A thermally induced phase transition in a viral capsid transforms the hexamers, leaving the pentamers unchanged

A symmetry mismatch unraveled: How phage HK97 scaffold flexibly accommodates a 12-fold pore at a 5-fold viral capsid vertex

Tailed bacteriophages and herpesviruses use a transient scaffold to assemble icosahedral capsids with hexameric capsomers on the faces and pentameric capsomers at all but one vertex where a 12-fold portal is thought to nucleate the assembly. How does the scaffold orchestrate this step? We have determined the portal vertex structure of the bacteriophage HK97 procapsid, where the scaffold is a domain of the major capsid protein. The scaffold forms rigid helix-turn-strand structures on the interior surfaces of all capsomers and is further stabilized around the portal, forming trimeric coiled-coil towers, two per surrounding capsomer. These 10 towers bind identically to 10 of 12 portal subunits, adopting a pseudo-12-fold organization that explains how the symmetry mismatch is managed at this early step.

Structural and Proteomic Characterization of the Initiation of Giant Virus Infection

Since their discovery, giant viruses have expanded our understanding of the principles of virology. Due to their gargantuan size and complexity, little is known about the life cycles of these viruses. To answer outstanding questions regarding giant virus infection mechanisms, we set out to determine biomolecular conditions that promote giant virus genome release. We generated four infection intermediates in Samba virus (Mimivirus genus, lineage A) as visualized by cryoelectron microscopy (cryo-EM), cryoelectron tomography (cryo-ET), and scanning electron microscopy (SEM). Each of these four intermediates reflects similar morphology to a stage that occurs in vivo. We show that these genome release stages are conserved in other mimiviruses. Finally, we identified proteins that are released from Samba and newly discovered Tupanvirus through differential mass spectrometry. Our work revealed the molecular forces that trigger infection are conserved among disparate giant viruses. This study is also the first to identify specific proteins released during the initial stages of giant virus infection.

Structural transitions during the scaffolding-driven assembly of a viral capsid

Assembly of tailed bacteriophages and herpesviruses starts with formation of procapsids (virion precursors without DNA). Scaffolding proteins (SP) drive assembly by chaperoning the major capsid protein (MCP) to build an icosahedral lattice. Here we report near-atomic resolution cryo-EM structures of the bacteriophage SPP1 procapsid, the intermediate expanded procapsid with partially released SPs, and the mature capsid with DNA. In the intermediate state, SPs are bound only to MCP pentons and to adjacent subunits from hexons. SP departure results in the expanded state associated with unfolding of the MCP N-terminus and straightening of E-loops. The newly formed extensive inter-capsomere bonding appears to compensate for release of SPs that clasp MCP capsomeres together. Subsequent DNA packaging instigates bending of MCP A domain loops outwards, closing the hexons central opening and creating the capsid auxiliary protein binding interface. These findings provide a molecular basis for the sequential structural rearrangements during viral capsid maturation.

pH-induced morphological changes of proteinaceous viral shells

Changes in environmental pH can induce morphological changes in empty proteinaceous shells of bacteriophages in vitro that are very similar to changes occurring in viral capsids in vivo after encapsidation of DNA. These changes in capsid shape and size cannot be explained with a simple elastic model alone. We propose a new theoretical framework that combines the elasticity of thin icosahedral shells with the pH dependence of capsid charge distribution. Minimization of the sum of elastic and electrostatic free energies leads to equilibrium shapes of viral shells that depend on a single elastic parameter and the detailed configuration of the imbedded protein charges. Based on the in vitro shell reconstructions of bacteriophage HK97 we elucidate the details of how the reversible transition between Prohead II and Expansion Intermediate II states of the HK97 procapsid is induced by pH changes, as well as some other features of the bacteriophage maturation.

Temperature-Dependent Nanomechanics and Topography of Bacteriophage T7

Viruses are nanoscale infectious agents which may be inactivated by heat treatment. The global molecular mechanisms of virus inactivation and the thermally induced structural changes in viruses are not fully understood. In this study, we measured the heat-induced changes in the properties of T7 bacteriophage particles exposed to a two-stage (65°C and 80°C) thermal effect, by using atomic force microscopy (AFM)-based nanomechanical and topographical measurements. We found that exposure to 65°C led to the release of genomic DNA and to the loss of the capsid tail; hence, the T7 particles became destabilized. Further heating to 80°C surprisingly led to an increase in mechanical stability, due likely to partial denaturation of the capsomeric proteins kept within the global capsid arrangement.IMPORTANCE Even though the loss of DNA, caused by heat treatment, destabilizes the T7 phage, its capsid is remarkably able to withstand high temperatures with a more or less intact global topographical structure. Thus, partial denaturation within the global structural constraints of the viral capsid may have a stabilizing effect. Understanding the structural design of viruses may help in constructing artificial nanocapsules for the packaging and delivery of materials under harsh environmental conditions.

