Strategies to decolonize the shoulder of Cutibacterium acnes: a review of the literature

A Literature Review of Cutibacterium Acnes: From Skin Commensal to Pathogen in Shoulder Surgery

Cutibacterium acnes, previously known as Propionibacterium acnes, is a gram-positive rod in the pilosebaceous glands and commonly implicated in acne vulgaris. Its role in prosthetic joint infections, particularly in shoulder surgeries, has recently gained attention due to its prevalence around the shoulder girdle. This review collates evidence on the pathogenic role of C. acnes in shoulder surgeries, discussing preventive measures, risk factors, clinical presentation, investigation, and treatment strategies. C. acnes infections are complex, often presenting with non-specific symptoms and delayed diagnoses. Risk factors include male sex, presence of hair, shoulder steroid injections, and previous shoulder surgeries. Investigations such as inflammatory markers, synovial fluid analysis, diagnostic arthroscopy, tissue cultures, and advanced molecular techniques like next-generation sequencing and multiplex polymerase chain reaction are explored for their effectiveness in detecting C. acnes. Treatment strategies range from prolonged antibiotics and antibiotic spacers to single-stage and two-stage revision surgeries. Studies indicate that single-stage revision may provide better outcomes compared to two-stage revision. Effective management of C. acnes infections requires careful assessment, relevant investigations, and tailored treatment approaches. This review emphasizes the need for further research to address intraoperative contamination and to develop more efficient diagnostic and treatment methods.

Hydrogen Peroxide May Reduce the Risk for Revision Surgery and Infection in Primary Shoulder Arthroplasty: Two-year Follow-up From a Prospective, Blinded, Controlled Trial

BACKGROUND

The purpose of this study was to determine whether the addition of hydrogen peroxide to the preoperative skin preparation for primary total shoulder arthroplasty is associated with a difference in patient-reported outcomes, risk for postoperative infection, and risk for revision surgery at a minimum of 2-year follow-up.

METHODS

This was a prospective, blinded, and controlled trial, which included a consecutive series of patients undergoing primary shoulder arthroplasty. The control group underwent standard sterile skin preparation using ethyl alcohol and ChloraPrep applicators, and the peroxide group had the same preparation with the addition of hydrogen peroxide between the alcohol and ChloraPrep applications. We then compared patient-reported outcome scores (American Shoulder and Elbow Surgeons Shoulder Score [ASES], simple shoulder test [SST], visual analog scale [VAS]), infections, and revision surgeries between the two groups at 2-year follow-up.

RESULTS

Of the 61 patients included in the original study, 52 of 58 (85%) living patients agreed to participate in this study. No preoperative differences were observed between groups. No difference was observed in ASES, SST, or VAS scores at 2 years. More revision surgeries were done in the control group (7 versus 2, P = 0.268) and Cutibacterium acnes infections (2 versus 0, P = 0.168).

CONCLUSION

The addition of hydrogen peroxide to the preoperative skin preparation before primary shoulder arthroplasty is safe, and additional research is warranted to investigate whether it may decrease the risk for revision surgery and postoperative C acnes infection.

LEVEL OF EVIDENCE

III.

Preventing and Treating Infection in Reverse Total Shoulder Arthroplasty

PURPOSE OF REVIEW

Periprosthetic infection after shoulder arthroplasty is relatively uncommon though associated with severe long-term morbidity when encountered. The purpose of the review is to summarize the recent literature regarding the definition, clinical evaluation, prevention, and management of prosthetic joint infection after reverse shoulder arthroplasty.

RECENT FINDINGS

The landmark report generated at the 2018 International Consensus Meeting on Musculoskeletal Infection has provided a framework for diagnosis, prevention, and management of periprosthetic infections after shoulder arthroplasty. Shoulder specific literature with validated interventions to reduce prosthetic joint infection is limited; however existing literature from retrospective studies and from total hip and knee arthroplasty allows us to make relative guidelines. One and two-stage revisions seem to demonstrate similar outcomes; however, no controlled comparative studies exist limiting the ability to make definitive recommendations between the two options. We report on recent literature regarding the current diagnostic, preventative, and treatment options for periprosthetic infection after shoulder arthroplasty. Much of the literature does not distinguish between anatomic and reverse shoulder arthroplasty, and further high-level shoulder specific studies are needed to answer questions generated from this review.

