Eighteen years of experience with pediatric nutcracker syndrome: the importance of the conservative approach

Nutcracker syndrome: a case-based review

The nutcracker phenomenon, also known as left renal vein entrapment, occurs when there is extrinsic compression of the left renal vein, most often between the abdominal aorta and the superior mesenteric artery. Nutcracker syndrome refers to the constellation of clinical symptoms that may arise from the nutcracker phenomenon, typically inclusive of haematuria, flank/pelvic pain, orthostatic proteinuria and (in male patients) varicocele. We provide a short review of the nutcracker syndrome including various diagnostic and therapeutic modalities. We utilise our own experience with a patient as a case study and highlight the modern management option of endovascular stenting.

Nutcracker syndrome in pediatrics: initial findings and long-term follow-up results

BACKGROUND

Nutcracker syndrome (NCS) describes a set of symptoms and signs resulting from compression of the left renal vein (LRV). There is a lack of knowledge about its natural course, diagnosis, and management, especially in children. Herein, we present our single-center experience with a large number of patients who have long-term follow-up results.

METHODS

All patients with NCS diagnosed between January 2011 and March 2021 were included and their data were obtained retrospectively.

RESULTS

A total of 123 NCS patients (85 females) were included. The median age at the time of diagnosis was 12 (IQR 10-14) years, and BMI percentiles were below 5% in 38% of the cases. At the time of diagnosis, two-thirds of the patients were asymptomatic. The most common laboratory finding was nephritic proteinuria (98%), followed by microscopic hematuria (16%). Signs of LRV compression were significantly more evident in upright position Doppler ultrasonography (DUS) examination. All patients have been followed conservatively; hematuria and/or proteinuria resolved in 43 of the 108 patients (40%) within 35.8 ± 25.8 months of follow-up. Control DUS was performed in 52 patients after a mean period of 39.1 ± 21.3 months. The median peak velocity and diameter ratios of the LRV in the upright position were found to be decreased significantly when compared to the initial assessment (p < 0.05). Normal DUS findings were noted in 13 patients at the final evaluation.

CONCLUSIONS

In unexplained proteinuria and/or hematuria, NCS should be considered, especially in asthenic adolescents. Our results support conservative management in children as the first-line treatment approach.

Diagnostic Clues in Pediatric Nutcracker Syndrome: From Two Clinical Cases to Current Literature Analysis

Nutcracker syndrome (NCS) is a rare pediatric disease caused by left kidney vein compression. Besides the "Triade's symptoms", including hematuria, proteinuria, and flank pain, a wide spectrum of clinical manifestations has been reported. As the significant hemodynamic changes secondary to the dilatation of the left renal vein, serious consequences such as renal vein thrombosis and severe anemia might occur in these children. NCS diagnosis includes a variety of invasive and non-invasive imaging tools, but cutoff values need to be further validated. A conservative treatment represents the most common therapeutic approach for these patients, but operative options are available in selected cases. To complicate matters, a standard diagnostic and treatment algorithm is currently lacking and scientific pediatric evidence in this field is still poor and limited. In this perspective, early recognition of NCS is crucial but challenging for pediatricians. Therefore, a better knowledge of the disease is recommended. Starting from two different clinical presentations of NCS, we aimed to provide a comprehensive overview of the disease in children.

Nutcracker syndrome in children: Appearance, diagnostics, and treatment - A systematic review

BACKGROUND

The nutcracker syndrome (NCS) is defined by compression of the left renal vein (LVR) and may present with a wide variety of symptoms. Due to its rarity in pediatric patients, incidence, diagnostics and performed therapy regimen are widely undefined. To this date, there are only case reports and small collectives of pediatric patients described but comprehensive research is lacking.

METHODS

A systematic literature research on pediatric NCS was carried out on Medline and Scopus databases according to PRISMA principles using predefined search terms and inclusion criteria. The PROSPERO registered review (CRD42021237415) identified patients' characteristics regarding age, sex, clinical symptoms, applied diagnostic methods and treatment options.

RESULTS

In total 47 articles were included. Overall, 423 children (218 boys and 205 girls) with diagnosed NCS were included in the analysis. Mean age was 12.0 (boys 12.9, girls 12.0) years. Hematuria was most common presentation (55.5%), followed by proteinuria (49.9%). Classical flank pain was only detected in 19.1% of patients. Sonographic evaluation was the most commonly used diagnostic tool (99%). Invasive diagnostic studies were performed in 97 children. 86.8% patients were treated conservatively and 94.9% showed complete resolution (42.8%) or at least improvement (52.2%) of symptoms. Type of operative treatment comprised of open surgery with transposition of LRV, endovascular stenting and laparoscopy.

