Is Surface Electromyography (sEMG) a Useful Tool in Identifying Muscle Tension Dysphonia? An Integrative Review of the Current Evidence

Predicting Dysphonia by Measuring Surface Electromyographic Activity of the Supralaryngeal Muscles

PURPOSE

This study set out to investigate whether individuals with dysphonia, as determined by either self-assessment or clinician-based auditory-perceptual judgment, exhibited differences in perilaryngeal muscle activities using surface electromyography (sEMG) during various phonatory tasks. Additionally, the study aimed to assess the effectiveness of sEMG in identifying dysphonic cases.

METHOD

A total of 77 adults (44 women, 33 men, Mage = 30.4 years) participated in this study, with dysphonic cases identified separately using either a 10-item Voice Handicap Index (VHI-10) or clinician-based auditory-perceptual voice quality (APVQ) evaluation. sEMG activities were measured from the areas of suprahyoid and sternocleidomastoid muscles during prolonged vowel /i/ phonations at different pitch and loudness levels. Normalized root-mean-square value against the maximal voluntary contraction (RMS %MVC) of the sEMG signals was obtained for each phonation and compared between subject groups and across phonatory tasks. Additionally, binary logistic regression analysis was performed to determine how the sEMG measures could predict the VHI-10-based or APVQ-based dysphonic cases.

RESULTS

Participants who scored above the criteria on either the VHI-10 (n = 29) or APVQ judgment (n = 17) exhibited significantly higher RMS %MVC in the right suprahyoid muscles compared to the corresponding control groups. Although the RMS %MVC value from the right suprahyoid muscles alone was not a significant predictor of self-evaluated dysphonic cases, a combination of the RMS %MVC values from both the right and left suprahyoid muscles significantly predicted APVQ-based dysphonic cases with a 69.66% fair level.

CONCLUSIONS

This study found that individuals with dysphonia, as determined by either self-assessment or APVQ judgment, displayed more imbalanced suprahyoid muscle activities in voice production compared to nondysphonic groups. The combination of the sEMG measures from both left and right suprahyoid muscles showed potential as a predictor of dysphonia with a fair level of confidence.

SUPPLEMENTAL MATERIAL

https://doi.org/10.23641/asha.25112804.

A new fractional fuzzy dispersion entropy and its application in muscle fatigue detection

Recently, fuzzy dispersion entropy (DispEn) has attracted much attention as a new nonlinear dynamics method that combines the advantages of both DispEn and fuzzy entropy. However, it suffers from limitation of insensitivity to dynamic changes. To solve this limitation, we proposed fractional fuzzy dispersion entropy (FFDispEn) based on DispEn, a novel fuzzy membership function and fractional calculus. The fuzzy membership function was defined based on the Euclidean distance between the embedding vector and dispersion pattern. Simulated signals generated by the one-dimensional (1D) logistic map were used to test the sensitivity of the proposed method to dynamic changes. Moreover, 29 subjects were recruited for an upper limb muscle fatigue experiment, during which surface electromyography (sEMG) signals of the biceps brachii muscle were recorded. Both simulated signals and sEMG signals were processed using a sliding window approach. Sample entropy (SampEn), DispEn and FFDispEn were separately used to calculate the complexity of each frame. The sensitivity of different algorithms to the muscle fatigue process was analyzed using fitting parameters through linear fitting of the complexity of each frame signal. The results showed that for simulated signals, the larger the fractional order q, the higher the sensitivity to dynamic changes. Moreover, DispEn performed poorly in the sensitivity to dynamic changes compared with FFDispEn. As for muscle fatigue detection, the FFDispEn value showed a clear declining tendency with a mean slope of -1.658 × 10-3 as muscle fatigue progresses; additionally, it was more sensitive to muscle fatigue compared with SampEn (slope: -0.4156 × 10-3) and DispEn (slope: -0.1675 × 10-3). The highest accuracy of 97.5% was achieved with the FFDispEn and support vector machine (SVM). This study provided a new useful nonlinear dynamic indicator for sEMG signal processing and muscle fatigue analysis. The proposed method may be useful for physiological and biomedical signal analysis.

