Testing the impact of discoplasty on the biomechanics of the intervertebral disc with simulated degeneration: An in vitro study

Finite element analysis of biomechanical effects of percutaneous cement discoplasty in scoliosis

OBJECTIVE

To investigate the effect of bone cement on the vertebral body and biomechanical properties in percutaneous cement discoplasty (PCD) for degenerative lumbar disc disease.

METHODS

Three-dimensional reconstruction of L2 ~ L3 vertebral bodies was performed in a healthy volunteer, and the corresponding finite element model of the spine was established. Biomechanical analysis was performed on the changes in stress distribution in different groups of models by applying quantitative loads.

RESULTS

Models with percutaneous discoplasty (PCD) showed improved stability under various stress conditions, and intervertebral foraminal heights were superior to models without discoplasty.

CONCLUSION

Cement discoplasty can improve the stability of the vertebral body to a certain extent and restore a certain height of the intervertebral foramen, which has a good development prospect and potential.

Complication Pattern After Percutaneous Cement Discoplasty: Identification of Factors Influencing Reoperation and Length of Hospital Stay

OBJECTIVE

Percutaneous cement discoplasty (PCD) was introduced to treat symptomatic vertical instability of the lumbar spine in a minimally invasive way. The aim of the present study was to analyze the complication pattern after PCD and to identify factors that predict the chance of cement leakage, reoperation, and length of hospital stay (LOS).

METHODS

patients were treated with PCD within the study period. Clinical features and complications were analyzed by applying descriptive statistics, whereas perioperative factors predictive of cement leakage, reoperation, and LOS were identified by regression models.

RESULTS

Cement leakage rate was 30.4% in the total cohort; however, only fifth of them were symptomatic. Cement leakage itself did not have a significant influence on clinical outcome. Other complications and nonsurgical adverse events were registered only in 2.0% of cases. Age, subcutaneous fat tissue thickness, low viscosity cement, lower level of surgeon's experience and the number of operated levels were identified as risk factors of cement leakage (P < 0.01; c-index = 0.836). Type of procedure, Charlson comorbidity score, reoperation, and nonsurgical adverse events significantly increased the LOS (P < 0.01). Cement leakage, early surgical practice, and increased subcutaneous fat tissue thickness were risk factors for reoperation (P < 0.01; c-index = 0.72).

CONCLUSIONS

PCD is a relatively safe and effective procedure for treating spinal instability caused by advanced-stage disc degeneration characterized by vacuum phenomenon. Cement leakage is not uncommon but is only a radiologic complication without clinical consequences in most cases. On the other hand, it can increase the LOS and is a significant risk factor for reoperation.

Assessment of foraminal decompression following discoplasty using a combination of ex vivo testing and numerical tools

Percutaneous Cement Discoplasty (PCD) is a minimally invasive surgical technique to treat degenerated intervertebral discs. When the disc is severely degenerated, the vacuum observed in place of the nucleus pulposus can be filled with bone cement to restore the disc height, open the foramen space, and relieve pain. This study aimed to evaluate the foramen geometry change due to PCD, in the loaded spine. Cadaveric spines (n = 25) were tested in flexion and extension while Digital Image Correlation (DIC) measured displacements and deformations. Tests were performed on simulated pre-operative condition (nucleotomy) and after PCD. Registering DIC images and the 3D specimen geometry from CT scans, a 3D model of the specimens aligned in the experimental pose was obtained for nucleotomy and PCD. Foramen space volume was geometrically measured for both conditions. The volume of cement injected was measured to explore correlation with the change of foramen space. PCD induced a significant overall foraminal decompression in both flexion (foramen space increased by 835 ± 1289 mm³, p = 0.001) and extension (1205 ± 1106 mm³, p < 0.001), confirming that the expected improvements of PCD show also during spine motion. Furthermore, in extension when the foramen is the most challenged, the impact of PCD on the foramen correlated with the injected cement volume.

