Improved antifouling properties of membranes by simple introduction of zwitterionic copolymers via electrostatic adsorption

Biomimetic Antibacterial Gelatin Hydrogels with Multifunctional Properties for Biomedical Applications

A facile novel approach of introducing dopamine and [2-(methacryloyloxy) ethyl] dimethyl-(3-sulfopropyl) ammonium hydroxide via dopamine-triggered in situ synthesis into gelatin hydrogels in the presence of ZnSO4 is presented in this study. Remarkably, the resulting hydrogels showed 99.99 and 100% antibacterial efficiency against Gram-positive and Gram-negative bacteria, respectively, making them the highest performing surfaces in their class. Furthermore, the hydrogels showed adhesive properties, self-healing ability, antifreeze properties, electrical conductivity, fatigue resistance, and mechanical stability from -100 to 80 °C. The added multifunctional performance overcomes several disadvantages of gelatin-based hydrogels such as poor mechanical properties and limited thermostability. Overall, the newly developed hydrogels show significant potential for numerous biomedical applications, such as wearable monitoring sensors and antibacterial coatings.

Ultrasensitive Ratiometric Electrochemiluminescence Sensor with an Efficient Antifouling and Antibacterial Interface of PSBMA@SiO2-MXene for Oxytetracycline Trace Detection in the Marine Environment

The sensitivity and accuracy of electrochemiluminescence (ECL) sensors for detecting small-molecule pollutants in environmental water are affected not only by nonspecific adsorption of proteins and other molecules but also by bacterial interference. Therefore, there is an urgent need to develop an ECL sensor with antifouling and antibacterial functions for water environment monitoring. Herein, a highly efficient antifouling sensing interface (PSBMA@SiO2-MXene) based on zwitterionic sulfobetaine methacrylate (SBMA) antifouling nanospheres (NPs) and two-dimensional MXene nanosheets was designed for the sensitive detection of oxytetracycline (OTC), an antibiotic small-molecule pollutant. Specifically, SBMA with good hydrophilicity and electrical neutrality was connected to SiO2 NPs, thus effectively reducing protein and bacterial adsorption and improving stability. Second, MXene with a high specific surface area was selected as the carrier to load more antifouling NPs, which greatly improves the antifouling performance. Meanwhile, the introduction of MXene also enhances the conductivity of the antifouling interface. In addition, a ratio-based sensing strategy was designed to further improve the detection accuracy and sensitivity of the sensor by utilizing Au@luminol as an internal standard factor. Based on antifouling and antibacterial interfaces, as well as internal standard and ratiometric sensing strategies, the detection range of the proposed sensor was 0.1 ng/mL to 100 μg/mL, with a detection limit of 0.023 ng/mL, achieving trace dynamic monitoring of antibiotics in complex aqueous media.

Improvement of Antibacterial and Antifouling Properties of a Cellulose Acetate Membrane by Surface Grafting Quaternary Ammonium Salt

Through etherification reaction, epoxy propyl dimethyl dodecyl ammonium chloride (EPDMDAC) was grafted onto the surface of a cellulose acetate (CA) membrane to prepare a stable nonleaching antibacterial antifouling membrane (QCA-X). The results showed that with the extension of grafting reaction time, the quaternary ammonium salt groups on the membrane surface increased and the hydrophilicity was enhanced. Compared with those of the CA membrane, the filtration capacity and antifouling performance of the QCA-X membrane are improved. When the grafting time is 4 h, the water permeability and flux recovery rate of the QCA-4 membrane are increased by 139 and 21.5%, respectively. The QCA-X membrane showed excellent antibacterial performance, and the sterilization rate against S. aureus and E. coli was more than 99.99%. After four repeated antibacterial cycles, the bactericidal rates against S. aureus and E. coli were maintained at about 99.69 ± 0.02 and 99.98 ± 0.02%, respectively, with good antibacterial persistence. Moreover, the QCA-X membrane can effectively inhibit bacterial adhesion. Mild and simple EPDMDAC grafting modifications improve the antibacterial, antifouling, and antibioadhesion properties of the CA membrane, showing its application potential in long-term water treatment, especially in biofouling water treatment.

