Importance of muscle biopsy to establish pathogenicity of DMD missense and splice variants

Clinical and genetic interpretation of uncertain DMD missense variants: evidence from mRNA and protein studies

BACKGROUND

Pathogenic missense variants in the dystrophin (DMD) gene are rarely reported in dystrophinopathies. Most DMD missense variants are of uncertain significance and their pathogenicity interpretation remains complicated. We aimed to investigate whether DMD missense variants would cause aberrant splicing and re-interpret their pathogenicity based on mRNA and protein studies.

METHODS

Nine unrelated patients who had an elevated serum creatine kinase level with or without muscle weakness were enrolled. They underwent a detailed clinical, imaging, and pathological assessment. Routine genetic testing and muscle-derived mRNA and protein studies of dystrophin and sarcoglycan genes were performed in them.

RESULTS

Three of the 9 patients presented with a Duchenne muscular dystrophy (DMD) phenotype and the remaining 6 patients had a suspected diagnosis of Becker muscular dystrophy (BMD) or sarcoglycanopathy based on their clinical and pathological characteristics. Routine genetic testing detected only 9 predicted DMD missense variants in them, of which 6 were novel and interpreted as uncertain significance. Muscle-derived mRNA studies of sarcoglycan genes didn't reveal any aberrant transcripts in them. Dystrophin mRNA studies confirmed that 3 predicted DMD missense variants (c.2380G > C, c.4977C > G, and c.5444A > G) were in fact splicing and frameshift variants due to aberrant splicing. The 9 DMD variants were re-interpreted as pathogenic or likely pathogenic based on mRNA and protein studies. Therefore, 3 patients with DMD splicing variants and 6 patients with confirmed DMD missense variants were diagnosed with DMD and BMD, respectively.

CONCLUSION

Our study highlights the importance of muscle biopsy and aberrant splicing for clinical and genetic interpretation of uncertain DMD missense variants.

Uncovering the true features of dystrophin gene rearrangement and improving the molecular diagnosis of Duchenne and Becker muscular dystrophies

Duchenne and Becker muscular dystrophies (DMD/BMD) are caused by complex mutations in the dystrophin gene (DMD). Currently, there is no integrative method for the precise detection of all potential DMD variants, a gap which we aimed to address using long-read sequencing. The captured long-read sequencing panel developed in this study was applied to 129 subjects, including 11 who had previously unsolved cases. The results showed that this method accurately detected DMD mutations, ranging from single-nucleotide variations to structural variations. Furthermore, our findings revealed that continuous exon duplication/deletion in the DMD/BMD cohort may be attributed to complex segmental rearrangements and that noncontiguous duplication/deletion is generally attributed to intragenic inversion or interchromosome translocation. Mutations in the deep introns were confirmed to produce a pseudoexon. Moreover, variations in female carriers were precisely identified. The integrated and precise DMD gene screening method proposed in this study could improve the molecular diagnosis of DMD/BMD.

Cryptic exon activation caused by a novel deep-intronic splice-altering variant in Becker muscular dystrophy

BACKGROUND

An accurate genetic diagnosis of Becker muscular dystrophy (BMD) can be sometimes challenging due to deep intronic DMD variants. Here, we report on the genetic diagnosis of a BMD patient with a novel deep-intronic splice-altering variant in DMD.

METHODS

The index case was a 3.8-year-old boy who was suspected of having a diagnosis of BMD based on his clinical, muscle imaging, and pathological features. Routine genomic detection approaches did not detect any disease-causing variants in him. Muscle-derived DMD mRNA studies, followed by genomic Sanger sequencing and in silico bioinformatic analyses, were performed in the patient.

