219th ENMC International Workshop Titinopathies International database of titin mutations and phenotypes, Heemskerk, The Netherlands, 29 April-1 May 2016

Heterozygous missense variant in the TTN gene causing Tibial muscular dystrophy

Background

Tibial muscular dystrophy (TMD), tardive, is a dominantly inherited mild degenerative disorder of anterior tibial muscles. Mutations of Titin (TTN) have been reported in patients with different phenotypes such as skeletal muscular abnormalities or complex overlapping disorders of muscles. Titin (TTN) is a large 363 exon gene that encodes an abundant protein (the longest polypeptide known in nature) expressed in the heart and skeletal muscles.

Methods

DNA from peripheral blood sample was extracted, whole exome sequencing (WES) was performed, and a neuromuscular disorders related gene-filtering strategy was used to analyse the disease-causing mutations. Further, sanger sequencing was applied to confirm the variant.

Results

A novel missense variant (c.41529G > C;p.Arg13843Ser) of TTN gene was identified in a patient with lower limb weakness, occasional tongue fasciculation and mild scoliosis. This variant leads to a substitution of arginine with serine, causing structural changes in titin protein that is responsible for the TMD disease.

Conclusion

The novel variant detected has widened the genetic spectrum of TTN-associated diseases, further functional studies will aid in establishing the clinical diagnosis.

In Vitro Fertilization Using Preimplantation Genetic Testing in a Romanian Couple Carrier of Mutations in the TTN Gene: A Case Report and Literature Review

Severe congenital myopathy with fatal cardiomyopathy (EOMFC) is a rare genetic neuromuscular disorder inherited in an autosomal recessive manner. Here we presented a successful pregnancy obtained by in vitro fertilization (IVF) using preimplantation genetic testing (PGT) in one young Romanian carrier couple that already lost mutation(s) within the TNN gene and whose first baby passed away due to multiple complications. It was delivered via emergency C-section at 36 weeks and fully dependent on artificial ventilation for a couple of months, weighing 2200 g and an APGAR score of 3. The aCGH + SNP analysis revealed an abnormal profile of the first newborn; three areas associated with loss of heterozygosity on chromosome 1 (q25.1–q25.3) of 6115 kb, 5 (p15.2–p15.1) of 2589 kb and 8 (q11.21–q11.23) of 4830 kb, a duplication of 1104 kb on chromosome 10 in the position q11.22, and duplication of 1193 kb on chromosome 16 in the position p11.2p11.1. Subsequently, we proceeded to test the parents and showed that both parents are carriers; confirmed by Sanger and NGS sequencing—father—on Chr2(GRCh37):g.179396832_179396833del—TTN variant c.104509_104510del p.(Leu34837Glufs*12)—exon 358 and mother—on Chr2(GRCh37):g.179479653G>C—TTN variant c.48681C>G p.(Tyr16227*)—exon 260. Their first child died shortly after birth due to multiple organ failures, possessing both parent’s mutations; weighing 2200 g at birth and received an APGAR score of 3 following premature delivery via emergency C-section at 36 weeks. Two embryos were obtained following the IVF protocol; one possessed the mother’s mutation, and the other had no mutations and was normal (WT). In contrast with the first birth, the second one was uneventful. A healthy female baby weighing 2990 g was delivered by C-section at 38 weeks, receiving an APGAR score of 9.

Diagnostic muscle biopsies in the era of genetics: the added value of myopathology in a selection of limb-girdle muscular dystrophy patients

In the second most common dystrophy associated with predominant pelvic and shoulder girdle muscle weakness termed Limb-Girdle Muscular Dystrophy (LGMD), genetic complexity, large phenotypic variability, and clinical overlap can result in extensive diagnostic delays in certain individuals. In view of the large strides genetics has taken in this day and age, we address the question if muscle biopsies can still provide diagnostic evidence of substance for these patients. We reviewed and reanalyzed muscle biopsy characteristics in a cohort of LGMD patient pairs in which gene variants were picked up in CAPN3, FKRP, TTN, and ANO5, using histochemical-immunohistochemical-and immunofluorescent staining, and western blotting. We found that not the nature and severity of inflammatory changes, but the changed properties of the dystrophin complex were the most valuable assets to differentiate LGMD from myositis. Proteomic evaluation brought both primary and secondary deficiencies to light, which could be equally revealing for diagnosis. Though a muscle biopsy might, at present, not always be strictly necessary anymore, it still represents an irrefutable asset when the genetic diagnosis is complicated.