On the catalytic mechanism of bacteriophage HK97 capsid crosslinking

During maturation of the phage HK97 capsid, each of the 415 capsid subunits forms covalent bonds to neighboring subunits, stabilizing the capsid. Crosslinking is catalyzed not by a separate enzyme but by subunits of the assembled capsid in response to conformational rearrangements during maturation. This report investigates the catalytic mechanism. Earlier work established that the crosslinks are isopeptide (amide) bonds between side chains of a lysine on one subunit and an asparagine on another subunit, aided by a catalytic glutamate on a third subunit. The mature capsid structure suggests that the reaction may be facilitated by the arrival of a valine with the lysine to complete a hydrophobic pocket surrounding the glutamate, lysine and asparagine. We show that this valine has an essential role for efficient crosslinking, and that any of six other amino acids can successfully substitute for valine. Evidently none of the remaining 13 amino acids will work.

Metastable intermediates as stepping stones on the maturation pathways of viral capsids

As they mature, many capsids undergo massive conformational changes that transform their stability, reactivity, and capacity for DNA. In some cases, maturation proceeds via one or more intermediate states. These structures represent local minima in a rich energy landscape that combines contributions from subunit folding, association of subunits into capsomers, and intercapsomer interactions. We have used scanning calorimetry and cryo-electron microscopy to explore the range of capsid conformations accessible to bacteriophage HK97. To separate conformational effects from those associated with covalent cross-linking (a stabilization mechanism of HK97), a cross-link-incompetent mutant was used. The mature capsid Head I undergoes an endothermic phase transition at 60°C in which it shrinks by 7%, primarily through changes in its hexamer conformation. The transition is reversible, with a half-life of ~3 min; however, >50% of reverted capsids are severely distorted or ruptured. This observation implies that such damage is a potential hazard of large-scale structural changes such as those involved in maturation. Assuming that the risk is lower for smaller changes, this suggests a rationalization for the existence of metastable intermediates: that they serve as stepping stones that preserve capsid integrity as it switches between the radically different conformations of its precursor and mature states.

Large-scale conformational changes are widespread in virus maturation and infection processes. These changes are accompanied by the release of conformational free energy as the virion (or fusogenic glycoprotein) switches from a precursor state to its mature state. Each state corresponds to a local minimum in an energy landscape. The conformational changes in capsid maturation are so radical that the question arises of how maturing capsids avoid being torn apart. Offering proof of principle, severe damage is inflicted when a bacteriophage HK97 capsid reverts from the (nonphysiological) state that it enters when heated past 60°C. We suggest that capsid proteins have been selected in part by the criterion of being able to avoid sustaining collateral damage as they mature. One way of achieving this—as with the HK97 capsid—involves breaking the overall transition down into several smaller steps in which the risk of damage is reduced.

Transient contacts on the exterior of the HK97 procapsid that are essential for capsid assembly

The G-loop is a 10-residue glycine-rich loop that protrudes from the surface of the mature bacteriophage HK97 capsid at the C-terminal end of the long backbone helix of major capsid protein subunits. The G-loop is essential for assembly, is conserved in related capsid and encapsulin proteins, and plays its role during HK97 capsid assembly by making crucial contacts between the hill-like hexamers and pentamers in precursor proheads. These contacts are not preserved in the flattened capsomers of the mature capsid. Aspartate 231 in each of the ~400 G-loops interacts with lysine 178 of the E-loop (extended loop) of a subunit on an adjacent capsomer. Mutations disrupting this interaction prevented correct assembly and, in some cases, induced abnormal assembly into tubes, or small, incomplete capsids. Assembly remained defective when D231 and K178 were replaced with larger charged residues or when their positions were exchanged. Second-site suppressors of lethal mutants containing substitution D231L replaced the ionic interaction with new interactions between neutral and hydrophobic residues of about the same size: D231L/K178V, D231L/K178I, and D231L/K178N. We conclude that it is not the charge but the size and shape of the side chains of residues 178 and 231 that are important. These two residues control the geometry of contacts between the E-loop and the G-loop, which apparently must be precisely spaced and oriented for correct assembly to occur. We present a model for how the G-loop could control HK97 assembly and identify G-loop-like protrusions in other capsid proteins that may play analogous roles.

