In vivo kinematic effects of ball and socket third condyle as a post-cam mechanism in tri-condylar knee implants

Implant survival of 3rd-condyle and post-cam posterior-stabilised total knee arthroplasty are comparable at follow-up > 10 years: a systematic review

PURPOSE

To summarise the literature on 3rd-condyle total knee arthroplasty (TKA) designs and compare their survival rates to those of post-cam TKA designs. The null hypothesis was that 3rd-condyle TKAs would have equivalent survival rates compared to contemporary post-cam TKAs.

METHODS

An electronic literature search for Level I-V studies was independently conducted by two researchers using Medline^® and Web of Science for studies published between January 1984 and October 2020 that specifically reported on rates of implant survival and complications, joint kinematics, clinical outcomes, and radiographic outcomes of 3rd-condyle TKA. The methodological quality of clinical studies was assessed according to the Downs and Black Quality Checklist for Health Care Intervention Studies, and for in vitro and in silico studies according to the Joanna Briggs Institute (JBI) tool for assessing analytical cross-sectional studies. Findings extracted for each TKA design were presented as reported and synthesised narratively. Survival rates at 5, 10 and > 10 years of 3rd-condyle TKA designs were graphically compared to rates of post-cam TKA designs published in joint registries.

RESULTS

A total of 38 studies were identified that reported on kinematics, clinical outcomes, radiographic alignment, and rates of complications and survival. Mean survival rates ranged from 96 to 98% at 5 years, 78-100% at 5-10 years, and 86-99% at > 10 years for 3rd-condyle PS TKAs. Mean survival rates ranged from 93 to 98% at 5 years, 89-99% at 5-10 years, and 88-95% at > 10 years for post-cam PS TKAs.

CONCLUSION

Implant survival rates of 3rd-condyle TKAs are comparable to those of post-cam TKAs at follow-up > 10 years. When compared to post-cam PS TKA, 3rd-condyle designs offer an alternative for younger and more active patients when considering the added benefits of a lowered point-of-contact and larger congruent contact area at the intercondylar tibial sulcus, that reduce risks of loosening and component wear.

LEVEL OF EVIDENCE

V.

Static Mediolateral Tilt of the Joint Line after Total Knee Arthroplasty Does Not Reflect Dynamic Tilt during a Stair Ascent Activity

The correlation between static and dynamic mediolateral (ML) tilts of the joint line in the coronal plane remains unknown after total knee arthroplasty (TKA). The purpose was to evaluate the ML tilt as measured by two-dimensional to three-dimensional registration during stair ascent in TKA patients, and to examine the correlation between the dynamic ML tilt and radiographic measurements of static indices. Thirty-two knees that underwent TKA using the mechanical alignment method were included. Continuous sagittal fluoroscopy was taken from before initial contact (IC) until after the toe-off (TO) phase during the stair ascent. The ML tilt of the tibial component relative to the ground was analyzed in terms of dynamic alignment using image-matching techniques, whereas static alignment was measured using standing long-leg radiographs. The correlation between static and dynamic ML tilts was evaluated. In the fluoroscopic analysis, the joint line was neutral (0.0 degree, standard deviation [SD] = 3.4 degrees) around IC phases, then was tilted valgus (5.5° valgus, SD = 2.6 degrees) in the mid-stance (MS) phase. After the TO phase, the joint line became almost neutral (0.4 degrees valgus, SD = 3.1 degrees). The dynamic ML tilt was significantly more varus during the IC phase and significantly more valgus in MS and TO phases than the static ML tilt (1.4 degrees valgus, SD = 2.0 degrees). No correlation was found between static and dynamic ML tilts in weight-bearing phases. During stair ascent, the static tilt had no correlation with the dynamic tilt in weight-bearing phases despite being in the same range. Static lower limb alignment does not reflect coronal alignment during motion. Further research should be conducted to determine whether the horizontal dynamic ML tilt can improve long-term durability and clinical outcomes after TKA.

