Is clavicular reconstruction imperative for total and subtotal claviculectomy? A systematic review

Vascularized Reconstruction of Recalcitrant Clavicular Nonunion with the Medial Femoral Condyle Free Flap: A Systematic Review of the Literature

Recalcitrant clavicular nonunion is an uncommon but challenging problem. Vascularized bone reconstruction is not first-line therapy due to complexity and donor morbidity, though it has utility in select cases. A systematic review of Embase and Medline databases was undertaken for cases of medial femoral condyle reconstruction for clavicle nonunion. Ten studies met inclusion, encompassing 26 patients. Mean age was 38.9 years. Ten patients were male and 16 female. Mean time of nonunion was 37.79 months prior to intervention; mean time to union following medial femoral condyle flap was 7.60 months. Two patients did not achieve union. Of the 11 patients who previously had at least one failed fixation with bone graft, considered the current "gold standard", 9 patients (81.81%) went on to achieve union, while 2 patients (18.19%) did not. There were six reported complications in five patients. Medial femoral condyle flap is a valuable option in recalcitrant clavicle nonunion.

Iatrogenic Excessive Clavicle Resection as a Complication of Arthroscopic Distal Clavicle Excision

Arthroscopic distal clavicle excision (DCE) is a reliable procedure to treat acromioclavicular joint arthritis. Typically, only 1 to 2 cm of distal clavicle should be removed. Resection of too much bone can lead to instability of the joint or lack of support to the shoulder. We describe 2 patients who had excessive clavicular bone removed arthroscopically, leading to irreparable clavicular pain and dysfunction. The 2 female patients, ages 56 and 60 years, presented to our clinic with continued pain after DCE. Both had pain intractable with nonoperative treatment and loss of range of motion of the shoulder. Radiographs revealed a distal clavicle defect of 7.5 cm in 1 patient. The second patient had a 2-cm distal clavicular defect with an adjacent 2-cm clavicle bone fragment between the defect and residual clavicle shaft. Both underwent surgery with subtotal claviculectomy for pain control. During surgery, 1 patient had a subclavian vein requiring vascular repair. After 1 year of follow-up, both patients had reduced but residual pain and restricted range of motion. Only 1 patient could rejoin her preinjury occupation. Neither patient could continue with preinjury recreational sports. Excessive removal of the distal clavicle during DCE can result in continued pain and disability of the shoulder. Methods to visualize the anatomy of the distal clavicle and its articulation to the acromion should be considered when performing this operation arthroscopically. Reoperation to remove subtotal clavicle has good clinical outcomes but may lead to serious complications due to the proximity to major neurovascular structures. [Orthopedics. 2024;47(1):e57-e60.].

Clinical and functional outcome after partial or total claviculectomy without reconstruction for oncologic causes

BACKGROUND

To achieve clear margins in rare malignant clavicular neoplasms, claviculectomy may become necessary. This study aimed to review clinical, functional, and oncologic outcomes following partial or total claviculectomy without reconstruction.

METHODS

This study retrospectively included 15 patients from 2 tertiary sarcoma centers (mean age, 42.6 ± 20.3 years; 66.7% male patients). The median length of clinical and oncologic follow-up was 48.0 months (interquartile range [IQR], 24.0-83.5 months). Functional follow-up (Musculoskeletal Tumor Society score and QuickDASH score [short version of the Disabilities of the Arm, Shoulder and Hand questionnaire]) was available in 9 patients at a median of 36.0 months (IQR, 20.0-100.0 months).

RESULTS

Of the 15 patients, 7 underwent total claviculectomy; 5, partial lateral claviculectomy; and 3, partial medial claviculectomy. No postoperative complications emerged. The median Musculoskeletal Tumor Society and QuickDASH scores at latest follow-up amounted to 26.0 points (IQR, 24.0-29.0 points) and 18.0 points (IQR, 11.0-22.0 points), respectively. Notably, scores tended to be lower in patients who underwent total claviculectomy (n = 2) in comparison to partial claviculectomy (n = 7).

CONCLUSION

Satisfactory clinical and functional results can be achieved following partial or total claviculectomy without reconstruction, with a low complication rate and acceptable mid- to long-term function.

