Comparative analysis of trace element accumulation in seagrasses Posidonia oceanica and Cymodocea nodosa: Biomonitoring applications and legislative issues

Possibilities of using biosorbents and synthetic sorbents in monitoring heavy metal pollution of surface waters

This article presents the findings of fundamental research designed to assess the viability of utilising a range of sorbents to determine whether preset concentration thresholds for specific heavy metals - namely nickel, zinc, cadmium, and lead - have been exceeded in prepared aqueous solutions. The biosorbents employed in the study were mosses, lichens and algae, modified zeolites, and synthetic cationites. It was demonstrated that a state of heterophasic ion exchange equilibrium was attained following an exposure period of approximately two hours. Of the heavy metal sorbents tested, synthetic cationites were found to exhibit the most favourable sorption properties. Furthermore, the sorption processes of heavy metal cations by synthetic cationites were found to be influenced by the pH and salinity of the solution. No significant changes were observed in the pH range of 4.0 to 8.0. A reduction in heavy metal sorption of up to 25% was observed in solutions with conductivity ranging from 300 to 1500 μS cm-1, and up to 15% in solutions with conductivity between 300 and 800 μS cm-1. The results presented here indicate that, with relatively stable water salinity levels, it is possible to detect exceedances of permissible heavy metal concentrations in surface waters on the basis of an analysis of metal concentrations in synthetic cationites exposed in water.

Trace metal pollution gradients in a tropical seagrass ecosystem

Trace metals are one of the most serious pollutants in tropical seagrass meadows given their persistence and toxicity. Whereas quantity is frequently measured, there is no information on the spatial extent of metal pollution in these systems. Here, we use an island in Indonesia (Barang Lompo) as a model system to study the impact radius of two major and eight trace metals in sediment and seagrass leaves. We provide evidence for exponential decay in both the metal pollution index and concentrations of most metals with increasing distance from the island (k = -0.01 to -0.08 m-1). Consequently, there is an impact radius of approximately 100 m around the island. The comparative analysis of both seagrass species further revealed interspecific differences in metal loads. This study highlights the importance of assessing the spatial extent of metal pollution in addition to its quantity.

Metal(loid)s and Rare Earth Elements in Posidonia oceanica (L.) Delile (1813) banquettes

The Posidonia oceanica (L.) Delile 1813 banquette provides precious ecosystem services for Mediterranean beach nourishment and protection, representing an important way of energy transfer through marine-coastal habitats. It is surprising to note how it is poorly investigated, especially concerning its double role as potential sink and source of chemicals. In particular, few studies exist about the metal (loid)s occurrence and no data are available on emerging contaminants, such as Rare Earth Elements (REEs). The present research investigated for the first time the concentrations of twenty-eight metal(loid)s and fifteen REEs in a well-structured banquette along the Italian coast (Central Tyrrhenian Sea) showing that (i) metal(loid)s and REEs occur in banquettes, with higher relative concentrations of some metal(loid)s (B, Sr, Mn, Fe, Al, Zn) and REEs (Ce, Y, La, Nd) with no statistically significant seasonal variations; (ii) Posidonia banquettes may represent an interesting biological model for chemicals monitoring.

Does transplanted Posidonia oceanica act as a sink or source of trace elements? Ecological implications for restoring polluted coastal areas

