Practical electron tomography guide: Recent progress and future opportunities

Sample thickness affects contrast and measured shape in TEM images and in electron tomograms

We investigated the effect of nanoparticle (NP) image broadening and its contrast change dependence on a support matrix thickness in a transmission electron microscope (TEM). We measured the effect of NP size and atomic number on its image broadening. Based on the experimental TEM images we generated tomograms of NPs on four types of support matrix. The measured shape aspect ratio of the NPs in such tomograms depends on the geometry of the support matrix. For example, the aspect ratio of 6 nm NP placed on a thin film with window-frame support is 1.14, while the aspect ratio of 6 nm NP on a rod-shaped support with 910 nm diameter is 1.67 in a tomogram.

Voxel dose-limited resolution for thick beam-sensitive specimens imaged in a TEM or STEM

The resolution limit imposed by radiation damage is quantified in terms of a voxel dose-limited resolution (DLR), applicable to small features within a thick specimen. An analytical formula for this DLR is derived and applied to bright-field mass-thickness contrast from organic (polymer or biological) specimens of thickness between 400 nm and 20 µm. For a permissible dose of 330 MGy (typical of frozen-hydrated tissue), the TEM or STEM image resolution is determined by radiation damage rather than by lens aberrations or beam-broadening effects, which can be restricted by use of a small angle-limiting aperture. DLR is improved by a up to factor of 2 by increasing the primary-electron energy from 300 keV to 3 MeV, or by up to a factor of 3 by heavy-metal staining. For stained samples, a higher electron fluence allows better resolution but the improvement is modest because the voxel DLR is proportional to the 1/4 power of electron dose. The relevance of voxel and columnar DLR is discussed, for both thick and thin samples.

Transmission electron microscopy of thick polymer and biological specimens

We explore the properties of elastic and inelastic scattering in a thick organic specimen, together with the mechanisms that provide contrast in a transmission electron microscope (TEM) and scanning-transmission electron microscope (STEM). Experimental data recorded from amorphous carbon are used to predict the bright-field image intensity, mass-thickness contrast and dose-limited resolution as a function of thickness, objective-aperture size, and primary-electron energy E₀. Combining this information with estimates of chromatic aberration, objective-aperture diffraction and beam broadening in the specimen, we calculate the achievable TEM and STEM resolution to be around 4 nm at E₀ = 300 keV (or below 3 nm at MeV energies) for a 10 µm-diameter objective aperture and 1 - 2 µm thickness of hydrated biological tissue. The 3 MeV resolution for a 10-μm tissue sample is probably closer to 10 nm. We also comment on the error involved in quadrature addition of resolution factors, when one or more of the point-spread functions are non-Gaussian.

Origin of spurious intensity in vacuum near sample edge in bright field TEM images

Bright-field transmission electron microscope (BFTEM) images exhibit spurious image intensity in the vacuum near the sample edge. The spurious intensity gradually decreases with increasing distance from the sample edge. By taking into account angular and energy loss distribution of the scattered electrons and lens aberrations, the origin of the spurious intensity of BFTEM images can be explained. The spurious intensity extent and magnitude can be significantly reduced by using either electron energy filtering or a small collection semiangle.

Higher-order structure of barley chromosomes observed by electron tomography

The higher order structure of the metaphase chromosome has been an enigma for over a century and several different models have been presented based on results obtained by a variety of techniques. Some disagreements in the results between methods have possibly arisen from artifacts caused during sample preparation such as staining and dehydration. Therefore, we treated barley chromosomes with ionic liquid to minimize the effects of dehydration. We also observed chromosomes on a film with holes to keep pristine chromosome structure from being flattened as seen when placed on a continuous support film. A chromosome placed over a hole in a thin carbon film was mounted on a tomography holder, and its structure was observed in three dimensions (3D) using electron tomography. We found that there are periodic structures with 300-400 nm pitch along the axis in barley chromosomes. The pitch sizes are larger than those observed in human chromosomes.