Studying the Effect of Pre-Polymer Composition and Incorporation of Surface-Modifying Amphiphilic Additives on the Fouling-Release Performance of Amphiphilic Siloxane-Polyurethane Coatings

Combining amphiphilic fouling-release (FR) coatings with the surface-active nature of amphiphilic additives can improve the antifouling/fouling-release (AF/FR) properties needed to offer broad-spectrum resistance to marine biofoulants. This work is focused on further tuning the amphiphilic character of a previously developed amphiphilic siloxane-polyurethane (SiPU) coating by varying the amount of PDMS and PEG in the base system. Furthermore, surface-modifying amphiphilic additives (SMAAs) were incorporated into these amphiphilic FR SiPU coatings in varying amounts. ATR-FTIR, contact angle and surface energy measurements, and AFM were performed to assess changes in surface composition, wettability, and morphology. AF/FR properties were evaluated using laboratory biological assays involving Cellulophaga lytica, Navicula incerta, Ulva linza, Amphibalanus amphitrite, and Geukensia demissa. The surfaces of these coatings varied significantly upon changes in PDMS and PEG content in the coating matrix, as well as with changes in SMAA incorporation. AF/FR properties were also significantly changed, with formulations containing the highest amounts of SMAA showing very high removal properties compared to other experimental formulations, in some cases better than that of commercial standard FR coatings.

In Situ Chemical Modification with Zwitterionic Copolymers of Nanofiltration Membranes: Cure for the Trade-Off between Filtration and Antifouling Performance

Breaking the trade-off between filtration performance and antifouling property is critical to enabling a thin-film nanocomposite (TFC) nanofiltration (NF) membrane for a wide range of feed streams. We proposed a novel design route for TFC NF membranes by grafting well-defined zwitterionic copolymers of [2-(methacryloyloxy)ethyl]dimethyl-(3-sulfopropyl)ammonium hydroxide (SBMA) and 2-aminoethyl methacrylate hydrochloride (AEMA) on the polyamide surfaces via an in situ surface chemical modification process. The successful grafting of a zwitterionic copolymer imparted the modified NF membranes with better surface hydrophilicity, a larger actual surface area (i.e., nodular structures), and a thinner polyamide layer. As a result, the water permeability of the modified membrane (i.e., TFC-10) was triple that of the pristine TFC membrane while maintaining high Na₂SO₄ rejection. We further demonstrated that the TFC-10 membrane possessed exceptional antifouling properties in both static adsorption tests and three cycles of dynamic protein and humic acid fouling tests. To recap, this work provides valuable insights and strategies for the fabrication of TFC NF membranes with simultaneously enhanced filtration performance and antifouling property.

Functionalization of PEG-AgNPs Hybrid Material to Alleviate Biofouling Tendency of Polyethersulfone Membrane

Membrane-based processes are a promising technology in water and wastewater treatments, to supply clean and secure water. However, during membrane filtration, biofouling phenomena severely hamper the performance, leading to permanent detrimental impacts. Moreover, regular chemical cleaning is ineffective in the long-run for overcoming biofouling, because it weakens the membrane structure. Therefore, the development of a membrane material with superior anti-biofouling performance is seen as an attractive option. Hydrophilic-anti-bacterial precursor polyethylene glycol-silver nanoparticles (PEG-AgNPs) were synthesized in this study, using a sol-gel method, to mitigate biofouling on the polyethersulfone (PES) membrane surface. The functionalization of the PEG-AgNP hybrid material on a PES membrane was achieved through a simple blending technique. The PES/PEG-AgNP membrane was manufactured via the non-solvent induced phase separation method. The anti-biofouling performance was experimentally measured as the flux recovery ratio (FRR) of the prepared membrane, before and after incubation in E. coli culture for 48 h. Nanomaterial characterization confirmed that the PEG-AgNPs had hydrophilic-anti-bacterial properties. The substantial improvements in membrane performance after adding PEG-AgNPs were evaluated in terms of the water flux and FRR after the membranes experienced biofouling. The results showed that the PEG-AgNPs significantly increased the water flux of the PES membrane, from 2.87 L·m⁻²·h⁻¹ to 172.84 L·m⁻²·h⁻¹. The anti-biofouling performance of the PES pristine membrane used as a benchmark showed only 1% FRR, due to severe biofouling. In contrast, the incorporation of PEG-AgNPs in the PES membrane decreased live bacteria by 98%. It enhanced the FRR of anti-biofouling up to 79%, higher than the PES/PEG and PES/Ag membranes.

