performed, the first 12 months following study entry.

METHODS

One hundred and thirteen caregivers (Mage = 32.12; 57.5% mothers; 72.6% Caucasian) of children (N = 70; Mage = 9.81 months; 65.7% female) with DSD were recruited from 12 DSD specialty clinics in the United States. Caregivers completed psychosocial measures at baseline, 6 and 12 months following genitoplasty, or study entry if parents elected not to have surgery for their child.

RESULTS

Caregiver illness uncertainty and both anxious and depressive symptoms were highest at baseline and decreased over time (ps < .05). Caregiver illness uncertainty predicted symptoms of anxious and depressive symptoms across all time points (ps < .05).

CONCLUSIONS

Caregivers' perceptions of uncertainty about their child's DSD are highest soon after diagnosis, and uncertainty continues to predict both anxious and depressive symptoms across time. Thus, the initial diagnostic period is a critical time for psychological assessment and intervention, with parent illness uncertainty being an important clinical target.

[Disorders of sex differentiation: state of the problem 15 years after the Chicago consensus]

It is well known that the nomenclature and classification were changed in 2005 at the international consensus conference on intersex disorders, held in Chicago, where, among others, the following recommendations were proposed: (1) all children should be assigned a gender identity, and this should be done as quickly as possible, taking into account the time required for the examination. (2) all infants with congenital adrenal hyperplasia and 46,XX karyotype, including those with pronounced masculinization, must be raised as women. (3) Surgical treatment should be performed early and in cases of feminizing genitoplasty, clitoral reduction should be performed simultaneously with reconstruction of the urogenital sinus (separation of the vagina and urethra). An analysis of contemporary literature shows that all these theories, proposed 15 years ago at the Chicago meeting, failed to stand the test of time. New nomenclature and classification are constantly being revised. Currently, many groups of patients want to abolish the term &laquo;sexual maturity disorders.&raquo; Recommendations regarding gender reassignment and appropriate early surgical treatment have been completely ignored in some countries. All this was largely facilitated by the confrontational activities of a number of support groups.

Congenital Adrenal Hyperplasia Due to Steroid 21-Hydroxylase Deficiency: An Endocrine Society Clinical Practice Guideline

Objective

To update the congenital adrenal hyperplasia due to steroid 21-hydroxylase deficiency clinical practice guideline published by the Endocrine Society in 2010.

Conclusions

The writing committee presents updated best practice guidelines for the clinical management of congenital adrenal hyperplasia based on published evidence and expert opinion with added considerations for patient safety, quality of life, cost, and utilization.