Subjective and Objective Voice Assessments After Recurrent Laryngeal Nerve-Preserved Total Thyroidectomy

Correlation of acoustic voice analysis and Voice Handicap Index in patients with postoperative unilateral vocal cord paralysis after thyroid surgery

Unilateral vocal cord paralysis is frequently observed in patients who undergo thyroid surgery. This study explored the correlation between acoustic voice analysis (objective measure) and Voice Handicap Index (VHI, a self-assessment tool). One hundred and forty patients who had thyroid surgery with or without postoperative unilateral vocal cord paralysis (PVCP and NPVCP) were included. The patients were evaluated by the VHI and Dysphonia Severity Index (DSI) tools. VHI scores were significantly higher in PVCP patients than in NPVCP patients. Jitter (%) and shimmer (%) were significantly increased, whereas DSI was significantly decreased in PVCP patients. Receiver operating characteristics curve revealed that VHI scores were associated with the diagnosis of PVCP, of which VHI total score yielded an area under the curve (AUC) of 0.81. Among acoustic parameters, DSI was highly associated to PVCP (AUC=0.82, 95%CI=0.75 to 0.89). Moreover, we found a correlation between VHI scores and voice acoustic parameters. Among them, DSI had a moderate correlation with functional and VHI scores, as suggested by an R value of 0.41 and 0.49, respectively. VHI scores and acoustic parameters were associated with the diagnosis of PVCP.

Early Assessment of Voice Problems in Post-Thyroidectomy Syndrome Using Cepstral Analysis

Post-thyroidectomy syndrome (PTS), characterized by voice issues after thyroidectomy without recurrent laryngeal nerve injury, was investigated in this study. The Voice Fatigue Index (VFI) and cepstral analysis were employed for subjective and objective voice evaluation. Retrospective analysis involved 96 patients (37 males, 59 females) who underwent thyroidectomy without nerve injury from April 2018 to June 2022. Assessments pre- and post-thyroidectomy included the Voice Handicap Index (VHI) and VFI, along with auditory perceptual, acoustic (including cepstral), aerodynamic, and glottal vibration analyses. In females, although the GRBAS scale showed no significant change, both VHI and VFI increased post-thyroidectomy. Significant correlations were observed between the VHI and VFI in females. Acoustic analysis indicated a decrease in the cepstral peak prominence (CPP) of vowels (/a/) and sentences in females, with significant correlations between changes in the CPP/a/ and VHI/VFI. The maximum fundamental frequency (F0max) exhibited a significant decrease, correlating with the VHI and VFI changes. The VFI demonstrated effectiveness in subjective PTS voice evaluation, comparable to the VHI. The present study highlights the potential of cepstral analysis as an index reflecting subjective voice discomfort, suggesting its promise for a comprehensive PTS voice evaluation.

Persistent subjective voice symptoms for two years after thyroidectomy

BACKGROUND

Voice change after thyroidectomy is an important issue in thyroid surgery. However, little is known about long-term voice outcomes after thyroidectomy. This study investigates the long-term voice outcomes of thyroidectomy up to two years after surgery. Also, we analyzed the pattern of recovery through acoustic tests over time.

METHODS

We reviewed data from 168 patients who underwent thyroidectomy between January 2020 and August 2020 at a single institution. The Thyroidectomy-related Voice and Symptom Questionnaire (TVSQ) score and acoustic voice analysis results were examined preoperatively and postoperative one, three, and six months, and one and two years after surgery. We divided patients into two groups based on the TVSQ score (≥15 or <15) at two years postoperatively. We investigated the difference of acoustic characteristics between the two groups and analyzed correlations between acoustic parameters and various clinical and surgical factors.

RESULTS

Voice parameters tended to recover, but some parameters and TVSQ scores exhibited deterioration two years after surgery. In the subgroups, among the many clinicopathologic factors examined, voice abuse history including professional voice users (p = 0.014), greater extent of thyroidectomy and neck dissection (p = 0.019, p = 0.029), and high pitch voice (F0; p = 0.005, SFF; p = 0.016) were associated with high TVSQ score at two years.

CONCLUSIONS

Patients frequently experience voice discomfort after thyroidectomy. After surgery, voice abuse history including professional voice users, greater extent of surgery, and higher pitch voice are associated with worse voice quality and increased risk of persistent voice symptoms over the long-term.