Despite the high potential of seagrass restoration to reverse the trend of marine ecosystem degradation, there are still many limitations, especially when ecosystems are severely degraded. In particular, it is not known whether restoring polluted ecosystems can lead to potentially harmful effects associated with contaminant remobilisation. Here, we aimed to investigate the role of P. oceanica transplanted from a pristine meadow to a polluted site (Augusta Bay, Italy, Mediterranean Sea) in two seasons of the year, as a sink or source of trace elements to the environment. The main results showed i) higher accumulation of chromium (Cr), copper (Cu) and total mercury (THg) in plants transplanted in summer than in winter, as well as an increase in Cr and THg in plants from sites with higher trace element loads; ii) an increase in leaf phenolics and a decrease in rhizome soluble carbohydrates associated with As and THg accumulation, suggesting the occurrence of defence strategies to cope with pollution stress; iii) a different partitioning of trace elements between below- and above-ground tissues, with arsenic (As) and Cr accumulating in roots, whereas Cu and THg in both roots and leaves. These results suggest that P. oceanica transplanted to polluted sites can act as both a sink and a source, sequestering trace elements in the below-ground tissues thus reducing their bioavailability, but also potentially remobilising them. However, the amount of trace elements potentially exported from P. oceanica to the environment through transfer into food webs via leaves and detritus appeared to be low under the specific conditions of the study site. Although further research into seagrass restoration of polluted sites would improve current knowledge to support effective ecosystem-based coastal management, the benefits of restoring polluted sites through seagrass transplantation appear to outweigh the potential costs of inaction over time.

The significance of heterophasic ion exchange in active biomonitoring of heavy metal pollution of surface waters

We have carried out studies to examine the possibility of using biosorbents: the epigeic mosses Pleurozium schreberi (Willd. ex Brid.) Mitt., and the epiphytic lichens Hypogymnia physodes (L.) Nyl. in active biomonitoring of heavy metal pollution of surface waters. The dried sea algae Palmaria palmata (L.) Weber & Mohr were used as the third biosorbent. The studies were conducted in the waters of the Turawa Reservoir, a dam reservoir with a significant level of eutrophication in south-western Poland. Incremental concentrations of Mn, Ni, Zn, Cu, Cd, and Pb were determined in the exposed samples. It was shown that a 2-h exposure period increases the concentration of some metals in the exposed samples, even by as much as several hundred percent. High increments of nickel concentrations in the algae Palmaria palmata (mean: 0.0040 mg/g, with the initial concentration of c0 < 0.0016 in the algae) were noted, with negligible increments in concentrations of this metal in mosses and lichens. In contrast, mosses and lichens accumulated relatively high amounts of Cd (mean: 0.0033 mg/g, c0 = 0.00043 mg/g) and Pb (mean: 0.0243 mg/g, c0 = 0.0103 mg/g), respectively.

Heavy metal compartmentalisation in salt marsh and seagrass of the urbanised Swartkops estuary, South Africa

Wetland plants are naturally exposed to high metal concentrations, and often have mechanisms to prevent metal toxicity. This study compared metal concentrations in seagrass (Zostera capensis) and salt marsh (Spartina maritima, Salicornia tegetaria) - to determine their niche as metal sinks. Samples were collected in each season over a year at five sites in the estuary and analysed using a Total X-Ray Fluorescence (TXRF) spectrometer. Spartina maritima and S. tegetaria accumulated in their roots, and displayed little translocation to leaves (BCF = 1-14; TF_[leaf/root] < 1). Contrastingly, Z. capensis showed high uptake to its leaves (TF_[leaf/root] = 1-8; Mn, Zn, Cr, Pb, Ni, Cu). Spartina maritima and S. tegetaria were identified as good phytostabilisers (BCF > 1, TF_[leaf/root] < 1). Compartmentalization was unique to each species, and considering their ecosystem service importance, more plant species should be analysed to estimate their ecological value for management purposes.

The efficiency of trace element uptake by seagrass Cymodocea serrulata in Rabigh lagoon, Red Sea

The search for solutions to environmental pollution has been on the increase, with many questions recently as to which marine organisms can bioaccumulate trace elements in the marine ecosystem. Cadmium, Cr, Cu, Fe, Mn, Ni, Pb, and Zn concentrations in sediment, seawater, and seagrass compartments (root, rhizome, and leaf blade) were determined at Rabigh lagoon, Red Sea. This is to provide an insight into the potential of Cymodocea serrulata to bioaccumulate trace elements and as a good candidate to biomonitor these elements in a natural aquatic ecosystem. Results revealed significant variations in trace element concentrations across the three compartments of C. serrulata and the sites, with site S8 located in the most closed part of the lagoon recording the highest concentrations for all the trace elements. The translocation factor (TF_rhizome/root = 1.00) of trace elements was higher in the root compartment. This implies that the root compartment is a better bioindicator of trace elements and has more potential to be utilized for biomonitoring. A significant positive correlation (p < 0.01) was established between the trace element concentrations in sediment, seawater, and the three compartments of C. serrulata except for Mn concentration in the compartments. The seagrass C. serrulata can be used for biomonitoring of trace elements in marine ecosystems as our results provide information on its capacity to bioaccumulate these elements. This is one of the key characteristics of a typical bioindicator of aquatic pollutants.