Architecture of a dsDNA viral capsid in complex with its maturation protease

Most double-stranded DNA (dsDNA) viruses, including bacteriophages and herpesviruses, rely on a staged assembly process of capsid formation. A viral protease is required for many of them to disconnect scaffolding domains/proteins from the capsid shell, therefore priming the maturation process. We used the bacteriophage HK97 as a model system to decipher the molecular mechanisms underlying the recruitment of the maturation protease by the assembling procapsid and the influence exerted onto the latter. Comparisons of the procapsid with and without protease using single-particle cryoelectron microscopy reconstructions, hydrogen/deuterium exchange coupled to mass spectrometry, and native mass spectrometry demonstrated that the protease interacts with the scaffolding domains within the procapsid interior and stabilizes them as well as the whole particle. The results suggest that the thermodynamic consequences of protease packaging are to shift the equilibrium between isolated coat subunit capsomers and procapsid in favor of the latter by stabilizing the assembled particle before making the process irreversible through proteolysis of the scaffolding domains.

Rescue of maturation off-pathway products in the assembly of Pseudomonas phage φ 6

Many complex viruses use an assembly pathway in which their genome is packaged into an empty procapsid which subsequently matures into its final expanded form. We utilized Pseudomonas phage 6, a well-established virus assembly model, to probe the plasticity of the procapsid maturation pathway. The 6 packaging nucleoside triphosphatase (NTPase), which powers sequential translocation of the three viral genomic single-stranded RNA molecules to the procapsid during capsid maturation, is part of the mature 6 virion but may spontaneously be dissociated from the procapsid shell. We demonstrate that the dissociation of NTPase subunits results in premature capsid expansion, which is detected as a change in the sedimentation velocity and as defects in RNA packaging and transcription activity. However, this dead-end conformation of the procapsids was rescued by the addition of purified NTPase hexamers, which efficiently associated on the NTPase-deficient particles and subsequently drove their contraction to the compact naive conformation. The resulting particles regained their biological and enzymatic activities, directing them into a productive maturation pathway. These observations imply that the maturation pathways of complex viruses may contain reversible steps that allow the rescue of the off-pathway conformation in an overall unidirectional virion assembly pathway. Furthermore, we provide direct experimental evidence that particles which have different physical properties (distinct sedimentation velocities and conformations) display different stages of the genome packaging program and show that the transcriptional activity of the 6 procapsids correlates with the number of associated NTPase subunits.

Functional domains of the HK97 capsid maturation protease and the mechanisms of protein encapsidation

Tailed double-stranded DNA bacteriophages and herpesviruses build capsids by co-assembling a major capsid protein with an internal scaffolding protein that then exits from the assembled structure either intact or after digestion in situ by a protease. In bacteriophage HK97, the 102-residue N-terminal delta domain of the major capsid protein is also removed by proteolysis after assembly and appears to perform the scaffolding function. We describe the HK97 protease that carries out these maturation cleavages. Insertion mutations at seven sites in the protease gene produced mutant proteins that assemble into proheads, and those in the N-terminal two-thirds were enzymatically inactive. Plasmid-expressed protease was rapidly cleaved in vivo but was stabilized by co-expression with the delta domain. Purified protease was found to be active during the assembly of proheads in vitro. Heterologous fusions to the intact protease or to C-terminal fragments targeted fusion proteins into proheads. We confirm that the catalytic activity resides in the N-terminal two-thirds of the protease polypeptide and suggest that the C-terminal one-fifth of the protein contains a capsid targeting signal. The implications of this arrangement are compared to capsid targeting systems in other phages, herpesviruses, and encapsulins.

Tubular crystals and helical arrays: structural determination of HIV-1 capsid assemblies using iterative helical real-space reconstruction

Helical structures are important in many different life forms and are well-suited for structural studies by cryo-EM. A unique feature of helical objects is that a single projection image contains all the views needed to perform a three-dimensional (3D) crystallographic reconstruction. Here, we use HIV-1 capsid assemblies to illustrate the detailed approaches to obtain 3D density maps from helical objects. Mature HIV-1 particles contain a conical- or tubular-shaped capsid that encloses the viral RNA genome and performs essential functions in the virus life cycle. The capsid is composed of capsid protein (CA) oligomers which are helically arranged on the surface. The N-terminal domain (NTD) of CA is connected to its C-terminal domain (CTD) through a flexible hinge. Structural analysis of two- and three-dimensional crystals provided molecular models of the capsid protein (CA) and its oligomer forms. We determined the 3D density map of helically assembled HIV-1 CA hexamers at 16 Å resolution using an iterative helical real-space reconstruction method. Docking of atomic models of CA-NTD and CA-CTD dimer into the electron density map indicated that the CTD dimer interface is retained in the assembled CA. Furthermore, molecular docking revealed an additional, novel CTD trimer interface.