Tibial Tubercle-Trochlear Groove Distance Influences Patellar Tilt After Total Knee Arthroplasty

BACKGROUND

Tibial tubercle-trochlear groove (TT-TG) distance is associated with a greater risk of recurrent patellar dislocation in young, active patients. However, the effect of TT-TG distance after total knee arthroplasty (TKA) has not been investigated. The purpose is to analyze the effect of TT-TG distance and component rotation on patellar tilt and patellar shift after TKA.

METHODS

After TKA, axial computed tomography scans and axial radiograph were taken in 115 consecutive knees. TT-TG distance was measured between the most anterior point of the tibial tuberosity and the deepest point of the femoral component relative to a line connecting the anterior condyles. Femoral and tibial component rotation was measured relative to the femoral and tibial rotational axis, respectively. Pearson correlation coefficients were calculated.

RESULTS

TT-TG distance had a significant correlation with patellar tilt in extension (R = 0.220, P = .018), patellar tilt in flexion (R = 0.438, P < .001), and patellar shift (R = 0.330, P < .001). Tibial component rotation had a significant correlation with patellar tilt in flexion (R = -0.251, P = .007) and patellar shift (R = -0.360, P < .001). Femoral component rotation had no significant correlations. Tibial component rotation had a significant correlation with TT-TG distance (R = -0.573, P < .001), whereas femoral component rotation had no correlation (P = .192).

CONCLUSION

TT-TG distance had a significant correlation with patellar tilt and patellar shift. Surgeons need to understand the factors affecting TT-TG distance and to pay attention to avoiding excessive TT-TG distance after TKA.

Correlation Between Intraoperative Anterior Stability and Flexion Gap in Total Knee Arthroplasty

BACKGROUND

Instability is a common failure mode after total knee arthroplasty. There have been only a few methods to quantify anterior translation with fixed forces applied during surgery. The purpose of the study was to measure the anterior translation with a new device and to analyze the relationships between the amount of anterior translation and the joint gaps.

METHODS

Fifty knees with medial osteoarthritis underwent surgery using a posterior-stabilized implant. During surgery, measurement of anterior translation was performed at 90° of knee flexion with a trial implant, applying a traction force of 70 N. The joint gap was measured using a tensor device, applying a distraction force of 178 N in flexion. The Pearson correlation coefficient was calculated between anterior translation and joint gaps and laxity.

RESULTS

On average, anterior translation during surgery was 8.5 mm (standard deviation [SD] = 3.6 mm). Medial gap (correlation coefficient [r] = 0.30), medial laxity (r = 0.33), and center laxity (r = 0.29) had a positive correlation with anterior translation, and anterior translation increased with larger joint gap or greater laxity.

CONCLUSION

Anterior translation was measured with a new device by applying the anterior force to the tibia, and the correlations between anterior translation and joint gap and laxity were analyzed. A larger medial gap and greater medial laxity were correlated with greater anterior translation, which could cause symptomatic feelings of instability. Surgeons should pay attention to the tension of medial structures in flexion and avoid excessive medial release during surgery.

The role of the patellar tendon angle and patellar flexion angle in the interpretation of sagittal plane kinematics of the knee after knee arthroplasty: A modelling analysis

BACKGROUND

Many different measures have been used to describe knee kinematics. This study investigated the changes of two measures, the patellar tendon angle and the patellar flexion angle, in response to variations in the geometry of the knee due to surgical technique or implant design.

METHODS

A mathematical model was developed to calculate the equilibrium position of the extensor mechanism for a particular tibiofemoral position. Calculating the position of the extensor mechanism allowed for the determination of the patellar tendon angle and patellar flexion angle relationships to the knee flexion angle. The model was used to investigate the effect of anterior-posterior position of the femur, change in joint line, patellar thickness (overstuffing, understuffing), and patellar tendon length; these parameters were varied to determine the effect on the patellar tendon angle/knee flexion angle and patellar flexion angle/knee flexion angle relationships.

RESULTS

The patellar tendon angle was a good indicator of anterior-posterior femoral position and change in patellar thickness, and the patellar flexion angle a good indicator of change in joint line, and patellar tendon length.

CONCLUSIONS

The patellar tendon angle/knee flexion angle relationship was found to be an effective means of identifying abnormal kinematics post-knee arthroplasty. However, the use of both the patellar tendon angle and patellar flexion angle together provided a more informative overview of the sagittal plane kinematics of the knee.