Effect of Chronic Cough on Voice Measures in Patients With Dysphonia

INTRODUCTION

Measuring the impact of chronic cough on voice quality can be difficult and challenging in daily practice. Evidence about its potential effects on diagnostic tools used in voice evaluation is lacking. We hypothesized that the presence of chronic cough plays a role in patients' perception of dysphonia severity, leading to a mismatch between the subjective, objective, and perceptual evaluations.

METHODS

A retrospective chart review involving patients with a diagnosis of dysphonia and a complete speech voice evaluation was performed. A total of 311 patients were stratified into two different groups according to the presence of chronic cough. A total of 151 patients were assigned to the dysphonia and chronic cough group, while 160 patients were assigned to the dysphonia only group. During the initial evaluation, patients completed the Voice Handicap Index (VHI)-30, Glottal Function Index (GFI), and Reflux Symptoms Index (RSI). Voice evaluation also included aerodynamic/acoustic measures and the application of the GRBAS scale by a speech-language specialist. A paired t test and a linear regression analysis were used to compare subjective, perceptual, and aerodynamic/acoustic measures in both groups.

RESULTS

The mean VHI-30 and GFI were elevated in both groups but significantly lower among patients with dysphonia and chronic cough when compared to patients with dysphonia only (P= 0.01). Additionally, a significantly higher RSI was found among patients with dysphonia and chronic cough (P< 0.01). No difference in aerodynamic/acoustic measures was found between groups (P> 0.05). Our linear regression model demonstrated a significant effect of the presence of chronic cough on the VHI-30, RSI, and GFI questionnaires (P< 0.05). Our model also found that the VHI-30 is a significant predictor for the (G), (B), (A), and (S) components of the GRBAS scale (P< 0.05).

CONCLUSION

The presence of chronic cough has a significant impact on the different patient-reported outcome measures, including VHI-30, RSI, and GFI. The use of VHI-30 as a predictor for the GRBAS scale reinforces the importance of subjective and perceptual assessment among patients with voice disorders and establishes a new area for exploration.

How the Severity and Mechanism of Recurrent Laryngeal Nerve Dysfunction during Monitored Thyroidectomy Impact on Postoperative Voice

Simple Summary

Recurrent laryngeal nerve (RLN) dysfunction remains a major source of morbidity after thyroid surgery. Intraoperative neuromonitoring can qualify and quantify RLN function according to the laryngeal electromyography (EMG) response evoked by electrical stimulation of the RLN. To the best of our knowledge, this is the first report to discuss the severity and mechanism of RLN dysfunction and postoperative voice in patients who have received monitored thyroidectomy. For optimal voice and swallowing outcomes after thyroid surgery, thermal injury must be avoided, especially when using energy-based devices, and mechanical injury must be identified early to avoid a more severe dysfunction. Adherence to standard intraoperative neuromonitoring (IONM) procedures for thyroid surgery is suggested, including standard procedures for acquiring and interpreting intraoperative RLN signals, for identifying and classifying RLN injury mechanisms, for performing laryngeal examinations and comprehensive voice assessments (subjective and objective voice analysis) before and after surgery, and for performing standard follow-up procedures.

Abstract

Intraoperative neuromonitoring can qualify and quantify RLN function during thyroid surgery. This study investigated how the severity and mechanism of RLN dysfunction during monitored thyroid surgery affected postoperative voice. This retrospective study analyzed 1021 patients that received standardized monitored thyroidectomy. Patients had post-dissection RLN(R2) signal <50%, 50–90% and >90% decrease from pre-dissection RLN(R1) signal were classified into Group A-no/mild, B-moderate, and C-severe RLN dysfunction, respectively. Demographic characteristics, RLN injury mechanisms(mechanical/thermal) and voice analysis parameters were recorded. More patients in the group with higher severity of RLN dysfunction had malignant pathology results (A/B/C = 35%/48%/55%, p = 0.017), received neck dissection (A/B/C = 17%/31%/55%, p < 0.001), had thermal injury (p = 0.006), and had asymmetric vocal fold motion in long-term postoperative periods (A/B/C = 0%/8%/62%, p < 0.001). In postoperative periods, Group C patients had significantly worse voice outcomes in several voice parameters in comparison to Group A/B. Thermal injury was associated with larger voice impairments compared to mechanical injury. This report is the first to discuss the severity and mechanism of RLN dysfunction and postoperative voice in patients who received monitored thyroidectomy. To optimize voice and swallowing outcomes after thyroidectomy, avoiding thermal injury is mandatory, and mechanical injury must be identified early to avoid a more severe dysfunction.