The constantly evolving spectrum of phenotypes in titinopathies - will it ever stop?

PURPOSE OF REVIEW

The last few years have confirmed previous assumptions of an enormous impact of the titin gene (TTN) on the occurrence of muscle disease, cardiomyopathy, or both together. The reason for this rather late understanding of its importance is because of the huge size which prevented sequencing of the whole gene by the previous Sanger technique in the individual cases. An update of the advances in diagnosing titinopathies is the main focus of this review.

RECENT FINDINGS

High throughput methods are now widely available for TTN sequencing and a corresponding explosion of different types of identified titinopathies is observed and published in the literature, although final confirmation is lacking in many cases with recessive missense variants.

SUMMARY

The implications of these findings for clinical practice are easy to understand: patients with previously undiagnosed muscle disease can now have a correct diagnosis and subsequently receive a likely prognosis, can have accurate genetic counseling for the whole family and early treatment for predictable complications from the heart and respiratory muscles. In addition not to forget, they can avoid wrong diagnoses leading to wrong treatments.

Is Gene-Size an Issue for the Diagnosis of Skeletal Muscle Disorders?

Human genes have a variable length. Those having a coding sequence of extraordinary length and a high number of exons were almost impossible to sequence using the traditional Sanger-based gene-by-gene approach. High-throughput sequencing has partly overcome the size-related technical issues, enabling a straightforward, rapid and relatively inexpensive analysis of large genes.

Several large genes (e.g. TTN, NEB, RYR1, DMD) are recognized as disease-causing in patients with skeletal muscle diseases. However, because of their sheer size, the clinical interpretation of variants in these genes is probably the most challenging aspect of the high-throughput genetic investigation in the field of skeletal muscle diseases.

The main aim of this review is to discuss the technical and interpretative issues related to the diagnostic investigation of large genes and to reflect upon the current state of the art and the future advancements in the field.

Panorama of the distal myopathies

Distal myopathies are genetic primary muscle disorders with a prominent weakness at onset in hands and/or feet. The age of onset (from early childhood to adulthood), the distribution of muscle weakness (upper versus lower limbs) and the histological findings (ranging from nonspecific myopathic changes to myofibrillar disarrays and rimmed vacuoles) are extremely variable. However, despite being characterized by a wide clinical and genetic heterogeneity, the distal myopathies are a category of muscular dystrophies: genetic diseases with progressive loss of muscle fibers. Myopathic congenital arthrogryposis is also a form of distal myopathy usually caused by focal amyoplasia. Massive parallel sequencing has further expanded the long list of genes associated with a distal myopathy, and contributed identifying as distal myopathy-causative rare variants in genes more often related with other skeletal or cardiac muscle diseases. Currently, almost 20 genes (ACTN2, CAV3, CRYAB, DNAJB6, DNM2, FLNC, HNRNPA1, HSPB8, KHLH9, LDB3, MATR3, MB, MYOT, PLIN4, TIA1, VCP, NOTCH2NLC, LRP12, GIPS1) have been associated with an autosomal dominant form of distal myopathy. Pathogenic changes in four genes (ADSSL, ANO5, DYSF, GNE) cause an autosomal recessive form; and disease-causing variants in five genes (DES, MYH7, NEB, RYR1 and TTN) result either in a dominant or in a recessive distal myopathy. Finally, a digenic mechanism, underlying a Welander-like form of distal myopathy, has been recently elucidated. Rare pathogenic mutations in SQSTM1, previously identified with a bone disease (Paget disease), unexpectedly cause a distal myopathy when combined with a common polymorphism in TIA1. The present review aims at describing the genetic basis of distal myopathy and at summarizing the clinical features of the different forms described so far.

Improved Criteria for the Classification of Titin Variants in Inherited Skeletal Myopathies

BACKGROUND

Extensive genetic screening results in the identification of thousands of rare variants that are difficult to interpret. Because of its sheer size, rare variants in the titin gene (TTN) are detected frequently in any individual. Unambiguous interpretation of molecular findings is almost impossible in many patients with myopathies or cardiomyopathies.

OBJECTIVE

To refine the current classification framework for TTN-associated skeletal muscle disorders and standardize the interpretation of TTN variants.

METHODS

We used the guidelines issued by the American College of Medical Genetics and Genomics (ACMG) and the Association for Molecular Pathology (AMP) to re-analyze TTN genetic findings from our patient cohort.