Development of Antibacterial and Antifouling Innovative and Eco-Sustainable Sol-Gel Based Materials: From Marine Areas Protection to Healthcare Applications

Bacterial colonization of surfaces is the leading cause of deterioration and contaminations. Fouling and bacterial settlement led to damaged coatings, allowing microorganisms to fracture and reach the inner section. Therefore, effective treatment of surface damaged material is helpful to detach bio-settlement from the surface and prevent deterioration. Moreover, surface coatings can withdraw biofouling and bacterial colonization due to inherent biomaterial characteristics, such as superhydrophobicity, avoiding bacterial resistance. Fouling was a past problem, yet its untargeted toxicity led to critical environmental concerns, and its use became forbidden. As a response, research shifted focus approaching a biocompatible alternative such as exciting developments in antifouling and antibacterial solutions and assessing their antifouling and antibacterial performance and practical feasibility. This review introduces state-of-the-art antifouling and antibacterial materials and solutions for several applications. In particular, this paper focuses on antibacterial and antifouling agents for concrete and cultural heritage conservation, antifouling sol-gel-based coatings for filtration membrane technology, and marine protection and textile materials for biomedicine. In addition, this review discusses the innovative synthesis technologies of antibacterial and antifouling solutions and the consequent socio-economic implications. The synthesis and the related physico-chemical characteristics of each solution are discussed. In addition, several characterization techniques and different parameters that influence the surface finishing coatings deposition were also described.

Zwitterionic Polysulfone Copolymer/Polysulfone Blended Ultrafiltration Membranes with Excellent Thermostability and Antifouling Properties

Membrane fouling has been one of the most important challenges in membrane separation operations. In this study, we report a facile strategy to prepare antifouling polysulfone (PSf) UF membranes by blending amphiphilic zwitterion polysulfone-co-sulfobetaine polysulfone (PSf-co-SBPSf) copolymer. The copolymer chemical structure was characterized by ¹HNMR spectroscopy. The PSf/PSf-co-SBPSf blend membranes with various zwitterionic SBPSf segment contents exhibited better surface hydrophilicity and excellent antifouling ability compared to PSf and PSf/PEG membranes. The significant increase of both porosity and water permeance indicates that the PSf-co-SBPSf has a pore-forming effect. The pure water flux and flux recovery ratio of the PSf/PSf-co-SBPSf blend membranes were both remarked to improve 286.43 L/m²h and 92.26%, while bovine serum albumin (BSA) rejection remained at a high level (97.66%). More importantly, the water flux and BSA rejection see minimal variance after heat treatment, indicating excellent thermostability. Overall, the PSf/PSf-co-SBPSf blend membranes achieved a comprehensive performance of sustainable hydrophilic, high permeation flux, and remarkable antifouling ability, thus becoming a promising candidate in high-temperature separation application.

Facile Fabrication of Multi-Hydrogen Bond Self-Assembly Poly(MAAc-co-MAAm) Hydrogel Modified PVDF Ultrafiltration Membrane to Enhance Anti-Fouling Property

In this work, a facile preparation method was proposed to reduce natural organics fouling of hydrophobic membrane via UV grafting polymerization with methacrylic acid (MAAc) and methyl acrylamide (MAAm) as hydrophilic monomers, followed by multihydrogen bond self-assembly. The resulting poly(vinylidene fluoride)-membranes were characterized with respect to monomer ratio, chemical structure and morphology, surface potential, and water contact angle, as well as water flux and organic foulants ultrafiltration property. The results indicated that the optimal membrane modified with a poly(MAAc-co-MAAm) polymer gel layer derived from a 1:1 monomer ratio exhibited superior hydrophilicity and excellent gel layer stability, even after ultrasonic treatment or soaking in acid or alkaline aqueous solution. The initial water contact angle of modified membranes was only 36.6° ± 2.9, and dropped to 0° within 13 s. Moreover, flux recovery rates (FRR) of modified membranes tested by bovine serum albumin (BSA), humic acid (HA), and sodium alginate (SA) solution, respectively, were all above 90% after one-cycle filtration (2 h), significantly higher than that of the pure membrane (70–76%). The total fouling rates (R_t) of the pure membrane for three foulants were as high as 47.8–56.2%, while the R_t values for modified membranes were less than 30.8%. Where R_t of BSA dynamic filtration was merely 10.7%. The membrane designed through grafting a thin-layer hydrophilic hydrogel possessed a robust antifouling property and stability, which offers new insights for applications in pure water treatment or protein purification.