Care and Management of Voice Change for Thyroid Surgery: Korean Society of Laryngology, Phoniatrics and Logopedics Clinical Practice Guideline

Voice change is a common complaint after thyroid surgery and has significant impacts on quality of life. The Korean Society of Laryngology, Phoniatrics, and Logopedics set up a task force team to establish guideline recommendations on education, care, and management related to thyroid surgery. The guideline recommendations include preoperative voice education, management of anticipated voice change during surgery, and comprehensive voice care after thyroid surgery, including in-depth information and up-to-date knowledge based on validated literature. The committee constructed 14 key questions (KQ) in three categories: preoperative (KQ1-2), intraoperative (KQ 3-8), and postoperative (KQ 9-14) management and developed 18 evidence-based recommendations. The Delphi survey reached an agreement on each recommendation. Detailed evidence profiles are presented for each recommendation. The level of evidence for each recommendation is classified into high, moderate, and low-quality. The recommendation's strengths are adjusted to consider the level of evidence resulting in the recommendation and are divided into strong and weak. The guidelines are primarily targeted toward physicians who treat thyroid surgery patients and speech-language pathologists participating in patient care. These guidelines will also help primary care physicians, nurses, healthcare policymakers, and patients improve their understanding of voice changes and voice care after thyroid surgery.

Long-term voice quality outcome after thyroidectomy without laryngeal nerve injury: a prospective 10 year follow up study

PURPOSE

This study investigates the long-term voice outcome of thyroidectomy up to 10 years after the surgery using a longitudinal prospective study design.

METHODS

Eighteen participants (6 men and 12 women, mean age: 54 years) who underwent a thyroidectomy between September 2006 and May 2007 were included in this study. A voice assessment protocol consisting of subjective (videolaryngostroboscopic evaluation, auditory- perceptual evaluation, patients' self-report) and objective voice assessments (maximum performance task, acoustic analysis, voice range profile and Dysphonia Severity Index) was used to evaluate the participants' pre- and postoperative voice. Voice measurements were compared before and one week, six weeks, three months and 10 years after the surgery.

RESULTS

No significant differences over time in auditory-perceptual and objective voice parameters were found, except for shimmer. Only in the first postoperative condition, significantly more patients reported vocal complaints. A progressive amelioration of the vocal folds' movement patterns was observed in the postoperative conditions.

CONCLUSION

The findings of this small longitudinal prospective study suggest that thyroidectomy without laryngeal nerve injury does not cause a permanent deterioration of the laryngeal aspect or function, vocal fold behavior and the self-perceived, perceptual and objective vocal quality. The increase of the shimmer 10 years post-thyroidectomy may be related to vocal aging.

Subjective voice analysis in patients with muscular tension dysphonia: comparison between clinician and patient evaluation

BACKGROUND

This study evaluated the correlation between patient and clinician subjective voice analysis in a group of patients suffering from muscular tension dysphonia. This disease does not usually present with organic lesions, and voice analysis is crucial to evaluate it.

METHODS

A retrospective study with 75 patients was performed. Correlation between grade, roughness, breathiness, asthenia and strain scale and voice handicap index-10 was analysed. Any possible influence of the type of muscular tension dysphonia on these two scales was studied.

RESULTS

There are only a few studies that correlate voice handicap index-10 and the grade, roughness, breathiness, asthenia and strain scale; however, none of them are specific for patients suffering from muscular tension dysphonia. A moderate correlation (r = 0.56) was found. No influence of muscular tension dysphonia type on voice handicap index-10 score was found, but muscular tension dysphonia type 4 had worse grade, roughness, breathiness, asthenia and strain scale scores than other muscular tension dysphonia types. This could be explained if muscular tension dysphonia type 4 is considered to be the most severe form of this disease.

CONCLUSION

The use of assessment scales based on the opinion of both the clinician and patient must be considered as complementary clinical tools in order to perform a complete assessment of dysphonia.

Evaluation of one-year incidence of vocal dysfunction and associated demographic factors in thyroidectomy patients: A descriptive analytical study

Background

Voice changes are common complaint following thyroidectomy that might or might not be associated with laryngeal nerve damage. Objective: The aim of this study is to evaluate the effect thyroidectomy on voice alteration and its association with gender and age.

