Optimization of immunohistochemical detection of rat ESR2 proteins with well-validated monoclonal antibody PPZ0506

Sex and interspecies differences in ESR2-expressing cell distributions in mouse and rat brains

BACKGROUND

ESR2, a nuclear estrogen receptor also known as estrogen receptor β, is expressed in the brain and contributes to the actions of estrogen in various physiological phenomena. However, its expression profiles in the brain have long been debated because of difficulties in detecting ESR2-expressing cells. In the present study, we aimed to determine the distribution of ESR2 in rodent brains, as well as its sex and interspecies differences, using immunohistochemical detection with a well-validated anti-ESR2 antibody (PPZ0506).

METHODS

To determine the expression profiles of ESR2 protein in rodent brains, whole brain sections from mice and rats of both sexes were subjected to immunostaining for ESR2. In addition, to evaluate the effects of circulating estrogen on ESR2 expression profiles, ovariectomized female mice and rats were treated with low or high doses of estrogen, and the resulting numbers of ESR2-immunopositive cells were analyzed. Welch's t-test was used for comparisons between two groups for sex differences, and one-way analysis of variance followed by the Tukey-Kramer test were used for comparisons among multiple groups with different estrogen treatments.

RESULTS

ESR2-immunopositive cells were observed in several subregions of mouse and rat brains, including the preoptic area, extended amygdala, hypothalamus, mesencephalon, and cerebral cortex. Their distribution profiles exhibited sex and interspecies differences. In addition, low-dose estrogen treatment in ovariectomized female mice and rats tended to increase the numbers of ESR2-immunopositive cells, whereas high-dose estrogen treatment tended to decrease these numbers.

CONCLUSIONS

Immunohistochemistry using the well-validated PPZ0506 antibody revealed a more localized expression of ESR2 protein in rodent brains than has previously been reported. Furthermore, there were marked sex and interspecies differences in its distribution. Our histological analyses also revealed estrogen-dependent changes in ESR2 expression levels in female brains. These findings will be helpful for understanding the ESR2-mediated actions of estrogen in the brain.

Ovarian ERβ cistrome and transcriptome reveal chromatin interaction with LRH-1

BACKGROUND

Estrogen receptor beta (ERβ, Esr2) plays a pivotal role in folliculogenesis and ovulation, yet its exact mechanism of action is mainly uncharacterized.

RESULTS

We here performed ERβ ChIP-sequencing of mouse ovaries followed by complementary RNA-sequencing of wild-type and ERβ knockout ovaries. By integrating the ERβ cistrome and transcriptome, we identified its direct target genes and enriched biological functions in the ovary. This demonstrated its strong impact on genes regulating organism development, cell migration, lipid metabolism, response to hypoxia, and response to estrogen. Cell-type deconvolution analysis of the bulk RNA-seq data revealed a decrease in luteal cells and an increased proportion of theca cells and a specific type of cumulus cells upon ERβ loss. Moreover, we identified a significant overlap with the gene regulatory network of liver receptor homolog 1 (LRH-1, Nr5a2) and showed that ERβ and LRH-1 extensively bound to the same chromatin locations in granulosa cells. Using ChIP-reChIP, we corroborated simultaneous ERβ and LRH-1 co-binding at the ERβ-repressed gene Greb1 but not at the ERβ-upregulated genes Cyp11a1 and Fkbp5. Transactivation assay experimentation further showed that ERβ and LRH-1 can inhibit their respective transcriptional activity at classical response elements.

CONCLUSIONS

By characterizing the genome-wide endogenous ERβ chromatin binding, gene regulations, and extensive crosstalk between ERβ and LRH-1, along with experimental corroborations, our data offer genome-wide mechanistic underpinnings of ovarian physiology and fertility.

Immunohistochemical Detection of Estrogen Receptor-Beta (ERβ) with PPZ0506 Antibody in Murine Tissue: From Pitfalls to Optimization

The estrogen receptor beta (ERβ) is physiologically essential for reproductive biology and is implicated in various diseases. However, despite more than 20 years of intensive research on ERβ, there are still uncertainties about its distribution in tissues and cellular expression. Several studies show contrasts between mRNA and protein levels, and the use of knockout strategies revealed that many commercially available antibodies gave false-positive expression results. Recently, a specific monoclonal antibody against human ERβ (PPZ0506) showed cross-reactivity with rodents and was optimized for the detection of rat ERβ. Herein, we established an immunohistochemical detection protocol for ERβ protein in mouse tissue. Staining was optimized on murine ovaries, as granulosa cells are known to strongly express ERβ. The staining results were confirmed by western blot analysis and RT-PCR. To obtain accurate and reliable staining results, different staining conditions were tested in paraffin-embedded tissues. Different pitfalls were encountered in immunohistochemical detection. Strong heat-induced epitope retrieval (HIER) and appropriate antibody dilution were required to visualize specific nuclear expression of ERβ. Finally, the specificity of the antibody was confirmed by using ovaries from Esr2-depleted mice. However, in some animals, strong (non-specific) background staining appeared. These signals could not be significantly alleviated with commercially available additional blocking solutions and are most likely due to estrus-dependent expression of endogenous immunoglobulins. In summary, our study showed that the antibody PPZ0506, originally directed against human ERβ, is also suitable for reliable detection of murine ERβ. An established staining protocol mitigated ambiguities regarding the expression and distribution of ERβ in different tissues and will contribute to an improved understanding of its role and functions in murine tissues in the future.

