An advanced compliance monitor for patients undergoing brace treatment for idiopathic scoliosis

Effectiveness of Orthotic Treatment on Clinical Outcomes of the Patients with Adolescent Idiopathic Scoliosis Under Different Wearing Compliance Levels: A Systematic Review

BACKGROUND

Wearing spinal orthosis for 16 to 23 hours a day during the teenage years could be challenging and stressful for patients with adolescent idiopathic scoliosis (AIS). The investigation of clinical outcomes under various orthosis-wearing compliances can provide helpful insight into orthotic treatment dosage. This systematic review aims to investigate actual orthosis-wearing compliance and evaluate the effectiveness of orthotic treatment in controlling scoliotic curvature and preventing surgery for patients with AIS under various levels of orthosis-wearing compliance.

METHODS

A literature search of 7 electronic databases, namely PubMed, MEDLINE, Cochrane Library, Scopus, CINAHL Complete, Web of Science, and Embase, was conducted on May 19, 2023. Participant characteristics, orthotic treatment protocols, compliance information, outcome measures, and key findings were extracted. The Newcastle-Ottawa Scales were used to evaluate the quality of included cohort and case-control studies.

RESULTS

This study systematically reviewed 17 of 1,799 identified studies, including 1,981 subjects. The actual compliance was inconsistent and ranged from 7.0 to 18.8 hours daily. The proportion of compliant subjects in each study varied from 16.0% to 78.6% due to the heterogeneity of calculation period, measurement methods, and orthosis prescription time. Thirteen studies were investigated to determine the effectiveness of orthotic treatment in controlling curve deformity under different compliance groups, and 2 studies compared the compliance under different treatment outcomes. The rate of curve progression, defined as surpassing the measurement error threshold of 5° or 6° after orthotic treatment, varied from 1.8% to 91.7% across the studies. Ten studies defined the treatment failure, surgery, or surgery indication as Cobb angle progressing to a certain degree (e.g., 40°, 45°, or 50°) and reported failure/surgery/surgery indication rates ranging from 0.0% to 91.7% among different compliance level groups.

CONCLUSION

This review found that the actual compliance with orthotic treatment was generally lower than the prescribed wearing time and exhibited wide variation among different studies. The electronic compliance monitors show promise in regular orthotic treatment practice. More importantly, the group with higher and consistent compliance has significantly less curve progression and lower surgery or failure rate than the group with lower and inconsistent compliance. Further studies are proposed to investigate the minimal orthosis-wearing compliance in patients with AIS treated with different types of orthoses.

LEVEL OF EVIDENCE

Level III, Systematic Review. See Instructions for Authors for a complete description of levels of evidence.

Influence of Specific Interventions on Bracing Compliance in Adolescents with Idiopathic Scoliosis-A Systematic Review of Papers Including Sensors' Monitoring

Adolescent idiopathic scoliosis (AIS) is a common disease that, in many cases, can be conservatively treated through bracing. High adherence to brace prescription is fundamental to gaining the maximum benefit from this treatment approach. Wearable sensors are available that objectively monitor the brace-wearing time, but their use, combined with other interventions, is poorly investigated. The aims of the current review are as follows: (i) to summarize the real compliance with bracing reported by studies using sensors; (ii) to find out the real brace wearing rate through objective electronic monitoring; (iii) to verify if interventions made to increase adherence to bracing can be effective according to the published literature. We conducted a systematic review of the literature published on Medline, EMBASE, CINAHL, Scopus, CENTRAL, and Web of Science. We identified 466 articles and included examples articles, which had a low to good methodological quality. We found that compliance a greatly varied between 21.8 and 93.9% (weighted average: 58.8%), real brace wearing time varied between 5.7 and 21 h per day (weighted average 13.3), and specific interventions seemed to improve both outcomes, with compliance increasing from 58.5 to 66% and brace wearing increasing from 11.9 to 15.1 h per day. Two comparative studies showed positive effects of stand-alone counseling and information on the sensors' presence when added to counseling. Sensors proved to be useful tools for objectively and continuously monitoring adherence to therapy in everyday clinical practice. Specific interventions, like the use of sensors, counseling, education, and exercises, could increase compliance. However, further studies using high-quality designs should be conducted in this field.

Effect of different undergarment designs on the compliance and acceptance of the patients with adolescent idiopathic scoliosis under orthotic treatment

BACKGROUND

Patient's acceptance and compliance to spinal orthosis could influence the outcome of orthotic treatment in adolescent idiopathic scoliosis. Two innovative undergarments (thin and thick designs) were designed to improve the patient's orthosis wearing experience and acceptance.