Trace element bioaccumulation in the seagrass Cymodocea nodosa from a polluted coastal lagoon: Biomonitoring implications

This is the first investigation of the potential for using Cymodocea nodosa to biomonitor trace element (TE) contamination in Marchica lagoon (Morocco), a Mediterranean pollution hotspot. We measured concentrations of seven TEs in seagrass tissues (leaf-rhizome-root) and sediments. Single and multi-element indices confirmed that sediments near illegal discharges were heavily polluted and we predicted risks of frequent adverse biological effects in these areas. Four of the TEs increased concentrations in C. nodosa leaf and root along sediment pollution gradient. Leaves and roots were both good indicators of Cu and Cd contamination in sediment, whereas leaves were the best indicator of Zn and roots for Pb. This seagrass was not a bioindicator of Al, Cr and Ni contamination. These results show the bioaccumulation patterns of TEs in C. nodosa, and can be used to design biomonitoring programs.

Environmentally relevant bisphenol A concentrations effects on the seagrass Cymodocea nodosa different parts elongation: perceptive assessors of toxicity

Toxicity data on bisphenol A (BPA) effects on aquatic macrophytes remain scarce. Therefore, environmentally relevant BPA concentrations (0.03, 0.1, 0.3, 0.5, 1, and 3 μg L^-1) were tested on the seagrass Cymodocea nodosa different parts length increase. All plant parts, at low BPA concentrations (0.03-0.3 μg L^-1), elongated equally to the control, while their lengthening and elongation rates gradually decreased by increasing BPA concentrations. A gradual increase of "Toxicity index" with increasing BPA concentrations was observed but was lower for juvenile blades and higher for plagiotropic rhizomes and adult leaves. In all parts, the LOECs were 0.3 and the NOECs 0.1 μg L^-1 at 10th day. Juvenile blades displayed, under acute stress, lengthening inhibition at lower concentrations than the rhizomes and adult blades, but at a lower extent. The EC₅₀ values were lower for the rhizome internodes, followed by the adult blades and higher for the juvenile blades. Using as a biological "endpoint" the elongation, all C. nodosa parts and specifically the rhizomes and adult blades, followed by intermediate blades, adult sheaths, and juvenile blades, seemed to be sensitive BPA toxicity assessors. The evaluation of the relative sensitivity of the different parts to BPA toxicity could help identify the most suitable seagrass part for early diagnosis of the risk posed by BPA to seagrass meadows and could constitute a valuable tool to derive the seawater quality criteria and to be used in BPA monitoring programs for rational management of the coastal environment.

Heavy metal accumulation and phytoremediation potential by transplants of the seagrass Zostera marina in the polluted bay systems

Although seagrasses can incorporate heavy metals from the marine environment, few studies have been conducted on heavy metal uptake and phytoremediation potential by seagrass transplants in the heavy metal contaminated sediments. Zostera marina shoots were transplanted in two polluted bay systems on Korean coasts to evaluate the heavy metal contaminations in sediments and the possibility of using Z. marina transplants as a bioindicator and phytoremediation agent. The major concentrated metals in sediments were As, Cu, Fe, and Pb in Jaran Bay, and Cd, Co, Zn, and Hg in Onsan Bay. The Co, Zn, Pb, and Hg concentrations in Z. marina tissues reflected the sediment heavy metal concentrations, and thus the tissue heavy metal concentrations may be used as bio-indicators of the metal contaminations. Since Z. marina transplants accumulated a great amount of heavy metals in their tissues, they may have the phytoremediation potential for the heavy metal contaminated sediments.

