Extraperitoneal Laparoscopic Trigonoplasty for Treatment of Vesicoureteral Reflux: Novel Technique Duplicating its Open Counterpart

Long-term follow-up of trigonoplasty antireflux operation

BACKGROUND

Open trigonoplasty antireflux operation has been associated with promising results. However, its success in controlling reflux has not been evaluated in the long term.

METHODS

All patients who underwent trigonoplasty for vesicoureteral reflux by one surgeon from 2004 to 2014 were included. Preoperative evaluations included direct radionuclide cystography (DRNC) or voiding cystourethrography, urine analysis and culture and abdominal sonography. Urodynamic study and cystoscopy was performed in selected patients. Trigonoplasty was done by a modified Gil-Verent method. The latest available patients' DRNCs were used to judge for reflux relapse.

RESULTS

Ninety-one patients, 142 refluxing units; median (range) age, 10.5 (1-45) years; M/F, (11/80) were followed for 18 to 135 months. Reflux resolution rate was 73.6% for patients and 75.4% for refluxing units. Relapse was associated with reflux grade (67% in grade V), ureteral orifice appearance (40% in golf hole/stadium), and patients with a history of pyelonephritis. Multivariable model based on the above variables had less than 10% sensitivity in predicting relapse.

CONCLUSIONS

Trigonoplasty success rate can decrease with long-term follow-up.

Evaluation of a process-of-care model for open intravesical ureteral reimplantation in children from a contemporary health care perspective

INTRODUCTION

Surgical management of patients with vesicoureteral reflux consists of both open and minimally invasive approaches. Open approaches are associated with postoperative hospitalization and stays of 2 to 3 days, dependent on the type of procedure; alternately, when endoscopic correction is performed, it is a same-day procedure. Changes in health care policy emphasize reduction in cost while maintaining and improving quality of care. We sought to evaluate the impact of a "1-night cost-saving process-of-care" model for open surgical correction of vesicoureteral reflux in children on quality of care, which was defined as a return to the emergency room (ER)/office or readmission to the hospital within 2 days of discharge.

MATERIALS AND METHODS

An institutional review board-approved retrospective chart review of all open ureteral reimplantations for uncomplicated vesicoureteral reflux from January 2009 through January 2013 was performed. Children who underwent ureteral stent placement and those who did not have a caudal anesthetic were excluded from the study. Length of postoperative stay, ER records, hospitalizations, and office records were reviewed to assess for presentation to the ER/office or readmission to the hospital within 2 days of discharge.

RESULTS

During the 4-year study period, 92 children (23 males, 69 females) underwent open ureteral reimplantation-there were 83 (89.1%) discharges on the first postoperative day; 9 (9.8%) on the second postoperative day; and 1 (1.1%) on the third postoperative day. One patient presented to the ER within 2 days of discharge, and 4 patients presented to the ER/office or were readmitted > 2 days after discharge.

CONCLUSION

Use of a caudal anesthetic, earlier catheter removal, a knowledgeable nursing team, and parental education allowed us to decrease the length of stay to 1 night in 82 of 92 patients (89.1%). These procedural changes allowed for a decrease in hospital stay comparable with and potentially shorter than robotic-assisted laparoscopic approaches. Additionally, these changes did not seem to increase the risk of early (≤ 2 days of discharge) presentation to the ER/office or readmission.

[Treatment of distal ureteral stricture by laparoscopic ureterovesical reimplantation]

INTRODUCTION

to analyse the results achieved to treat iliac or pelvic ureteric stricture using laparoscopic reimplantation of the ureter in a psoic bladder.

MATERIAL AND METHOD

in a four-year period, we performed laparoscopic ureteral reimplantation in a psoic bladder in 6 patients (right/left 1:1; male/female 1:2; mean age 59.2 years, range 47-87). In 4 cases the lesion was iatrogenic and in 2 cases idiopathic. Ureteral resection with bladder cuff and cystorraphy followed by ipsilateral lymph node dissection was performed in idiopathic cases or those with history of previous urothelial tumour (4 cases in total) before ureteral reimplantation. Bladder was extensively mobilized and fixed to minor psoas tendon before performing ureteroneocystostomy. Mixed intra and extravesical technique with submucosal tunnel (Politano) was used in a case and in the remaining 5 cases extravesical technique with submucosal tunnel (Goodwin) was used. Mean follow-up was 26 months (range 18-34).

RESULTS

there was no need to convert to open surgery. Time of surgery was 230 minutes in the case treated with Politano ureteroneocystostomy and 120 (range 75-150) in those treated purely extravesically. The mean hospital stay was 3.2 days (range 2-5). There were no intra or postoperative complications. Histologic assessment always revealed ureteral fibrosis and in 2 cases accompanying granulomatous inflammation and dysplasia. No patient suffered re-stricture or impairment in renal function during follow-up.