OBJECTIVE

This study aimed to evaluate the effects of patients' self-provided undergarment and 2 newly designed undergarments with respect to the orthosis wearing compliance and quality of life (QoL) measures.

METHODS

A prospective randomized-controlled study was conducted to compare the effect of three types of undergarments. Thirty-eight subjects with adolescent idiopathic scoliosis were randomly assigned to one of the three groups: self-provided, thin-design, or thick-design undergarment. Wearing compliance logbook, Scoliosis Research Society questionnaire, and Brace Questionnaire were used to document the orthosis wearing period and quantify the health-related and orthosis-related QoL measures. Kruskal-Wallis one-way analysis of variance (ANOVA) and Friedman two-way ANOVA by ranks tests were conducted for intergroup and intragroup comparisons, respectively.

RESULTS

The compliance and QoL domains of the subjects in the thin-design undergarment group were significantly higher than those of the other two undergarment groups (P < .05). The intragroup compliance and QoL scores varied significantly in the 4 visits throughout the study period (P < .05).

CONCLUSIONS

It was observed that an adaptation period toward the prescribed spinal orthosis is required to help patients gradually achieve a more stable acceptance. The thin-design undergarment was ranked higher than the other two tested undergarments in compliance and QoL measures.

TLSO with Graphene Sensors-An Application to Measurements of Corrective Forces in the Prototype of Intelligent Brace

This study presents a prototype of Intelligent Brace-the gold medal winner in the 68th edition of the International EUREKA 2019 Competition, in Valencia, Spain. It shows how to improve the effectiveness of a static orthopedic brace, with modern technology based on advanced electronic solutions. The research uses in-house-made thin-film graphene sensors, an electronic system with a microcontroller and derotating pads, a mobile application for Android system, and a remote database. The article presents a description of the real project, the system principle of operation, and the layout of the system elements in the orthosis. A prototype device was designed and built that was tested not only in laboratory conditions, but also during trials with the first patient. Approximately two months of data were collected and interpreted. The collected research results provided basic knowledge about the range of forces exerted by the brace on the patient's body, as well as the regularity of wearing the orthosis by the patient and compliance with the doctor's recommendations.

The Optimal Anatomical Position and Threshold Temperature of a Temperature Data Logger for Brace-Wearing Compliance in Patients with Scoliosis

Introduction

Although strict compliance with brace wearing is important for patients with scoliosis, no study has analyzed the most ideal conditions for temperature logger accuracy. We evaluated the optimal brace position and threshold temperature for the logger and determined the reliability of its measurements in patients with scoliosis.

Methods

Five temperature loggers were embedded into holes generated at five different brace positions (right scapula, right chest, left chest, lumbar, and abdomen) within the brace. We compared measurement errors at each position using different threshold temperatures to determine the ideal anatomical position and threshold temperature. Under the ideal conditions determined, we calculated the reliability of the temperature logger readings in three healthy participants.

Results

Measurement errors (i.e., differences between the actual and logger-recorded brace wearing times) were the lowest at the 28°C and 30°C threshold temperatures when the logger was positioned at the left chest and at 30°C at the abdomen. Among these three temperature/position combinations, we considered the abdomen to be the least affected by the shape of the brace; thus, the placement of the temperature logger at the abdomen using a threshold temperature of 30°C was the most ideal condition.

Conclusions

The placement of the temperature logger at the abdomen using a threshold temperature of 30°C was the most ideal condition, with the reliability of the logger being 97.9%±0.9%. This information might be useful for scoliosis management teams, and this temperature logger provides a valuable clinical tool.

The ISJ 3D Brace, a Providence Brace Evolution, as a Surgery Prevention Method in Idiopathic Scoliosis

Background: The high incidence of idiopathic scoliosis worldwide as well as the serious health problems it can cause in adulthood, make it necessary to seek effective treatments to prevent the progression of the disease to more aggressive treatments such as surgery and improve patients’ quality of life. The use of night braces, besides a less severe influence on the patient’s quality of life, is effective in stopping the progression of the curve in idiopathic scoliosis. Methods: A longitudinal study was performed with an experimental population of 108 participants who attended orthotic treatment at the University Hospital of Barcelona, with ages between 4 and 15 years old, with a main curvature greater than 25 degrees and a Risser between 0 and 3. The participants received treatment with Providence ISJ-3D night braces until their pubertal change (mean duration of 2.78 years for males and 1.97 years for females). Results: The implementation of night-time orthotic treatment in children with idiopathic scoliosis is effective in slowing the progression of the curve and in the prevention of more aggressive treatments such as surgery, maintaining the patient’s quality of life. Conclusions: The use of night braces is efficacious in the treatment of idiopathic scoliosis, although new studies including more sociodemographic data as well as curves from 20 degrees of progression are necessary.

