Nucleotide dependent packing differences in helical crystals of the ABC transporter MsbA

What monomeric nucleotide binding domains can teach us about dimeric ABC proteins

The classic conceptualization of ATP binding cassette (ABC) transporter function is an ATP-dependent conformational change coupled to transport of a substrate across a biological membrane via the transmembrane domains (TMDs). The binding of two ATP molecules within the transporter's two nucleotide binding domains (NBDs) induces their dimerization. Despite retaining the ability to bind nucleotides, isolated NBDs frequently fail to dimerize. ABC proteins without a TMD, for example ABCE and ABCF, have NBDs tethered via elaborate linkers, further supporting that NBD dimerization does not readily occur for isolated NBDs. Intriguingly, even in full-length transporters, the NBD-dimerized, outward-facing state is not as frequently observed as might be expected. This leads to questions regarding what drives NBD interaction and the role of the TMDs or linkers. Understanding the NBD-nucleotide interaction and the subsequent NBD dimerization is thus pivotal for understanding ABC transporter activity in general. Here, we hope to provide new insights into ABC protein function by discussing the perplexing issue of (missing) NBD dimerization in isolation and in the context of full-length ABC proteins.

The ABC exporter MsbA probed by solid state NMR – challenges and opportunities

ATP binding cassette (ABC) transporters form a superfamily of integral membrane proteins involved in translocation of substrates across the membrane driven by ATP hydrolysis. Despite available crystal structures and extensive biochemical data, many open questions regarding their transport mechanisms remain. Therefore, there is a need to explore spectroscopic techniques such as solid state NMR in order to bridge the gap between structural and mechanistic data. In this study, we investigate the feasibility of using Escherichia coli MsbA as a model ABC transporter for solid state NMR studies. We show that optimised solubilisation and reconstitution procedures enable preparing stable and homogenous protein samples. Depending on the duration of solubilisation, MsbA can be obtained in either an apo- or in a native lipid A bound form. Building onto these optimisations, the first promising MAS-NMR spectra with narrow lines have been recorded. However, further sensitivity improvements are required so that complex NMR experiments can be recorded within a reasonable amount of time. We therefore demonstrate the usability of paramagnetic doping for rapid data acquisition and explore dynamic nuclear polarisation as a method for general signal enhancement. Our results demonstrate that solid state NMR provides an opportunity to address important biological questions related to complex mechanisms of ABC transporters.

Deducing the symmetry of helical assemblies: Applications to membrane proteins

Helical reconstruction represents a convenient and powerful approach for structure determination of macromolecules that assemble into helical arrays. In the case of membrane proteins, formation of tubular crystals with helical symmetry represents an attractive alternative, especially when their small size precludes the use of single-particle analysis. An essential first step for helical reconstruction is to characterize the helical symmetry. This process is often daunting, due to the complexity of helical diffraction and to the low signal-to-noise ratio in images of individual assemblies. Furthermore, the large diameters of the tubular crystals produced by membrane proteins exacerbates the innate ambiguities that, if not resolved, will produce incorrect structures. In this report, we describe a set of tools that can be used to eliminate ambiguities and to validate the choice of symmetry. The first approach increases the signal-to-noise ratio along layer lines by incoherently summing data from multiple helical assemblies, thus producing several candidate indexing schemes. The second approach compares the layer lines from images with those from synthetic models built with the various candidate schemes. The third approach uses unit cell dimensions measured from collapsed tubes to distinguish between these candidate schemes. These approaches are illustrated with tubular crystals from a boron transporter from yeast, Bor1p, and a β-barrel channel from the outer membrane of E. coli, OmpF.

Structure, mechanism and cooperation of bacterial multidrug transporters

Cells from all domains of life encode energy-dependent trans-membrane transporters that can expel harmful substances including clinically applied therapeutic agents. As a collective body, these transporters perform as a super-system that confers tolerance to an enormous range of harmful compounds and consequently aid survival in hazardous environments. In the Gram-negative bacteria, some of these transporters serve as energy-transducing components of tripartite assemblies that actively efflux drugs and other harmful compounds, as well as deliver virulence agents across the entire cell envelope. We draw together recent structural and functional data to present the current models for the transport mechanisms for the main classes of multi-drug transporters and their higher-order assemblies.