Enhancing the antifouling property of polymeric membrane via surface charge regulation

In this study, positively charged monomers were grafted onto negatively charged membranes via UV radiation to improve the antifouling/antibiofouling properties of the polymeric membrane and the stability of the modification layer. The surface properties, morphologies, antifouling and antibiofouling properties, and stability of the modified membranes were systematically characterized. Results indicated that the introduction of [2-(methacryloyloxy) ethyl] trimethylammonium chloride (MTAC) monomers onto polyethersulfone (PES)/sulfonated polyethersulfone (SPES) membranes effectively increased the surface hydrophilicity. Meanwhile, the surfaces were neutralized with ~0 mV zeta potential in pH 3-10. Moreover, the formation of a polyampholytic copolymer and the antibacterial ability of MTAC considerably improved the antibiofouling properties of the modified membranes. The MTAC-grafted PES/SPES membranes showed excellent antifouling/antibiofouling properties during the treatment of various types of wastewater, including bovine serum albumin solution, oil/water emulsion, and bacterial suspension. Therefore, this study provides a simple and effective method of constructing stable and antifouling membranes for sustainable water treatment.

Modification of Polysulfone Ultrafiltration Membranes via Addition of Anionic Polyelectrolyte Based on Acrylamide and Sodium Acrylate to the Coagulation Bath to Improve Antifouling Performance in Water Treatment

Surface modification of polysulfone ultrafiltration membranes was performed via addition of an anionic polymer flocculant based on acrylamide and sodium acrylate (PASA) to the coagulation bath upon membrane preparation by non-solvent induced phase separation (NIPS). The effect of PASA concentration in the coagulant at different coagulation bath temperatures on membrane formation time, membrane structure, surface roughness, hydrophilic-hydrophobic balance of the skin layer, surface charge, as well as separation and antifouling performance was studied. Scanning electron microscopy (SEM), atomic force microscopy (AFM), Fourier transform infrared (FTIR) spectroscopy, contact angle and zeta potential measurements were utilized for membrane characterization. Membrane barrier and antifouling properties were evaluated in ultrafiltration of model solutions containing human serum albumin and humic acids as well as with real surface water. PASA addition was found to affect the kinetics of phase separation leading to delayed demixing mechanism of phase separation due to the substantial increase of coagulant viscosity, which is proved by a large increase of membrane formation time. Denser and thicker skin layer is formed and formation of macrovoids in membrane matrix is suppressed. FTIR analysis confirms the immobilization of PASA macromolecules into the membrane skin layer, which yields improvement of hydrophilicity and change of zeta potential. Modified membrane demonstrated better separation and antifouling performance in the ultrafiltration of humic acid solution and surface water compared to the reference membrane.

Zwitterionic Polymer Brush Grafted on Polyvinylidene Difluoride Membrane Promoting Enhanced Ultrafiltration Performance with Augmented Antifouling Property

Superhydrophilic zwitterions on the membrane surface have been widely exploited to improve antifouling properties. However, the problematic formation of a <20 nm zwitterionic layer on the hydrophilic surface remains a challenge in wastewater treatment. In this work, we focused on the energy consumption and time control of polymerization and improved the strong hydrophilicity of the modified polyvinylidene difluoride (PVDF) membrane. The sulfobetaine methacrylate (SBMA) monomer was treated with UV-light through polymerization on the PVDF membrane at a variable time interval of 30 to 300 s to grow a poly-SBMA (PSBMA) chain and improve the membrane hydrophilicity. We examined the physiochemical properties of as-prepared PVDF and PVDF-PSBMA_x using numeric analytical tools. Then, the zwitterionic polymer with controlled performance was grafted onto the SBMA through UV-light treatment to improve its antifouling properties. The PVDF-PSBMA_120s modified membrane exhibited a greater flux rate and indicated bovine serum albumin (BSA) rejection performance. PVDF-PSBMA_120s and unmodified PVDF membranes were examined for their antifouling performance using up to three cycles dynamic test using BSA as foulant. The PVDF-modified PSBMA polymer improved the antifouling properties in this experiment. Overall, the resulting membrane demonstrated an enhancement in the hydrophilicity and permeability of the membrane and simultaneously augmented its antifouling properties.