A compliance real-time monitoring system for the management of the brace usage in adolescent idiopathic scoliosis patients: a pilot study

Background

Patient compliance is essential to the effectiveness of brace treatment for adolescent idiopathic scoliosis (AIS) patients. Subjective measurements like questionnaires and inquiries proved to be arguably inaccurate. Although some scholars have applied temperature/force monitors to measuring patient compliance objectively, few studies to date could monitor patient compliance in real time. The objective of this study is to describe and evaluate a compliance real-time monitoring system of the brace usage in AIS patients.

Methods

A compliance real-time monitoring system (specifically consisting of a compliance monitor, a WeChat Mini Program, a cloud-based storage system and a website backstage management system) was designed to manage the brace treatment. Thirty patients receiving brace treatment were enrolled. They were told to upload the data at least once a day. Clinicians downloaded the compliance data and communicated with the patients online based on their analysis of data at least once every 3 months. The measured force, quality compliance (measured force / baseline force), measured time, and quantity compliance (measured time/ prescribed time) were used to evaluate patient compliance. Patients were also asked to rate their satisfaction at the final follow-up.

Results

Twenty-eight patients were included in the final analysis. The mean baseline force was 1.23 ± 0.28 N. The mean measured force was 0.79 ± 0.29 N. The mean quality compliance was 64.8 ± 22.2%. The prescribed time of all patients was 23 h. The mean measured time was 14.1 ± 2.9 h. The mean quantity compliance was 61.3 ± 12.6%. Both the quality and quantity compliance during the first 3 months of treatment was significantly lower than the latter 3 months. In this study, 96.4% (27/28) patients were satisfied with the use of the monitoring system, among whom 21.4% (6/28) are very satisfied and 75.0% (21/28) are somewhat satisfied.

Conclusions

The compliance real-time monitoring system, without evaluating the clinical and radiographic outcomes for now, has already shown some feasibility and effectiveness for the management of the brace usage in AIS patients. This system, as a useful tool for online patient management and patient-clinician communication, would be potentially employed on a large scale in future for clinicians to improve the compliance and satisfaction of AIS patients who have received brace treatment.

The Intelligent Automated Pressure-Adjustable Orthosis for Patients With Adolescent Idiopathic Scoliosis: A Bi-Center Randomized Controlled Trial

STUDY DESIGN

Randomized controlled trial.

OBJECTIVE

To compare the effectiveness of the automated pressure-adjustable orthosis (PO) and conventional orthosis (CO) for treatment of adolescent idiopathic scoliosis (AIS).

SUMMARY OF BACKGROUND DATA

Orthosis wearing quality may influence its effectiveness for AIS. An automated PO aimed to provide a more optimized and consistent biomechanical environment. Clinical evaluation was conducted to study the effectiveness of this innovative orthosis.

METHODS

Patients with AIS who met the criteria (Age 10-14, Cobb 20°-40°, and Risser sign 0-2) were recruited from two clinics and randomly assigned to the PO and CO groups. Compliance sensors were embedded in both groups, while the PO group was set to adjust the interfacial pressure as prescribed automatically. Clinical assessments (radiology and quality of life, QoL) were conducted at the baseline, immediate after orthosis fitting and 1-year follow-up. Orthosis wearing compliance was tracked using thermo and pressure sensors.

RESULTS

Twenty-four patients were enrolled with one drop-out (PO, n = 11; CO, n = 12). Significant immediate in-orthosis correction was observed in the PO (11.0° ± 6.5°, 42.0%, P < 0.001) and CO (10.3° ± 5.3°, 37.6%, P < 0.001) groups. After 1 year, no patient with PO progressed while two with CO had progression more than 5°. The mean daily wearing duration was 1.1 hours longer in the PO group as compared with the CO group (15.4 ± 4.5 vs. 14.3 ± 3.8 h). Moreover, the wearing quality within the targeted pressure was 33.9% higher in the PO group (56.5 ± 16.5% vs. 23.1 ± 12.1%, P < 0.001). No significant difference in the QoL results was observed between two groups nor within both groups during the study period.

CONCLUSION

This study showed that the automated PO could enhance wearing quality when compared with the CO, thus offering a better biomechanical corrective effect in the study period without adverse effect on the patients' wearing quantity and QoL.

LEVEL OF EVIDENCE

1.

