Makings of a brittle bone: Unexpected lessons from a low protein diet study of a mouse OI model

Modulation of biomineralization morphology by phosphorylated collagen peptides: insights into osteogenesis imperfecta pathophysiology

Osteogenesis imperfecta (OI) is a hereditary skeletal disorder characterized by bone fragility and deformities, primarily attributed to defects in type I collagen, the most abundant structural protein in humans. Multiple phosphorylation sites have been detected within collagen, suggesting that phosphorylation may influence mineralization processes, thereby impacting the development of OI. In this study, we investigated the modulation of biomineralization morphology by phosphorylated collagen peptides mimicking Gly-Ser mutations in osteogenesis imperfecta. A series of collagen peptide sequences, including GPO13S, GPO13pS, GPO12S, GPO12pS, GPO11S, and GPO11pS, were synthesized to explore the role of phosphorylation in peptide stability and its templating effect on biomineralization. The CD results indicated that the phosphorylation of Gly-pSer mutants reduces the stability of collagen peptides. SEM images revealed that phosphorylated peptides acted as templates, guiding the morphology of calcium carbonate into either olive-like or spherical structures, depending on their conformational state of the peptides. Non-phosphorylated peptides maintained a calcite crystal structure. The XRD patterns predominantly exhibited peaks associated with calcite and vaterite for GPO13pS-CaCO3, GPO12pS-CaCO3, and GPO11pS-CaCO3, and peaks associated with calcite for GPO13S-CaCO3, GPO12S-CaCO3, and GPO11S-CaCO3, indicating a transformation of mesocrystals influenced by peptide phosphorylation. Our findings elucidate the crucial role of phosphorylated collagen peptides in mediating biomineralization morphology and polymorph selection, offering insights into the complex pathophysiology of OI.

Bone Quality and Mineralization and Effects of Treatment in Osteogenesis Imperfecta

Osteogenesis imperfecta (OI) is a rare congenital bone dysplasia characterized by high fracture rates and broad variations in clinical manifestations ranging from mild to increasingly severe and perinatal lethal forms. The underlying mutations affect either the synthesis or processing of the type I procollagen molecule itself or proteins that are involved in the formation and mineralization of the collagen matrix. Consequently, the collagen forming cells, the osteoblasts, become broadly dysfunctional in OI. Strikingly, hypermineralized bone matrix seems to be a frequent feature in OI, despite the variability in clinical severity and mutations in the so far studied different forms of human OI. While the causes of the increased mineral content of the bone matrix are not fully understood yet, there is evidence that the descendants of the osteoblasts, the osteocytes, which play a critical role not only in bone remodeling, but also in mineralization and sensing of mechanical loads, are also highly dysregulated and might be of major importance in the pathogenesis of OI. In this review article, we firstly summarize findings of cellular abnormalities in osteoblasts and osteocytes, alterations of the organic matrix, as well as of the microstructural organization of bone. Secondly, we focus on the hypermineralization of the bone matrix in OI as observed in several different forms of human OI as well as in animal models, its measurement and potential mechanical implications and its effect on the bone mineral density measured by dual X-ray absorptiometry. Thirdly, we give an overview of established medication treatments of OI and new approaches with a focus of their known or possible effects on the bone material, particularly on bone matrix mineralization.

Murine Animal Models in Osteogenesis Imperfecta: The Quest for Improving the Quality of Life

Osteogenesis imperfecta is a rare genetic disorder characterized by bone fragility, due to alterations in the type I collagen molecule. It is a very heterogeneous disease, both genetically and phenotypically, with a high variability of clinical phenotypes, ranging from mild to severe forms, the most extreme cases being perinatal lethal. There is no curative treatment for OI, and so great efforts are being made in order to develop effective therapies. In these attempts, the in vivo preclinical studies are of paramount importance; therefore, serious analysis is required to choose the right murine OI model able to emulate as closely as possible the disease of the target OI population. In this review, we summarize the features of OI murine models that have been used for preclinical studies until today, together with recently developed new murine models. The bone parameters that are usually evaluated in order to determine the relevance of new developing therapies are exposed, and finally, current and innovative therapeutic strategies attempts considered in murine OI models, along with their mechanism of action, are reviewed. This review aims to summarize the in vivo studies developed in murine models available in the field of OI to date, in order to help the scientific community choose the most accurate OI murine model when developing new therapeutic strategies capable of improving the quality of life.

