Flanking nucleotide specificity for DNA mismatch repair-deficient frameshifts within activin receptor 2 (ACVR2)

Tetranucleotide Microsatellite Mutational Behavior Assessed in Real Time: Implications for Future Microsatellite Panels

BACKGROUND & AIMS

Fifty percent of colorectal cancers show elevated microsatellite alterations at selected tetranucleotide repeats (EMAST) and are associated with inflammation, metastasis, and poor patient outcome. EMAST results from interleukin 6-induced nuclear-to-cytosolic displacement of the DNA mismatch repair protein Mutated S Homolog 3, allowing frameshifts of dinucleotide and tetranucleotide but not mononucleotide microsatellites. Unlike mononucleotide frameshifts that universally shorten in length, we previously observed expansion and contraction frameshifts at tetranucleotide sequences. Here, we developed cell models to assess tetranucleotide frameshifts in real time.

METHODS

We constructed plasmids containing native (AAAG)18 and altered-length ([AAAG]15 and [AAAG]12) human D9S242 locus that placed enhanced green fluorescent protein +1 bp/-1 bp out-of-frame for protein translation and stably transfected into DNA mismatch repair-deficient cells for clonal selection. We used flow cytometry to detect enhanced green fluorescent protein-positive cells to measure mutational behavior.

RESULTS

Frameshift mutation rates were 31.6 to 71.1 × 10-4 mutations/cell/generation and correlated with microsatellite length (r2 = 0.986, P = .0375). Longer repeats showed modestly higher deletion over insertion rates, with both equivalent for shorter repeats. Accumulation of more deletion frameshifts contributed to a distinct mutational bias for each length (overall: 77.8% deletions vs 22.2% insertions), likely owing to continual deletional mutation of insertions. Approximately 78.9% of observed frameshifts were 1 AAAG repeat, 16.1% were 2 repeats, and 5.1% were 3 or more repeats, consistent with a slipped strand mispairing mutation model.

CONCLUSIONS

Tetranucleotide frameshifts show a deletion bias and undergo more than 1 deletion event via intermediates, with insertions converted into deletions. Tetranucleotide markers added to traditional microsatellite instability panels will be able to determine both EMAST and classic microsatellite instability, but needs to be assessed by multiple markers to account for mutational behavior and intermediates.

A new method for discovering EMAST sequences in animal models of cancer

Elevated Microsatellite Alterations at Selected Tetranucleotide repeats (EMAST) occur in up to 60% of colorectal cancers and may associate with aggressive and advanced disease in patients. Although EMAST occurs in many cancer types, current understanding is limited due to the lack of an animal model. Reported here is the design and implementation of an algorithm for detecting EMAST repeats in mice. This algorithm incorporates properties of known human EMAST sequences to identify repeat sequences in animal genomes and was able to identify EMAST-like sequences in the mouse. Seven of the identified repeats were analyzed further in a colon cancer mouse model and six of the seven displayed EMAST instability characteristic of that seen in human colorectal cancers. In conclusion, the algorithm developed successfully identified EMAST repeats in an animal genome and, for the first time, EMAST has been shown to occur in a mouse model of colon cancer.

Microsatellite Instability Pathway and EMAST in Colorectal Cancer

Microsatellite instability (MSI) refers to the biochemical detection of frameshifted microsatellite sequences from genomic DNA. Genesis of MSI is due to defective DNA mismatch repair (MMR) that fails to correct post DNA replicative slippage mistakes at microsatellites. Most of the estimated 100,000 genomic microsatellites are non-coding; however, ~150-300 microsatellites are coding such that, when frameshifted during the pathogenesis of an MSI tumor, can generate immunogenic neopeptide antigens that limit the growth of tumor and prolong patient survival. In addition to the immune reaction and longer survival, patients with MSI colorectal cancers tend to have poorly differentiated tumors with mucinous features that are located in the right colon. Patients with MSI tumors are more resistant to 5-fluorouracil-based adjuvant chemotherapy but may be responsive to PD-1 immune checkpoint blockade. Specific defects of MMR function not only drive MSI but also elevate microsatellite alterations at selected tetranucleotide repeats that may further modify patient outcome.

Production of truncated MBD4 protein by frameshift mutation in DNA mismatch repair-deficient cells enhances 5-fluorouracil sensitivity that is independent of hMLH1 status

Methyl-CpG binding domain protein 4 (MBD4) is a DNA glycosylase that can remove 5-fluorodeoxyuracil from DNA as well as repair T:G or U:G mismatches. MBD4 is a target for frameshift mutation with DNA mismatch repair (MMR) deficiency, creating a truncated MBD4 protein (TruMBD4) that lacks its glycosylase domain. Here we show that TruMBD4 plays an important role for enhancing 5-fluorouracil (5FU) sensitivity in MMR-deficient colorectal cancer cells. We found biochemically that TruMBD4 binds to 5FU incorporated into DNA with higher affinity than MBD4. TruMBD4 reduced the 5FU affinity of the MMR recognition complexes that determined 5FU sensitivity by previous reports, suggesting other mechanisms might be operative to trigger cytotoxicity. To analyze overall 5FU sensitivity with TruMBD4, we established TruMBD4 overexpression in hMLH1-proficient or -deficient colorectal cancer cells followed by treatment with 5FU. 5FU-treated TruMBD4 cells demonstrated diminished growth characteristics compared to controls, independently of hMLH1 status. Flow cytometry revealed more 5FU-treated TruMBD4 cells in S phase than controls. We conclude that patients with MMR-deficient cancers, which show characteristic resistance to 5FU therapy, may be increased for 5FU sensitivity via secondary frameshift mutation of the base excision repair gene MBD4.