Methods

In this descriptive analytical study, patients who underwent thyroidectomy at (XXX) without laryngeal nerve damage were included. These patients were evaluated based on subjective (self-reported) and objective (videostroboscopy) voice assessment. The data was collected immediately after the surgery and 6 months after the surgery during the follow-up.

Results

Of 76 patients included, the mean age of patients was 46.3 year. 25 (43.4%) were males and 51 (56.6%) were female. 28.9% patients were presented with apparent damage to the vocal cords, of which 8 (10.5) had voice changes. There was no statistically significant difference between sex and postoperative vocal cord dysfunction (P = 0.592). However, in male gender, late postoperative voice changes were significantly more, p = 0.013. The age was also not associated with immediate or late postoperative changes and damage to vocal cords, p > 0.05.

Conclusion

Our study reported that male gender can be an important factor in deterring voice changes after thyroidectomy nonetheless, it can not predict the risk of vocal cord damage. Furthermore, age might not a risk factor either. Studies with greater sample size are required to confirm these findings.

•

Voice changes are common complaint following thyroidectomy.

•

That might or might not be associated with laryngeal nerve damage.

•

Male gender can be an important factor in deterring voice changes after thyroidectomy.

•

Studies with greater sample size are required to confirm these findings.

Assessment of Dysphonia Using the Japanese Version of the Voice Handicap Index and Determination of Cutoff Points for Screening

INTRODUCTION

The Voice Handicap Index (VHI) is recognized as a useful subjective assessment method for dysphonia. The original VHI has been translated into numerous other languages, including Japanese (J-VHI). Although the reliability and validity of the J-VHI have already been established, the cutoff point has not been determined. The aims of this study were to investigate the relationship between the J-VHI and other voice laboratory measurements, and determine the cutoff point.

METHOD

This study included 167 dysphonic patients and 55 healthy volunteers. All patients and volunteers completed the J-VHI at the initial visit, and the following outcomes were determined: VHI scores of patients with dysphonia and healthy volunteers, VHI scores according to disease, cutoff point, and correlations between VHI scores and other voice laboratory measurements.

RESULTS

Both the total VHI (VHI-T) and individual domain (functional domain [VHI-F], emotional domain [VHI-E], physical domain [VHI-P]) scores were significantly higher in the dysphonia group compared to the healthy volunteer group. VHI-T, VHI-F, and VHI-E scores were significantly lower in the benign mucosal lesion subgroup, compared to the other disease subgroups. The G scale and B scale of the grade-roughness-breathiness-asthenia-strain scale showed a significant association with VHI-T, VHI-F, and VHI-P scores. Similarly, the A scale showed a significant association with VHI-T, VHI-F, and VHI-E scores. The cutoff point (12) for VHI-T was chosen from the receiver operating characteristic curve to maximize sensitivity and specificity. Similarly, the cutoff points for VHI-F (5), VHI-P (5), and VHI-E (3) were also obtained. Significant differences in maximum phonation time, pitch range, G scale, and B scale were observed between the VHI-T negative (VHI ≤ 12) and positive (VHI-T > 13) groups.

CONCLUSION

These findings suggest that self-evaluation using the VHI could serve as an independent assessment and screening tool for patients with dysphonia.

Development and Validation of the Thyroidectomy-Related Voice and Symptom Questionnaire (TVSQ)

OBJECTIVES

Common symptoms after thyroidectomy include voice change and throat and neck discomfort. But no common questionnaire has been developed. This study was performed to evaluate the reliability and validity of the Thyroidectomy-related Voice and Symptom Questionnaire (TVSQ).

METHODS

Fourty items of the TVSQ were divided into 20 items related to the "voice change" and "throat and neck discomfort" subcategories, using item generation. Through a reduction process, 20 items were removed and 20 items were used. For the patients after thyroidectomy, we evaluated the reliability and validity of each of the 20 items through item discrimination, test-retest reliability, concurrent validity, and external validity by comparing normal group and laryngeal disease patients. Also, the patients were compared before as well as 2 and 4 weeks after thyroidectomy.