In vivo kinematics of knee replacement during daily living activities: Condylar and post-cam contact assessment by three-dimensional fluoroscopy and finite element analyses

In total knee replacement, the investigation on the exact contact patterns at the post-cam in implanted patients from real in vivo data during daily living activities is fundamental for validating implant design concepts and assessing relevant performances. This study is aimed at verifying the restoration of natural tibio-femoral condylar kinematics by investigating the post-cam engagement at different motor tasks. An innovative validated technique, combining three-dimensional fluoroscopic and finite element analyses, was applied to measure joint kinematics during daily living activities in 15 patients implanted with guided motion posterior-stabilized total knee replacement. Motion results showed physiological antero-posterior translations of the tibio-femoral condyles for every motor task. However, high variability was observed in the position of the calculated pivot point among different patients and different motor tasks, as well as in the range of post-cam engagement. Physiological tibio-femoral joint rotations and contacts at the condyles were found restored in the present knee replacement. Articular contact patterns experienced at the post-cam were found compatible with this original prosthesis design. The present study reports replaced knee kinematics also in terms of articular surface contacts, both at the condyles and, for the first time, at the post-cam. © 2016 Orthopaedic Research Society. Published by Wiley Periodicals, Inc. J Orthop Res 35:1396-1403, 2017.

In vitro biomechanical evaluation of tri-condylar total knee arthroplasty with posterior release for restoration of full extension

Background/Objective

The continuous improvement of knee function during deep flexion remains a challenge in total knee arthroplasty. Tri-condylar total knee arthroplasty has been designed to achieve this goal. However, the introduction of a third nonanatomic spherical condyle might prevent the joint from reaching full extension due to posterior soft tissue tightening. This study aimed to address these issues related to soft tissue tightening and full extension limitation.

Methods

Biomechanical tests were performed on six cadaveric specimens of the entire lower extremities. The tri-condylar design was compared with a posterior cruciate sacrificing design of the same shape without the ball structure. Knee joint kinematics was measured, including the extension and flexion angles, the extension balance, and the extension gap. The test was repeated after release of the medial and lateral posterior intercondylar soft tissues at a safe distance from the popliteal artery and nerves.

Results

Both designs resulted in a knee flexion angle up to ∼130°. The tri-condylar design showed an extension angle of -11.2 ± 5.4°, which was a significantly greater limitation than that obtained with the cruciate sacrificing design (-3.8 ± 4.7°; p = 0.047). Moreover, the extension angle of the tri-condylar design was significantly improved after the release of posterior intercondylar soft tissues (-0.1 ± 6.7°; p = 0.028).

Conclusion

The tri-condylar design efficiently allowed the full extension by the release of posterior intercondylar soft tissues at a safe distance from the popliteal artery and nerves.

How exactly can computer simulation predict the kinematics and contact status after TKA? Examination in individualized models

BACKGROUND

It is unknown whether a computer simulation with simple models can estimate individual in vivo knee kinematics, although some complex models have predicted the knee kinematics. The purposes of this study are first, to validate the accuracy of the computer simulation with our developed model during a squatting activity in a weight-bearing deep knee bend and then, to analyze the contact area and the contact stress of the tri-condylar implants for individual patients.

METHODS

We compared the anteroposterior (AP) contact positions of medial and lateral condyles calculated by the computer simulation program with the positions measured from the fluoroscopic analysis for three implanted knees. Then the contact area and the stress including the third condyle were calculated individually using finite element (FE) analysis.

FINDINGS

The motion patterns were similar in the simulation program and the fluoroscopic surveillance. Our developed model could nearly estimate the individual in vivo knee kinematics. The mean and maximum differences of the AP contact positions were 1.0mm and 2.5mm, respectively. At 120° of knee flexion, the contact area at the third condyle was wider than the both condyles. The mean maximum contact stress at the third condyle was lower than the both condyles at 90° and 120° of knee flexion.

INTERPRETATION

Individual bone models are required to estimate in vivo knee kinematics in our simple model. The tri-condylar implant seems to be safe for deep flexion activities due to the wide contact area and low contact stress.