Evaluation of the effectiveness of skin preparation methods for the reduction of Cutibacterium acnes (formerly Propionibacterium acnes) in shoulder surgery: a systematic review

Background

Cutibacterium acnes (C. acnes) is the most common pathogen responsible for post-operative shoulder infections. The purpose of this study was to evaluate the effectiveness of skin preparation methods against C. acnes in shoulder surgery.

Methods

A systematic review was conducted evaluating the effectiveness of skin preparation methods in the reduction of C. acnes in patients undergoing shoulder surgery. Outcomes were assessed based on the effectiveness of the method used; side effects and cost were also analysed.

Results

Of the 19 included studies, 9 evaluated pre-surgical home treatments: 8 assessed benzoyl peroxide (BPO) and 6 concluded it is effective in reducing C. acnes. Nine studies assessed surgical skin preparation and concluded that Chlorhexidine gluconate (CHG) was not effective; in contrast hydrogen peroxide reduced C. acnes. Finally, one study evaluated an aseptic protocol using CHG and concluded that it was not effective.

Conclusions

It was demonstrated that BPO as home treatment is effective in reducing C. acnes load on skin; it rarely causes side effects and is also cost-effective. This study highlights non-effectiveness of CHG. There was some evidence that the addition of hydrogen peroxide could have a positive effect in the reduction of C. acnes skin load; however, more studies are required.

Efficacy of Three Povidone Iodine Formulations against Cutibacterium acnes Assessed through In Vitro Studies: A Preliminary Study

Cutibacterium acnes (C. acnes, formerly known as Propionibacterium acnes) is the major causative agent of prosthetic joint infections (PJI). Treatment of PJI with antibiotics is difficult due to antibiotic resistance and adverse side effects on patients’ health. Proper disinfection of the surgical site using a variety of povidone iodine formulations could prevent C. acnes infection. In the current study, the efficacy of the three povidone iodine (PVP-I) formulations, viz: PVP-I 10% dermic solution, PVP-I 5% alcoholic solution and PVP-I 4% scrub, was tested against C. acnes, in vitro, in the presence of interfering substances mimicking soiling conditions. C. acnes strain ATCC 6919 was used to test the bactericidal activity of the povidone iodine formulations according to the modified dilution-neutralization method described in French Norm EN standard 13727. A 3-log reduction in the bacterial cell count in 60 s was considered to be significant. The results showed that under experimental conditions, the three PVP-I formulations displayed bactericidal activity against the micro-organism, Cutibacterium acnes, and that the lowest concentration of povidone-iodine active against C. acnes was 0.4%. These results are encouraging as PVP-I offers a low-cost and efficient method of disinfection.

Patient Compliance and Satisfaction with Topical Benzoyl Peroxide Gel Prior to Shoulder Surgery

Background

Methods

Results

Conclusion

Silver carboxylate-doped titanium dioxide-polydimethylsiloxane coating decreases Cutibacterium acnes adherence and biofilm formation on polyether ether ketone

BACKGROUND CONTEXT

Cutibacterium acnes (C. acnes) is a gram-positive facultative anaerobe found in the deep sebaceous follicles of the skin on the shoulder and back. C. acnes has been increasingly recognized as a pathogen in spinal surgical site infection (SSI) especially in the presence of instrumentation.

PURPOSE

This study assesses whether a silver carboxylate-doped titanium dioxide-polydimethylsiloxane (TiO₂-PDMS) coating can decrease C. acnes adherence and biofilm formation on PEEK and four other commonly used spinal implant materials, stainless steel, cobalt chromium, titanium, and titanium alloy.