RESULTS

We identified in the classification guidelines three rules that are not applicable to titin-related skeletal muscle disorders; six rules that require disease-/gene-specific adjustments and four rules requiring quantitative thresholds for a proper use. In three cases, the rule strength need to be modified.

CONCLUSIONS

We suggest adjustments are made to the guidelines. We provide frequency thresholds to facilitate filtering of candidate causative variants and guidance for the use and interpretation of functional data and co-segregation evidence. We expect that the variant classification framework for TTN-related skeletal muscle disorders will be further improved along with a better understanding of these diseases.

The Impact of Next-Generation Sequencing on the Diagnosis, Treatment, and Prevention of Hereditary Neuromuscular Disorders

The impact of high-throughput sequencing in genetic neuromuscular disorders cannot be overstated. The ability to rapidly and affordably sequence multiple genes simultaneously has enabled a second golden age of Mendelian disease gene discovery, with flow-on impacts for rapid genetic diagnosis, evidence-based treatment, tailored therapy development, carrier-screening, and prevention of disease recurrence in families. However, there are likely many more neuromuscular disease genes and mechanisms to be discovered. Many patients and families remain without a molecular diagnosis following targeted panel sequencing, clinical exome sequencing, or even genome sequencing. Here we review how massively parallel, or next-generation, sequencing has changed the field of genetic neuromuscular disorders, and anticipate future benefits of recent technological innovations such as RNA-seq implementation and detection of tandem repeat expansions from short-read sequencing.

The importance of an integrated genotype-phenotype strategy to unravel the molecular bases of titinopathies

Next generation sequencing (NGS) has allowed the titin gene (TTN) to be identified as a major contributor to neuromuscular disorders, with high clinical heterogeneity. The mechanisms underlying the phenotypic variability and the dominant or recessive pattern of inheritance are unclear. Titin is involved in the formation and stability of the sarcomeres. The effects of the different TTN variants can be harmless or pathogenic (recessive or dominant) but the interpretation is tricky because the current bioinformatics tools can not predict their functional impact effectively. Moreover, TTN variants are very frequent in the general population. The combination of deep phenotyping associated with RNA molecular analyses, western blot (WB) and functional studies is often essential for the interpretation of genetic variants in patients suspected of titinopathy. In line with the current guidelines and suggestions, we implemented for patients with skeletal myopathy and with potentially disease causing TTN variant(s) an integrated genotype-transcripts-protein-phenotype approach, associated with phenotype and variants segregation studies in relatives and confrontation with published data on titinopathies to evaluate pathogenic effects of TTN variants (even truncating ones) on titin transcripts, amount, size and functionality. We illustrate this integrated approach in four patients with recessive congenital myopathy.

Genotype-phenotype correlations in recessive titinopathies

PURPOSE

High throughput sequencing analysis has facilitated the rapid analysis of the entire titin (TTN) coding sequence. This has resulted in the identification of a growing number of recessive titinopathy patients. The aim of this study was to (1) characterize the causative genetic variants and clinical features of the largest cohort of recessive titinopathy patients reported to date and (2) to evaluate genotype-phenotype correlations in this cohort.

METHODS

We analyzed clinical and genetic data in a cohort of patients with biallelic pathogenic or likely pathogenic TTN variants. The cohort included both previously reported cases (100 patients from 81 unrelated families) and unreported cases (23 patients from 20 unrelated families).

RESULTS

Overall, 132 causative variants were identified in cohort members. More than half of the cases had hypotonia at birth or muscle weakness and a delayed motor development within the first 12 months of life (congenital myopathy) with causative variants located along the entire gene. The remaining patients had a distal or proximal phenotype and a childhood or later (noncongenital) onset. All noncongenital cases had at least one pathogenic variant in one of the final three TTN exons (362-364).

CONCLUSION

Our findings suggest a novel association between the location of nonsense variants and the clinical severity of the disease.

Update on Congenital Myopathies in Adulthood

Congenital myopathies (CMs) constitute a group of heterogenous rare inherited muscle diseases with different incidences. They are traditionally grouped based on characteristic histopathological findings revealed on muscle biopsy. In recent decades, the ever-increasing application of modern genetic technologies has not just improved our understanding of their pathophysiology, but also expanded their phenotypic spectrum and contributed to a more genetically based approach for their classification. Later onset forms of CMs are increasingly recognised. They are often considered milder with slower progression, variable clinical presentations and different modes of inheritance. We reviewed the key features and genetic basis of late onset CMs with a special emphasis on those forms that may first manifest in adulthood.