Involvement of the major capsid protein and two early-expressed phage genes in the activity of the lactococcal abortive infection mechanism AbiT

The dairy industry uses the mesophilic, Gram-positive, lactic acid bacterium (LAB) Lactococcus lactis to produce an array of fermented milk products. Milk fermentation processes are susceptible to contamination by virulent phages, but a plethora of phage control strategies are available. One of the most efficient is to use LAB strains carrying phage resistance systems such as abortive infection (Abi) mechanisms. Yet, the mode of action of most Abi systems remains poorly documented. Here, we shed further light on the antiviral activity of the lactococcal AbiT system. Twenty-eight AbiT-resistant phage mutants derived from the wild-type AbiT-sensitive lactococcal phages p2, bIL170, and P008 were isolated and characterized. Comparative genomic analyses identified three different genes that were mutated in these virulent AbiT-insensitive phage derivatives: e14 (bIL170 [e14(bIL170)]), orf41 (P008 [orf41(P008)]), and orf6 (p2 [orf6(p2)] and P008 [orf6(P008)]). The genes e14(bIL170) and orf41(P008) are part of the early-expressed genomic region, but bioinformatic analyses did not identify their putative function. orf6 is found in the phage morphogenesis module. Antibodies were raised against purified recombinant ORF6, and immunoelectron microscopy revealed that it is the major capsid protein (MCP). Coexpression in L. lactis of ORF6(p2) and ORF5(p2), a protease, led to the formation of procapsids. To our knowledge, AbiT is the first Abi system involving distinct phage genes.

Thermodynamic characterization of viral procapsid expansion into a functional capsid shell

The assembly of "complex" DNA viruses such as the herpesviruses and many tailed bacteriophages includes a DNA packaging step where the viral genome is inserted into a preformed procapsid shell. Packaging triggers a remarkable capsid expansion transition that results in thinning of the shell and an increase in capsid volume to accept the full-length genome. This transition is considered irreversible; however, here we demonstrate that the phage λ procapsid can be expanded with urea in vitro and that the transition is fully reversible. This provides an unprecedented opportunity to evaluate the thermodynamic features of this fascinating and essential step in virus assembly. We show that urea-triggered expansion is highly cooperative and strongly temperature dependent. Thermodynamic analysis indicates that the free energy of expansion is influenced by magnesium concentration (3-13 kcal/mol in the presence of 0.2-10 mM Mg(2+)) and that significant hydrophobic surface area is exposed in the expanded shell. Conversely, Mg(2+) drives the expanded shell back to the procapsid conformation in a highly cooperative transition that is also temperature dependent and strongly influenced by urea. We demonstrate that the gpD decoration protein adds to the urea-expanded capsid, presumably at hydrophobic patches exposed at the 3-fold axes of the expanded capsid lattice. The decorated capsid is biologically active and sponsors packaging of the viral genome in vitro. The roles of divalent metal and hydrophobic interactions in controlling packaging-triggered expansion of the procapsid shell are discussed in relation to a general mechanism for DNA-triggered procapsid expansion in the complex double-stranded DNA viruses.

Virus maturation

We examine virus maturation of selected nonenveloped and enveloped single-stranded RNA viruses, retroviruses, bacteriophages, and herpesviruses. Processes associated with maturation in the RNA viruses range from subtle (nodaviruses and picornaviruses) to dramatic (tetraviruses and togaviruses). The elaborate assembly and maturation pathway of HIV is discussed in contrast to the less sophisticated but highly efficient processes associated with togaviruses. Bacteriophage assembly and maturation are discussed in general terms, with specific examples chosen for emphasis. Finally the herpesviruses are compared with bacteriophages. The data support divergent evolution of nodaviruses, picornaviruses, and tetraviruses from a common ancestor and divergent evolution of alphaviruses and flaviviruses from a common ancestor. Likewise, bacteriophages and herpesviruses almost certainly share a common ancestor in their evolution. Comparing all the viruses, we conclude that maturation is a convergent process that is required to solve conflicting requirements in biological dynamics and function.