STUDY DESIGN

We compared the adherence of C. acnes over 24 hours between uncoated, 95:5 TiO₂ to PDMS ratio with 10× silver carboxylate coating and a 100% silver carboxylate coating on each implant material, which were uniformly saw cut and sterilized. Implants were then subjected to scanning electron microscopy (SEM) and confocal scanning laser microscopy (CSLM).

METHODS

Samples were coated using 95:5 TiO₂-PDMS 10× silver carboxylate, 100% silver carboxylate, or left uncoated. C. acnes was applied onto the samples and allowed to adhere for periods of 4, 8, 12, 16, or 20 hours. Nonadherent bacteria were then washed from the samples. These samples were then allowed to continue incubating for a total of 24 hours. SEM and confocal laser scanning microscope were used to visualize all samples for the presence of biofilm and quantification of C. acnes adherence at each time point.

RESULTS

The 95:5 TiO₂-PDMS 10× silver carboxylate coating was able to significantly decrease C. acnes adherence on PEEK after 8, 12, 16, and 20 hours of adherence. No statistical difference was found between the 95:5 TiO₂-PDMS 10× silver carboxylate coating and the 100% silver carboxylate positive control. We previously observed extensive C. acnes biofilm formation on uncoated PEEK, but none on PEEK coated with either the 95:5 TiO₂-PDMS 10× silver carboxylate or 100% Ag coating . Furthermore, no biofilm formation was observed on stainless steel, cobalt chromium, titanium, and titanium alloy coated with 95:5 TiO₂-PDMS 10× silver carboxylate or 100% Ag coating.

CONCLUSION

A 95:5 TiO₂-PDMS 10× silver carboxylate coating decreases C. acnes adhesion and prevents biofilm formation on PEEK and other common orthopedic implant materials.

CLINICAL SIGNIFICANCE

A 95:5 TiO₂-PDMS 10× silver carboxylate coating may help decrease spinal SSI due to C. acnes, especially in procedures with instrumentation.

Dynamics of skin microbiota in shoulder surgery infections

Post-surgical infections arise due to various contributing factors. Most important is the presence of potential pathogenic microorganisms in the skin complemented by the patient´s health status. Cutibacterium acnes is commonly present in the pilosebaceous glands and hair follicle funnels in human skin. After surgical intervention, these highly prevalent, slow-growing bacteria can be found in the deeper tissues and in proximity of implants. C. acnes is frequently implicated in post-surgical infections, often resulting in the need for revision surgery. This review summarizes the current understanding of microbial dynamics in shoulder surgical infections. In particular, we shed light on the contribution of C. acnes to post-surgical shoulder infections as well as their colonization and immune-modulatory potential. Despite being persistently found in post-surgical tissues, C. acnes is often underestimated as a causative organism due to its slow growth and the inefficient detection methods. We discuss the role of the skin environment constituted by microbial composition and host cellular status in influencing C. acnes recolonization potential. Future mapping of the individual skin microbiome in shoulder surgery patients using advanced molecular methods would be a useful approach for determining the risk of post-operative infections.

Meta-analysis of the efficacy of preoperative skin preparation with alcoholic chlorhexidine compared to povidone iodine in orthopedic surgery

Preoperative skin preparation is an effective method to prevent surgical site infections (SSI). Alcoholic chlorhexidine (CHG) and povidone iodine (PV-I) are the most widely used antiseptic agents. This meta-analysis aims to determine their efficacy in reducing natural bacterial skin flora in clean orthopedic surgery. A systematic search was conducted through current literature up to June 2021 to identify clinical randomized trials that compared the efficacy of alcoholic chlorhexidine and povidone iodine in reducing bacterial skin colonization after preoperative skin preparation. A meta-analysis was conducted. Of 235 screened articles, 8 randomized controlled trials were included. The results of the meta-analysis demonstrate a significantly lower positive culture rate in the chlorhexidine group than in the povidone iodine group (RR = 0.53, 95% Cl: 0.32-0.88). The present data show the superiority of chlorhexidine in reducing the normal bacterial flora compared to povidone iodine in clean orthopedic surgery.