Interpreting Genetic Variants in Titin in Patients With Muscle Disorders

Importance

Mutations in the titin gene (TTN) cause a wide spectrum of genetic diseases. The interpretation of the numerous rare variants identified in TTN is a difficult challenge given its large size.

Objective

To identify genetic variants in titin in a cohort of patients with muscle disorders.

Design, Setting, and Participants

In this case series, 9 patients with titinopathy and 4 other patients with possibly disease-causing variants in TTN were identified. Titin mutations were detected through targeted resequencing performed on DNA from 504 patients with muscular dystrophy, congenital myopathy, or other skeletal muscle disorders. Patients were enrolled from 10 clinical centers in April 2012 to December 2013. All of them had not received a diagnosis after undergoing an extensive investigation, including Sanger sequencing of candidate genes. The data analysis was performed between September 2013 and January 2017. Sequencing data were analyzed using an internal custom bioinformatics pipeline.

Main Outcomes and Measures

The identification of novel mutations in the TTN gene and novel patients with titinopathy. We performed an evaluation of putative causative variants in the TTN gene, combining genetic, clinical, and imaging data with messenger RNA and/or protein studies.

Results

Of the 9 novel patients with titinopathy, 5 (55.5%) were men and the mean (SD) age at onset was 25 (15.8) years (range, 0-46 years). Of the 4 other patients (3 men and 1 woman) with possibly disease-causing TTN variants, 2 (50%) had a congenital myopathy and 2 (50%) had a slowly progressive distal myopathy with onset in the second decade. Most of the identified mutations were previously unreported. However, all the variants, even the already described mutations, require careful clinical and molecular evaluation of probands and relatives. Heterozygous truncating variants or unique missense changes are not sufficient to make a diagnosis of titinopathy.

Conclusions and Relevance

The interpretation of TTN variants often requires further analyses, including a comprehensive evaluation of the clinical phenotype (deep phenotyping) as well as messenger RNA and protein studies. We propose a specific workflow for the clinical interpretation of genetic findings in titin.

Congenital Titinopathy: Comprehensive characterization and pathogenic insights

OBJECTIVE

Comprehensive clinical characterization of congenital titinopathy to facilitate diagnosis and management of this important emerging disorder.

METHODS

Using massively parallel sequencing we identified 30 patients from 27 families with 2 pathogenic nonsense, frameshift and/or splice site TTN mutations in trans. We then undertook a detailed analysis of the clinical, histopathological and imaging features of these patients.

RESULTS

All patients had prenatal or early onset hypotonia and/or congenital contractures. None had ophthalmoplegia. Scoliosis and respiratory insufficiency typically developed early and progressed rapidly, whereas limb weakness was often slowly progressive, and usually did not prevent independent walking. Cardiac involvement was present in 46% of patients. Relatives of 2 patients had dilated cardiomyopathy. Creatine kinase levels were normal to moderately elevated. Increased fiber size variation, internalized nuclei and cores were common histopathological abnormalities. Cap-like regions, whorled or ring fibers, and mitochondrial accumulations were also observed. Muscle magnetic resonance imaging showed gluteal, hamstring and calf muscle involvement. Western blot analysis showed a near-normal sized titin protein in all samples. The presence of 2 mutations predicted to impact both N2BA and N2B cardiac isoforms appeared to be associated with greatest risk of cardiac involvement. One-third of patients had 1 mutation predicted to impact exons present in fetal skeletal muscle, but not included within the mature skeletal muscle isoform transcript. This strongly suggests developmental isoforms are involved in the pathogenesis of this congenital/early onset disorder.

INTERPRETATION

This detailed clinical reference dataset will greatly facilitate diagnostic confirmation and management of patients, and has provided important insights into disease pathogenesis. Ann Neurol 2018;83:1105-1124.

Myoimaging in Congenital Myopathies

There is a great clinical and genetic heterogeneity in congenital myopathies. Myo-MRI with pattern recognition has become a first-line complementary tool in clinical practice for this group of diseases. For diagnostic purposes, whole-body imaging techniques are preferred when involvement is axial or diffuse, as in most congenital myopathies, because of involvement of the tongue, masticator, neck or trunk muscles. Myo-MRI is widely used to identify abnormalities in muscle signal, volume or texture. Recognizable profiles or patterns have been identified in many of these genetic myopathies. The role of the radiologist is crucial in order to adapt the Myo-MRI protocols to the age of the patient and several clinical situations. Myo-MRI in children with congenital myopathies is a very demanding technique with a balance between acceptable time of examination and sufficient spatial resolution in order to detect subtle changes. Technical evolutions combining qualitative and quantitative analysis are useful to follow disease progression overtime. Outcome measures are expected to play a role in natural history description as well as in future therapeutic trials. Genetic diagnosis and interpretation of next generation sequencing results could be greatly influenced by statistical analysis with tools such as algorithms as well as graphical representations using heatmaps.