The Prohead-I structure of bacteriophage HK97: implications for scaffold-mediated control of particle assembly and maturation

Virus capsid assembly requires recruiting and organizing multiple copies of protein subunits to form a closed shell for genome packaging that leads to infectivity. Many viruses encode scaffolding proteins to shift the equilibrium toward particle formation by promoting intersubunit interactions and stabilizing assembly intermediates. Bacteriophage HK97 lacks an explicit scaffolding protein, but the capsid protein (gp5) contains a scaffold-like N-terminal segment termed the delta domain. When gp5 is expressed in Escherichia coli, the delta domain guides 420 copies of the subunit into a procapsid with T=7 laevo icosahedral symmetry named Prohead-I. Prohead-I can be disassembled and reassembled under mild conditions and it cannot mature further. When the virally encoded protease (gp4) is coexpressed with gp5, it is incorporated into the capsid and digests the delta domain followed by autoproteolysis to produce the metastable Prohead-II. Prohead-I(+P) was isolated by coexpressing gp5 and an inactive mutant of gp4. Prohead-I and Prohead-I(+P) were compared by biochemical methods, revealing that the inactive protease stabilized the capsid against disassembly by chemical or physical stress. The crystal structure of Prohead-I(+P) was determined at 5.2 Å resolution, and distortions were observed in the subunit tertiary structures similar to those observed previously in Prohead-II. Prohead-I(+P) differed from Prohead-II due to the presence of the delta domain and the resulting repositioning of the N-arms, explaining why Prohead-I can be reversibly dissociated and cannot mature. Low-resolution X-ray data enhanced the density of the relatively dynamic delta domains, revealing their quaternary arrangement and suggesting how they drive proper assembly.

A hypothesis for bacteriophage DNA packaging motors

The hypothesis is presented that bacteriophage DNA packaging motors have a cycle comprised of bind/release thermal ratcheting with release-associated DNA pushing via ATP-dependent protein folding. The proposed protein folding occurs in crystallographically observed peptide segments that project into an axial channel of a protein 12-mer (connector) that serves, together with a coaxial ATPase multimer, as the entry portal. The proposed cycle begins when reverse thermal motion causes the connector’s peptide segments to signal the ATPase multimer to bind both ATP and the DNA molecule, thereby producing a dwell phase recently demonstrated by single-molecule procedures. The connector-associated peptide segments activate by transfer of energy from ATP during the dwell. The proposed function of connector/ATPase symmetry mismatches is to reduce thermal noise-induced signaling errors. After a dwell, ATP is cleaved and the DNA molecule released. The activated peptide segments push the released DNA molecule, thereby producing a burst phase recently shown to consist of four mini-bursts. The constraint of four mini-bursts is met by proposing that each mini-burst occurs via pushing by three of the 12 subunits of the connector. If all four mini-bursts occur, the cycle repeats. If the mini-bursts are not completed, a second cycle is superimposed on the first cycle. The existence of the second cycle is based on data recently obtained with bacteriophage T3. When both cycles stall, energy is diverted to expose the DNA molecule to maturation cleavage.

P22 coat protein structures reveal a novel mechanism for capsid maturation: stability without auxiliary proteins or chemical crosslinks

Viral capsid assembly and stability in tailed, dsDNA phage and Herpesviridae are achieved by various means including chemical crosslinks (unique to HK97), or auxiliary proteins (lambda, T4, phi29, and herpesviruses). All these viruses have coat proteins (CP) with a conserved, HK97-like core structure. We used a combination of trypsin digestion, gold labeling, cryo-electron microscopy, 3D image reconstruction, and comparative modeling to derive two independent, pseudoatomic models of bacteriophage P22 CP: before and after maturation. P22 capsid stabilization results from intersubunit interactions among N-terminal helices and an extensive "P loop," which obviate the need for crosslinks or auxiliary proteins. P22 CP also has a telokin-like Ig domain that likely stabilizes the monomer fold so that assembly may proceed via individual subunit addition rather than via preformed capsomers as occurs in HK97. Hence, the P22 CP structure may be a paradigm for understanding how monomers assemble in viruses like phi29 and HSV-1.

In vitro assembly of the T=13 procapsid of bacteriophage T5 with its scaffolding domain

The Siphoviridae coliphage T5 differs from other members of this family by the size of its genome (121 kbp) and by its large icosahedral capsid (90 nm), which is organized with T=13 geometry. T5 does not encode a separate scaffolding protein, but its head protein, pb8, contains a 159-residue aminoterminal scaffolding domain (Delta domain) that is the mature capsid. We have deciphered the early events of T5 shell assembly starting from purified pb8 with its Delta domain (pb8p). The self assembly of pb8p is regulated by salt conditions and leads to structures with distinct morphologies. Expanded tubes are formed in the presence of NaCl, whereas Ca(2+) promotes the association of pb8p into contracted tubes and procapsids. Procapsids display an angular organization and 20-nm-long internal radial structures identified as the Delta domain. The T5 head maturation protease pb11 specifically cleaves the Delta domain of contracted and expanded tubes. Ca(2+) is not required for proteolytic activity but for the organization of the Delta domain. Taken together, these data indicate that pb8p carries all of the information in its primary sequence to assemble in vitro without the requirement of the portal and accessory proteins. Furthermore, Ca(2+) plays a key role in introducing the conformational diversity that permits the formation of a stable procapsid. Phage T5 is the first example of a viral capsid consisting of quasi-equivalent hexamers and pentamers whose assembly can be carried out in vitro, starting from the major head protein with its scaffolding domain, and whose endpoint is an icosahedral T=13 particle.