Innovative method with two-stage surgery for Ewing sarcoma with personalized distal clavicle reconstruction: A case report and diagnosis review

A 13-year-old boy presented with a growing lump on his left clavicle for 5 months. The plain radiograph revealed an osteolytic mass with aggressive periosteal reaction, suggesting a malignant lesion. The results of advanced imaging and histopathological examinations revealed that the patient had Ewing sarcoma without metastasis. The two-stage surgery was as follows: resection–observation–reconstruction. The underlying rationale was that Ewing sarcoma has a high recurrence. After 2 years of resection, the patient had remission, and he currently has a personal 3D-printed titanium implant with intact shoulder function.

Periosteal osteosarcoma of the clavicle: A case report and review of the literature

•

Periosteal osteosarcoma arising from clavicle is extremely rare with only two cases documented in English literature.

•

Diagnosis based on the relation of clinical symptoms, radiology and histology.

•

Current treatment included neo-adjuvant chemotherapy and wide resection of the tumor.

•

Total claviculectomy without reconstruction can achieved good oncological and functional outcome.

Multispecialty surgical management of large clavicular tumor: A case report

INTRODUCTION

Primary and metastatic malignancies of the clavicle are extremely uncommon and difficult to treat. It carries a high morbidity rate. Total or partial claviculectomy is the recommended treatment option.

PRESENTATION OF CASE

A 59-year-old male was admitted with a large left clavicular huge mass; biopsy showed poorly differentiated adenocarcinoma. Treatment started with chemoradiotherapy followed by complete excision of the tumor surgically.

DISCUSSION

For treating this rare, difficult case, partial claviculectomy performed by a multispecialty team integrating three surgical skill sets: thoracic, ENT, and orthopedic surgeons, yields the best results. Clavicular carcinoma of known primary (CUP) is rare, and chemoradiotherapy showed preferable results in management.

CONCLUSION

MDT reviews with surgeons, radiologists, pathologists, oncologists, and radiation oncologists are required in rare and complex cases of clavicular malignancy. Multispecialty surgical involvement is required for the safe excision of clavicular tumors with appropriate oncologic margins and fewer complications.

Functional and Oncological Outcomes of Multidisciplinary Management of Ewing's Sarcoma of Clavicle: A Single-Center Experience

Objectives Ewing's sarcoma is best treated using a multidisciplinary approach. We discuss the functional and oncological outcomes of clavicular Ewing's sarcoma which has been sparsely reported in literature. Materials and Methods We retrospectively evaluated patients who underwent resections for Ewing's sarcoma of clavicle from January 2002 to December 2017. The study end points were locoregional recurrence free survival (LRFS), disease-free survival (DFS), and overall survival (OS) at 3 and 5 years, and functional outcomes measured by Musculoskeletal Tumor Society (MSTS) scores. Statistical Analysis The LRFS, DFS, and OS were calculated and analyzed using the Kaplan-Meier method and log-rank test. Results Data of 21 patients (male: 12, female: 9) was analyzed with a mean age [range] of 15.3 [6-40] years. Total clavicle excision was done in 62% (13 of 21) while 38% ( n = 8) had partial resections. Radiotherapy was administered in 15 patients (71.5%). At a median follow-up of 42 months (range: 7-198), data of 20 patients was available for follow-up. Ten patients died (due to disease: nine, other reasons: One), eight are disease free and alive, one had metastasectomy on recurrence and is disease free and, one patient is alive with disease and on palliative chemotherapy. The LRFS, DFS, and OS were 95, 59, 65% and 95, 47, 59% at 3 and 5 years, respectively. The functional evaluation done for nine patients who are free of disease showed a mean MSTS score of 29 (range: 27-30; total clavicle excision: 28.5, partial clavicle excision: 29.5). Conclusion Patients with Ewing's sarcoma of the clavicle who underwent resection without reconstruction have acceptable local control rates and excellent functional outcomes.

Allograft reconstruction for large parosteal osteoma of the clavicle: a case report

A large parosteal osteoma arising on the surface of the right clavicle of a 39-year-old male patient was suspected preoperatively as a parosteal osteosarcoma. The lesion was treated with wide resection and allograft reconstruction. In this case report, we discuss the accurate diagnosis and appropriate surgical treatment for unusual clavicular tumors.

A 19-Year Experience With Clavicular Defects: An Algorithm for Flap Selection and Surgical Outcomes

BACKGROUND

The clavicle contributes to the stability and functional integrity of the shoulder. Clavicle bone defects are uncommon, and the strategy for their management is variable.

