ECG beat classification via deterministic learning

Automated cardiac arrhythmia detection techniques: a comprehensive review for prospective approach

Abnormal cardiac functionality produces irregular heart rhythms which are commonly known as arrhythmias. In some conditions, arrhythmias are treated as very dangerous which may lead to sudden cardiac arrest. The incidence and prevalence of cardiac anomalies seeks early detection of arrhythmias using automated classification techniques. In the past, numerous automated arrhythmia detection techniques have been developed that are based on electrocardiogram (ECG) signal analysis. Focusing on the prospective research in this field, this article reports a comprehensive review of existing techniques that are obtained using search engines such as IEEE explore, Google scholar and science direct. Based on the review, the existing techniques are broadly categorized into two types: machine-learning and deep-learning-based techniques. In this study, it is noticed that the performance of the machine-learning-based arrhythmia detection techniques depend on pre-processing of ECG signal, R-peaks detection, features extraction and classification tools while the deep-learning-based techniques do not require the features extraction step. Generally, the existing techniques utilize Massachusetts Institute of Technology-Beth Israel Hospital arrhythmia database to evaluate the classification performance. The classification performance of automated techniques also depends on ECG data used for training and testing of the classifier. It is expected that the performance should be evaluated using a variety of ECG signals including the cases of inter-patient and intra-patient paradigm. The existing techniques also require to deal with the class-imbalance problem. In addition to this, a specific partition-ratio between training and testing datasets should be maintained for fair comparison of performance of different techniques.

Deterministic learning-based neural identification and knowledge fusion

Recent deterministic learning methods have achieved locally-accurate identification of unknown system dynamics. However, the locally-accurate identification means that the neural networks can only capture the local dynamics knowledge along the system trajectory. In order to capture a broader knowledge region, this article investigates the knowledge fusion problem of deterministic learning, that is, the integration of different knowledge regions along different individual trajectories. Specifically, two kinds of knowledge fusion schemes are systematically introduced: an online fusion scheme and an offline fusion scheme. The online scheme can be viewed as an extension of distributed cooperative learning control to cooperative neural identification for sampled-data systems. By designing an auxiliary information transmission strategy to enable the neural network to receive information learned from other tasks while learning its own task, it is proven that the weights of all localized RBF networks exponentially converge to their common true/ideal values. The offline scheme can be regarded as a knowledge distillation strategy, in which the fused network is obtained by offline training through the knowledge learned from all individual system trajectories via deterministic learning. A novel weight fusion algorithm with low computational complexity is proposed based on the least squares solution under subspace constraints. Simulation studies show that the proposed fusion schemes can successfully integrate the knowledge regions of different individual trajectories while maintaining the learning performance, thereby greatly expanding the knowledge region learned from deterministic learning.

Electrocardiogram morphological arrhythmia classification using fuzzy entropy-based feature selection and optimal classifier

Electrocardiogram (ECG) signal analysis has become significant in recent years as cardiac arrhythmia shares a major portion of all mortality worldwide. To detect these arrhythmias, computer-assisted algorithms play a pivotal role as beat-by-beat monitoring of holter ECG signals is required. In this paper, a morphological arrhythmia classification algorithm has been proposed to classify seven different ECG beats, namely Normal Beat (N), Left Bundle Branch Block Beat (L), Right Bundle Branch Block Beat (R), Atrial Premature Contraction Beat (A), Premature Ventricular Contraction Beat (V), Fusion of Normal and Ventricle Beat (F) and Pace Beat (P). A novel feature set of 25 attributes has been extracted from each ECG beat and ranked using the Fuzzy Entropy-based feature selection (FEBFS) technique. In addition, two distinct classifiers, support vector machine with radial basis function as the kernel (SVM-RBF) and weighted K-nearest neighbor (WKNN), are used to categorize ECG beats, and their performances are also evaluated after adjusting vital parameters. The performance of classifiers is compared for four different ECG beat segmentation approaches and further analyzed using three similarity measurement techniques and two fuzzy entropy methods while feature selection. The classifier results are also cross-validated using a 10-fold cross-validation scheme, and the MIT-BIH Arrhythmia Database has been used to validate the proposed work. After selecting 21 highly ranked features, WKNN achieves the best results with the nearest neighbor value K = 3 and cityblock distance metrics, with Average Sensitivity (Sen) = 94.89%, Positive Predictivity (Ppre) = 97.13%, Specificity (Spe) = 99.72%, F1 Score = 95.95%, and Overall Accuracy (Acc) = 99.15%. The novelty of this work relies on formulating a unique feature set, including proposed symbolic features, followed by the FEBFS technique making this algorithm efficient and reliable for morphological arrhythmia classification. The above results demonstrate that the proposed algorithm performs better than many existing state-of-the-art works.