High-Energy Electron Scattering in Thick Samples Evaluated by Bright-Field Transmission Electron Microscopy, Energy-Filtering Transmission Electron Microscopy, and Electron Tomography

Energy-filtering transmission electron microscopy (TEM) and bright-field TEM can be used to extract local sample thickness $t$ and to generate two-dimensional sample thickness maps. Electron tomography can be used to accurately verify the local $t$. The relations of log-ratio of zero-loss filtered energy-filtering TEM beam intensity ($I_{{\rm ZLP}}$) and unfiltered beam intensity ($I_{\rm u}$) versus sample thickness $t$ were measured for five values of collection angle in a microscope equipped with an energy filter. Furthermore, log-ratio of the incident (primary) beam intensity ($I_{\rm p}$) and the transmitted beam $I_{{\rm tr}}$ versus $t$ in bright-field TEM was measured utilizing a camera before the energy filter. The measurements were performed on a multilayer sample containing eight materials and thickness $t$ up to 800 nm. Local thickness $t$ was verified by electron tomography. The following results are reported:• The maximum thickness $t_{{\rm max}}$ yielding a linear relation of log-ratio, $\ln ( {I_{\rm u}}/{I_{{\rm ZLP}}})$ and $\ln ( {I_{\rm p}}/{I_{{\rm tr}}} )$, versus $t$.• Inelastic mean free path ($\lambda _{{\rm in}}$) for five values of collection angle.• Total mean free path ($\lambda _{{\rm total}}$) of electrons excluded by an angle-limiting aperture.• $\lambda _{{\rm in}}$ and $\lambda _{{\rm total}}$ are evaluated for the eight materials with atomic number from $\approx$10 to 79.The results can be utilized as a guide for upper limit of $t$ evaluation in energy-filtering TEM and bright-field TEM and for optimizing electron tomography experiments.

Chromosome inner structure investigation by electron tomography and electron diffraction in a transmission electron microscope

Our understanding of the inner structure of metaphase chromosomes remains inconclusive despite intensive studies using multiple imaging techniques. Transmission electron microscopy has been extensively used to visualize chromosome ultrastructure. This review summarizes recent results obtained using two transmission electron microscopy-based techniques: electron tomography and electron diffraction. Electron tomography allows advanced three-dimensional imaging of chromosomes, while electron diffraction detects the presence of periodic structures within chromosomes. The combination of these two techniques provides results contributing to the understanding of local structural organization of chromatin fibers within chromosomes.

Nano- and Microspheres Containing Inorganic and Biological Nanoparticles: Self-Assembly and Electron Tomographic Analysis

Organofullerene amphiphiles show diverse behaviors in water, forming vesicles, micelles, Langmuir-Blodgett films, and anisotropic nanostructures. We found that gradual in situ protonation of an organic solution of (4-heptylphenyl)₅C₆₀^-K⁺ by water or buffer generates the corresponding protonated molecule, (4-heptylphenyl)₅C₆₀H, which self-assembles to form nano- and microspheres of organofullerene (fullerspheres) with uniform diameters ranging from 30 nm to 2.5 μm that are controlled by the preparation or pH of the buffer. By using an aqueous solution of an organic dye, inorganic nanoparticle, protein, and virus, we encapsulated these entities in the fullersphere. This approach via self-assembly is distinct from other preparations of organic core-shell particles that generally require polymerization for the construction of a robust shell. The sphere is entirely amorphous, thermally stable up to 300 °C under vacuum, and resistant to electron irradiation, and we found the unconventional utility of the sphere for electron tomographic imaging of nanoparticles and biomaterials.

Higher-Order Structure of Human Chromosomes Observed by Electron Diffraction and Electron Tomography

It is well known that two DNA molecules are wrapped around histone octamers and folded together to form a single chromosome. However, the nucleosome fiber folding within a chromosome remains an enigma, and the higher-order structure of chromosomes also is not understood. In this study, we employed electron diffraction which provides a noninvasive analysis to characterize the internal structure of chromosomes. The results revealed the presence of structures with 100–200 nm periodic features directionally perpendicular to the chromosome axis in unlabeled isolated human chromosomes. We also visualized the 100–200 nm periodic features perpendicular to the chromosome axis in an isolated chromosome whose DNA molecules were specifically labeled with OsO4 using electron tomography in 300 keV and 1 MeV transmission electron microscopes.

Nanoparticle size and 3D shape measurement by electron tomography: An Inter-Laboratory Comparison