Biomechanical consequences of cement discoplasty: An in vitro study on thoraco-lumbar human spines

With the ageing of the population, there is an increasing need for minimally invasive spine surgeries to relieve pain and improve quality of life. Percutaneous Cement Discoplasty is a minimally invasive technique to treat advanced disc degeneration, including vacuum phenomenon. The present study aimed to develop an in vitro model of percutaneous cement discoplasty to investigate its consequences on the spine biomechanics in comparison with the degenerated condition. Human spinal segments (n = 27) were tested at 50% body weight in flexion and extension. Posterior disc height, range of motion, segment stiffness, and strains were measured using Digital Image Correlation. The cement distribution was also studied on CT scans. As main result, percutaneous cement discoplasty restored the posterior disc height by 41% for flexion and 35% for extension. Range of motion was significantly reduced only in flexion by 27%, and stiffness increased accordingly. The injected cement volume was 4.56 ± 1.78 ml (mean ± SD). Some specimens (n = 7) exhibited cement perforation of one endplate. The thickness of the cement mass moderately correlated with the posterior disc height and range of motion with different trends for flexions vs. extension. Finally, extreme strains on the discs were reduced by percutaneous cement discoplasty, with modified patterns of the distribution. To conclude, this study supported clinical observations in term of recovered disc height close to the foramen, while percutaneous cement discoplasty helped stabilize the spine in flexion and did not increase the risk of tissue damage in the annulus.

Biomechanical effects of cement discoplasty on the lumbar spinal unit

BACKGROUND

Percutaneous cement discoplasty (PCD) is used to treat patients with low back and leg pain due to the intervertebral disc vacuum phenomena. Whether PCD can restore lumbar spinal stability remains unknown.

OBJECTIVE

The purpose of our in vitro study was to evaluate the biomechanical changes brought about by PCD.

METHODS

Eight fresh pig lumbar spines were tested in the following order: intact, after nucleotomy, and after discoplasty. Flexion/extension, lateral bending, and axial rotation were induced by pure moments. The range of motion and neutral zone were recorded. A CT scan was performed to assess the injection volume of the bone cement and to observe whether the bone cement was fractured. After removing the facet joint, a compression failure test was conducted to observe the fracture of bone cement.

RESULTS

Compared with nucleotomy, range of motion (ROM) after discoplasty was reduced only in lateral flexion (P < 0.05). The results of the neutral zone showed that the neutral zones in flexion-extension and lateral bending were significantly reduced after discoplasty (P < 0.05). The neutral zone was more sensitive to changes in lumbar stability than ROM. Bone cement slides were observed during the biomechanical test. The CT scan and compression failure test showed that bone cement fracture was more likely to occur at the puncture channel in the annulus fibrosus region.

CONCLUSION

In all, the biomechanical study indicates that discoplasty helps enhance the stability of the lumbar spine in flexion-extension and lateral bending, which explains how PCD works for low back pain. Fractures and sliding of bone cement were observed after discoplasty, and this was more likely to occur at the puncture channel in the annulus fibrosus region. This suggests that bone cement displacement after PCD may cause nerve compression.

[Biomechanical evaluation of effects of percutaneous cement discoplasty and percutaneous cement interbody fusion on spinal stability]

OBJECTIVE

To investigate the effects of percutaneous cement discoplasty (PCD) and percutaneous cement interbody fusion (PCIF) on spinal stability by in vitro biomechanical tests.

METHODS

Biomechanical test was divided into intact (INT) group, percutaneous lumbar discectomy (PLD) group, PCD group, and PCIF group. Six specimens of L _{4, 5} (including vertebral bodies and intervertebral discs) from fresh male cadavers were taken to prepare PLD, PCD, and PCIF specimens, respectively. Before treatment and after the above treatments, the MTS multi-degree-of-freedom simulation test system was used to conduct the biomechanical test. The intervertebral height of the specimen was measured before and after the axial loading of 300 N, and the difference was calculated. The range of motion (ROM) and stiffness of the spine in flexion, extension, left/right bending, and left/right rotation under a torque of 7.5 Nm were calculated.

RESULTS

After axial loading, the change of intervertebral height in PLD group was more significant than that in other three groups ( P<0.05). Compared with INT group, the ROM in all directions significantly increased and the stiffness significantly decreased in PLD group ( P<0.05). Compared with INT group, the ROM of flexion, extension, and left/right rotation in PCD group significantly increased and the stiffness significantly decreased ( P<0.05); compared with PLD group, the ROM of flexion, extension, and left/right bending in PCD group significantly decreased and the stiffness significantly increased ( P<0.05). Compared with INT group, ROM of left/right bending in PCIF group significantly decreased and stiffness significantly increased ( P<0.05); compared with PLD group, the ROM in all directions significantly decreased and the stiffness significantly increased ( P<0.05); compared with PCD group, the ROM of flexion, left/right bending, and left/right rotation significantly decreased and stiffness significantly increased ( P<0.05).