Surface electromyographic (sEMG) activity of the suprahyoid and sternocleidomastoid muscles in pitch and loudness control

Purpose: This study set out to determine the contributions of the suprahyoid and sternocleidomastoid (SCM) muscles in changing pitch and loudness during phonation among vocally healthy populations. Method: Thirty-nine participants were first recruited, and twenty-nine of them who passed the screening test (Voice Handicap Index [VHI]-10 score ≤11, auditory-perceptual voice rating score ≤2) were finally selected (mean age = 28.2 years). All participants were measured for their surface electromyographic (sEMG) activity collected from the bilateral suprahyoid and SCM muscles when producing the vowel /a/, /i/, and /u/ in natural (baseline) and at different pitch (+3, +6, -3, -6 semitones) and loudness (+5, +10, -5 dB) levels. Linear mixed-effects models were performed to determine the influencing factors on the root-mean-square percentage of maximal voluntary contraction (RMS %MVC) value of the sEMG signals. Results: Compared with the baseline, a significant decrease of RMS %MVC was found in the suprahyoid muscles during overall phonations of lower pitches (-3 and -6 semitones) and loudness (-5 dB). However, no significant change was detected when producing speech at higher pitch (+3 and +6 semitones) and loudness (+5 and +10 dB) levels. Among the three vowels, /i/ demonstrated significantly higher RMS %MVC than those of /a/ and /u/. The SCM muscles, however, did not show any significant change in the RMS %MVC values among different vowels in relation to the pitch and loudness changes. When the muscles were compared across the two sides, significantly higher RMS %MVC was found in the right side of the suprahyoid (in pitch and loudness control) and SCM (in pitch control) when compared to the left side. Conclusions: The suprahyoid muscle activities were significantly decreased when producing lower pitches and intensities compared to the natural baselines. The production of sustained /i/ required significantly more suprahyoid muscle activities than those of /a/ and /u/. The SCM muscles did not show much sEMG activity in any of the pitch and loudness levels, which could be used potentially as the calibration or normalization of peri-laryngeal sEMG measurement. The findings also showed a tendency for bilateral asymmetry in the use of suprahyoid and SCM muscles.

Is Thyrohyoid Space Palpation a Reliable and Useful Clinical Tool Within Diagnostic Protocol for Voice Disorders?

OBJECTIVES

Palpation of the extrinsic laryngeal muscles is a common part of examination performed by otolaryngologists and speech-language pathologists on individuals presenting with voice complaints, thought to aid in diagnosis and treatment planning. While research has identified a significant relationship between thyrohyoid tension and hyperfunctional voice disorders, we are not aware of any studies exploring correlations between thyrohyoid posture during palpation and the full spectrum of voice disorders. This study aims to identify whether patterns in thyrohyoid posture at rest and during phonation can be related to stroboscopic findings and voice disorder diagnoses.

METHODS

A multidisciplinary team of three laryngologists and three speech-language pathologists participated in data collection during 47 new patient visits for voice complaints. Each patient underwent neck palpation and evaluation of thyrohyoid space at rest and during phonation by two independent raters. Clinicians then used stroboscopy to rate glottal closure and supraglottic activity as part of determining primary diagnosis.

RESULTS

Strong inter-rater agreement was found for ratings of thyrohyoid space posture both at rest (κ = 0.93) and during phonation (κ = 0.80). Findings revealed no significant correlations between patterns of thyrohyoid posture and laryngoscopic findings or primary diagnoses.