Behaviours of poly(ε-caprolactone)/silver-montmorillonite nanocomposite in membrane ultrafiltration for wastewater treatment

The scope of this work consists in studying the possibility of using the long-lasting antimicrobial poly(ε-caprolactone)/silver-montmorillonite (PCL/Ag-MMT) materials which we have developed in our previous research, as new class of nanocomposite membranes, finding their application in the wastewater treatment. The surface properties of these hybrid membranes were investigated by scanning electron microscopy (SEM) analysis and contact angle measurements. The SEM results showed that the synthesized membranes exhibited homogeneous sponge microstructures. It was found that the gradual inclusion of nanoparticles (2, 3 and 5 wt. %) into PCL matrix induced a remarkable increase of the membrane thickness. Moreover, these hybrid materials exhibited an enhancement of the surface hydrophilicity attributed to the hydrophilic nature of clay incorporated. The water contact angle of the PCL membrane surface noticeably decreased after the Ag-MMT addition: dropping from 82.60° for PCL 0%Ag-MMT to 64.28° for PCL 5%Ag-MMT membrane. The antimicrobial properties of the membranes were confirmed using Staphylococcus aureus (Gram-positive) and Escherichia coli (Gram-negative) as the model bacteria. Quality parameters including total suspended solids (TSS), electric conductivity (EC), nitrates, chlorides, bicarbonates, heavy metals and other trace elements, were determined before and after treatment of real wastewater. A decrease of nitrates by 15.12%, a diminution of sulphates by 45.61% and a removal of 41.38%, 53.57% and61.11% for heavy metals Pb, Zn and Cd respectively indicating clearly that the ultrafiltration process using PCL/AgMMT nanocomposite membranes is an effective way to eliminate the wastewater effluents.

Superhydrophilicity and strong salt-affinity: Zwitterionic polymer grafted surfaces with significant potentials particularly in biological systems

In recent years, zwitterionic polymers have been frequently reported to modify various surfaces to enhance hydrophilicity, antifouling and antibacterial properties, which show significant potentials particularly in biological systems. This review focuses on the fabrication, properties and various applications of zwitterionic polymer grafted surfaces. The "graft-from" and "graft-to" strategies, surface grafting copolymerization and post zwitterionization methods were adopted to graft lots type of the zwitterionic polymers on different inorganic/organic surfaces. The inherent hydrophilicity and salt affinity of the zwitterionic polymers endow the modified surfaces with antifouling, antibacterial and lubricating properties, thus the obtained zwitterionic surfaces show potential applications in biosystems. The zwitterionic polymer grafted membranes or stationary phases can effectively separate plasma, water/oil, ions, biomolecules and polar substrates. The nanomedicines with zwitterionic polymer shells have "stealth" effect in the delivery of encapsulated drugs, siRNA or therapeutic proteins. Moreover, the zwitterionic surfaces can be utilized as wound dressing, self-healing or oil extraction materials. The zwitterionic surfaces are expected as excellent support materials for biosensors, they are facing the severe challenges in the surface protection of marine facilities, and the dense ion pair layers may take unexpected role in shielding the grafted surfaces from strong electromagnetic field.

Preparation of a novel zwitterionic striped surface thin-film composite nanofiltration membrane with excellent salt separation performance and antifouling property

Thin-film composite (TFC) nanofiltration (NF) membranes were fabricated via the co-deposition of taurine, tannic acid (TA), and polyethyleneimine (PEI), followed by subsequent interfacial polymerization with trimesoyl chloride (TMC) on the surface of the polysulfone ultrafiltration substrates. The surface properties, including the roughness, hydrophilicity, surface potential, and NF performances were facilely tuned by varying the taurine content for the prepared TFC membranes. In addition, the as-prepared TFC NF membranes had an excellent antifouling property and flux recovery ratio (FRR) in humic acid (HA), bovine serum albumin (BSA) and sodium alginate (SA) filtration tests. These results also revealed that the taurine content controlled the formation of the striped surface. Thus, this work provided a viable strategy for fabricating TFC NF membranes with high selectivity and outstanding antifouling ability.