3D cryo-electron reconstruction of BmrA, a bacterial multidrug ABC transporter in an inward-facing conformation and in a lipidic environment

ABC (ATP-binding cassette) membrane exporters are efflux transporters of a wide diversity of molecule across the membrane at the expense of ATP. A key issue regarding their catalytic cycle is whether or not their nucleotide-binding domains (NBDs) are physically disengaged in the resting state. To settle this controversy, we obtained structural data on BmrA, a bacterial multidrug homodimeric ABC transporter, in a membrane-embedded state. BmrA in the apostate was reconstituted in lipid bilayers forming a mixture of ring-shaped structures of 24 or 39 homodimers. Three-dimensional models of the ring-shaped structures of 24 or 39 homodimers were calculated at 2.3 nm and 2.5 nm resolution from cryo-electron microscopy, respectively. In these structures, BmrA adopts an inward-facing open conformation similar to that found in mouse P-glycoprotein structure with the NBDs separated by 3 nm. Both lipidic leaflets delimiting the transmembrane domains of BmrA were clearly resolved. In planar membrane sheets, the NBDs were even more separated. BmrA in an ATP-bound conformation was determined from two-dimensional crystals grown in the presence of ATP and vanadate. A projection map calculated at 1.6 nm resolution shows an open outward-facing conformation. Overall, the data are consistent with a mechanism of drug transport involving large conformational changes of BmrA and show that a bacterial ABC exporter can adopt at least two open inward conformations in lipid membrane.

Molecular disruption of the power stroke in the ATP-binding cassette transport protein MsbA

ATP-binding cassette transporters affect drug pharmacokinetics and are associated with inherited human diseases and impaired chemotherapeutic treatment of cancers and microbial infections. Current alternating access models for ATP-binding cassette exporter activity suggest that ATP binding at the two cytosolic nucleotide-binding domains provides a power stroke for the conformational switch of the two membrane domains from the inward-facing conformation to the outward-facing conformation. In outward-facing crystal structures of the bacterial homodimeric ATP-binding cassette transporters MsbA from gram-negative bacteria and Sav1866 from Staphylococcus aureus, two transmembrane helices (3 and 4) in the membrane domains have their cytoplasmic extensions in close proximity, forming a tetrahelix bundle interface. In biochemical experiments on MsbA from Escherichia coli, we show for the first time that a robust network of inter-monomer interactions in the tetrahelix bundle is crucial for the transmission of nucleotide-dependent conformational changes to the extracellular side of the membrane domains. Our observations are the first to suggest that modulation of tetrahelix bundle interactions in ATP-binding cassette exporters might offer a potent strategy to alter their transport activity.

A helical processing pipeline for EM structure determination of membrane proteins

Electron crystallography plays a key role in the structural biology of integral membrane proteins (IMPs) by offering one of the most direct means of providing insight into the functional state of these molecular machines in their lipid-associated forms, and also has the potential to facilitate examination of physiologically relevant transitional states and complexes. Helical or tubular crystals, which are the natural product of proteins crystallizing on the surface of a cylindrical vesicle, offer some unique advantages, such as three-dimensional (3D) information from a single view, compared to other crystalline forms. While a number of software packages are available for processing images of helical crystals to produce 3D electron density maps, widespread exploitation of helical image reconstruction is limited by a lack of standardized approaches and the initial effort and specialized expertise required. Our goal is to develop an integrated pipeline to enable structure determination by transmission electron microscopy (TEM) of IMPs in the form of tubular crystals. We describe here the integration of standard Fourier-Bessel helical analysis techniques into Appion, an integrated, database-driven pipeline.

Proteins that bind and move lipids: MsbA and NPC1

Membrane proteins that bind and transport lipids face special challenges. Since lipids typically have low water solubility, both accessibility of the substrate to the protein and delivery to the desired destination are problematical. The amphipathic nature of membrane lipids, and their relatively large molecular size, also means that these proteins must possess substrate-binding sites of a different nature than those designed to handle small polar molecules. This review considers two integral proteins whose function is to bind and transfer membrane lipids within or across a membrane. The first protein, MsbA, is a putative lipid flippase that is a member of the ATP-binding cassette (ABC) superfamily. The protein is found in the inner (cytoplasmic) membrane (IM) of Gram-negative bacteria such as E. coli, where it is proposed to move lipid A from the inner to the outer membrane (OM) leaflet, an important step in the lipopolysaccharide biosynthetic pathway. Cholesterol is a major component of the plasma membrane in eukaryotic cells, where it regulates bilayer fluidity. The other lipid-binding protein discussed here, mammalian NPC1 (Niemann-Pick disease, Type C1), binds cholesterol inside late endosomes/lysosomes (LE/LY) and is involved in its transfer to the cytosol as part of a key intracellular sterol-trafficking pathway. Mutations in NPC1 lead to a devastating neurodegenerative condition, Niemann-Pick Type C disease, which is characterized by massive cholesterol accumulation in LE/LY. The accelerating pace of membrane protein structure determination over the past decade has allowed us a glimpse of how lipid binding and transfer by membrane proteins such as MsbA and NPC1 might be achieved.