Bone Formation in 2D Culture of Primary Cells

Relevance of mineralized nodules in two-dimensional (2D) osteoblast/osteocyte cultures to bone biology, pathology, and engineering is a decades old question, but a comprehensive answer appears to be still wanting. Bone-like cells, extracellular matrix (ECM), and mineral were all reported but so were non-bone-like ones. Many studies described seemingly bone-like cell-ECM structures based on similarity to few select bone features in vivo, yet no studies examined multiple bone features simultaneously and none systematically studied all types of structures coexisting in the same culture. Here, we report such comprehensive analysis of 2D cultures based on light and electron microscopies, Raman microspectroscopy, gene expression, and in situ messenger RNA (mRNA) hybridization. We demonstrate that 2D cultures of primary cells from mouse calvaria do form bona fide bone. Cells, ECM, and mineral within it exhibit morphology, structure, ultrastructure, composition, spatial-temporal gene expression pattern, and growth consistent with intramembranous ossification. However, this bone is just one of at least five different types of cell-ECM structures coexisting in the same 2D culture, which vary widely in their resemblance to bone and ability to mineralize. We show that the other two mineralizing structures may represent abnormal (disrupted) bone and cartilage-like structure with chondrocyte-to-osteoblast transdifferentiation. The two nonmineralizing cell-ECM structures may mimic periosteal cambium and pathological, nonmineralizing osteoid. Importantly, the most commonly used culture conditions (10mM β-glycerophosphate) induce artificial mineralization of all cell-ECM structures, which then become barely distinguishable. We therefore discuss conditions and approaches promoting formation of bona fide bone and simple means for distinguishing it from the other cell-ECM structures. Our findings may improve osteoblast differentiation and function analyses based on 2D cultures and extend applications of these cultures to general bone biology and tissue engineering research. Published 2022. This article is a U.S. Government work and is in the public domain in the USA. JBMR Plus published by Wiley Periodicals LLC on behalf of American Society for Bone and Mineral Research.

ER, Mitochondria, and ISR Regulation by mt-HSP70 and ATF5 upon Procollagen Misfolding in Osteoblasts

Cellular response to protein misfolding underlies multiple diseases. Collagens are the most abundant vertebrate proteins, yet little is known about cellular response to misfolding of their procollagen precursors. Osteoblasts (OBs)-the cells that make bone-produce so much procollagen that it accounts for up to 40% of mRNAs in the cell, which is why bone bears the brunt of mutations causing procollagen misfolding in osteogenesis imperfecta (OI). The present study of a G610C mouse model of OI by multiple transcriptomic techniques provides first solid clues to how OBs respond to misfolded procollagen accumulation in the endoplasmic reticulum (ER) and how this response affects OB function. Surprisingly, misfolded procollagen escapes the quality control in the ER lumen and indirectly triggers the integrated stress response (ISR) through other cell compartments. In G610C OBs, the ISR is regulated by mitochondrial HSP70 (mt-HSP70) and ATF5 instead of their BIP and ATF4 paralogues, which normally activate and regulate ISR to secretory protein misfolding in the ER. The involvement of mt-HSP70 and ATF5 together with other transcriptomic findings suggest that mitochondria might initiate the ISR upon disruption of ER-mitochondria connections or might respond to the ISR activated by a yet unknown sensor.