Thin-film composite (TFC) nanofiltration (NF) membranes with zwitterionic striped surface were fabricated via the co-deposition and interfacial polymerization.

Electrostatic Adsorption Behavior of Zwitterionic Copolymers on Negatively Charged Surfaces

To investigate the effect of the surface properties and the coating layer properties on surface modification via electrostatic adsorption, the electrostatic adsorption behavior of zwitterionic copolymers on negatively charged surfaces was studied. A series of positively charged zwitterionic copolymers and a series of negatively charged surfaces, including porous substrates and dense films, were fabricated. The electrostatic adsorption behavior of the zwitterionic copolymers on the negatively charged porous substrates was confirmed using the contact angles and fluorescently labeled protein adsorption experiments. The adsorption behavior of the zwitterionic copolymers on the negatively charged dense films was confirmed using quartz crystal microbalance determination and a fluorescently labeled protein adsorption experiment. The results indicated that a lower charge density on the zwitterionic copolymer brings about a higher adsorption mass on the charged surface, whereas an extremely low charge density on the coating layer results in a lower adsorption mass on the charged surface, due to weak interaction. A high density of the film surface charge is beneficial for surface adsorption, whereas an extremely high density of the film surface charge leads to low surface adsorption due to steric hindrance of the negatively charged sites. This work provides an insight into the best strategy for surface modification via electrostatic adsorption.

Toward Antibiofouling PVDF Membranes

Membranes for biologically and biomedically related applications must be bioinert, that is, resist biofouling by proteins, human cells, bacteria, algae, etc. Hydrophobic materials such as polysulfone, polypropylene, or poly(vinylidene fluoride) (PVDF) are often chosen as matrix materials but their hydrophobicity make them prone to biofouling, which in turn limits their application in biological/biomedical fields. Here, we designed PVDF-based membranes by precipitation from the vapor phase and zwitterionized them in situ to reduce their propensity to biofouling. To achieve this goal, we used a copolymer containing phosphorylcholine groups. An in-depth physicochemical characterization revealed not only the controlled presence of the copolymer in the membrane but also that bicontinuous membranes could be formed. Membrane hydrophilicity was greatly improved, resulting in the mitigation of a variety of biofoulants: the attachment of Stenotrophomonas maltophilia, Streptococcus mutans, and platelets was reduced by 99.9, 99.9, and 98.9%, respectively. Besides, despite incubation in a plasma platelet-poor medium, rich in plasma proteins, a flux recovery ratio of 75% could be measured while it was only 40% with a hydrophilic commercial membrane of similar structure and physical properties. Similarly, the zwitterionic membrane severely mitigated biofouling by microalgae during their harvesting. All in all, the material/process combination presented in this work leads to antibiofouling porous membranes with a large span of potential biomedically and biologically related applications.

Antifouling Surfaces Based on Fluorine-Containing Asymmetric Polymer Brushes: Effect of Chain Length of Fluorinated Side Chain

The influence of chain length of a fluorinated side chain of an asymmetric polymer brush with poly(ethylene glycol) (PEG) side chains on the antifouling property was systematically investigated so as to obtain more knowledge for deepening our understanding of the structure-(antifouling)-property relationship of asymmetric polymer brush. A series of asymmetric polymer brushes, consisting of hydrophobic poly(pentafluoropropyl methacrylate) (PPTFMA) side chains with the number of repeat units of pentafluoropropyl methacrylate (PTFMA) ranging from 8 to 42 and hydrophilic PEG side chains, was first synthesized by sequential reversible addition-fragmentation chain transfer (RAFT) polymerization and atom transfer radical polymerization (ATRP). Subsequently, thin films were prepared by spin-casting the solution of these brushes onto indium tin oxide (ITO) and SiO₂ substrates. Water contact angle analysis showed that the hydrophobicity of the film surface increased with the length of PPTFMA side chain. The atomic force microscopy (AFM) measurement demonstrated that these films had a roughness of <3 and <10 nm onto ITO glass and SiO₂ substrates, respectively. The antifouling behaviors of these films in bovine serum albumin (BSA) solution were evaluated by quartz crystal microbalance (QCM), which showed that the asymmetric brush surfaces had considerable antifouling performance with less protein adsorption in comparison with the bare surface. In addition, the films made from polymer brushes with shorter PPTFMA side chains exhibited better antifouling and fouling-release behaviors.