Classification of Vulvar Squamous Cell Carcinoma and Precursor Lesions by p16 and p53 Immunohistochemistry: Considerations, Caveats, and an Algorithmic Approach

Simultaneous p53 and p16 Immunostaining for Molecular Subclassification of Head and Neck Squamous Cell Carcinomas

PURPOSE

Our aim was to assess the ability of simultaneous immunohistochemical staining (IHC) for p16 and p53 to accurately subclassify head and neck squamous cell carcinomas (HNSCC) as HPV-associated (HPV-A) versus HPV-independent (HPV-I) and compare p53 IHC staining patterns to TP53 mutation status, p16 IHC positivity and HPV status.

METHODS

We stained 31 HNSCCs for p53 and p16, and performed next-generation sequencing (FoundationOne©CDx) on all cases and HPV in-situ hybridization (ISH) when sufficient tissue was available (n = 23). p53 IHC staining patterns were assessed as wildtype (wt) or abnormal (abn) patterns i.e. overexpression, null or cytoplasmic staining.

RESULTS

In a majority of cases (28/31) interpretation of p16 and p53 IHC was straightforward; 10 were considered HPV-A (p16+/p53wt) and 18 cases were HPV-I (p16-/p53abn). In the remaining three tumours the unusual immunophenotype was resolved by molecular testing, specifically (i) subclonal p16 staining and wild type p53 staining in a tumour positive for HPV and with no TP53 mutation (HPV-A), (ii) negative p16 and wild type p53 staining with a TP53 mutation and negative for HPV (HPV-I), and (iii) equivocally increased p16 staining with mutant pattern p53 expression, negative HPV ISH and with a TP53 mutation (HPV-I).

CONCLUSION

Performing p16 and p53 IHC staining simultaneously allows classification of most HNSCC as HPV-A (p16 +, p53 wild type (especially basal sparing or null-like HPV associated staining patterns, which were completely specific for HPV-A SCC) or HPV-I (p16 -, p53 mutant pattern expression), with the potential for limiting additional molecular HPV or mutational testing to selected cases only.

Proliferating inverted follicular keratosis of genital skin: Case series of a challenging variant

BACKGROUND

Inverted follicular keratosis (IFK) is a benign cutaneous epithelial tumor typically presenting as a small papule on the head and neck. We have encountered deep endophytic tumors on genital skin with some characteristics of IFK but also atypical features, raising concern for squamous cell carcinoma (SCC).

METHODS

Four such tumors were identified in our database. Histopathologic analysis and ancillary studies were performed.

RESULTS

All patients were young women who presented with a solitary 0.5-1.0 cm lesion on the vulva, perineum, or inner buttock. Each showed a squamous proliferation arising from the epidermis, with endophytic growth that was deep and bulbous but not infiltrative. The tumor lobules contained eosinophilic keratinocytes, forming numerous squamous eddies. Small irregular spaces and dyskeratotic cells were frequently found. Nuclear pleomorphism was minimal to absent. All demonstrated wild-type p53 expression and lack of p16 block positivity. In situ hybridizations for human papillomavirus were negative. None of the three cases with follow-up data showed evidence of recurrence.

CONCLUSIONS

The absence of infiltrative growth or significant pleomorphism, the presence of numerous squamous eddies, the reassuring immunoprofile, and the lack of evidence of recurrence support a variant of IFK and speak against SCC. We propose the term "proliferating IFK" to highlight the florid squamous proliferation. Recognition of this unusual variant would avoid overdiagnosis of SCC.

High concordance of molecular subtyping between pre-surgical biopsy and surgical resection specimen (matched-pair analysis) in patients with vulvar squamous cell carcinoma using p16- and p53-immunostaining

OBJECTIVE

Vulvar squamous cell carcinoma (VSCC) can be stratified into three molecular subtypes based on the immunoexpression of p16 and p53: HPV-independent p53-abnormal (p53abn) (most common, biologically aggressive), HPV-associated, with p16-overexpression (second most common, prognostically more favourable) and more recently recognised HPV-independent p53-wildtype (p53wt) (rarest subtype, prognostically intermediate). Our aim was to determine whether molecular subtypes can be reliably identified in pre-operative biopsies and whether these correspond to the subsequent vulvectomy specimen.

METHODS

Matched-paired pre-surgical biopsies and subsequent resection specimen of 57 patients with VSCC were analysed for the immunohistochemical expression of p16 and p53 by performing a three-tiered molecular subtyping to test the accuracy rate.