Effects of Topical Hydrogen Purification on Skin Parameters and Acne Vulgaris in Adult Women

BACKGROUND

Acne vulgaris is a prevalent dermatological disease characterized by skin eruptions, which may decrease the sufferer's quality of life. Hydrogen purification treatment is a new procedure used in cosmetology to improve the skin parameters of the face. This study examined the effectiveness of hydrogen purification treatment to improve women's skin conditions with regard to acne vulgaris.

METHODS

In this study, 30 women participated who suffered from a high level of sebum and acne. The control group was comprised of 30 healthy women with a low level of sebum. The Hellgren-Vincent Scale and Derma Unit SSC 3 device were used to assess acne vulgaris severity and skin properties, respectively. Four hydrogen purification sessions were carried out at 7-day intervals, using the Hebe Hydrogenium+ generating alkaline water.

RESULTS

At baseline and 7 and 14 days after finishing the series of treatments, the levels of oiliness, moisture, and skin pH were tested. The main effects of treatment were significant in the following parameters: pH around the bottom lip, moisture between the eyebrows and around the nose, and oily skin in all three face sites.

CONCLUSIONS

The level of sebum decreased and moisture levels increased during hydrogen purification. Topical hydrogen purification is an effective and safe treatment for acne vulgaris.

Periprosthetic Infection After Reverse Shoulder Arthroplasty: a Review

PURPOSE OF REVIEW

Periprosthetic infection is a relatively rare but potentially devastating complication after shoulder arthroplasty. The purpose of this article is to review the incidence, diagnosis, prevention, and management of periprosthetic infections after reverse shoulder arthroplasty, with a focus on literature published within the last 5 years.

RECENT FINDINGS

The 2018 International Consensus Meeting on Musculoskeletal Infection provides us with a framework for the diagnosis and management of periprosthetic infections after shoulder arthroplasty. Reverse shoulder arthroplasty has a higher reported rate of infection compared with anatomic total shoulder arthroplasty. Our current diagnostic tests do not appear to be as sensitive when compared with the hip and knee literature. Similar success has been reported with single and two-stage revision protocols, although prospective comparative data are lacking. The significance of unexpected positive cultures during revision arthroplasty remains unclear. We report current diagnostic and therapeutic options for periprosthetic infection after reverse shoulder arthroplasty. Much of the current literature does not distinguish between anatomic and reverse shoulder arthroplasty. Further high-level studies are warranted to refine these definitions and guide management.

A break-even analysis of benzoyl peroxide and hydrogen peroxide for infection prevention in shoulder arthroplasty

BACKGROUND

Newer strategies to decolonize the shoulder of Cutibacterium acnes may hold promise in minimizing the occurrence of infections after shoulder arthroplasty, but little is known about their cost-effectiveness. Break-even models can determine the economic viability of interventions in settings with low outcome event rates that would realistically preclude a randomized clinical trial. We used such modeling to determine the economic viability of benzoyl peroxide and hydrogen peroxide for infection prevention in shoulder arthroplasty.

METHODS

Skin decolonization protocol costs ($11.76 for benzoyl peroxide; $0.96 for hydrogen peroxide), baseline infection rates for shoulder arthroplasty (0.70%), and infection-related care costs ($50,230) were derived from institutional records and the literature. A break-even equation incorporating these variables was developed to determine the absolute risk reduction (ARR) in the infection rate to make prophylactic use economically justified. The number needed to treat was calculated from the ARR.

RESULTS

Topical benzoyl peroxide is considered economically justified if it prevents at least 1 infection out of 4348 shoulder arthroplasties (ARR = 0.023%). Hydrogen peroxide is economically justified if it prevents at least 1 infection out of 50,000 cases (ARR = 0.002%). These protocols remained economically viable at varying unit costs, initial infection rates, and infection-related care costs.

CONCLUSIONS

The use of topical benzoyl peroxide and skin preparations with hydrogen peroxide are highly economically justified practices for infection prevention in shoulder arthroplasty. Efforts to determine drawbacks of routine skin decolonization strategies are warranted as they may change the value analysis.