RESULTS

Item discrimination assessment showed a significant correlation between TVSQ total score and both the TVSQ "voice change" score (r = 0.908**) and TVSQ "throat and neck discomfort" score (r = 0.862**). Test-retest reliability assessment showed a significant correlation between TVSQ total scores at 2 and 4 weeks postoperatively (r = 0.764**). Concurrent validity assessment revealed that the TVSQ showed high correlations with other voice questionnaires (Voice Handicap Index, Reflux Finding Index, and Vocal Track Discomfort Scale; r = 0.538**-0.830**). External validity assessment revealed that the TVSQ was suitable for patients after thyroidectomy (P < 0.000**).

CONCLUSIONS

Validity and reliability tests revealed that the TVSQ was suitable for assessment of the subjective feelings of patients with voice change and throat and neck discomfort after thyroidectomy.

Voice Outcomes After Radiation for Early-Stage Laryngeal Cancer

OBJECTIVES

Radiation treatment for laryngeal cancer has been shown to cause tissue changes to the vocal folds, which can result in degradation of voice. Our objective in this study was to investigate changes in perceptual, acoustic, and patient-reported outcomes over an extended period of follow-up after radiation.

DESIGN

Retrospective review.

METHODS

All patients treated with radiation for early-stage laryngeal carcinoma (in situ, T1, or T2) by a single surgeon from 2011-2018 were reviewed. Demographics and treatment information were recorded. Only patients with at least two dates of follow-up with acoustic data (cepstral spectral index of dysphonia [CSID]) and patient-reported surveys (voice handicap index-10 [VHI-10]) were included. Voice samples were rated by two senior speech-language pathologists on the grade, roughness, breathiness, asthenia, and strain scale.

RESULTS

Of 115 patients with early-stage laryngeal cancer, 31 patients met inclusion criteria. The average follow-up from time of treatment was 9.6 years (range 3.0-20.3 years), and the average time in between the first and last voice recordings was 2.6 years (range 0.3-5.5 years). The lesions represented were carcinoma in situ (n = 4), T1 (n = 22), and T2 (n = 5). The VHI-10 scores worsened slightly (mean increase +0.27, median +1) from first to last measurements as did the CSID score (median increase +7.0, median +7.4), though neither reached statistical significance when correlated with time since radiation (P = 0.269 and P = 0.0850). Perceptual analysis as rated by two speech-language pathologists raters showed excellent inter-rater reliability (Cronbach's alpha = 0.84), with no significant change over time (mean +0.39, median, with P = 0.347). Grade, roughness, breathiness, asthenia, and strain, VHI-10, and CSID were all correlated (all pairwise comparisons P < 0.001).

CONCLUSION

Perceptual, acoustic, and patient-reported outcomes years after radiation for early-stage laryngeal cancer do not show voice degradation over time in this preliminary analysis. Further research with a larger cohort may elucidate voice changes in this population.

Association Between Age and Patient-Reported Changes in Voice and Swallowing After Thyroidectomy

OBJECTIVES

Despite intact recurrent laryngeal nerves, patient-reported voice and swallowing changes are common after thyroidectomy. The association between patient age or frailty status and these changes is unknown. The aim of this study was to evaluate the impact of age and frailty on the incidence of voice and swallowing alterations after thyroidectomy.

METHODS

We performed an institutional review board (IRB)-approved retrospective review of consecutive patients who underwent total thyroidectomy with intraoperative recurrent laryngeal nerve (RLN) monitoring at a single institution between January 2014 and September 2016. Patients with RLN injury were excluded. After data extraction, a modified frailty index (mFI) was calculated for each patient. The association among risk factors, including age, mFI, prior history of neck surgery, frequent voice use, presence of malignancy or gastroesophageal reflux disease, and smoking status and reported voice and/or swallowing changes was examined.

RESULTS

Of 924 patients undergoing thyroidectomy, 148 (16.0%) reported only changes in voice; 52 (5.6%) reported only difficulty in swallowing; and 26 (2.8%) reported changes with both voice and swallowing. On multivariate analysis, we found a significant increase in voice or swallowing alterations up to the age of 50 years (5% increased odds per year), after which these changes plateaued. We found that mFI was not associated with voice or swallowing changes.

CONCLUSION

Age ≥ 50 years is independently associated with the development of voice or swallowing changes after thyroidectomy, despite intact RLN. Additional prospective studies are needed to validate these findings, further define this association, and identify risk factors for developing these changes.

LEVEL OF EVIDENCE

2b Laryngoscope, 129:519-524, 2019.