The clinical spectrum and genetic variability of limb-girdle muscular dystrophy in a cohort of Chinese patients

Background

Limb-girdle muscular dystrophy (LGMD) is a commonly diagnosed hereditary muscular disorder, characterized by the progressive weakness of the limb-girdle muscles. Although the condition has been well-characterized, clinical and genetic heterogeneity can be observed in patients with LGMD. Here, we aimed to describe the clinical manifestations and genetic variability among a cohort of patients with LGMD in South China.

Results

We analyzed the clinical information, muscle magnetic resonance imaging (MRI) findings, and genetic results obtained from 30 patients (24 families) with clinically suspected LGMD. In 24 probands, 38 variants were found in total, of which 18 were shown to be novel. Among the 30 patients, the most common subtypes were dysferlinopathy in eight (26.67%), sarcoglycanopathies in eight [26.67%; LGMD 2C in three (10.00%), LGMD 2D in three (10.00%), and LGMD 2F in two (6.67%)], LGMD 2A in seven (23.33%), followed by LGMD 1B in three (10.00%), LGMD 2I in three (10.00%), and early onset recessive Emery-Dreifuss-like phenotype without cardiomyopathy in one (3.33%). Furthermore, we also observed novel clinical presentations for LGMD 1B, 2F, and 2I patients with hypermobility of the joints in the upper limbs, a LGMD 2F patient with delayed language development, and other manifestations. Moreover, distinct distributions of fatty infiltration in patients with LGMD 2A, dysferlinopathy, and the early onset recessive Emery-Dreifuss-like phenotype without cardiomyopathy were also observed based on muscle MRI results.

Conclusions

In this study, we expanded the clinical spectrum and genetic variability found in patients with LGMD, which provided additional insights into genotype and phenotype correlations in this disease.

Electronic supplementary material

The online version of this article (10.1186/s13023-018-0859-6) contains supplementary material, which is available to authorized users.

Knockout of human muscle genes revealed by large scale whole-exome studies

Large scale whole-exome sequence studies have revealed that a number of individuals from different populations have predicted loss-of-function of different genes due to nonsense, frameshift, or canonical splice-site mutations. Surprisingly, many of these mutations do not apparently show the deleterious phenotypic consequences expected from gene knockout. These homozygous null mutations, when confirmed, can provide insight into human gene function and suggest novel approaches to correct gene dysfunction, as the lack of the expected disease phenotype may reflect the existence of modifier genes that reveal potential therapeutic targets. Human knockouts complement the information derived from mouse knockouts, which are not always good models of human disease. We have examined human knockout datasets searching for genes expressed exclusively or predominantly in striated muscle. A number of well-known muscle genes was found in one or more datasets, including genes coding for sarcomeric myosins, components of the sarcomeric cytoskeleton, sarcoplasmic reticulum and plasma membrane, and enzymes involved in muscle metabolism. The surprising absence of phenotype in some of these human knockouts is critically discussed, focusing on the comparison with the corresponding mouse knockouts.

The complexity of titin splicing pattern in human adult skeletal muscles

BACKGROUND

Mutations in the titin gene (TTN) cause a large spectrum of diseases affecting skeletal and/or cardiac muscle. TTN includes 363 coding exons, a repeated region with a high degree of complexity, isoform-specific elements, and metatranscript-only exons thought to be expressed only during fetal development. Although three main classes of isoforms have been described so far, alternative splicing events (ASEs) in different tissues or in different developmental and physiological states have been reported.

METHODS

To achieve a comprehensive view of titin ASEs in adult human skeletal muscles, we performed a RNA-Sequencing experiment on 42 human biopsies collected from 12 anatomically different skeletal muscles of 11 individuals without any skeletal-muscle disorders.

RESULTS

We confirmed that the skeletal muscle N2A isoforms are highly prevalent, but we found an elevated number of alternative splicing events, some at a very high level. These include previously unknown exon skipping events and alternative 5' and 3' splice sites. Our data suggests the partial inclusion in the TTN transcript of some metatranscript-only exons and the partial exclusion of canonical N2A exons.