Compliance with night-time overcorrection bracing in adolescent idiopathic scoliosis: Result from a cohort follow-up

The main issue that may be encountered during brace treatment of idiopathic scoliosis is the patient's compliance. While compliance with full-time brace treatment has been well documented, compliance with night-time brace treatment has not. The main feature of night-time braces is their ability to overcorrect the scoliotic curvature, which could decrease compliance. The primary aim of this study was to evaluate objectively the compliance of patients with idiopathic scoliosis when undergoing treatment by means of a night-time overcorrection brace. Twenty patients with adolescent idiopathic scoliosis were prescribed treatment with an overcorrection brace for 8 h per night. Compliance was determined by the percentage of actual hours the brace was worn relative to the prescribed regimen. Compliance was measured during 1 year via a hidden temperature monitor embedded within the brace. Patients were informed that their compliance was monitored. The brace acceptance period and the full acceptance period were analysed, and correlations were measured. The average compliance (% wearing hours/prescribed regimen) was 90.7%; 45% of the participants met or exceeded the prescribed brace time. Three girls were lost to follow-up. The mean acceptance period was 22,8 days, and half of the patients succeeded in achieving the acceptance period in less than 7 days. The mean full acceptance period was 26,9 days. The acceptance period was significantly and negatively correlated with the mean wearing time (r = -0,61, P = 0,004). There was no correlation between the in-brace overcorrection and the wearing time. These results suggest that patients with an overcorrection night-time brace had good compliance. The overcorrection did not seem to influence compliance. The first weeks of treatment seemed to be crucial for treatment compliance.

Effective factors on brace compliance in idiopathic scoliosis: a literature review

Objectives: Compliance plays a major role in the success of brace treatment and is influenced by factors such as the kind of brace, measurements method, regimen for brace wear, pattern wearing at night/day or full/part time and another factor is also psychological condition of the wearer. The objective of this review is to assess affecting factors on compliance of spinal braces in idiopathic scoliosis.Materials and methods: The guideline of the Preferred Reporting Items for Systematic Review and Meta-Analysis (PRISMA) was used for conducting review and assessing the quality of evidence. The search in Pubmed databases had 175 results of which 17 articles met the inclusion criteria. Effective factors on compliance were extracted and categorized into six groups based on type of brace, measurement method, age, day/night time pattern wearing, full/part time wearing and psychological aspect that can improve the result of spinal brace treatment in idiopathic scoliosis.Results: The results demonstrated that the type of braces determines structure and appearance and affects compliance. Psychological aspects, age, brace wear pattern (daytime or nighttime or part-time versus fulltime) and the assessment method (using temperature versus pressure sensors) can affect recorded compliance.Conclusions: Compliance can be augmented by considering factors in the design and delivery of the brace. Superior appearance and comfortable within the brace can improve psychological acceptance and improve the compliance. Lower age, involving the patient in treatment procedure, considering the child habits, and improved family awareness of the treatment plan of idiopathic scoliosis can also improve overall compliance of the brace.Implications for rehabilitationThis article reviews factors that affect compliance with orthotic treatment in idiopathic scoiliosis.

A Preliminary Study of the Objective Measurement of Compliance Rates for Semirigid Lumbar-Support Use in Patients with Chronic Nonspecific Low Back Pain: How Important Is the Compliance Rate?

Study Design

Clinical pilot study.

Purpose

To objectively evaluate the compliance rate of lumbar-support use in patients with chronic nonspecific low back pain, as well as to assess low back pain intensity, disability, and fear-avoidance beliefs.

Overview of Literature

Wearing time is an important factor in the assessment of the efficacy of lumbar-support use in patients with chronic nonspecific low back pain. Previous studies have measured lumbar-support wearing time based on subjective assessment, and these evaluations are not easily verifiable and are usually overestimated by subjects.

Methods

Twelve subjects with chronic nonspecific low back pain who had been wearing semirigid lumbar supports for 6 weeks were evaluated. Compliance was objectively monitored using temperature sensors integrated into the semirigid lumbar supports. Subjects wore their lumbar supports for 8 hour/day on workdays and 3 hour/day on holidays during the first 3 weeks. During the next 3 weeks, subjects were gradually weaned off the lumbar supports. Pain intensity was measured using a numerical rating scale. The Oswestry disability index was used to assess the subjects' disability. Fear-avoidance behavior was evaluated using a fear-avoidance beliefs questionnaire.

Results

The mean compliance rate of the subjects was 78.16%±13.9%. Pain intensity was significantly lower in patients with a higher compliance rate (p=0.001). Disability index and fear-avoidance beliefs (functional outcomes) significantly improved during the second 3-weeks period of the treatment (p<0.001, p=0.02, respectively).

Conclusions

The compliance rate of patients wearing lumbar supports is a determining factor in chronic low back pain management. Wearing semirigid lumbar supports, as advised, was associated with decreased pain intensity, improved disability index scores, and improved fear-avoidance beliefs in patients with chronic nonspecific low back pain.