Morphological and mechanical characterization of bone phenotypes in the Amish G610C murine model of osteogenesis imperfecta

Osteogenesis imperfecta (OI) is a hereditary bone disease where gene mutations affect Type I collagen formation resulting in osteopenia and increased fracture risk. There are several established mouse models of OI, but some are severe and result in spontaneous fractures or early animal death. The Amish Col1a2G610C/+ (G610C) mouse model is a newer, moderate OI model that is currently being used in a variety of intervention studies, with differing background strains, sexes, ages, and bone endpoints. This study is a comprehensive mechanical and architectural characterization of bone in G610C mice bred on a C57BL/6 inbred strain and will provide a baseline for future treatment studies. Male and female wild-type (WT) and G610C mice were euthanized at 10 and 16 weeks (n = 13-16). Harvested tibiae, femora, and L4 vertebrae were scanned via micro-computed tomography and analyzed for cortical and trabecular architectural properties. Femora and tibiae were then mechanically tested to failure. G610C mice had less bone but more highly mineralized cortical and trabecular tissue than their sex- and age-matched WT counterparts, with cortical cross-sectional area, thickness, and mineral density, and trabecular bone volume, mineral density, spacing, and number all differing significantly as a function of genotype (2 Way ANOVA with main effects of sex and genotype at each age). In addition, mechanical yield force, ultimate force, displacement, strain, and toughness were all significantly lower in G610C vs. WT, highlighting a brittle phenotype. This characterization demonstrates that despite being a moderate OI model, the Amish G610C mouse model maintains a distinctly brittle phenotype and is well-suited for use in future intervention studies.

Targeting cellular stress in vitro improves osteoblast homeostasis, matrix collagen content and mineralization in two murine models of osteogenesis imperfecta

Most cases of dominantly inherited osteogenesis imperfecta (OI) are caused by glycine substitutions in the triple helical domain of type I collagen α chains, which delay collagen folding, and cause the synthesis of collagen triple helical molecules with abnormal structure and post-translational modification. A variable extent of mutant collagen ER retention and other secondary mutation effects perturb osteoblast homeostasis and impair bone matrix quality. Amelioration of OI osteoblast homeostasis could be beneficial both to osteoblast anabolic activity and to the content of the extracellular matrix they deposit. Therefore, the effect of the chemical chaperone 4-phenylbutyrate (4-PBA) on cell homeostasis, collagen trafficking, matrix production and mineralization was investigated in primary osteoblasts from two murine models of moderate OI, Col1a1+/G349C and Col1a2+/G610C. At the cellular level, 4-PBA prevented intracellular accumulation of collagen and increased protein secretion, reducing aggregates within the mutant cells and normalizing ER morphology. At the extracellular level, increased collagen incorporation into matrix, associated with more mature collagen fibrils, was observed in osteoblasts from both models. 4-PBA also promoted OI osteoblast mineral deposition by increasing alkaline phosphatase expression and activity. Targeting osteoblast stress with 4-PBA improved both cellular and matrix abnormalities in culture, supporting further in vivo studies of its effect on bone tissue composition, strength and mineralization as a potential treatment for classical OI.

The lack of neuropeptide Y-Y1 receptor signaling modulates the chemical and mechanical properties of bone matrix

Genetic and pharmacological functional studies have provided evidence that the lack of Neuropeptide Y-Y₁  receptor (Y₁ R) signaling pathway induces a high bone mass phenotype in mice. However, clinical observations have shown that drug or genetic mediated improvement of bone mass might be associated to alterations to bone extracellular matrix (ECM) properties, leading to bone fragility. Hence, in this study we propose to characterize the physical, chemical and biomechanical properties of mature bone ECM of germline NPY-Y₁ R knockout (Y₁ R^-/- ) mice, and compare to their wild-type (WT) littermates. Our results demonstrated that the high bone mass phenotype observed in Y₁ R^-/- mice involves alterations in Y₁ R^-/-  bone ECM ultrastructure, as a result of accelerated deposition of organic and mineral fractions. In addition, Y₁ R^-/- bone ECM displays enhanced matrix maturation characterized by greater number of mature/highly packed collagen fibers without pathological accumulation of immature/mature collagen crosslinks nor compromise of mineral crystallinity. These unique features of Y₁ R^-/-  bone ECM improved the biochemical properties of Y₁ R^-/-  bones, reflected by mechanically robust bones with diminished propensity to fracture, contributing to greater bone strength. These findings support the future usage of drugs targeting Y₁ R signaling as a promising therapeutic strategy to treat bone loss-related pathologies.