The prediction of cardiac abnormality and enhancement in minority class accuracy from imbalanced ECG signals using modified deep neural network models

Cardiovascular disease (CVD) is the most fatal disease in the world, so its accurate and automated detection in the early stages will certainly support the medical expert in timely diagnosis and treatment, which can save many lives. Many types of research have been carried out in this regard, but due to the problem of data imbalance in the medical and health care sector, it may not provide the desired results in all aspects. To overcome this problem, a sequential ensemble technique has been proposed that detects 6 types of cardiac arrhythmias on large ECG imbalanced datasets, and the data imbalanced issue of the ECG dataset has been addressed by using a hybrid data resampling technique called "Synthetically Minority Oversampling Technique and Tomek Link (SMOTE + Tomek)". The sequential ensemble technique employs two distinct deep learning models: Convolutional Neural Network (CNN) and a hybrid model, CNN with Long Short-Term Memory Network (CNN-LSTM). The two standard datasets "MIT-BIH arrhythmias database" (MITDB) and "PTB diagnostic database" (PTBDB) are combined and extracted 23, 998 ECG beats for the model validation. In this work, the three models CNN, CNN-LSTM, and ensemble approach were tested on four kinds of ECG datasets: the original data (imbalanced), the data sampled using a random oversampled technique, data sampled using SMOTE, and the dataset resampled using SMOTE + Tomek algorithm. The overall highest accuracy was obtained of 99.02% on the SMOTE + Tomek sampled dataset by ensemble technique and the minority class accuracy result (Recall) is improved by 20% as compared to the imbalanced data.

A Machine Learning Approach for the Detection of QRS Complexes in Electrocardiogram (ECG) Using Discrete Wavelet Transform (DWT) Algorithm

This study describes a modified approach for the detection of cardiac abnormalities and QRS complexes using machine learning and support vector machine (SVM) classifiers. The suggested technique overtakes prevailing approaches in terms of both sensitivity and specificity, with 0.45 percent detection error rate for cardiac irregularities. Moreover, the vector machine classifiers validated the proposed method's superiority by accurately categorising four ECG beat types: normal, LBBBs, RBBBs, and Paced beat. The technique had 96.67 percent accuracy in MLP-BP and 98.39 percent accuracy in support of vector machine classifiers. The results imply that the SVM classifier can play an important role in the analysis of cardiac abnormalities. Furthermore, the SVM classifier also categorises ECG beats using DWT characteristics collected from ECG signals.

Multi-Filter Clustering Fusion for Feature Selection in Rotating Machinery Fault Classification

In the fault classification process, filter methods that sequentially remove unnecessary features have long been studied. However, the existing filter methods do not have guidelines on which, and how many, features are needed. This study developed a multi-filter clustering fusion (MFCF) technique, to effectively and efficiently select features. In the MFCF process, a multi-filter method combining existing filter methods is first applied for feature clustering; then, key features are automatically selected. The union of key features is utilized to find all potentially important features, and an exhaustive search is used to obtain the best combination of selected features to maximize the accuracy of the classification model. In the rotating machinery examples, fault classification models using MFCF were generated to classify normal and abnormal conditions of rotational machinery. The obtained results demonstrated that classification models using MFCF provide good accuracy, efficiency, and robustness in the fault classification of rotational machinery.

Deep learning-based electrocardiogram rhythm and beat features for heart abnormality classification

BACKGROUND

Electrocardiogram (ECG) signal classification plays a critical role in the automatic diagnosis of heart abnormalities. While most ECG signal patterns cannot be recognized by a human interpreter, they can be detected with precision using artificial intelligence approaches, making the ECG a powerful non-invasive biomarker. However, performing rapid and accurate ECG signal classification is difficult due to the low amplitude, complexity, and non-linearity. The widely-available deep learning (DL) method we propose has presented an opportunity to substantially improve the accuracy of automated ECG classification analysis using rhythm or beat features. Unfortunately, a comprehensive and general evaluation of the specific DL architecture for ECG analysis across a wide variety of rhythm and beat features has not been previously reported. Some previous studies have been concerned with detecting ECG class abnormalities only through rhythm or beat features separately.

METHODS

This study proposes a single architecture based on the DL method with one-dimensional convolutional neural network (1D-CNN) architecture, to automatically classify 24 patterns of ECG signals through both rhythm and beat. To validate the proposed model, five databases which consisted of nine-class of ECG-base rhythm and 15-class of ECG-based beat were used in this study. The proposed DL network was applied and studied with varying datasets with different frequency samplings in intra and inter-patient scheme.

RESULTS

Using a 10-fold cross-validation scheme, the performance results had an accuracy of 99.98%, a sensitivity of 99.90%, a specificity of 99.89%, a precision of 99.90%, and an F1-score of 99.99% for ECG rhythm classification. Additionally, for ECG beat classification, the model obtained an accuracy of 99.87%, a sensitivity of 96.97%, a specificity of 99.89%, a precision of 92.23%, and an F1-score of 94.39%. In conclusion, this study provides clinicians with an advanced methodology for detecting and discriminating heart abnormalities between different ECG rhythm and beat assessments by using one outstanding proposed DL architecture.