Virus particle maturation: insights into elegantly programmed nanomachines

Similar modes of virus maturation have been observed in dsDNA bacteriophages and the structurally related herpes viruses and some type of maturation occur in most animal viruses. Recently a variety of biophysical studies of maturation intermediates of bacteriophages P22, lambda, and HK97 have suggested an energy landscape that drives the transitions and structure-based mechanisms for its formation. Near-atomic resolution models of subunit tertiary structures in an early intermediate of bacteriophage HK97 maturation revealed a remarkable distortion of the secondary structures when compared to the mature particle. Scaffolding proteins may induce the distortion that is maintained by quaternary structure interactions following scaffold release, making the intermediate particle metastable.

Critical salt bridges guide capsid assembly, stability, and maturation behavior in bacteriophage HK97

HK97 is a double-stranded DNA bacteriophage that undergoes dramatic conformational changes during viral capsid maturation and for which x-ray structures, at near atomic resolution, of multiple intermediate and mature capsid states are available. Both amide H/(2)H exchange and crystallographic comparisons between the pre-expanded Prohead II particles and the expanded Head II of bacteriophage HK97 revealed quaternary interactions that remain fixed throughout maturation and appear to maintain intercapsomer integrity at all quasi- and icosahedral 3-fold axes. These 3-fold staples are formed from Arg and Glu residues and a metal binding site. Mutations of either Arg-347 or Arg-194 or a double mutation of E344Q and E363A resulted in purification of the phage in capsomer form (hexamers and pentamers). Mutants that did assemble had both decreased thermal stability and decreased in vitro expansion rates. Amide H/(2)H exchange mass spectrometry showed that in the wild type capsid some subunits had a bent "spine" helix (highly exchanging), whereas others were straight (less exchanging). Similar analysis of the never assembled mutant capsomers showed uniform amide exchange in all of these that was higher than that of the straight spine helices (characterized in more mature intermediates), suggesting that the spine helix is somewhat bent prior to capsid assembly. The result further supports a previously proposed mechanism for capsid expansion in which the delta domains of each subunit induce a high energy intermediate conformation, which now appears to include a bent helix during capsomer assembly.

Periodic table of virus capsids: implications for natural selection and design

BACKGROUND

For survival, most natural viruses depend upon the existence of spherical capsids: protective shells of various sizes composed of protein subunits. So far, general evolutionary pressures shaping capsid design have remained elusive, even though an understanding of such properties may help in rationally impeding the virus life cycle and designing efficient nano-assemblies.

PRINCIPAL FINDINGS

This report uncovers an unprecedented and species-independent evolutionary pressure on virus capsids, based on the the notion that the simplest capsid designs (or those capsids with the lowest "hexamer complexity", C(h)) are the fittest, which was shown to be true for all available virus capsids. The theories result in a physically meaningful periodic table of virus capsids that uncovers strong and overarching evolutionary pressures, while also offering geometric explanations to other capsid properties (rigidity, pleomorphy, auxiliary requirements, etc.) that were previously considered to be unrelatable properties of the individual virus.

SIGNIFICANCE

Apart from describing a universal rule for virus capsid evolution, our work (especially the periodic table) provides a language with which highly diverse virus capsids, unified only by geometry, may be described and related to each other. Finally, the available virus structure databases and other published data reiterate the predicted geometry-derived rules, reinforcing the role of geometry in the natural selection and design of virus capsids.

Structure and function of a genetically engineered mimic of a nonenveloped virus entry intermediate

Divalent metal ions are components of numerous icosahedral virus capsids. Flock House virus (FHV), a small RNA virus of the family Nodaviridae, was utilized as an accessible model system with which to address the effects of metal ions on capsid structure and on the biology of virus-host interactions. Mutations at the calcium-binding sites affected FHV capsid stability and drastically reduced virus infectivity, without altering the overall architecture of the capsid. The mutations also altered the conformation of gamma, a membrane-disrupting, virus-encoded peptide usually sequestered inside the capsid, by increasing its exposure under neutral pH conditions. Our data demonstrate that calcium binding is essential for maintaining a pH-based control on gamma exposure and host membrane disruption, and they reveal a novel rationale for the metal ion requirement during virus entry and infectivity. In the light of the phenotypes displayed by a calcium site mutant of FHV, we suggest that this mutant corresponds to an early entry intermediate formed in the endosomal pathway.