CONCLUSION

Both PCD and PCIF can provide good biomechanical stability. The former mainly affects the stiffness in flexion, extension, and bending, while the latter is more restrictive on lumbar ROM in all directions, especially in bending and rotation.

An ex-vivo model for the biomechanical assessment of cement discoplasty

Percutaneous Cement Discoplasty (PCD) is a surgical technique developed to relieve pain in patients with advanced degenerative disc disease characterized by a vacuum phenomenon. It has been hypothesized that injecting bone cement into the disc improves the overall stability of the spinal segment. However, there is limited knowledge on the biomechanics of the spine postoperatively and a lack of models to assess the effect of PCD ex-vivo. This study aimed to develop a biomechanical model to study PCD in a repeatable and clinically relevant manner. Eleven ovine functional spinal units were dissected and tested under compression in three conditions: healthy, injured and treated. Injury was induced by a papain buffer and the treatment was conducted using PMMA cement. Each sample was scanned with micro-computed tomography (CT) and segmented for the three conditions. Similar cement volumes (in %) were injected in the ovine samples compared to volumes measured on clinical PCD CT images. Anterior and posterior disc heights decreased on average by 22.5% and 23.9% after injury. After treatment, the anterior and posterior disc height was restored on average to 98.5% and 83.6%, respectively, of their original healthy height. Compression testing showed a similar stiffness behavior between samples in the same group. A decrease of 51.5% in segment stiffness was found after injury, as expected. The following PCD treatment was found to result in a restoration of stiffness—showing only a difference of 5% in comparison to the uninjured state. The developed ex-vivo model gave an adequate representation of the clinical vacuum phenomena in terms of volume, and a repeatable mechanical response between samples. Discoplasty treatment was found to give a restoration in stiffness after injury. The data presented confirm the effectiveness of the PCD procedure in terms of restoration of axial stiffness in the spinal segment. The model can be used in the future to test more complex loading scenarios, novel materials, and different surgical techniques.

In-vitro models of disc degeneration - A review of methods and clinical relevance

The intervertebral disc (IVD) provides flexibility, acts as a shock absorber, and transmits load. Degeneration of the IVD includes alterations in the biomechanics, extracellular matrix (ECM), and cellular activity. These changes are not always perceived, however, IVD degeneration can lead to severe health problems including long-term disability. To understand the pathogenesis of IVD degeneration and suitable testing methods for emerging treatments and therapies, this review documents in-vitro models of IVD degeneration including physical disruption, hyperphysiological loading, ECM degradation by enzyme digestion, or a combination of these methods. This paper reviews and critically analyses the models of degeneration published since the year 2000 in either in human or animal specimens. The results are categorised in terms of the IVD biomechanics, physical attributes, ECM composition, tissue damage and cellularity to evaluate the models with respect to natural human degeneration, and to provide recommendations for clinically relevant models for the various stages of degeneration. There is no one model that replicates the wide range of degenerative changes that occur as part of normal degeneration. However, cyclic overloading replicates many aspects of degeneration, with the advantage of a dose-response allowing the tuning of damage initiated. Models of severe degeneration are currently lacking, but there is potential that combining cyclic overloading and enzymatic digestion will provide model that closely resembles human IVD degeneration. This will provide an effective way to investigate the effects of severe degeneration, and the evaluation of treatments for the IVD, which would generally be indicated at this advanced stage of degeneration.

Biomechanical evaluation of percutaneous cement discoplasty by finite element analysis

Background

Percutaneous cement discoplasty (PCD) is a minimally invasive treatment for degenerative lumbar spine disease, but the relationship between decompression effect on the nerve root and different doses of bone cement is uncertain.

Purpose

To investigate the indirect decompression effect of cement with different doses on nerve roots and the biomechanical changes on the spine during PCD using finite element analysis (FEA).

Methods

FEA was adapted to analyze the mechanical changes in the lumbar vertebrae before and after the application of PCD.CT scan images of adult males were utilized to establish a finite element model of the lumbar vertebral body using mimics and Pro/E software. The images were divided into four models: the normal model (normal, model N), the disc degeneration model (high, model H), the intervertebral disc injected with 3 mL of bone cement (model H1), and the intervertebral disc injected with 5 mL of bone cement (model H2). All models were analyzed using the ABAQUS6.14.2 software. The normal physiological movements were simulated, and the mechanical changes in the lumbar vertebrae were observed prior to and after the cement filling application.