CONCLUSIONS

Overall, data quality regarding NCS in children is poor. However, conservative approach in pediatric patients is recommended and should be regarded first treatment option. Diagnostic and treatment should follow a defined algorithm when NCS is suspected. Sufficient observation and follow-up must be assured in all patients to get significant results in this heterogenous syndrome.

LEVEL OF EVIDENCE

V-IV.

Left renal vein entrapment in postural proteinuria: the diagnostic utility of the aortomesenteric angle

Nutcracker syndrome related to the left kidney vein compression is a cause of orthostatic proteinuria during childhood. Some studies have shown that the ratios between maximum velocities and anterior-posterior diameters of hilar and aortomesenteric segments of the left kidney vein between upright and supine positions must be more than 4 in order to make a Nutcracker syndrome diagnosis. Our aim was to investigate whether the use of a decrease in aortomesenteric angle between upright and supine positions in the presence of isolated orthostatic proteinuria can be a criterion for the diagnosis of Nutcracker syndrome. Relevant patient information, which included demographic data, clinical examination findings, laboratory data, urinary system ultrasound, and kidney color flow Doppler ultrasound results, were prospectively collected. Thirty-nine pediatric patients with orthostatic proteinuria were included in the study. Left kidney vein compression findings were demonstrated in 31 patients. The ratio of maximum velocities of hilar and aortomesenteric segments of the left kidney vein between upright and supine positions was above 4 in only 7 of our patients. Ratio of aortomesenteric angle between upright and supine positions was significantly decreased for patients with left kidney vein compression findings.  Conclusion: The use of a decrease in the ratio of aortomesenteric angle between upright and supine positions in the presence of orthostatic proteinuria, instead of the ratios for maximum velocities and anterior-posterior diameters of hilar and aortomesenteric segments, can be more helpful for the diagnosis of Nutcracker syndrome in the differential diagnosis of orthostatic proteinuria. What is Known: • Proteinuria may be a sign of an impending kidney disease • Nutcracker syndrome is a cause of orthostatic proteinuria. What is New: • Ratio of aortomesenteric angle between upright and supine positions > 0.6 can be used for Nutcracker syndrome diagnosis.

Bibliometric and visual analysis of research on nutcracker syndrome from 1974 to 2021: A systematic review

BACKGROUND

At present, researchers have obtained fruitful results in the study of nutcracker syndrome (NCS), but there is still a lack of systematic research on the overall status of this disease. This article aims to describe the past and current status of research into NCS, and predict future research trends and popular research topics.

METHODS

Using bibliometric and visualization methods, 552 articles related to NCS collected from the Scopus database from 1974 to 2021 were analyzed from multiple perspectives.

RESULTS

Overall, the amount of literature related to NCS is on the rise every year, and the number of citations is the turning point in 2006. The United States has the largest number of publications and has the most extensive cooperation with other countries. The main contents of the co-authored study focused on the symptoms, surgical procedures, and concomitant diseases of NCS. Keywords such as peak velocity, ultrasonography, orthostatic proteinuria, etc appeared earlier, whereas diagnosis, chronic pelvic pain, endovascular stents, etc appeared later.

CONCLUSIONS

The literature utilization rate of NCS is relatively insufficient. The pathogenesis and pathological mechanisms need to be further studied, and the diagnostic criteria and surgical methods will continue to be favored by clinicians.

[Trampolining-induced gross hematuria : Unmasking the nutcracker syndrome]

The case of a 12-year-old boy with sports-induced recurrent macrohematuria and left-sided flank pain is reported. After extensive laboratory and imaging diagnostics, the diagnosis of nutcracker syndrome is made based on the characteristic clinical manifestation. Under a conservative approach and abstention from the triggering sport, a clinical as well as image-morphologically confirmed maturation occurred.