DNA heats up: energetics of genome ejection from phage revealed by isothermal titration calorimetry

Most bacteriophages are known to inject their double-stranded DNA into bacteria upon receptor binding in an essentially spontaneous way. This downhill thermodynamic process from the intact virion to the empty viral capsid plus released DNA is made possible by the energy stored during active packaging of the genome into the capsid. Only indirect measurements of this energy have been available until now, using either single-molecule or osmotic suppression techniques. In this work, we describe for the first time the use of isothermal titration calorimetry to directly measure the heat released (or, equivalently, the enthalpy) during DNA ejection from phage lambda, triggered in solution by a solubilized receptor. Quantitative analyses of the results lead to the identification of thermodynamic determinants associated with DNA ejection. The values obtained were found to be consistent with those previously predicted by analytical models and numerical simulations. Moreover, the results confirm the role of DNA hydration in the energetics of genome confinement in viral capsids.

Structure and energetics of encapsidated DNA in bacteriophage HK97 studied by scanning calorimetry and cryo-electron microscopy

Encapsidation of duplex DNA by bacteriophages represents an extreme case of genome condensation, reaching near-crystalline concentrations of DNA. The HK97 system is well suited to study this phenomenon in view of the detailed knowledge of its capsid structure. To characterize the interactions involved, we combined calorimetry with cryo-electron microscopy and native gel electrophoresis. We found that, as in other phages, HK97 DNA is organized in coaxially wound nested shells. When DNA-filled capsids (heads) are scanned in buffer containing 1 mM Mg(2+), DNA melting and capsid denaturation both contribute to the complex thermal profile between 82 degrees C and 96 degrees C. In other conditions (absence of Mg(2+) and lower ionic strength), DNA melting shifts to lower temperatures and the two events are resolved. Heads release their DNA at temperatures well below the onset of DNA melting or capsid denaturation. We suggest that, on heating, the internal pressure increases, causing the DNA to exit-probably via the portal vertex-while the capsid, although largely intact, sustains local damage that leads to an earlier onset of thermal denaturation. Heads differ structurally from empty capsids in the curvature of their protein shell, a change attributable to outwards pressure exerted by the DNA. We propose that this transition is sensed by the portal that is embedded in the capsid wall, whereupon the structure of the portal and its interactions with terminase, the packaging enzyme, are altered, thus signaling that packaging is at or approaching completion.

Geometric considerations in virus capsid size specificity, auxiliary requirements, and buckling

Spherical capsids are shells of protein subunits that protect the genomes of many viral strains. Although nature displays a range of spherical capsid sizes (reflected by the number of subunits in the formation), specific strains display stringent requirements for forming capsids of specific sizes, a requirement that appears crucial to infectivity. Despite its importance in pathogenicity, little is known regarding the determinants of capsid size. Still less is known about exactly which capsids can undergo maturation events such as buckling transitions--postcapsid-assembly events that are crucial to some virus strains. We show that the exclusive determinant of capsid size is hexamer shape, as defined by subunit-subunit dihedral angles. This conclusion arises from considering the dihedral angle patterns within hexamers belonging to natural canonical capsids and geometric capsid models (deltahedra). From simple geometric models and an understanding of endo angle propagation discussed here, we then suggest that buckling transitions may be available only to capsids of certain size (specifically, T < 7 capsids are precluded from such transformations) and that T > 7 capsids require the help of auxiliary mechanisms for proper capsid formation. These predictions, arising from simple geometry and modeling, are backed by a body of empirical evidence, further reinforcing the extent to which the evolution of the atomistically complex virus capsid may be principled around simple geometric design/requirements.