The choreography of multidrug export

Multidrug transporters have a crucial role in causing the drug resistance that can arise in infectious micro-organisms and tumours. These integral membrane proteins mediate the export of a broad range of unrelated compounds from cells, including antibiotics and anticancer agents, thus reducing the concentration of these compounds to subtoxic levels in target cells. In spite of intensive research, it is not clear exactly how multidrug transporters work. The present review focuses on recent advancements in the biochemistry and structural biology of bacterial and human multidrug ABC (ATP-binding cassette) transporters. These advancements point to a common mechanism in which polyspecific drug-binding surfaces in the membrane domains are alternately exposed to the inside and outside surface of the membrane in response to the ATP-driven dimerization of nucleotide-binding domains and their dissociation following ATP hydrolysis.

Optimized purification of a heterodimeric ABC transporter in a highly stable form amenable to 2-D crystallization

Optimized protocols for achieving high-yield expression, purification and reconstitution of membrane proteins are required to study their structure and function. We previously reported high-level expression in Escherichia coli of active BmrC and BmrD proteins from Bacillus subtilis, previously named YheI and YheH. These proteins are half-transporters which belong to the ABC (ATP-Binding Cassette) superfamily and associate in vivo to form a functional transporter able to efflux drugs. In this report, high-yield purification and functional reconstitution were achieved for the heterodimer BmrC/BmrD. In contrast to other detergents more efficient for solubilizing the transporter, dodecyl-ß-D-maltoside (DDM) maintained it in a drug-sensitive and vanadate-sensitive ATPase-competent state after purification by affinity chromatography. High amounts of pure proteins were obtained which were shown either by analytical ultracentrifugation or gel filtration to form a monodisperse heterodimer in solution, which was notably stable for more than one month at 4°C. Functional reconstitution using different lipid compositions induced an 8-fold increase of the ATPase activity (k_cat∼5 s⁻¹). We further validated that the quality of the purified BmrC/BmrD heterodimer is suitable for structural analyses, as its reconstitution at high protein densities led to the formation of 2-D crystals. Electron microscopy of negatively stained crystals allowed the calculation of a projection map at 20 Å resolution revealing that BmrC/BmrD might assemble into oligomers in a lipidic environment.

Dissection of the conformational cycle of the multidrug/lipidA ABC exporter MsbA

Recent crystal structures of the multidrug ATP-binding cassette (ABC) exporters Sav1866 from Staphylococcus aureus, MsbA from Escherichia coli, Vibrio cholera, and Salmonella typhimurium, and mouse ABCB1a suggest a common alternating access mechanism for export. However, the molecular framework underlying this mechanism is critically dependent on assumed conformational relationships between nonidentical crystal structures and therefore requires biochemical verification. The structures of homodimeric MsbA reveal a pair of glutamate residues (E208 and E208') in the intracellular domains of its two half-transporters, close to the nucleotide-binding domains (NBDs), which are in close proximity of each other in the outward-facing state but not in the inward-facing state. Using intermolecular cysteine crosslinking between E208C and E208C' in E. coli MsbA, we demonstrate that the NBDs dissociate in nucleotide-free conditions and come close on ATP binding and ADP·vanadate trapping. Interestingly, ADP alone separates the half-transporters like a nucleotide-free state, presumably for the following catalytic cycle. Our data fill persistent gaps in current studies on the conformational dynamics of a variety of ABC exporters. Based on a single biochemical method, the findings describe a conformational cycle for a single ABC exporter at major checkpoints of the ATPase reaction under experimental conditions, where the exporter is transport active.

Dynamics and structural changes induced by ATP binding in SAV1866, a bacterial ABC exporter

Multidrug transporters of the ATP-binding cassette family export a wide variety of compounds across membranes in both prokaryotes and eukaryotes, using ATP hydrolysis as energy source. Several of these membrane proteins are of clinical importance. Although biochemical and structural studies have provided insights into the mechanism underlying substrate transport, many key questions subsist regarding the molecular and structural nature of this mechanism. In particular, the detailed conformational changes occurring during the catalytic cycle are still elusive. We explored the conformational changes occurring upon ATP/Mg(2+) binding using molecular dynamics simulations starting from the nucleotide-bound structure of SAV1866 embedded in an explicit lipid bilayer. The removal of nucleotide revealed a major rearrangement in the outer membrane leaflet portion of the transmembrane domain (TMD) resulting in the closure of the central cavity at the extracellular side. This closure is similar to that observed in the crystal nucleotide-free structures. The interface of the nucleotide-binding domain dimer (NDB) is significantly more hydrated in the nucleotide-free trajectory though it is not disrupted. This finding suggests that the TMD closure could occur as a first step preceding the dissociation of the dimer. The transmission pathway of the signal triggered by the removal of ATP/Mg(2+) mainly involves the conserved Q-loop and X-loop as well as TM6.