RESULTS

DMD mRNA studies detected a cryptic exon-containing transcript and normally spliced DMD transcript in the patient. The cryptic exon-containing transcript encoded a frameshift and premature termination codon (NP_003997.1:p.[=,Asp2740Valfs*52]). Further genomic Sanger sequencing and bioinformatic analysis identified a novel deep-intronic splice-altering variant in DMD (c.8217 + 23338A > G). The novel variant strengthened a cryptic donor splice site and activated a cryptic acceptor splice site in the deep-intronic region of DMD intron 55, resulting in the activation of a new dystrophin cryptic exon found in the patient.

CONCLUSION

Our case report expands the genetic spectrum of BMD and highlights the essential role of deep-intronic cryptic exon-activating variants in genetically unsolved BMD patients.

Clinical, muscle imaging, and genetic characteristics of dystrophinopathies with deep-intronic DMD variants

BACKGROUND

Phenotypic heterogeneity within or between families with a same deep-intronic splice-altering variant in the DMD gene has never been systematically analyzed. This study aimed to determine the phenotypic and genetic characteristics of patients with deep-intronic DMD variants.

METHODS

Of 1338 male patients with a suspected dystrophinopathy, 38 were confirmed to have atypical pathogenic DMD variants via our comprehensive genetic testing approach. Of the 38 patients, 30 patients from 22 unrelated families with deep-intronic DMD variants underwent a detailed clinical and imaging assessment.

RESULTS

Nineteen different deep-intronic DMD variants were identified in the 30 patients, including 15 with Duchenne muscular dystrophy (DMD), 14 with Becker muscular dystrophy (BMD), and one with X-linked dilated cardiomyopathy. Of the 19 variants, 15 were single-nucleotide variants, 2 were structural variants (SVs), and 2 were pure-intronic large-scale SVs causing aberrant inclusion of other protein-coding genes sequences into the mature DMD transcripts. The trefoil with single fruit sign was observed in 18 patients and the concentric fatty infiltration pattern was observed in 2 patients. Remarkable phenotypic heterogeneity was observed not only in skeletal but also cardiac muscle involvement in 2 families harboring a same deep-intronic variant. Different skeletal muscle involvement between families with a same variant was observed in 4 families. High inter-individual phenotypic heterogeneity was observed within two BMD families and one DMD family.

CONCLUSIONS

Our study first highlights the variable phenotypic expressivity of deep-intronic DMD variants and demonstrates a new class of deep-intronic DMD variants, i.e., pure-intronic SVs involving other protein-coding genes.

SpliceVault predicts the precise nature of variant-associated mis-splicing

Even for essential splice-site variants that are almost guaranteed to alter mRNA splicing, no current method can reliably predict whether exon-skipping, cryptic activation or multiple events will result, greatly complicating clinical interpretation of pathogenicity. Strikingly, ranking the four most common unannotated splicing events across 335,663 reference RNA-sequencing (RNA-seq) samples (300K-RNA Top-4) predicts the nature of variant-associated mis-splicing with 92% sensitivity. The 300K-RNA Top-4 events correctly identify 96% of exon-skipping events and 86% of cryptic splice sites for 140 clinical cases subject to RNA testing, showing higher sensitivity and positive predictive value than SpliceAI. Notably, RNA re-analyses showed we had missed 300K-RNA Top-4 events for several clinical cases tested before the development of this empirical predictive method. Simply, mis-splicing events that happen around a splice site in RNA-seq data are those most likely to be activated by a splice-site variant. The SpliceVault web portal allows users easy access to 300K-RNA for informed splice-site variant interpretation and classification.

Tissue- and cell-specific whole-transcriptome meta-analysis from brain and retina reveals differential expression of dystrophin complexes and new dystrophin spliced isoforms