Effect of rapamycin on bone mass and strength in the α2(I)-G610C mouse model of osteogenesis imperfecta

Osteogenesis imperfecta (OI) is commonly caused by heterozygous type I collagen structural mutations that disturb triple helix folding and integrity. This mutant‐containing misfolded collagen accumulates in the endoplasmic reticulum (ER) and induces a form of ER stress associated with negative effects on osteoblast differentiation and maturation. Therapeutic induction of autophagy to degrade the mutant collagens could therefore be useful in ameliorating the ER stress and deleterious downstream consequences. To test this, we treated a mouse model of mild to moderate OI (α2(I) G610C) with dietary rapamycin from 3 to 8 weeks of age and effects on bone mass and mechanical properties were determined. OI bone mass and mechanics were, as previously reported, compromised compared to WT. While rapamycin treatment improved the trabecular parameters of WT and OI bones, the biomechanical deficits of OI bones were not rescued. Importantly, we show that rapamycin treatment suppressed the longitudinal and transverse growth of OI, but not WT, long bones. Our work demonstrates that dietary rapamycin offers no clinical benefit in this OI model and furthermore, the impact of rapamycin on OI bone growth could exacerbate the clinical consequences during periods of active bone growth in patients with OI caused by collagen misfolding mutations.

Substitutions for arginine at position 780 in triple helical domain of the α1(I) chain alter folding of the type I procollagen molecule and cause osteogenesis imperfecta

OI is a clinically and genetically heterogeneous disorder characterized by bone fragility. More than 90% of patients are heterozygous for mutations in type I collagen genes, COL1A1 and COL1A2, and a common mutation is substitution for an obligatory glycine in the triple helical Gly-X-Y repeats. Few non-glycine substitutions in the triple helical domain have been reported; most result in Y-position substitutions of arginine by cysteine. Here, we investigated leucine and cysteine substitutions for one Y-position arginine, p.Arg958 (Arg780 in the triple helical domain) of proα1(I) chains that cause mild OI. We compared their effects with two substitutions for glycine located in close proximity. Like substitutions for glycine, those for arginine reduced the denaturation temperature of the whole molecule and caused asymmetric posttranslational overmodification of the chains. Circular dichroism and increased susceptibility to cleavage by MMP1, MMP2 and catalytic domain of MMP1 revealed significant destabilization of the triple helix near the collagenase cleavage site. On a cellular level, we observed slower triple helix folding and intracellular collagen retention, which disturbed the Endoplasmic Reticulum function and affected matrix deposition. Molecular dynamic modeling suggested that Arg780 substitutions disrupt the triple helix structure and folding by eliminating hydrogen bonds of arginine side chains, in addition to preventing HSP47 binding. The pathogenic effects of these non-glycine substitutions in bone are probably caused mostly by procollagen misfolding and its downstream effects.

Extracellular matrix: The driving force of mammalian diseases

Like the major theme of a Mozart concerto, the immense and pervasive extracellular matrix drives each movement and ultimately closes the symphony, embracing a unique role as the fundamental mediator for most, if not all, ensuing intracellular events. As such, it comes as no surprise that the mechanism of just about every known disease can be traced back to some part of the matrix, typically in the form of an abnormal amount or activity level of a particular matrix component. These defects considerably affect downstream signaling axes leading to overt cellular dysfunction, organ failure, and death. From skin to bone, from vessels to brain, from eyes to all the internal organs, the matrix plays an incredible role as both a cause and potential means to reverse diseases. Human malaises including connective tissue disorders, muscular dystrophy, fibrosis, and cancer are all extracellular matrix-driven diseases. The ability to understand and modulate these matrix-related mechanisms may lead to the future discovery of novel therapeutic options for these patients.