CONCLUSIONS

Findings suggest that the presented method of laryngeal palpation is a reliable measure for assessing thyrohyoid posture at rest and during phonation. Lack of significant correlation between palpation ratings and other collected measures suggests that this method of palpation is not a useful tool for predicting laryngoscopic findings or voice diagnoses. Laryngeal palpation may still be useful in predicting extrinsic laryngeal muscle tension and guiding treatment planning; however, further research exploring the validity of laryngeal palpation as a measure of extrinsic laryngeal muscle tension is needed, as well as studies that include patient-reported measures and repeated measurements of thyrohyoid posture over time to explore whether thyrohyoid posture is impacted by other factors.

Methods of Measuring Laryngeal Muscle Tension in Patients with Muscle Tension Dysphonia: A Scoping Review

BACKGROUND

In clinical practice and research relating to Muscle Tension Dysphonia (MTD), several laryngeal muscle tension measurement methods are used to diagnose, to identify specific muscle strengths and deficits, and to measure therapeutic outcomes. The variety and reliability of available measurement methods presents challenges within diagnosis and treatment. The lack of methodical standardization presents a barrier to homogeneous practice in this area. There is a need for a comprehensive scoping review of laryngeal muscle tension measurement methods.

STUDY DESIGN

Scoping review.

OBJECTIVES

(1) To identify current methods of laryngeal muscle measurement which have been developed or tested with people with MTD; and (2) To identify the construct/s measured, reliability, validity, ability to detect change, efficiency and accessibility of identified methods.

METHOD

This scoping review was conducted using the Arksey and O'Malley framework. Studies were identified through searches of 4 major databases. The reviewer independently assessed titles, abstracts, and full-text articles.

RESULTS

Twenty seven papers published from 2000 to 2022 that satisfied the inclusion criteria were selected from 194 studies. The papers showed a variety of approaches with regards to the measurement of laryngeal activity and tension in subjects with MTD. Just over a quarter (25.9%) were reviews of the validity of assessment methods of MTD, including surface electromyography (sEMG), while 22.2% discussed surface electromyography as a measurement of muscle activity in subjects with MTD. 96.3% used a published methodological framework.

CONCLUSIONS

Assessment methods for Primary MTD are multifaceted, including patient history, laryngoscopic examination, and voice-related musculoskeletal features. Potential use of objective measurement methods, including sEMG, Real Time Elastosonography, Magnetic Resonance Imaging was noted. Due to variability in assessment methods and results, there is a need for greater objective practical methodological standardization to ensure accurate diagnosis, appropriate care, and chart patient progress.

Fatigue-Related Change in Surface Electromyographic Activities of the Perilaryngeal Muscles

PURPOSE

This study set out to quantify the fatigue-related changes in surface electromyographic (sEMG) activities of the perilaryngeal muscles following a vocal loading task.

METHOD

Thirty-six young healthy participants (M _age = 22.4 years) with normal voice performed karaoke singing for at least 100 min. Before the singing task, all participants underwent the sEMG measure and completed a Perceived Vocal Fatigue Score (P-VFS) questionnaire. After the singing task, all participants were immediately measured with the P-VFS again. Half of the participants were then measured for their sEMG immediately after their karaoke singing task, and the other half were given 20 min of rest before undertaking the sEMG measure. The P-VFS and the median frequency (MDF) of the sEMG signals collected from the suprahyoid, infrahyoid, and sternocleidomastoid muscles before and after the singing task were compared using a linear mixed-effects model.

RESULTS

All participants reported a perceived vocal fatigue after singing, with a significantly increased P-VFS. Compared with the presinging baseline, the MDF of the sEMG signals in perilaryngeal muscles was significantly lower immediately after the singing task. Such a significant difference was also found after 20 min following the singing task.

CONCLUSIONS

The MDF analysis of the sEMG signals could identify and quantify the performance vocal fatigue contributed by perilaryngeal muscles following a vocal loading task. The findings also showed that such fatigue in perilaryngeal muscles, as far as sEMG activities are concerned, can last for at least 20 min.