CONCLUSIONS

This study provides an extensive picture of the complex TTN splicing pattern in human adult skeletal muscle, which is crucial for a proper clinical interpretation of TTN variants.

Congenital myopathies: disorders of excitation-contraction coupling and muscle contraction

The congenital myopathies are a group of early-onset, non-dystrophic neuromuscular conditions with characteristic muscle biopsy findings, variable severity and a stable or slowly progressive course. Pronounced weakness in axial and proximal muscle groups is a common feature, and involvement of extraocular, cardiorespiratory and/or distal muscles can implicate specific genetic defects. Central core disease (CCD), multi-minicore disease (MmD), centronuclear myopathy (CNM) and nemaline myopathy were among the first congenital myopathies to be reported, and they still represent the main diagnostic categories. However, these entities seem to belong to a much wider phenotypic spectrum. To date, congenital myopathies have been attributed to mutations in over 20 genes, which encode proteins implicated in skeletal muscle Ca²⁺ homeostasis, excitation-contraction coupling, thin-thick filament assembly and interactions, and other mechanisms. RYR1 mutations are the most frequent genetic cause, and CCD and MmD are the most common subgroups. Next-generation sequencing has vastly improved mutation detection and has enabled the identification of novel genetic backgrounds. At present, management of congenital myopathies is largely supportive, although new therapeutic approaches are reaching the clinical trial stage.

[Titin-related muscle disorders: an expanding spectrum]

Titin-related diseases of the skeletal and cardiac muscles open a new, fruitful chapter of myology. Confined for a long time to a limited number of clinical entities, the phenotypic spectrum of titinopthies is nowadays expanding rapidly together with the discovery of many pathogenic mutations of the TTN gene. Like for many genes of large size, the fine tuning and use of high-throughput sequencing (NGS) constitutes a little revolution in the field. This powerful tool allows, although with real technical hurdles, the establishment of the definite diagnosis of titinopathy. A better knowledge of the natural history of each subtype of titinopathy enables as of now an optimized management of patients, notably when a cardiac or respiratory risk factor is identified. Research efforts in the titin-related conditions are gradually getting organized. Interactions between clinicians and geneticists are an absolute necessity. The still fragmentary knowledge of the pathogenesis of each titinopathy prevents to date to figure out any curative therapy in the very near future.

Exome sequences versus sequential gene testing in the UK highly specialised Service for Limb Girdle Muscular Dystrophy

BACKGROUND

Limb girdle muscular dystrophies are a group of rare and genetically heterogeneous diseases that share proximal weakness as a common feature; however they are often lacking very specific phenotypic features to allow an accurate differential diagnosis based on the clinical signs only, limiting the diagnostic rate using phenotype driven genetic testing. Next generation sequencing provides an opportunity to obtain molecular diagnoses for undiagnosed patients, as well as identifying novel genetic causes of muscle diseases. We performed whole exome sequencing (WES) on 104 affected individuals from 75 families in who standard gene by gene testing had not yielded a diagnosis. For comparison we also evaluated the diagnostic rate using sequential gene by gene testing for 91 affected individuals from 84 families over a 2 year period.

RESULTS

Patients selected for WES had undergone more extensive prior testing than those undergoing standard genetic testing and on average had had 8 genes screened already. In this extensively investigated cohort WES identified the genetic diagnosis in 28 families (28/75, 37%), including the identification of the novel gene ZAK and two unpublished genes. WES of a single affected individual with sporadic disease yielded a diagnosis in 13/38 (34%) of cases. In comparison, conventional gene by gene testing provided a genetic diagnosis in 28/84 (33%) families. Titinopathies and collagen VI related dystrophy were the most frequent diagnoses made by WES. Reasons why mutations in known genes were not identified previously included atypical phenotypes, reassignment of pathogenicity of variants, and in one individual mosaicism for a COL6A1 mutation which was undetected by prior direct sequencing.

CONCLUSION

WES was able to overcome many limitations of standard testing and achieved a higher rate of diagnosis than standard testing even in this cohort of extensively investigated patients. Earlier application of WES is therefore likely to yield an even higher diagnostic rate. We obtained a high diagnosis rate in simplex cases and therefore such individuals should be included in exome or genome sequencing projects. Disease due to somatic mosaicism may be increasingly recognised due to the increased sensitivity of next generation sequencing techniques to detect low level mosaicism.