Electron tomography (ET) has been used for quantitative measurement of shape and size of objects in three dimensions (3D) for many years. However, systematic investigation of repeatability and reproducibility of ET has not been evaluated in detail. To assess the reproducibility and repeatability of a protocol for measuring size and three-dimensional (3D) shape parameters for nanoparticles (NPs) by ET, an inter-laboratory comparison (ILC) has been performed. The ILC included six laboratories and six instruments models from three instrument manufacturers following a standard measurement protocol. A technical specification describing the normative steps of the protocol is published by the International Standards Organization (ISO). Gold NPs with 30 nm nominal diameter contained within a rod-shaped carbon support were measured. The use of a rod-shaped sample support eliminated the missing wedge effect in the experimental tilt series of projected images for improved quantification. A total of 443 NPs were initially measured by NRC-NANO and then 115 out of the 443 NPs were measured by five other labs to compare measurands such as the Volume (V), maximum Feret diameter (F_max), minimum Feret diameter (F_min), volume-equivalent diameter (D_eq) and aspect ratio (F_rat) of the NPs. The results of the five labs were compared with the results obtained at NRC-NANO. The maximum disagreement in measurements of F_min and F_max obtained by the participating labs did not exceed 7 %. The measured D_eq was between 27.5 nm and 30.3 nm in agreement with the NP manufacturer's specification (28 nm-32 nm). In addition to the above, the influence of the missing wedge effect and beam-induced NP movement was quantified based on the differences of the results between labs.

Application of ultra-high voltage electron microscope tomography to 3D imaging of microtubules in neurites of cultured PC12 cells

Electron tomography methods using the conventional transmission electron microscope have been widely used to investigate the three-dimensional distribution patterns of various cellular structures including microtubules in neurites. Because the penetrating power of electrons depends on the section thickness and accelerating voltage, conventional TEM, having acceleration voltages up to 200 kV, is limited to sample thicknesses of 0.2 µm or less. In this paper, we show that the ultra-high voltage electron microscope (UHVEM), employing acceleration voltages of higher than 1000 kV (1 MV), allowed distinct reconstruction of the three-dimensional array of microtubules in a 0.7-µm-thick neurite section. The detailed structure of microtubules was more clearly reconstructed from a 0.7-µm-thick section at an accelerating voltage of 1 MV compared with a 1.0 µm section at 2 MV. Furthermore, the entire distribution of each microtubule in a neurite could be reconstructed from serial-section UHVEM tomography. Application of optimised UHVEM tomography will provide new insights, bridging the gap between the structure and function of widely-distributed cellular organelles such as microtubules for neurite outgrowth. LAY DESCRIPTION: An optimal 3D visualisation of microtubule cytoskeleton using ultra-high voltage electron microscopy tomography The ultra-high voltage electron microscope (UHVEM) is able to visualise a micrometre-thick specimen at nanoscale spatial resolution because of the high-energy electron beam penetrating such a specimen. In this study, we determined the optimal conditions necessary for microtubule cytoskeleton imaging within 0.7-µm-thick section using a combination with UHVEM and electron tomography method. Our approach provides excellent 3D information about the complex arrangement of the individual microtubule filaments that make up the microtubule network.

3D observation of chromosome scaffold structure using a 360° electron tomography sample holder

The chromosome scaffold is considered to be a key structure of the mitotic chromosome. It plays a vital role in chromosome condensation, shaping the X-shaped structure of the mitotic chromosome, and also provides flexibility for chromosome movement during cell division. However, it remains to be elucidated how the chromosome scaffold organizes the mitotic chromosome and how it supports shaping the structure of the chromosome during metaphase. Here we present a new technique that enables the observation of the chromosome scaffold structure in metaphase chromosomes from any direction, by transferring an isolated chromosome to a 360° rotational holder for electron tomography (ET). The chromosome was stained with immunogold-labeled condensin complex, one of the major chromosome scaffold proteins and then observed in three dimensions using ET. Using the locations of gold nanoparticles to visualize the underlying structure, the tomograms we obtained reveal the patterns of chromosome scaffold organization, which appears to consist of a helical structure that serves to organize chromatin loops into the metaphase chromosome.

Parameters affecting the accuracy of nanoparticle shape and size measurement in 3D

While electron tomography can be used to visualize objects at nanoscale, it is difficult to perform reproducible quantitative measurements. Here we measure the shape and size of nanoparticles (NPs) in three dimensions (3D) using electron tomography. We evaluated the accuracy of maximum Feret diameter (Feret_max), minimum Feret diameter (Feret_mini) and volume of NPs measurements from reconstructed 3D images which were obtained from data acquired with varied electron dose. We perform both simulations and experiment to clarify what factors effect on the accuracy of the NP shape measurement. Based on the results, suitable reconstruction methods and threshold for binarization were evaluated. We also report comparison results obtained on exactly the same samples in two different laboratories.