Helical crystallization of two example membrane proteins MsbA and the Ca(2+)-ATPase

Helical crystallization is a powerful tool for the moderate resolution structure determination of integral membrane proteins, where the insight gained often includes domain architecture and the disposition of α-helical segments. A necessary first step toward helical crystallization involves membrane protein reconstitution, which itself is a powerful technique for structure-function studies of integral membrane proteins. The correct insertion of a detergent-solubilized, purified membrane protein into lipid vesicles (proteoliposomes) can facilitate the functional characterization of the protein in a well-defined, chemically pure environment without interference from other membrane-associated components. In addition, the lipid-to-protein ratio can be controlled during reconstitution to generate a high concentration of a particular membrane protein in the proteoliposomes, which are then suitable for both functional assays and crystallization trials. Traditional approaches to two-dimensional crystallization for electron microscopy rely on dialysis methods for the simultaneous reconstitution and crystallization of a membrane protein [Kühlbrandt, W. (1992). Two-dimensional crystallization of membrane proteins. Q. Rev. Biophys.25, 1-49.], yet some systems allow these two steps to be experimentally separated and independently considered. Some examples of integral membrane proteins that have been reconstituted and crystallized in a helical lattice include cytochrome bc1 complex from bovine heart [Akiba, T., et al. (1996). Three-dimensional structure of bovine cytochrome bc(1) complex by electron cryomicroscopy and helical image reconstruction. Nat. Struct. Biol.3, 553-561.], Escherichia coli melibiose permease [Rigaud, J. L., et al. (1997). Bio-beads: An efficient strategy for two-dimensional crystallization of membrane proteins. J. Struct. Biol.118, 226-235.], a bacterial ATP-binding cassette transporter MsbA [Ward, A., et al. (2009). Nucleotide dependent packing differences in helical crystals of the ABC transporter MsbA. J. Struct. Biol.165, 169-175.], and the sarcoplasmic reticulum Ca(2+)-ATPase [Young, H. S., et al. (1997). How to make tubular crystals by reconstitution of detergent-solubilized Ca(2+)-ATPase. Biophys. J.72, 2545-2558.]. The reconstitution and helical crystallization of MsbA and Ca(2+)-ATPase will be the focus of this chapter.

Deleting two C-terminal alpha-helices is effective to crystallize the bacterial ABC transporter Escherichia coli MsbA complexed with AMP-PNP

An MsbA deletion mutant DeltaC21 that lacks the two C-terminal alpha-helices was expressed in Escherichia coli strain C41 and purified by metal-affinity and gel-filtration chromatography. Purified DeltaC21 retained 26% of the activity of the wild-type ATPase and had a similar binding affinity to fluorescent nucleotide derivatives. Although crystals of wild-type MsbA complexed with adenosine 5'-(beta,gamma-imido)triphosphate could not be obtained, crystals of DeltaC21 that diffracted to 4.5 A resolution were obtained. The preliminary DeltaC21 structure had the outward-facing conformation, in contrast to the previously reported E. coli MsbA structure. This result suggests that deletion of the C-terminal alpha-helices may play a role in facilitating the outward-facing nucleotide-bound crystal structure of EcMsbA.

Assessing the stability of membrane proteins to detect ligand binding using differential static light scattering

Protein stabilization upon ligand binding has frequently been used to identify ligands for soluble proteins. Methods such as differential scanning fluorimetry (DSF) and differential static light scattering (DSLS) have been employed in the 384-well format and have been useful in identifying ligands that promote crystallization and 3D structure determination of proteins. However, finding a generic method that is applicable to membrane proteins has been a challenge as the high hydrophobicity of membrane proteins and the presence of detergents essential for their solubilization interfere with fluorescence-based detections. Here the authors used MsbA (an adenosine triphosphate binding cassette transporter), CorA (a Mg(++) channel), and CpxA (a histidine kinase) as model proteins and show that DSLS is not sensitive to the presence of detergents or protein hydrophobicity and can be used to monitor thermodenaturation of membrane proteins, assess their stability, and detect ligand binding in a 384-well format.