A novel variant of osteogenesis imperfecta type IV and low serum phosphorus level caused by a Val94Asp mutation in COL1A1

Osteogenesis imperfecta (OI) is a rare congenital disorder characterized by bone fragility and fractures, and associated with bone deformity, short stature, dentin, ligament and blue-gray eye sclera. OI is caused by a heterozygous mutation in collagen α-1(I) chain (COL1A1) or collagen α-2(I) chain (COL1A2) genes that encode α chains of type I collagen. Collagen α chain peptide contains an N-propeptide, which has a role in assembly and processing of collagen. Point mutations in the N-propeptide domain appear to trigger OI. In the present study, a novel heterozygous missense mutation, c.281T>A (p.Val94Asp), was identified in the von Willebrand C domain of N-terminal of type I collagen in an individual with type IV OI. The majority of N-terminal mutations are associated with OI/Ehlers-Danlos syndrome (EDS); however, in the present study, the affected individual did not suffer from EDS and the level of serum phosphorus of the patient was low (0.67 mmol/l). A number of clinical phenotypes were observed at the same variation site or in the same region on the polypeptide chain of COL1A, which suggests that additional genetic and environmental factors may influence the severity of OI. The present study may provide insight into the phenotype-genotype association in collagen-associated diseases and improve clinical diagnosis of OI.

The chaperone activity of 4PBA ameliorates the skeletal phenotype of Chihuahua, a zebrafish model for dominant osteogenesis imperfecta

Classical osteogenesis imperfecta (OI) is a bone disease caused by type I collagen mutations and characterized by bone fragility, frequent fractures in absence of trauma and growth deficiency. No definitive cure is available for OI and to develop novel drug therapies, taking advantage of a repositioning strategy, the small teleost zebrafish (Danio rerio) is a particularly appealing model. Its small size, high proliferative rate, embryo transparency and small amount of drug required make zebrafish the model of choice for drug screening studies, when a valid disease model is available. We performed a deep characterization of the zebrafish mutant Chihuahua, that carries a G574D (p.G736D) substitution in the α1 chain of type I collagen. We successfully validated it as a model for classical OI. Growth of mutants was delayed compared with WT. X-ray, µCT, alizarin red/alcian blue and calcein staining revealed severe skeletal deformity, presence of fractures and delayed mineralization. Type I collagen extracted from different tissues showed abnormal electrophoretic migration and low melting temperature. The presence of endoplasmic reticulum (ER) enlargement due to mutant collagen retention in osteoblasts and fibroblasts of mutant fish was shown by electron and confocal microscopy. Two chemical chaperones, 4PBA and TUDCA, were used to ameliorate the cellular stress and indeed 4PBA ameliorated bone mineralization in larvae and skeletal deformities in adult, mainly acting on reducing ER cisternae size and favoring collagen secretion. In conclusion, our data demonstrated that ER stress is a novel target to ameliorate OI phenotype; chemical chaperones such as 4PBA may be, alone or in combination, a new class of molecules to be further investigated for OI treatment.

mTORC1 hyperactivation arrests bone growth in lysosomal storage disorders by suppressing autophagy

The mammalian target of rapamycin complex 1 (mTORC1) kinase promotes cell growth by activating biosynthetic pathways and suppressing catabolic pathways, particularly that of macroautophagy. A prerequisite for mTORC1 activation is its translocation to the lysosomal surface. Deregulation of mTORC1 has been associated with the pathogenesis of several diseases, but its role in skeletal disorders is largely unknown. Here, we show that enhanced mTORC1 signaling arrests bone growth in lysosomal storage disorders (LSDs). We found that lysosomal dysfunction induces a constitutive lysosomal association and consequent activation of mTORC1 in chondrocytes, the cells devoted to bone elongation. mTORC1 hyperphosphorylates the protein UV radiation resistance-associated gene (UVRAG), reducing the activity of the associated Beclin 1-Vps34 complex and thereby inhibiting phosphoinositide production. Limiting phosphoinositide production leads to a blockage of the autophagy flux in LSD chondrocytes. As a consequence, LSD chondrocytes fail to properly secrete collagens, the main components of the cartilage extracellular matrix. In mouse models of LSD, normalization of mTORC1 signaling or stimulation of the Beclin 1-Vps34-UVRAG complex rescued the autophagy flux, restored collagen levels in cartilage, and ameliorated the bone phenotype. Taken together, these data unveil a role for mTORC1 and autophagy in the pathogenesis of skeletal disorders and suggest potential therapeutic approaches for the treatment of LSDs.