EMAST is a Form of Microsatellite Instability That is Initiated by Inflammation and Modulates Colorectal Cancer Progression

DNA mismatch repair (MMR) function is critical for correcting errors coincident with polymerase-driven DNA replication, and its proteins are frequent targets for inactivation (germline or somatic), generating a hypermutable tumor that drives cancer progression. The biomarker for defective DNA MMR is microsatellite instability-high (MSI-H), observed in ~15% of colorectal cancers, and defined by mono- and dinucleotide microsatellite frameshift mutations. MSI-H is highly correlated with loss of MMR protein expression, is commonly diploid, is often located in the right side of the colon, prognosticates good patient outcome, and predicts poor efficacy with 5-fluorouracil treatment. Elevated microsatellite alterations at selected tetranucleotide repeats (EMAST) is another form of MSI at tetranucleotide repeats that has been observed in multiple cancers, but its etiology and clinical relevance to patient care has only been recently illuminated. Specifically, EMAST is an acquired somatic defect observed in up to 60% of colorectal cancers and caused by unique dysfunction of the DNA MMR protein MSH3 (and its DNA MMR complex MutSβ, a heterodimer of MSH2-MSH3), and in particular a loss-of-function phenotype due to a reversible shift from its normal nuclear location into the cytosol in response to oxidative stress and the pro-inflammatory cytokine interleukin-6. Tumor hypoxia may also be a contributor. Patients with EMAST colorectal cancers show diminished prognosis compared to patients without the presence of EMAST in their cancer. In addition to defective DNA MMR recognized by tetranucleotide (and di- and tri-nucleotide) frameshifts, loss of MSH3 also contributes to homologous recombination-mediated repair of DNA double stranded breaks, indicating the MSH3 dysfunction is a complex defect for cancer cells that generates not only EMAST but also may contribute to chromosomal instability and aneuploidy. Areas for future investigation for this most common DNA MMR defect among colorectal cancers include relationships between EMAST and chemotherapy response, patient outcome with aneuploid changes in colorectal cancers, target gene mutation analysis, and mechanisms related to inflammation-induced compartmentalization and inactivation for MSH3.

Oxidative stress induces nuclear-to-cytosol shift of hMSH3, a potential mechanism for EMAST in colorectal cancer cells

Background

Elevated microsatellite alterations at selected tetranucleotide repeats (EMAST) is a genetic signature observed in 60% of sporadic colorectal cancers (CRCs). Unlike microsatellite unstable CRCs where hypermethylation of the DNA mismatch repair (MMR) gene hMLH1’s promoter is causal, the precise cause of EMAST is not clearly defined but points towards hMSH3 deficiency.

Aim

To examine if hMSH3 deficiency causes EMAST, and to explore mechanisms for its deficiency.

Methods

We measured −4 bp framshifts at D8S321 and D20S82 loci within EGFP-containing constructs to determine EMAST formation in MMR-proficient, hMLH1^−/−, hMSH6^−/−, and hMSH3^−/− CRC cells. We observed the subcellular location of hMSH3 with oxidative stress.

Results

D8S321 mutations occurred 31-and 40-fold higher and D20S82 mutations occurred 82-and 49-fold higher in hMLH1^−/− and hMSH3^−/− cells, respectively, than in hMSH6^−/− or MMR-proficient cells. hMSH3 knockdown in MMR-proficient cells caused higher D8S321 mutation rates (18.14 and 11.14×10⁻⁴ mutations/cell/generation in two independent clones) than scrambled controls (0 and 0.26×10⁻⁴ mutations/cell/generation; p<0.01). DNA sequencing confirmed the expected frameshift mutations with evidence for ongoing mutations of the constructs. Because EMAST-positive tumors are associated with inflammation, we subjected MMR-proficient cells to oxidative stress via H₂O₂ to examine its effect on hMSH3. A reversible nuclear-to-cytosol shift of hMSH3 was observed upon H₂O₂ treatment.

Conclusion

EMAST is dependent upon the MMR background, with hMSH3^−/− more prone to frameshift mutations than hMSH6^−/−, opposite to frameshift mutations observed for mononucleotide repeats. hMSH3^−/− mimics complete MMR failure (hMLH1^−/−) in inducing EMAST. Given the observed heterogeneous expression of hMSH3 in CRCs with EMAST, hMSH3-deficiency appears to be the event that commences EMAST. Oxidative stress, which causes a shift of hMSH3’s subcellular location, may contribute to an hMSH3 loss-of-function phenotype by sequestering it to the cytosol.