RESULTS

Most cases 36/57 (63.2%) belonged to the HPV-independent (p53-abn) molecular subtype, followed by HPV-associated 17/57 (29.8%) and HPV-independent (p53wt) 4/57 (7.0%). The overall accuracy rate on biopsy was 91.2% (52/57): 97.3% for p53-abnormal, 94.1% for p16-overexpression and 50% for p16-neg/p53-wt VSCC. Incorrect interpretation of immunohistochemical p53 staining pattern was the reason for discordant results in molecular subtyping in all five cases. In one case there was an underestimation of p53 pattern (wildtype instead of abnormal/aberrant) and in one case an overestimation of the p53 staining pattern (abnormal/aberrant instead of wildtype). In 3/5 there was a "double positive" staining result (p16 overexpression and abnormal/aberrant p53 staining pattern). In that cases additional molecular workup is required for correct molecular subtyping, resulting in an overall need for molecular examination of 3/57 (3.5%).

CONCLUSIONS

Compared to the final resections specimen, the three-tiered molecular classification of VSCC can be determined on pre-surgical biopsies with a high accuracy rate. This enables more precise surgical planning, prediction of the response to (chemo) radiation, selection of targeted therapies and planning of the optimal follow-up strategy for patients in the age of personalised medicine.

Predictive and prognostic biomarkers in female genital tract tumours: an update highlighting their clinical relevance and practical issues

The evaluation of biomarkers by molecular techniques and immunohistochemistry has become increasingly relevant to the treatment of female genital tract tumours as a consequence of the greater availability of therapeutic options and updated disease classifications. For ovarian cancer, mutation testing for BRCA1/2 is the standard predictive biomarker for poly(ADP-ribose) polymerase inhibitor therapy, while homologous recombination deficiency testing may allow the identification of eligible patients among cases without demonstrable BRCA1/2 mutations. Clinical recommendations are available which specify how these predictive biomarkers should be applied. Mismatch repair (MMR) protein and folate receptor alpha immunohistochemistry may also be used to guide treatment in ovarian cancer. In endometrial cancer, MMR immunohistochemistry is the preferred test for predicting benefit from immune checkpoint inhibitor (ICI) therapy, but molecular testing for microsatellite instability may have a supplementary role. HER2 testing by immunohistochemistry and in situ hybridisation is applicable to endometrial serous carcinomas to assess trastuzumab eligibility. Immunohistochemistry for oestrogen receptor and progesterone receptor expression may be used for prognostication in endometrial cancer, but its predictive value for hormonal therapy is not yet proven. POLE mutation testing and p53 immunohistochemistry (as a surrogate for TP53 mutation status) serve as prognostic markers for favourable and adverse outcomes, respectively, in endometrial cancer, especially when combined with MMR testing for molecular subtype designation. For cervical cancer, programmed death ligand 1 immunohistochemistry may be used to predict benefit from ICI therapy although its predictive value is under debate. In vulvar cancer, p16 and p53 immunohistochemistry has established prognostic value, stratifying patients into three groups based on the human papillomavirus and TP53 mutation status of the tumour. Awareness of the variety and pitfalls of expression patterns for p16 and p53 in vulvar carcinomas is crucial for accurate designation. It is hoped that collaborative efforts in standardising and optimising biomarker testing for gynaecological tumours will contribute to evidence-based therapeutic decisions.

High-grade vulvar intraepithelial neoplasia: comprehensive characterization and long-term vulvar carcinoma risk

AIMS

Adequate diagnosis of human papillomavirus (HPV)-associated high-grade squamous intraepithelial lesion (HSIL) and HPV-independent vulvar intraepithelial neoplasia (VIN) is essential but can be challenging. We comprehensively characterized a large population-based series of vulvar lesions, originally reported as high-grade VIN, and assessed the cancer risk.

METHODS AND RESULTS

Baseline high-grade VIN of 751 patients were categorized by histopathological reassessment, integrating the results of immunohistochemistry (p16INK4a , p53, Ki-67) and HPV DNA testing. Integrated analyses resulted in 88.4% HPV-associated lesions (77.0% HSIL, 10.9% low-grade SIL [LSIL], and 0.4% vulvar squamous cell carcinoma [VSCC]), 10.9% HPV-independent lesions (6.1% HPV-independent VIN, 4.7% nondysplastic lesions, and 0.1% VSCC) and 1.1% inconclusive lesions. HSIL demonstrated p16INK4a block-positivity in 99.0%, increased Ki-67 in ≥2/3rd of the epithelium in 93.6%, and HPV positivity in 99.6%. In HSIL, a p53 wildtype mid-epithelial staining pattern was common (51.6%) while this was not observed in HPV-independent lesions. HPV-independent VIN harboured mutant p53 patterns in 65.2% and showed a wide morphological spectrum, ranging from differentiated to nondifferentiated ('HPV-associated-like', in 41.3%). Kaplan-Meier analyses showed a 10-year cancer risk of 8.0% in HPV-associated HSIL, 67.4% in HPV-independent VIN/p53mutant, and 27.8% in HPV-independent VIN/p53wildtype. Strikingly, the 10-year cancer risk was 73.3% in HPV-independent VIN with nondifferentiated ('HPV-associated-like') morphology.