Optimized Mouse-on-mouse Immunohistochemical Detection of Mouse ESR2 Proteins with PPZ0506 Monoclonal Antibody

Despite the physiological significance of ESR2, a lack of well-validated detection systems for ESR2 proteins has hindered progress in ESR2 research. Thus, recent identification of a specific anti-human ESR2 monoclonal antibody (PPZ0506) and its specific cross-reactivity against mouse and rat ESR2 proteins heightened momenta toward development of appropriate immunohistochemical detection systems for rodent ESR2 proteins. Building upon our previous optimization of ESR2 immunohistochemical detection in rats using PPZ0506, in this study, we further aimed to optimize mouse-on-mouse immunohistochemical detection using PPZ0506. Our assessment of several staining conditions using paraffin-embedded ovary sections revealed that intense heat-induced antigen retrieval, appropriate blocking, and appropriate antibody dilutions were necessary for optimization of mouse-on-mouse immunohistochemistry. Subsequently, we applied the optimized immunostaining method to determine expression profiles of mouse ESR2 proteins in peripheral tissues and brain subregions. Our analyses revealed more localized distribution of mouse ESR2 proteins than previously assumed. Moreover, comparison of these results with those obtained in humans and rats using PPZ0506 revealed interspecies differences in ESR2 expression. We expect that our optimized methodology for immunohistochemical staining of mouse ESR2 proteins will help researchers to solve multiple lines of controversial evidence concerning ESR2 expression.

Antibody Validation for Estrogen Receptor Beta

Antibodies can cross-react with proteins other than their intended targets, and antibody-based applications can, if not properly validated, lead to flawed interpretations. When evaluating 13 anti-estrogen receptor beta (ERβ) antibodies in 2017, we concluded that only one of them was specific. Applying this antibody in immunohistochemistry of over 44 different normal human tissues and 20 types of cancers revealed ERβ expression in only a few selected tissues. This aligned with mRNA evidence but contradicted a large set of published literature. ERβ protein expression continues to be reported in tissues without clear support by mRNA expression. In this chapter, we describe how ERβ antibodies can be thoroughly validated and discuss selection of well-characterized positive and negative controls. The validation scheme presented is applicable for immunohistochemistry and Western blotting. The protocol includes evaluation of mRNA evidence, use of public databases, assessment of on- and off-target binding, and an optional step for corroboration with immunoprecipitation and mass spectrometry.

Estrogen receptors and the aging brain

The female sex hormone estrogen has been ascribed potent neuroprotective properties. It signals by binding and activating estrogen receptors that, depending on receptor subtype and upstream or downstream effectors, can mediate gene transcription and rapid non-genomic actions. In this way, estrogen receptors in the brain participate in modulating neural differentiation, proliferation, neuroinflammation, cholesterol metabolism, synaptic plasticity, and behavior. Circulating sex hormones decrease in the course of aging, more rapidly at menopause in women, and slower in men. This review will discuss what this drop entails in terms of modulating neuroprotection and resilience in the aging brain downstream of spatiotemporal estrogen receptor alpha (ERα) and beta (ERβ) signaling, as well as in terms of the sex differences observed in Alzheimer's disease (AD) and Parkinson's disease (PD). In addition, controversies related to ER expression in the brain will be discussed. Understanding the spatiotemporal signaling of sex hormones in the brain can lead to more personalized prevention strategies or therapies combating neurodegenerative diseases.

Estrogen receptor actions in colitis

In recent years, researchers have demonstrated that estrogen and its receptors, aside from their role in regulating several biological functions, contribute to the development and progression/severity of inflammatory bowel diseases (IBDs). IBDs include both ulcerative colitis (UC) and Crohn's disease (CD). Epidemiological data indicate a clear difference in the incidence, severity, and complications of IBDs between sexes. Men present a higher risk of developing colitis than women and a higher risk of developing colorectal cancer, a common complication of this condition. However, fluctuations of estrogen levels have yielded inconsistent data, where oral contraceptives and hormone replacement therapy have been associated with an increased risk of IBDs in premenopausal women but significantly reduce disease activity after menopause. Likewise, improvement of symptoms related to CD has been reported during pregnancy, but not in UC, who often experience worsening symptoms. In the colonic epithelium, estrogen receptor β (ERβ) is the predominant form of the protein expressed, and it helps maintain normal epithelial function and organization. Preclinical data suggest that ER expression and activation via estrogen confers different responses on disease severity depending on the model used to induce colitis, which may reflect what is observed in patients with IBDs. Hence, this review aims to provide an overview of estrogen and its receptors, particularly ERβ, in the pathophysiology of IBDs.