An unexpected twist in viral capsid maturation

Lambda-like double-stranded (ds) DNA bacteriophage undergo massive conformational changes in their capsid shell during the packaging of their viral genomes. Capsid shells are complex organizations of hundreds of protein subunits that assemble into intricate quaternary complexes that ultimately are able to withstand over 50 atm of pressure during genome packaging. The extensive integration between subunits in capsids requires the formation of an intermediate complex, termed a procapsid, from which individual subunits can undergo the necessary refolding and structural rearrangements needed to transition to the more stable capsid. Although various mature capsids have been characterized at atomic resolution, no such procapsid structure is available for a dsDNA virus or bacteriophage. Here we present a procapsid X-ray structure at 3.65 A resolution, termed prohead II, of the lambda-like bacteriophage HK97, the mature capsid structure of which was previously solved to 3.44 A (ref. 2). A comparison of the two largely different capsid forms has unveiled an unprecedented expansion mechanism that describes the transition. Crystallographic and hydrogen/deuterium exchange data presented here demonstrate that the subunit tertiary structures are significantly different between the two states, with twisting and bending motions occurring in both helical and beta-sheet regions. We also identified subunit interactions at each three-fold axis of the capsid that are maintained throughout maturation. The interactions sustain capsid integrity during subunit refolding and provide a fixed hinge from which subunits undergo rotational and translational motions during maturation. Previously published calorimetric data of a closely related bacteriophage, P22, showed that capsid maturation was an exothermic process that resulted in a release of 90 kJ mol(-1) of energy. We propose that the major tertiary changes presented in this study reveal a structural basis for an exothermic maturation process probably present in many dsDNA bacteriophage and possibly viruses such as herpesvirus, which share the HK97 subunit fold.

Unfolding thermodynamics of the Delta-domain in the prohead I subunit of phage HK97: determination by factor analysis of Raman spectra

An early step in the morphogenesis of the double-stranded DNA (dsDNA) bacteriophage HK97 is the assembly of a precursor shell (prohead I) from 420 copies of a 384-residue subunit (gp5). Although formation of prohead I requires direct participation of gp5 residues 2-103 (Delta-domain), this domain is eliminated by viral protease prior to subsequent shell maturation and DNA packaging. The prohead I Delta-domain is thought to resemble a phage scaffolding protein, by virtue of its highly alpha-helical secondary structure and a tertiary fold that projects inward from the interior surface of the shell. Here, we employ factor analysis of temperature-dependent Raman spectra to characterize the thermostability of the Delta-domain secondary structure and to quantify the thermodynamic parameters of Delta-domain unfolding. The results are compared for the Delta-domain within the prohead I architecture (in situ) and for a recombinantly expressed 111-residue peptide (in vitro). We find that the alpha-helicity (approximately 70%), median melting temperature (T(m)=58 degrees C), enthalpy (DeltaH(m)=50+/-5 kcal mol(-1)), entropy (DeltaS(m)=150+/-10 cal mol(-1) K(-1)), and average cooperative melting unit (n(c) approximately 3.5) of the in situ Delta-domain are altered in vitro, indicating specific interdomain interactions within prohead I. Thus, the in vitro Delta-domain, despite an enhanced helical secondary structure ( approximately 90% alpha-helix), exhibits diminished thermostability (T(m)=40 degrees C; DeltaH(m)=27+/-2 kcal mol(-1); DeltaS(m)=86+/-6 cal mol(-1) K(-1)) and noncooperative unfolding ( approximately 1) vis-à-vis the in situ Delta-domain. Temperature-dependent Raman markers of subunit side chains, particularly those of Phe and Trp residues, also confirm different local interactions for the in situ and in vitro Delta-domains. The present results clarify the key role of the gp5 Delta-domain in prohead I architecture by providing direct evidence of domain structure stabilization and interdomain interactions within the assembled shell.

The thermodynamics of virus capsid assembly

Virus capsid assembly is a critical step in the viral life cycle. The underlying basis of capsid stability is key to understanding this process. Capsid subunits interact with weak individual contact energies to form a globally stable icosahedral lattice; this structure is ideal for encapsidating the viral genome and host partners and protecting its contents upon secretion, yet the unique properties of its assembly and inter-subunit contacts allow the capsid to dissociate upon entering a new host cell. The stability of the capsid can be analyzed by treating capsid assembly as an equilibrium polymerization reaction, modified from the traditional polymer model to account for the fact that a separate nucleus is formed for each individual capsid. From the concentrations of reactants and products in an equilibrated assembly reaction, it is possible to extract the thermodynamic parameters of assembly for a wide array of icosahedral viruses using well-characterized biochemical and biophysical methods. In this chapter we describe this basic analysis and provide examples of thermodynamic assembly data for several different icosahedral viruses. These data provide new insights into the assembly mechanisms of spherical virus capsids, as well as into the biology of the viral life cycle.

Biophysics of viral infectivity: matching genome length with capsid size

In this review, we discuss recent advances in biophysical virology, presenting experimental and theoretical studies on the physical properties of viruses. We focus on the double-stranded (ds) DNA bacteriophages as model systems for all of the dsDNA viruses both prokaryotic and eukaryotic. Recent studies demonstrate that the DNA packaged into a viral capsid is highly pressurized, which provides a force for the first step of passive injection of viral DNA into a bacterial cell. Moreover, specific studies on capsid strength show a strong correlation between genome length, and capsid size and robustness. The implications of these newly appreciated physical properties of a viral particle with respect to the infection process are discussed.