The large DMD gene encodes a group of dystrophin proteins in brain and retina, produced from multiple promoters and alternative splicing events. Dystrophins are core components of different scaffolding complexes in distinct cell types. Their absence may thus alter several cellular pathways, which might explain the heterogeneous genotype-phenotype relationships underlying central comorbidities in Duchenne muscular dystrophy (DMD). However, the cell-specific expression of dystrophins and associated proteins (DAPs) is still largely unknown. The present study provides a first RNA-Seq-based reference showing tissue- and cell-specific differential expression of dystrophins, splice variants and DAPs in mouse brain and retina. We report that a cell type may express several dystrophin complexes, perhaps due to expression in separate cell subdomains and/or subpopulations, some of which with differential expression at different maturation stages. We also identified new splicing events in addition to the common exon-skipping events. These include a new exon within intron 51 (E51b) in frame with the flanking exons in retina, as well as inclusions of intronic sequences with stop codons leading to the presence of transcripts with elongated exons 40 and/or 41 (E40e, E41e) in both retina and brain. PCR validations revealed that the new exons may affect several dystrophins. Moreover, immunoblot experiments using a combination of specific antibodies and dystrophin-deficient mice unveiled that the transcripts with stop codons are translated into truncated proteins lacking their C-terminus, which we called N-Dp427 and N-Dp260. This study thus uncovers a range of new findings underlying the complex neurobiology of DMD.

Intron mutations and early transcription termination in Duchenne and Becker muscular dystrophy

DMD pathogenic variants for Duchenne and Becker muscular dystrophy are detectable with high sensitivity by standard clinical exome analyses of genomic DNA. However, up to 7% of DMD mutations are deep intronic and analysis of muscle-derived RNA is an important diagnostic step for patients who have negative genomic testing but abnormal dystrophin expression in muscle. In this study, muscle biopsies were evaluated from 19 patients with clinical features of a dystrophinopathy, but negative clinical DMD mutation analysis. Reverse transcription-polymerase chain reaction or high-throughput RNA sequencing methods identified 19 mutations with one of three pathogenic pseudoexon types: deep intronic point mutations, deletions or insertions, and translocations. In association with point mutations creating intronic splice acceptor sites, we observed the first examples of DMD pseudo 3'-terminal exon mutations causing high efficiency transcription termination within introns. This connection between splicing and premature transcription termination is reminiscent of U1 snRNP-mediating telescripting in sustaining RNA polymerase II elongation across large genes, such as DMD. We propose a novel classification of three distinct types of mutations identifiable by muscle RNA analysis, each of which differ in potential treatment approaches. Recognition and appropriate characterization may lead to therapies directed toward full-length dystrophin expression for some patients.

Rapid identification of human muscle disease with fibre optic Raman spectroscopy

We demonstrate the use of fibre optic Raman spectroscopy for the rapid identification of muscle disorders.

Standardized practices for RNA diagnostics using clinically accessible specimens reclassifies 75% of putative splicing variants

PURPOSE

Genetic variants causing aberrant premessenger RNA splicing are increasingly being recognized as causal variants in genetic disorders. In this study, we devise standardized practices for polymerase chain reaction (PCR)-based RNA diagnostics using clinically accessible specimens (blood, fibroblasts, urothelia, biopsy).

METHODS

A total of 74 families with diverse monogenic conditions (31% prenatal-congenital onset, 47% early childhood, and 22% teenage-adult onset) were triaged into PCR-based RNA testing, with comparative RNA sequencing for 19 cases.

RESULTS

Informative RNA assay data were obtained for 96% of cases, enabling variant reclassification for 75% variants that can be used for genetic counseling (71%), to inform clinical care (32%) and prenatal counseling (41%). Variant-associated mis-splicing was highly reproducible for 28 cases with samples from ≥2 affected individuals or heterozygotes and 10 cases with ≥2 biospecimens. PCR amplicons encompassing another segregated heterozygous variant was vital for clinical interpretation of 22 of 79 variants to phase RNA splicing events and discern complete from partial mis-splicing.

CONCLUSION

RNA diagnostics enabled provision of a genetic diagnosis for 64% of recruited cases. PCR-based RNA diagnostics has capacity to analyze 81.3% of clinically significant genes, with long amplicons providing an advantage over RNA sequencing to phase RNA splicing events. The Australasian Consortium for RNA Diagnostics (SpliceACORD) provide clinically-endorsed, standardized protocols and recommendations for interpreting RNA assay data.