Lipid bilayer regulation of membrane protein function: gramicidin channels as molecular force probes

Membrane protein function is regulated by the host lipid bilayer composition. This regulation may depend on specific chemical interactions between proteins and individual molecules in the bilayer, as well as on non-specific interactions between proteins and the bilayer behaving as a physical entity with collective physical properties (e.g. thickness, intrinsic monolayer curvature or elastic moduli). Studies in physico-chemical model systems have demonstrated that changes in bilayer physical properties can regulate membrane protein function by altering the energetic cost of the bilayer deformation associated with a protein conformational change. This type of regulation is well characterized, and its mechanistic elucidation is an interdisciplinary field bordering on physics, chemistry and biology. Changes in lipid composition that alter bilayer physical properties (including cholesterol, polyunsaturated fatty acids, other lipid metabolites and amphiphiles) regulate a wide range of membrane proteins in a seemingly non-specific manner. The commonality of the changes in protein function suggests an underlying physical mechanism, and recent studies show that at least some of the changes are caused by altered bilayer physical properties. This advance is because of the introduction of new tools for studying lipid bilayer regulation of protein function. The present review provides an introduction to the regulation of membrane protein function by the bilayer physical properties. We further describe the use of gramicidin channels as molecular force probes for studying this mechanism, with a unique ability to discriminate between consequences of changes in monolayer curvature and bilayer elastic moduli.

The ATP-binding cassette family: a structural perspective

The ATP-binding cassette family is one of the largest groupings of membrane proteins, moving allocrites across lipid membranes, using energy from ATP. In bacteria, they reside in the inner membrane and are involved in both uptake and export. In eukaryotes, these transporters reside in the cell's internal membranes as well as in the plasma membrane and are unidirectional-out of the cytoplasm. The range of substances that these proteins can transport is huge, which makes them interesting for structure-function studies. Moreover, their abundance in nature has made them targets for structural proteomics consortia. There are eight independent structures for ATP-binding cassette transporters, making this one of the best characterised membrane protein families. Our understanding of the mechanism of transport across membranes and membrane protein structure in general has been enhanced by recent developments for this family.

ABC transporters: a riddle wrapped in a mystery inside an enigma

ATP-binding cassette (ABC) transporters form one of the largest and most ancient of protein families. ABC transporters couple hydrolysis of ATP to vectorial translocation of diverse substrates across cellular membranes. Many human ABC transporters are medically important in causing, for example, multidrug resistance to cytotoxic drugs. Seven complete prokaryotic structures and one eukaryotic structure have been solved for transporters from 2002 to date, and a wealth of research is being conducted on and around these structures to resolve the mechanistic conundrum of how these transporters couple ATP hydrolysis in cytosolic domains to substrate translocation through the transmembrane pore. Many questions remained unanswered about this mechanism, despite a plethora of data and a number of interesting and controversial models.

Conformational cycle of the ABC transporter MsbA in liposomes: detailed analysis using double electron-electron resonance spectroscopy

Driven by the energy of ATP binding and hydrolysis, ATP-binding cassette transporters alternate between inward- and outward-facing conformations, allowing vectorial movement of substrates. Conflicting models have been proposed to describe the conformational motion underlying this switch in access of the transport pathway. One model, based on three crystal structures of the lipid flippase MsbA, envisions a large-amplitude motion that disengages the nucleotide-binding domains and repacks the transmembrane helices. To test this model and place the crystal structures in a mechanistic context, we use spin labeling and double electron-electron resonance spectroscopy to define the nature and amplitude of MsbA conformational change during ATP hydrolysis cycle. For this purpose, spin labels were introduced at sites selected to provide a distinctive pattern of distance changes unique to the crystallographic transformation. Distance changes in liposomes, induced by the transition from nucleotide-free MsbA to the highest energy intermediate, fit a simple pattern whereby residues on the cytoplasmic side undergo 20-30 A closing motion while a 7- to 10-A opening motion is observed on the extracellular side. The transmembrane helices undergo relative movement to create the outward opening consistent with that implied by the crystal structures. Double electron-electron resonance distance distributions reveal asymmetric backbone flexibility on the two sides of the transporter that correlates with asymmetric opening of the substrate-binding chamber. Together with extensive accessibility analysis, our results suggest that these structures capture features of the motion that couples ATP energy expenditure to work, providing a framework for the mechanism of substrate transport.