Results

The stress of the nerve root in model H was the largest. The nerve root stress in the model H2 was the smallest during flexion, extension, left bending, right bending, left rotation, and right rotation at 90%, 44%, 25%, 56%, 56%, and 51% of the normal benchmark, respectively. After the injection of bone cement, the nerve root stress is reduced. The greater the amount of cement, the lesser the nerve root stress. The motion was reduced in models H, H1, and H2, and there were differences between models H1 and H2. Cartilage endplate stress was less in model H2 than in model H1.

Conclusions

The nerve root stress increased after degeneration and decreased after intervertebral height recovery through cement injection, resulting in a significant indirect decompression effect.The stress of the nerve root decreased with the increase in the amount of cement injection.

Critical Review of the State-of-the-Art on Lumbar Percutaneous Cement Discoplasty

Interbody fusion is the gold standard surgery to treat lumbar disc degeneration disease but can be a high-risk procedure in elderly and polymorbid patients. Percutaneous Cement Discoplasty (PCD) is a minimally invasive technique developed to treat advanced stage of disc degeneration exhibiting a vacuum phenomenon. A patient-specific stand-alone spacer is created by filling the disc with polymethylmethacrylate cement, allowing to recover the disc height and improve the patient’s conditions. As it has recently been introduced in the lumbar spine, this review aims to present a transversal state-of-the-art of the surgery from its clinical practice and outcome to biomechanical and engineering topics. The literature was searched across multiple databases using predefined keywords over no limited period of time. Papers about vertebroplasty were excluded. Among 466 identified papers, the relevant ones included twelve clinical papers reporting the variations of the surgical technique, follow-up and complications, four papers reporting biomechanical ex vivo and numerical tests, and four letters related to published clinical papers. Papers presenting the operative practice are reported, as well as follow-ups up to four years. The papers found, consistently reported that PCD significantly improved the clinical status of the patients and maintained it after two years. Spine alignment was impacted by PCD: the sacral slope was significantly reduced, and disc height increased. The foramen opening correlated to the volume of injected cement. Substitutes to the acrylic cement exhibited better osteointegration and mechanical properties closer to bone tissue. Finally, limitations and risks of the surgery are discussed as well as potential improvements such as the development of new filling materials with better mechanical properties and biological integration or the investigation of the inner disc.

Low-Modulus PMMA Has the Potential to Reduce Stresses on Endplates after Cement Discoplasty

Cement discoplasty has been developed to treat patients with advanced intervertebral disc degeneration. In discoplasty, poly(methylmethacrylate) (PMMA) bone cement is injected into the disc, leading to reduced pain and certain spinal alignment correction. Standard PMMA-cements have much higher elastic modulus than the surrounding vertebral bone, which may lead to a propensity for adjacent fractures. A PMMA-cement with lower modulus might be biomechanically beneficial. In this study, PMMA-cements with lower modulus were obtained using previously established methods. A commercial PMMA-cement (V-steady^®, G21 srl) was used as control, and as base cement. The low-modulus PMMA-cements were modified by 12 vol% (LA12), 16 vol% (LA16) and 20 vol% (LA20) linoleic acid (LA). After storage in 37 °C PBS from 24 h up to 8 weeks, specimens were tested in compression to obtain the material properties. A lower E-modulus was obtained with increasing amount of LA. However, with storage time, the E-modulus increased. Standard and low-modulus PMMA discoplasty were compared in a previously developed and validated computational lumbar spine model. All discoplasty models showed the same trend, namely a substantial reduction in range of motion (ROM), compared to the healthy model. The V-steady model had the largest ROM-reduction (77%), and the LA20 model had the smallest (45%). The average stress at the endplate was higher for all discoplasty models than for the healthy model, but the stresses were reduced for cements with higher amounts of LA. The study indicates that low-modulus PMMA is promising for discoplasty from a mechanical viewpoint. However, validation experiments are needed, and the clinical setting needs to be further considered.