Evaluation of electron tomography reconstruction methods for interface roughness measurement

We evaluate the suitability of simultaneous iterative reconstruction technique (SIRT), filtered back projection, and simultaneous algebraic reconstruction technique methods for buried interface roughness measurements. We also investigate the effect of total electron dose distributed over the entire tilt series on measured roughness values. We investigate the applicability of the dose fractionation theorem by evaluating the effect of an increasing number of images, i.e., decreasing tilt increment size at fixed total electron irradiation dose on the quantitative measurement of buried interface roughness. The results indicate that SIRT is the most suitable method for reconstruction and a 3° to 5° angle is optimal for the roughness measurement.

Structural variability and complexity of the giant Pithovirus sibericum particle revealed by high-voltage electron cryo-tomography and energy-filtered electron cryo-microscopy

The Pithoviridae giant virus family exhibits the largest viral particle known so far, a prolate spheroid up to 2.5 μm in length and 0.9 μm in diameter. These particles show significant variations in size. Little is known about the structure of the intact virion due to technical limitations with conventional electron cryo-microscopy (cryo-EM) when imaging thick specimens. Here we present the intact structure of the giant Pithovirus sibericum particle at near native conditions using high-voltage electron cryo-tomography (cryo-ET) and energy-filtered cryo-EM. We detected a previously undescribed low-density outer layer covering the tegument and a periodical structuring of the fibres in the striated apical cork. Energy-filtered Zernike phase-contrast cryo-EM images show distinct substructures inside the particles, implicating an internal compartmentalisation. The density of the interior volume of Pithovirus particles is three quarters lower than that of the Mimivirus. However, it is remarkably high given that the 600 kbp Pithovirus genome is only half the size of the Mimivirus genome and is packaged in a volume up to 100 times larger. These observations suggest that the interior is densely packed with macromolecules in addition to the genomic nucleic acid.

Automatic system for electron tomography data collection in the ultra-high voltage electron microscope

In this study, we report an automatic system for collection of tilt series for electron tomography based on the ultra-HVEM in Osaka University. By remotely controlling the microscope and reading the observation image, the system can track the field of view and do focus in each tilt angle. The automatic tracking is carried out with an image matching technique based on normalized correlation coefficient. Auto focus is realized by the optimization of image sharpness. A toolkit that can expand the field of view with technique of image stitching is also developed. The system can automatically collect the tilt series with much smaller time consumption.

AuTom: A novel automatic platform for electron tomography reconstruction

We have developed a software package towards automatic electron tomography (ET): Automatic Tomography (AuTom). The presented package has the following characteristics: accurate alignment modules for marker-free datasets containing substantial biological structures; fully automatic alignment modules for datasets with fiducial markers; wide coverage of reconstruction methods including a new iterative method based on the compressed-sensing theory that suppresses the "missing wedge" effect; and multi-platform acceleration solutions that support faster iterative algebraic reconstruction. AuTom aims to achieve fully automatic alignment and reconstruction for electron tomography and has already been successful for a variety of datasets. AuTom also offers user-friendly interface and auxiliary designs for file management and workflow management, in which fiducial marker-based datasets and marker-free datasets are addressed with totally different subprocesses. With all of these features, AuTom can serve as a convenient and effective tool for processing in electron tomography.

Interconnectivity imaged in three dimensions: Nano-particulate silica-hydrogel structure revealed using electron tomography

We have used Electron Tomography (ET) to reveal the detailed three-dimensional structure of particulate hydrogels, a material category common in e.g. controlled release, food science, battery and biomedical applications. A full understanding of the transport properties of these gels requires knowledge about the pore structure and in particular the interconnectivity in three dimensions, since the transport takes the path of lowest resistance. The image series for ET were recorded using High-Angle Annular Dark Field Scanning Transmission Electron Microscopy (HAADF-STEM). We have studied three different particulate silica hydrogels based on primary particles with sizes ranging from 3.6nm to 22nm and with pore-size averages from 18nm to 310nm. Here, we highlight the nanostructure of the particle network and the interpenetrating pore network in two and three dimensions. The interconnectivity and distribution of width of the porous channels were obtained from the three-dimensional tomography studies while they cannot unambiguously be obtained from the two-dimensional data. Using ET, we compared the interconnectivity and accessible pore volume fraction as a function of pore size, based on direct images on the nanoscale of three different hydrogels. From this comparison, it was clear that the finest of the gels differentiated from the other two. Despite the almost identical flow properties of the two finer gels, they showed large differences concerning the accessible pore volume fraction for probes corresponding to their (two-dimensional) mean pore size. Using 2D pore size data, the finest gel provided an accessible pore volume fraction of over 90%, but for the other two gels the equivalent was only 10-20%. However, all the gels provided an accessible pore volume fraction of 30-40% when taking the third dimension into account.