Trace elements in the seagrass Posidonia oceanica: Compartmentation and relationships with seawater and sediment concentrations

Seagrasses are employed to assess trace element levels in seawater and sediments; however, their capacity as bioindicators of trace elements in seawater has been recently questioned, due to the scarcity of a significant seagrass-seawater relationship. In the aim to provide an insight into trace element accumulation in the seagrass Posidonia oceanica, Cd, Co, Cr, Cu, Ni and Pb concentrations in seawater, sediments, and several seagrass compartments (adult leaf blades, intermediate leaf blades, adult leaf sheaths, juvenile leaves, orthotropic rhizomes, plagiotropic rhizomes, and roots of plagiotropic rhizomes) from the coasts of Thrace, Greece were determined. Uni- and multivariate data analyses were applied. A comparison with reported element concentrations revealed that this coastal area can be generally classified as an area of no marked Cd, Co, Cr, Cu, Ni and Pb anthropogenic enrichment. Trace elements showed a non-uniform distribution among seagrass compartments; adult leaf blades displayed the highest mean Cd and Ni concentrations, adult leaf blades, plagiotropic rhizomes and roots the highest mean Co concentrations, juvenile leaves the highest mean Cu concentration, and plagiotropic rhizomes the highest mean Cr and Pb concentrations, indicating that the accumulation varies with element, compartment and compartment age. Cd, Cr and Ni in adult leaf blades reached mean tissue-seawater accumulation factors of 10³, while Co of 10⁴, implying that this seagrass is a strong accumulator of these elements from solution. Cd, Co, Cr, and Ni concentrations in leaf compartments, particularly adult leaf blades, positively correlated with their concentrations in seawater, and Pb concentrations in plagiotropic rhizomes and roots with sediment Pb concentration. Thereby, P. oceanica could be regarded as a biondicator for Cd, Co, Cr and Ni in seawater, and for Pb in sediments. The results presented provide an insight on trace element accumulation in P. oceanica, and can be utilized for the design of biomonitoring programs.

A comparative study of trace elements in Cymodocea nodosa from three semi-enclosed coastal areas in Tunisia

The present study quantifies the levels of five trace elements (TEs) Zn, Cu, Ni, Pb, and Cd in the leaves and rhizomes of Cymodocea nodosa as well as the surficial sediments from three semi-enclosed coastal areas in Tunisia, in the south Mediterranean Sea. Samples were taken from the Bizerte and Ghar El Melh lagoons and from marina Cap Monastir. The TE ranking was found to be Zn > Cu > Pb > Ni > Cd in sediments and Zn > Cu = Ni = Pb = Cd in C. nodosa leaves and rhizomes. Except for Ni, levels of Zn, Cu, Pb, and Cd significantly differed between the sites. Translocation factors (TFs) were > 1 for all trace elements proving the high capacity of C. nodosa to accumulate TEs in its above-ground tissues. Results show that marina Cap Monastir's meadow exhibits higher TFs than the Bizerte and Ghar El Melh lagoons. This can be due to the presence of the non-indigenous species Halophila stipulacea. The present study highlights the need for further investigation on the effect of interspecific interaction on TE uptake by seagrasses.

Seagrass Halophila stipulacea: Capacity of accumulation and biomonitoring of trace elements

This study aimed to shed further light on the capacity of the seagrass Halophila stipulacea to accumulate and biomonitor the elements As, Cd, Cr, Cu, Hg, Mn, Ni, Pb, and Zn, present in water and sediments. Results showed that the organs of H. stipulacea accumulate different levels of trace elements, whose concentrations decrease mainly in the order of roots>rhizomes>leaves. The seagrass H. stipulacea showed levels of trace elements similar to those found in other Mediterranean seagrasses, e.g. Posidonia oceanica and Cymodocea nodosa. This study showed that H. stipulacea could act as a promising bioindicator of several elements, present in sediments, including As, Cd, Cu, Mn, Ni and Zn.