The future of stem cells: Should we keep the "stem" and skip the "cells"?

Effects of a collagen hyaluronic acid silk-fibroin patch with the electroconductive element polyaniline on left ventricular remodeling in an infarct heart model

Biodegradable cardiac patches have been able to induce improvement in left ventricular (LV) remodeling. A novel scaffold patch made with collagen and silk-fibroin (COL-SF) was further associated to polyaniline (PANi) to increase conductivity. Thus, this study investigated the safety of the association of PANi to a patch, and the improvement in LV remodeling in a myocardial infarct (MI) rat model. Wistar rats underwent MI induction. MI was confirmed with echocardiographic and after 2 weeks, animals (n = 10/group) were randomized into: (a) COL-SF hyaluronic acid patch, (b) PANi hyaluronic acid patch, (c) MI Control (just repeat thoracotomy). Healthy animals were also followed. Echocardiography was performed at pre-treatment, and at 2-, 4-, and 8-weeks post-treatment. Hearts underwent hemodynamic evaluation on Langendorff apparatus and histology for LV thickness and percent of infarct size. Liver, kidneys, and blood samples were evaluated for biochemical, hematological, oxidative stress, and histology. There was a tendency of lower %infarct size in patched animals. LV thickness was higher in the patched animals than controls. Functional echocardiographic indices %Fractional shortening and %LV ejection fraction decreased in the MI control group, but not in the patched animals. PANi presented higher %LVEF versus MI control. PANi presented higher liver transaminases; no morphological changes were observed in histology. Elevation of antioxidant markers was observed. COL-SF and PANi patches were able to induce better remodeling features compared to MI controls on %infarct size and LV thickness and have not presented echocardiographic worsening. Polyaniline may present a slight improvement on LV remodeling, despite associated to signs of hepatotoxicity and pro-oxidant effect.

Can a Biohybrid Patch Salvage Ventricular Function at a Late Time Point in the Post-Infarction Remodeling Process?

•

A simple, biohybrid patch made of polymer (PECUU) and ECM, without cellular components, was able to induce positive remodeling features when applied over chronic infarcts with severely dilated hearts and high cardiac function impairment in rats.

•

The remodeling benefit was particularly notable in a subgroup of the sickest rats with very low initial ejection fraction in which the echocardiographic endpoints were found to improve after treatment.

•

This technological approach may hold promise for future translation to patients in a chronic scenario.

A biohybrid patch without cellular components was implanted over large infarcted areas in severely dilated hearts. Nonpatched animals were assigned to control or losartan therapy. Patch-implanted animals responded with better morphological and functional echocardiographic endpoints, which were more evident in a subgroup of animals with very low pre-treatment ejection fraction (<35%). Patched animals also had smaller infarcts than both nonpatched groups. This simple approach could hold promise for clinical translation and be applied using minimally invasive procedures over the epicardium in a large set of patients to induce better ventricular remodeling, especially among those who are especially frail.

Application of Bioengineered Materials in the Surgical Management of Heart Failure

The epicardial surface of the heart is readily accessible during cardiac surgery and presents an opportunity for therapeutic intervention for cardiac repair and regeneration. As an important anatomic niche for endogenous mechanisms of repair, targeting the epicardium using decellularized extracellular matrix (ECM) bioscaffold therapy may provide the necessary environmental cues to promote functional recovery. Following ischemic injury to the heart caused by myocardial infarction (MI), epicardium derived progenitor cells (EPDCs) become activated and migrate to the site of injury. EPDC differentiation has been shown to contribute to endothelial cell, cardiac fibroblast, cardiomyocyte, and vascular smooth muscle cell populations. Post-MI, it is largely the activation of cardiac fibroblasts and the resultant dysregulation of ECM turnover which leads to maladaptive structural cardiac remodeling and loss of cardiac function. Decellularized ECM bioscaffolds not only provide structural support, but have also been shown to act as a bioactive reservoir for growth factors, cytokines, and matricellular proteins capable of attenuating maladaptive cardiac remodeling. Targeting the epicardium post-MI using decellularized ECM bioscaffold therapy may provide the necessary bioinductive cues to promote differentiation toward a pro-regenerative phenotype and attenuate cardiac fibroblast activation. There is an opportunity to leverage the clinical benefits of this innovative technology with an aim to improve the prognosis of patients suffering from progressive heart failure. An enhanced understanding of the utility of decellularized ECM bioscaffolds in epicardial repair will facilitate their growth and transition into clinical practice. This review will provide a summary of decellularized ECM bioscaffolds being developed for epicardial infarct repair in coronary artery bypass graft (CABG) surgery.