METHOD

Six patients presented with clavicle bone defects. The causes were as follows: traumatic defects (2 patients), electric injury (1 patient), osteoradionecrosis (2 patients), and nonunion (1 patient). One patient had upper limb palsy for 40 years, and another had posttraumatic shoulder function impairment. A pedicled pectoralis major myocutaneous flap was used for the patient with a dysfunctional limb, and 5 bone flaps (3 free fibular flaps, 1 free iliac flap, and 1 pedicled rib flap) were used for reconstruction in the other patients.

RESULT

All flaps (2 pedicled flaps and 4 free flaps) were successfully used for wound repair; the pedicled rib flap demonstrated partial marginal necrosis, and the free fibular flap required reexploration for venous kinking. Five functionally impaired upper limbs showed functional improvements postoperatively.

CONCLUSION

For functionless composite clavicles and soft tissue defects, a soft tissue flap will be required for wound repair. A bone flap, especially a fibular flap, is required for the upper limb to show functional recovery. The variety of flaps will be planned according to the defect size comparison between the bone and soft tissue, and ipsilateral upper limb function, and a proposed algorithm will be discussed.

Personalized three-dimensional printed polyether-ether-ketone prosthesis for reconstruction after subtotal removal of chronic clavicle osteomyelitis: A case report

RATIONALE

Three-dimensional (3D) printing has attracted wide attention for its potential and abilities in the assistance of surgical planning and the development of personalized prostheses. We herewith report a unique case of chronic clavicle osteomyelitis treated with a two-stage subtotal clavicle reconstruction using a 3D printed polyether-ether-ketone (PEEK) prosthesis.

PATIENT CONCERNS

A 23-year-old Chinese female presented to our clinic complaining about a progressive pain of her right clavicle for about 1 year.

DIAGNOSES

Chronic clavicle osteomyelitis confirmed by percutaneous biopsy and lesion biopsy.

INTERVENTIONS

This patient accepted a long-term conservative treatment, which did not gain satisfactory outcomes. Thus, a subtotal removal and two-stage reconstruction of the right clavicle with a 3D-printed polyether-ether-ketone prosthesis stabilized by screw fixation system was performed.

OUTCOMES

At 2-year follow-up, complete pain relief and satisfactory functional recovery of her right shoulder were observed.

LESSONS

Personalized 3D printed prosthesis is an effective and feasible method for reconstruction of complex bone defects.

Total clavicle reconstruction with free peroneal graft for the surgical management of chronic nonbacterial osteomyelitis of the clavicle: a case report

BACKGROUND

Chronic nonbacterial osteomyelitis (CNO) is a rare chronic autoinflammatory syndrome affecting mainly children and young adults. The natural history of the disease is marked by recurrent pain as the mainstay of inflammatory outbreaks. Typical radiographic findings are osteosclerosis and hyperostosis of the medial clavicle, sternum and first rib. Compression of the brachial plexus is exceedingly rare and one of the few surgical indications. Literature on total clavicle reconstruction is scarce. While claviclectomy alone has been associated with fair functional and cosmetic outcomes, several reconstruction techniques with autograft, allograft or even cement ("Oklahoma prosthesis") have been reported with the aim of achieving better pain control, cosmetic outcome and protecting the brachial plexus and subclavian vessels. We herewith report a unique case of complicated CNO of the clavicle treated with total clavicle reconstruction using a free peroneal graft.

CASE PRESENTATION

A 21-year-old female patient presented with CNO of her left clavicle, associated with recurrent, progressive and debilitating pain as well as limited range of motion. In recent years, she started complaining of paresthesia, weakness and pain radiating to her left arm during arm abduction. The clavicle diameter reached 6 cm on computed tomography, with direct compression of the brachial plexus and subclavian vessels. Following surgical biopsy for diagnosis confirmation, she further developed a chronic cutaneous fistula. Therefore, a two-stage total clavicle reconstruction using a vascularized peroneal graft stabilized by ligamentous reconstruction was performed. At two-year follow-up, complete pain relief and improvement of her left shoulder Constant-Murley score were observed, along with satisfactory cosmetic outcome.

CONCLUSIONS

This case illustrates a rarely described complication of CNO with direct compression of the brachial plexus and subclavian vessels, and chronic cutaneous fistula. To our knowledge, there is no consensus regarding the optimal management of this rare condition in this context. Advantages and complications of clavicle reconstruction should be carefully discussed with patients due to limited evidence of superior clinical outcome and potential local and donor-site complications. While in our case the outcomes met the patient's satisfaction, it remains an isolated case and further reports are awaited to help surgeons and patients in their decision process.