Reaction Forces and Flexion-Extension Moments Imposed On Functional Spinal Units with Constrained and Unconstrained in Vitro Testing Systems

A mechanical goal of in vitro testing systems is to minimize differences between applied and actual forces and moments experienced by spinal units. This study quantified the joint reaction forces and reaction flexion-extension moments during dynamic compression loading imposed throughout the physiological flexion-extension range-of-motion. Constrained (fixed base) and unconstrained (floating base) testing systems were compared. Sixteen porcine spinal units were assigned to both testing groups. Following conditioning tests, specimens were dynamically loaded for 1 cycle with a 1 Hz compression waveform to a peak load of 1 kN and 2 kN while positioned in five different postures (neutral, 100% and 300% of the flexion and extension neutral zone), totalling ten trials per FSU. A six degree-of-freedom force and torque sensor was used to measure peak reaction forces and moments for each trial. Shear reaction forces were significantly greater (25.5 N - 85.7 N) when the testing system was constrained compared to unconstrained (p < 0.029). The reaction moment was influenced by posture (p = 0.037), particularly in C5C6 spinal units. In 300% extension (C5C6), the reaction moment was, on average, 9.9 Nm greater than the applied moment in both testing systems and differed from all other postures (p < 0.001). The reaction moment error was, on average, 0.45 Nm at all other postures. In conclusion, these findings demonstrate that comparable reaction moments can be achieved with unconstrained systems, but without inducing appreciable shear reaction forces.

A novel approach to evaluate the effects of artificial bone focal lesion on the three-dimensional strain distributions within the vertebral body

The spine is the first site for incidence of bone metastasis. Thus, the vertebrae have a high potential risk of being weakened by metastatic tissues. The evaluation of strength of the bone affected by the presence of metastases is fundamental to assess the fracture risk. This work proposes a robust method to evaluate the variations of strain distributions due to artificial lesions within the vertebral body, based on in situ mechanical testing and digital volume correlation. Five porcine vertebrae were tested in compression up to 6500N inside a micro computed tomography scanner. For each specimen, images were acquired before and after the application of the load, before and after the introduction of the artificial lesions. Principal strains were computed within the bone by means of digital volume correlation (DVC). All intact specimens showed a consistent strain distribution, with peak minimum principal strain in the range -1.8% to -0.7% in the middle of the vertebra, demonstrating the robustness of the method. Similar distributions of strains were found for the intact vertebrae in the different regions. The artificial lesion generally doubled the strain in the middle portion of the specimen, probably due to stress concentrations close to the defect. In conclusion, a robust method to evaluate the redistribution of the strain due to artificial lesions within the vertebral body was developed and will be used in the future to improve current clinical assessment of fracture risk in metastatic spines.

A novel three-dimensional volumetric method to measure indirect decompression after percutaneous cement discoplasty

Purpose

Percutaneous cement discoplasty (PCD) is a minimally invasive surgical option to treat patients who suffer from the consequences of advanced disc degeneration. As the current two-dimensional methods can inappropriately measure the difference in the complex 3D anatomy of the spinal segment, our aim was to develop and apply a volumetric method to measure the geometrical change in the surgically treated segments.

Methods

Prospective clinical and radiological data of 10 patients who underwent single- or multilevel PCD was collected. Pre- and postoperative CT scan-based 3D reconstructions were performed. The injected PMMA (Polymethylmethacrylate) induced lifting of the cranial vertebra and the following volumetric change was measured by subtraction of the geometry of the spinal canal from a pre- and postoperatively predefined cylinder. The associations of the PMMA geometry and the volumetric change of the spinal canal with clinical outcome were determined.

Results

Change in the spinal canal volume (ΔV) due to the surgery proved to be significant (mean ΔV = 2266.5 ± 1172.2 mm³, n = 16; p = 0.0004). A significant, positive correlation was found between ΔV, the volume and the surface of the injected PMMA. A strong, significant association between pain intensity (low back and leg pain) and the magnitude of the volumetric increase of the spinal canal was shown (ρ = 0.772, p = 0.009 for LBP and ρ = 0.693, p = 0.026 for LP).

Conclusion

The developed method is accurate, reproducible and applicable for the analysis of any other spinal surgical method. The volume and surface area of the injected PMMA have a predictive power on the extent of the indirect spinal canal decompression. The larger the ΔV the higher clinical benefit was achieved with the PCD procedure.

The translational potential of this article

The developed method has the potential to be integrated into clinical software’s to evaluate the efficacy of different surgical procedures based on indirect decompression effect such as PCD, anterior lumbar interbody fusion (ALIF), lateral lumbar interbody fusion (LLIF), oblique lumbar interbody fusion (OLIF), extreme lateral interbody fusion (XLIF). The intraoperative use of the method will allow the surgeon to respond if the decompression does not reach the desired level.