CONCLUSIONS

laparoscopic ureteral reimplantation is an effective and safe minimally invasive technique to treat benign distal stricture of the ureter. Simplicity of extravesical reimplantation has an advantage over its intravesical counterpart.

Gil-Vernet antireflux surgery in children's primary vesicoureteral reflux

PURPOSE

The assessment of the results of Gil-Vernet antireflux surgery in children with primary vesicoureteral reflux.

MATERIALS AND METHODS

In a descriptive retrospective study, 72 patients with vesicoureteral reflux (VUR) and 104 refluxing units underwent Gil-Vernet antireflux surgery in Mofid children's hospital from Dec 2000 to Nov 2005. The study group was selected from among the patients with VUR who had been operated in our center. Data were collected from the medical records of the patients in the archive of the hospital and analyzed for gender, age, method of diagnosis, side of involvement, grading types, usage of catheter and stent, operating time, hospital stay, reflux down grading, operative success rate, recurrence and operative complication.

RESULTS

Among 72 patients, 47 (65%) were females and 25 (35%) were males with a mean age of 4.35 ± 2.96 years (range 1-13 years). 32 patients had bilateral and 40 had unilateral reflux, and 76% were in grades III and IV. Mean operative time was 55 ± 13 min, median hospital stay was 2 ± 0.9 days and mean follow-up period was 48 ± 9 months. Reflux was improved completely in 100 (96.15%) refluxing units, and down-graded in 4 (3.84%) units. Treatment was performed medically in 2 and surgically in 2 refluxing units, and all were improved successfully. There were no complications post-operatively.

CONCLUSION

Gil-Vernet antireflux technique is a useful method, and it has many advantages such as simplicity, shorter operative time, lower complication rate and high success rate.

Management of vesicoureteral reflux without indwelling catheter and drain, using trigonoplasty technique

PURPOSE

Gil-Vernet trigonoplasty is a simple, fast and effective technique for treating primary VUR, and is the only technique used to manage unilateral reflux that does not result in contralateral new reflux, due to its inherent bilateral nature. We have tried to further simplify postoperative management of the procedure by eliminating the use of an indwelling urethral catheter and drain.

PATIENTS AND METHODS

In a prospective study during a 15-month period, 65 children with 103 refluxing units (56 girls, nine boys), aged 1-15 years, underwent the designed surgery.

RESULTS

Preoperative voiding cystourethrogram revealed bilateral reflux in 38 and unilateral reflux in 27 children. Of 130 renal units, 103 were associated with reflux grade I, II, III, IV and V in 8.73%, 24.27%, 35.92%, 30.9% and 0.9% units, respectively. Of 103 refluxing units, 97 units had stopped refluxing on cystogram 3 months after surgery, giving the overall success rate of 94.1% for all grades of reflux included in the study. Only 7.6% of the children needed urethral catheterization after surgery. No ureteral obstruction occurred. Two patients developed urinary extravasation, both managed conservatively. No patient needed reoperation. The procedure was done on an outpatient basis in 40% of cases, while 60% of the children were hospitalized with a mean admission time of 3.4 days.

CONCLUSION

The Gil-Vernet trigonoplasty technique is simple, safe and effective. Our study further simplified postoperative management by avoiding an indwelling catheter and drain. Also, we have shown that this can be done as an outpatient procedure.

Current status of Gil-Vernet trigonoplasty technique

Significant controversy exists regarding vesicoureteral reflux (VUR) management, due to lack of sufficient prospective studies. The rationale for surgical management is that VUR can cause recurrent episodes of pyelonephritis and long-term renal damage. Several surgical techniques have been introduced during the past decades. Open anti-reflux operations have high success rate, exceeding 95%, and long durability. The goal of this article is to review the Gil-Vernet trigonoplasty technique, which is a simple and highly successful technique but has not gained the attention it deserves. The mainstay of this technique is approximation of medial aspects of ureteral orifices to midline by one mattress suture. A unique advantage of Gil-Vernet trigonoplasty is its bilateral nature, which results in prevention from contralateral new reflux. Regarding not altering the normal course of the ureter in Gil-Vernet procedure, later catheterization of and retrograde access to the ureter can be performed normally. There is no report of ureterovesical junction obstruction following Gil-Vernet procedure. Gil-Vernet trigonoplasty can be performed without inserting a bladder catheter and drain on an outpatient setting. Several exclusive advantages of Gil-Vernet trigonoplasty make it necessary to reconsider the technique role in VUR management.