CONCLUSION

Immunohistochemistry by p16INK4a and p53 is highly recommended for optimal categorization into HPV-associated and HPV-independent VIN, which is of utmost importance given the different cancer risk. The high cancer risk of HPV-independent VIN underscores the need for surgical treatment and close follow-up, especially in case of a p53 mutant pattern and/or nondifferentiated morphology.

Utilization of p53 and p16 Immunohistochemistry in the Classification of Human Papillomavirus-Associated, p53 Wild-Type, and p53 Abnormal Oral Epithelial Dysplasia

p53 immunohistochemistry (IHC) has recently been shown to be a clinically useful marker for predicting risk of progression to invasive squamous cell carcinoma in oral epithelial dysplasia (OED). The literature supports the use of p53 IHC as a marker to identify TP53 mutation in in situ and invasive vulvar lesions and as a surrogate marker for high-risk human papillomavirus (HPV) infection, but there is little documentation for similar use in OED. The purpose of this study was to determine whether p53 IHC is a reliable surrogate marker for detecting both TP53 mutation and high-risk HPV infection in OED. We studied 57 cases of OED (11 mild, 18 moderate, and 28 severe), and all were stained for p16 and p53 IHC. High-risk HPV RNA in situ hybridization (ISH) was performed in selected cases (all p16-positive cases and all OED showing abundant apoptotic cells and karyorrhectic cells; N = 27). Targeted next-generation sequencing (NGS) was performed in 33 p16-negative cases and all high-risk HPV RNA ISH-negative cases (N = 36). We identified 21 cases with p53 basal sparing patterns (mid-epithelial and markedly reduced [null-like]), 14 cases with p53 wild-type patterns (scattered basal and patchy basal/parabasal), and 22 cases with p53 abnormal patterns (18 overexpression, 3 null, and 1 novel cytoplasmic pattern). Among cases with p53 basal sparing patterns, 20 were positive for p16 (20/21, 95%), and all were positive for high-risk HPV RNA ISH (21/21, 100%). The 36 sequenced cases had IHC patterns concordant with TP53 mutation status in 92% (33/36) of lesions. This study demonstrates that p53 IHC expression patterns are sensitive and specific for detection of both high-risk HPV infection and TP53 mutation. Coupled with selective p16 IHC testing, this IHC panel can accurately subclassify OED into HPV-associated, p53 wild-type (conventional), and p53 abnormal OED.

Incidence and Clinicopathologic Characteristics of Human Papillomavirus-independent Invasive Squamous Cell Carcinomas of the Cervix: A Morphologic, Immunohistochemical, and Human Papilloma-Virologic Study of 670 Cases

We aimed to determine the frequency of human papillomavirus-independent (HPVI) cervical squamous cell carcinoma (SCC) and to describe clinicopathologic characteristics. Among 670 patients with surgically treated SCCs in an established multi-institutional cohort, 447 had available tissue. Tissue microarrays were constructed and studied by in situ hybridization (ISH) for high-risk and low-risk human papillomavirus (HPV) mRNA and immunohistochemistry for p16 and p53. Tumors were HPVI if negative by HPV ISH and they failed to show diffuse p16 positivity by immunohistochemistry, and human papillomavirus-associated (HPVA) if positive by HPV ISH. Ten HPVI SCCs and 435 HPVA SCCs were identified; 2 cases were equivocal and excluded from analysis. The overall rate of HPVI SCC was low (2%) but was higher among older patients (7% in patients above 60 y of age and 17% in patients above 70 y of age). Compared with HPVA, patients with HPVI SCC were significantly older (median age, 72 vs. 49, P <0.001) and diagnosed at a higher stage (40% vs. 18% with stage III/IV disease, P =0.055). p53 expression was varied; 2 cases (20%) had null expression and 8 (80%) had wild-type expression. HPVI SCCs were heterogenous, with keratinizing, nonkeratinizing, and warty morphologies observed. Several cases had a precursor lesion reminiscent of differentiated vulvar intraepithelial neoplasia, with prominent basal atypia and hypereosinophilia or a basaloid-like morphology. Two patients (20%) had distant recurrences within 12 months, and 3 (30%) died of disease during follow-up. HPVI SCCs are rare tumors that are more common among older patients with higher stage disease and have important clinical and histologic differences from HPVA SCCs.