Structural investigation of liquid acetic acid by neutron scattering, DFT calculations and molecular dynamics simulations. Complementarity to x-ray scattering results

Theoretical study on formation mechanism of acetic acid associating configurations and their distributions under saturated conditions

CONTEXT

The vapor-liquid equilibrium (VLE) properties of acetic acid systems generally behave strong non-ideality due to the associating interaction among acetic acid molecules. Theoretical study of the associating mechanism will provide guidance for the VLE property prediction, which is crucial for the designing on the separation process of the acetic acid systems. In this work, the association conformers and their distribution on acetic acid molecules in saturated gas and liquid phase were firstly studied. The proportions of the acetic acid monomer and multimers were obtained, which will contribute to the foundation for the vapor-liquid equilibrium simulations. The association mechanism on acetic acid molecules was then investigated by comparing among the structures and non-bonded interaction energies of different dimers. The structure of the cyclic dimer containing two OC-HO hydrogen bonds, may be found probably when acetic acid molecules approached. Electronic properties of different acetic acid dimers showed that the electrons around carbonyl oxygen atoms were deflected by the attraction of hydrogen atoms in the other molecule, which polarized the acetic acid molecules when the hydrogen bonds between acetic acid molecules were formed, providing theoretical basis for the polarized acetic acid molecular model.

METHODS

In this work, the molecular dynamics (MD) simulations and DFT calculations were conducted through the software GROMACS and Gaussian 09, respectively. For the MD simulations, the OPLS-AA force field was used as the atomic force field, with the cubic simulation cells constructed by Packmol program. For the DFT calculations, the M06-2X functional was employed for the optimization of the associating structures with the 6-311G** basis sets. Hydrogen bonding energies of dimers were corrected for the basis set superposition error (BSSE) and the deformation energies of monomers. Furthermore, the energy decomposition analysis was conducted at DFT/M06-2X/def-tzp level by the ADF software, and the wave function analysis was conducted by the Multiwfn software including the atom in molecule (AIM) topology analysis, the electronic potential analysis, and the electron density difference analysis.

Dimerization of Acetic Acid in the Gas Phase-NMR Experiments and Quantum-Chemical Calculations

Due to the nature of the carboxylic group, acetic acid can serve as both a donor and acceptor of a hydrogen bond. Gaseous acetic acid is known to form cyclic dimers with two strong hydrogen bonds. However, trimeric and various oligomeric structures have also been hypothesized to exist in both the gas and liquid phases of acetic acid. In this work, a combination of gas-phase NMR experiments and advanced computational approaches were employed in order to validate the basic dimerization model of gaseous acetic acid. The gas-phase experiments performed in a glass tube revealed interactions of acetic acid with the glass surface. On the other hand, variable-temperature and variable-pressure NMR parameters obtained for acetic acid in a polymer insert provided thermodynamic parameters that were in excellent agreement with the MP2 (the second order Møller–Plesset perturbation theory) and CCSD(T) (coupled cluster with single, double and perturbative triple excitation) calculations based on the basic dimerization model. A slight disparity between the theoretical dimerization model and the experimental data was revealed only at low temperatures. This observation might indicate the presence of other, entropically disfavored, supramolecular structures at low temperatures.

Molecular aggregation in liquid acetic acid: insight from molecular dynamics/quantum mechanics modelling of structural and NMR properties

The 1H NMR signal of the acidic proton in acetic acid molecules shows a marked upfield shift in the neat liquid as compared to that in low-concentration acetic acid solution in inert solvents where acetic acid cyclic dimers predominate. The underlying reasons for this phenomenon are analyzed in this work by considering classical molecular dynamics simulations and combined quantum mechanics/molecular mechanics calculations of the 1H NMR chemical shift of the acidic proton in the neat liquid and in the cyclic dimer of acetic acid in cyclohexane solution. Recorded trajectories were quantitatively analyzed in terms of different types of molecular aggregates formed in the neat liquid by using a geometrical definition of the hydrogen bond. Both the geometrical analysis and the computational NMR results indicate that the cyclic dimer cannot be the dominating aggregation pattern for acetic acid molecules in the neat liquid. The applied computational approach reproduces the lowering of the 1H NMR chemical shift of the acidic proton in acetic acid when going from cyclohexane solution to the neat liquid very well. The presence of acetic acid aggregates with hydrogen bonding between hydroxyl moieties and of monomeric acetic acid molecules in the neat liquid is found to lead to the observed lowering of the chemical shift, with lesser contribution from the formation of open acetic acid aggregates.