Nutcracker syndrome: diagnosis and therapy

Nutcracker syndrome (NCS) is an extrinsic compression of the left renal vein (LRV) by the superior mesenteric artery (SMA) anteriorly and aorta posteriorly resulting in renal vascular congestion manifesting as hematuria, proteinuria, orthostatic hypotension, pain, or even renal dysfunction. Long-standing venous compression can encourage collateral drainage pathways through gonadal and pelvic veins, which may explain reported symptom and syndrome overlap with pelvic congestion syndrome. Diagnosis can be challenging and variable, frequently involving a combination of ultrasound Doppler, cross-sectional, and invasive imaging. Often, intravascular pressure measurements are required to prove a renocaval pressure gradient to aid in a definitive diagnosis. Conservative management is appropriate, especially in children, who tend to outgrow the disorder. In the interim, medical management with angiotensin converting enzyme inhibitors (ACEIs) is a useful therapy to manage orthostatic hypotension in the pediatric population. In adults, invasive therapies are more frequently pursued. These are aimed at relieving the extrinsic compression on the LRV. The standard of care is renal vein transposition, with renal autotransplantation reserved for recalcitrant cases. Endovascular stenting is a less invasive option. Laparoscopic placement of an exovascular stent is a newer therapy intended to minimize trauma to the LRV. In this review, we will discuss the clinical manifestations, diagnostic criterion, imaging features, and conservative and surgical therapies for this condition.

Nutcracker Syndrome Masquerading as Renal Colic in an Adolescent Athlete: A Case Report

Introduction

Abdominal pain and flank pain cause a significant proportion of emergency department (ED) visits. The diagnosis often remains unclear and is frequently associated with repeat visits to the ED for the same complaint. A rare cause of left upper abdominal and flank pain is compression of the left renal vein between the aorta and the superior mesenteric artery known as nutcracker syndrome. Diagnostic findings on ultrasound include increased left renal vein diameter proximal and peak blood flow velocity increase distal to the superior mesenteric artery. We describe such a patient presenting to an ED repeatedly with severe pain mimicking renal colic before the final diagnosis and intervention occurred.

Case Report

A 16-year-old female, long-distance runner presented four times complaining of intractable left upper quadrant abdominal pain radiating to the left flank after exercise. On each visit urinalysis revealed proteinuria and hematuria, and on two visits abdominal computed tomography revealed no kidney stone or dilatation of the collecting system. Ultimately, she was referred to vascular surgery where Doppler ultrasonography was used to diagnose left renal vein compression. Transposition of the left renal vein improved Doppler diameter and flow measurements and eliminated symptoms.

Conclusion

Emergency physicians must maintain a large list of possible diagnoses during the evaluation of abdominal and flank pain with a repetitive and uncertain etiology. Nutcracker syndrome may mimic other causes of abdominal and flank pain such as renal colic and requires appropriate referral.

Endovascular management of nutcracker syndrome in an adolescent patient population

BACKGROUND

Nutcracker syndrome is defined as left renal vein compression with concomitant clinical symptoms that include flank pain and hematuria. Historically, pediatric and adolescent patients with mild symptoms of nutcracker syndrome were simply observed while those with more severe symptoms underwent left renal vein transposition. Endovascular stenting of the left renal vein is a potentially efficacious and less invasive alternative for managing nutcracker syndrome in adolescents.

OBJECTIVE

The purpose of this study was to investigate the technical feasibility, efficacy and safety of left renal vein stenting in adolescents with nutcracker syndrome.

MATERIALS AND METHODS

We conducted a retrospective review of electronic medical records and imaging archives to identify adolescents undergoing endovascular stenting for nutcracker syndrome. We reviewed patient demographics including age, gender, presenting symptoms and diagnostic imaging findings. We compared pre- and post-stent deployment intravascular ultrasound (IVUS) and venography and evaluated patient symptoms in clinic up to 6 months following stent placement.

RESULTS

Ten patients (average age 16 years, range 12-20 years) underwent 13 procedures. Initial symptoms included pain (n=10) and gross hematuria (n=5). Diagnostic imaging studies included CT abdomen pelvis (n=8), retroperitoneal US (n=6), MRI abdomen/pelvis (n=4), scrotal US (n=2), pelvic US (n=1) and renal Doppler US (n=2). Venography and IVUS demonstrated venous collaterals, proximal blanching at the left-renal-vein-IVC junction, pre-stenotic dilation and intraluminal compression. Most patients (n=9) experienced symptomatic resolution; however, three patients required reintervention to achieve asymptomatic status. No periprocedural complications occurred.

CONCLUSION

In this carefully selected adolescent cohort, left renal vein stenting for nutcracker syndrome was often technically feasible, safe and effective in symptom management.