Local feature descriptors based ECG beat classification

ECG beat type analysis is important in the detection of various heart diseases. The ECG beats give useful information about the status of the monitored heart condition. Up to now, various artificial intelligence-based methods have been proposed for ECG based heart failure detection. These methods were generally based on either time or frequency domain signal processing routines. In this study, we propose a different approach for ECG beat classification. The proposed approach is based on image processing. Thus, the initial step of the proposed work is converting the ECG beat signals to the ECG beat images. To do that, the ECG beat snapshots are initially saved as ECG beat images and then local feature descriptors are considered for feature extraction from ECG beat images. Eight local feature descriptors namely Local Binary Patterns, Frequency Decoded LBP, Quaternionic Local Ranking Binary Pattern, Binary Gabor Pattern, Local Phase Quantization, Binarized Statistical Image Features, CENsus TRansform hISTogram and Pyramid Histogram of Oriented Gradients are considered for feature extraction. The Support Vector Machines (SVM) classifier is used in the classification stage of the study. Linear, Quadratic, Cubic and Gaussian kernel functions are used in the SVM classifier. Five types of ECG beats from the MIT-BIH arrhythmia dataset are considered in experiments and the classification accuracy is used for performance measure. To construct a balanced training and test sets, 5000 and 10,000 ECG beat samples are randomly selected and are used in experiments in tenfold cross-validation fashion. The obtained results show that the proposed method is quite efficient where the calculated accuracy score is 99.9% and the comparisons with the state-of-the-art method show that the proposed method outperforms other methods.

A cascaded classifier for multi-lead ECG based on feature fusion

BACKGROUND AND OBJECTIVE

Electrocardiogram (ECG) is an important diagnostic tool for the diagnosis of heart disorders. Useful features and well-designed classification method are crucial for automatic diagnosis. However, most of the contributions were in single lead or two-lead ECG signal and only features from single lead were used to classify the ECG beats. In this paper, a cascaded classification system is proposed to extract features and classify heartbeats in order to improve the performance of ECG beat classification via multi-lead ECG.

METHODS

In contrast with most of the literatures, ten signal features were chosen and run on each of the 12 leads separately. Based on these features, we developed a novel feature fusion method combining information from all available leads, and then implemented a cascaded classifier utilizing random forest (RF) and multilayer perceptron (MLP). Besides, in order to reduce the feature space dimension, principal component analysis (PCA) was applied in the method.

MATERIALS

Four open source databases including MIT-BIH Arrythmia Database, QT Database, MIT-BIH Supraventricular Arrhythmia Database and St. Petersburg Institute of Cardiological Technics 12-lead Arrhythmia Database (INCART Database) were used in this work. These four databases are different in classes of beats, volume of dataset, number of individual volunteers. Except INCART database, in which the recording format is 12-lead, the other three databases consist of 2-lead recordings. Above all, they all have annotations for every single beat including the type of each beat.

CONCLUSIONS

Extensive experimental results shown that the average accuracy achieved 99.3%, 99.8%, 97.6% and 99.6% on four databases respectively. Compared with most state-of-the-art methods, our work has better performance and strong generalization capability.

A topological approach to delineation and arrhythmic beats detection in unprocessed long-term ECG signals

BACKGROUND AND OBJECTIVE

Arrhythmias are one of the most common symptoms of cardiac failure. They are usually diagnosed using ECG recordings, particularly long ambulatory recordings (AECG). These recordings are tedious to interpret by humans due to their extent (up to 48 h) and the relative scarcity of arrhythmia events. This makes automated systems for detecting various AECG anomalies indispensable. In this work we present a novel procedure based on topological principles (Morse theory) for detecting arrhythmic beats in AECG. It works in nearly real-time (delayed by a 14 s window), and can be applied to raw (unprocessed) ECG signals.

METHODS

The procedure is based on a subject-specific adaptation of the one-dimensional discrete Morse theory (ADMT), which represents the signal as a sequence of its most important extrema. The ADMT algorithm is applied twice; for low-amplitude, high-frequency noise removal, and for detection of the characteristic waves of individual ECG beats. The waves are annotated using the ADMT algorithm and template matching. The annotated beats are then compared to the adjacent beats with two measures of similarity: the distance between two beats, and the difference in shape between them. The two measures of similarity are used as inputs to a decision tree algorithm that classifies the beats as normal or abnormal. The classification performance is evaluated with the leave-one-record-out cross-validation method.

RESULTS

Our approach was tested on the MIT-BIH database, where it exhibited a classification accuracy of 92.73%, a sensitivity of 73.35%, a specificity of 96.70%, a positive predictive value of 88.01%, and a negative predictive value of 95.73%.

CONCLUSIONS

Compared to related studies, our algorithm requires less preprocessing while retaining the capability to detect and classify beats in almost real-time. The algorithm exhibits a high degree of accuracy in beats detection and classification that are at least comparable to state-of-the-art methods.