A mechanistic roadmap for the clinical application of cardiac cell therapies

The development of cells for regenerative therapy has encountered many pitfalls on its path to clinical translation. In cardiology, clinical studies of heart-targeted cell therapies began two decades ago, yet progress towards reaching an approved product has been slow. In this Perspective, I provide an overview of recent cardiac cell therapies, with a focus on the hurdles limiting the translation of cell products from research laboratories to clinical practice. By focusing on heart failure as a target indication, I argue that strategies for overcoming limitations in clinical translation require an increasing emphasis on mechanism-supported efficacy, rather than on phenomenological observations. As research progresses from cells to paracrine mechanisms to defined factors, identifying those defined factors that are involved in achieving superior therapeutic efficacy will better inform the use of cells as therapeutic candidates. The next generation of cell-free biologics may provide the benefits of cell therapy without the intrinsic limitations of whole-cell products.

Using Acellular Bioactive Extracellular Matrix Scaffolds to Enhance Endogenous Cardiac Repair

An inability to recover lost cardiac muscle following acute ischemic injury remains the biggest shortcoming of current therapies to prevent heart failure. As compared to standard medical and surgical treatments, tissue engineering strategies offer the promise of improved heart function by inducing regeneration of functional heart muscle. Tissue engineering approaches that use stem cells and genetic manipulation have shown promise in preclinical studies but have also been challenged by numerous critical barriers preventing effective clinical translational. We believe that surgical intervention using acellular bioactive ECM scaffolds may yield similar therapeutic benefits with minimal translational hurdles. In this review, we outline the limitations of cellular-based tissue engineering strategies and the advantages of using acellular biomaterials with bioinductive properties. We highlight key anatomic targets enriched with cellular niches that can be uniquely activated using bioactive scaffold therapy. Finally, we review the evolving cardiovascular tissue engineering landscape and provide critical insights into the potential therapeutic benefits of acellular scaffold therapy.

Phase I Clinical Trial of Autologous Stem Cell-Sheet Transplantation Therapy for Treating Cardiomyopathy

Background

When transplanted into failing heart, autologous somatic tissue–derived cells yield functional recovery via paracrine effects that enhance native regeneration. However, the therapeutic effects are modest. We developed a method in which scaffold‐free cell sheets are attached to the epicardial surface to maximize paracrine effects. This Phase I clinical trial tested whether transplanting autologous cell–sheets derived from skeletal muscle is feasible, safe, and effective for treating severe congestive heart failure.

Methods and Results

Fifteen ischemic cardiomyopathy patients and 12 patients with dilated cardiomyopathy, who were in New York Heart Association functional class II or III and had been treated with the maximum medical and/or interventional therapies available, were enrolled. Scaffold‐free cell sheets of 3 to 9×10⁸ cells derived from autologous muscle were transplanted over the LV free wall via left thoracotomy, without additional interventional treatments. There were no procedure‐related major complications during follow‐up. The majority of the ischemic cardiomyopathy patients showed marked symptomatic improvement in New York Heart Association classification (pre: 2.9±0.5 versus 6 months: 2.1±0.4, P<0.01; 1 year: 1.9±0.3, P<0.01) and the Six‐Minute Walk Test with significant reduction of serum brain natriuretic peptide level (pre: 308±72 pg/mL versus 6 months: 191±56 versus 1 year: 182±46, P<0.05), pulmonary artery pressure, pulmonary capillary wedge pressure, pulmonary vein resistance, and left ventricular wall stress after transplantation instead of limited efficacy in dilated cardiomyopathy patients.

Conclusions

Cell‐sheet transplantation as a sole therapy was feasible for treating cardiomyopathy. Promising results in the safety and functional recovery warrant further clinical follow‐up and larger studies to confirm this treatment's efficacy for severe congestive heart failure.

Clinical Trial Registration

URL: http://www.umin.ac.jp/english/. Unique identifier: UMIN000003273.

[Cell therapies for cardiopathies: the shift of paradigms]

Heart failure is a major concern for public health systems, and several approaches of cellular therapy are being investigated with the goal of improving the function of these failing hearts. Many cell types have been used (skeletal myoblasts, hematopoietic, endothelial or mesenchymal progenitors, cardiac cells…), most often in the indication of post-ischemic heart failure rather than in the indication of genetic dilated cardiomyopathy. It is easier, indeed, to target a restricted area than the whole myocardium. Several clinical trials have reported slight but encouraging functional benefits, but their interpretations were frequently limited by the small sizes of cohorts, and by the biological variabilities inherent to the patients status and to the biology of the cells. These trials also shed light on unexpected mechanisms of action of the cells, which are changing the concepts and methodologies of the studies. The functional benefits observed would be due, indeed, to the secretion of trophic factors by the cells, instead of their true structural and mechanical integration within the myocardial tissue. Accordingly, the new generations of clinical trials aim at improving the size and homogeneity of the patient cohorts to increase the statistical power. On the other hand, several studies are associating or conditionning cells with biomaterials or cocktails of cytokines to improve their survival and their biological efficacy. In parallel, bio-engineering investigates several ways to support cells in vitro and in vivo, to sustain the architectural structure of the failing myocardium, to produce ex vivo some true substitutive cardiac tissue, or to purely replace the cells by their active secreted products. Several therapeutic devices should emerge from these researches, and the choice of their respective use will be ultimately guided by the medical indication.