Diagnostic muscle biopsies in the era of genetics: the added value of myopathology in a selection of limb-girdle muscular dystrophy patients

In the second most common dystrophy associated with predominant pelvic and shoulder girdle muscle weakness termed Limb-Girdle Muscular Dystrophy (LGMD), genetic complexity, large phenotypic variability, and clinical overlap can result in extensive diagnostic delays in certain individuals. In view of the large strides genetics has taken in this day and age, we address the question if muscle biopsies can still provide diagnostic evidence of substance for these patients. We reviewed and reanalyzed muscle biopsy characteristics in a cohort of LGMD patient pairs in which gene variants were picked up in CAPN3, FKRP, TTN, and ANO5, using histochemical-immunohistochemical-and immunofluorescent staining, and western blotting. We found that not the nature and severity of inflammatory changes, but the changed properties of the dystrophin complex were the most valuable assets to differentiate LGMD from myositis. Proteomic evaluation brought both primary and secondary deficiencies to light, which could be equally revealing for diagnosis. Though a muscle biopsy might, at present, not always be strictly necessary anymore, it still represents an irrefutable asset when the genetic diagnosis is complicated.

WGS and RNA Studies Diagnose Noncoding DMD Variants in Males With High Creatine Kinase

Objective

To describe the diagnostic utility of whole-genome sequencing and RNA studies in boys with suspected dystrophinopathy, for whom multiplex ligation-dependent probe amplification and exomic parallel sequencing failed to yield a genetic diagnosis, and to use remnant normal DMD splicing in 3 families to define critical levels of wild-type dystrophin bridging clinical spectrums of Duchenne to myalgia.

Methods

Exome, genome, and/or muscle RNA sequencing was performed for 7 males with elevated creatine kinase. PCR of muscle-derived complementary DNA (cDNA) studied consequences for DMD premessenger RNA (pre-mRNA) splicing. Quantitative Western blot was used to determine levels of dystrophin, relative to control muscle.

Results

Splice-altering intronic single nucleotide variants or structural rearrangements in DMD were identified in all 7 families. Four individuals, with abnormal splicing causing a premature stop codon and nonsense-mediated decay, expressed remnant levels of normally spliced DMD mRNA. Quantitative Western blot enabled correlation of wild-type dystrophin and clinical severity, with 0%-5% dystrophin conferring a Duchenne phenotype, 10% ± 2% a Becker phenotype, and 15% ± 2% dystrophin associated with myalgia without manifesting weakness.

Conclusions

Whole-genome sequencing relied heavily on RNA studies to identify DMD splice-altering variants. Short-read RNA sequencing was regularly confounded by the effectiveness of nonsense-mediated mRNA decay and low read depth of the giant DMD mRNA. PCR of muscle cDNA provided a simple, yet informative approach. Highly relevant to genetic therapies for dystrophinopathies, our data align strongly with previous studies of mutant dystrophin in Becker muscular dystrophy, with the collective conclusion that a fractional increase in levels of normal dystrophin between 5% and 20% is clinically significant.

X-Linked Duchenne-Type Muscular Dystrophy in Jack Russell Terrier Associated with a Partial Deletion of the Canine DMD Gene

A 9-month old male Jack Russell Terrier started showing paraparesis of the hindlimbs after a walk. Hospitalized, the dog went into cardiac arrest, and later died. Necroscopic examination revealed a severe thickness of the diaphragm, esophagus, and base of the tongue, leading to the diagnosis of muscular dystrophy. The histology confirmed the marked size variation, regeneration, and fibrosis replacement of the skeletal muscle fibers. Immunohistochemistry demonstrated the absence of dystrophin confirming the diagnosis. Transmission electron microscopy showed disarrangement of skeletal muscle fibers. Finally, whole-genome sequencing identified a ~368kb deletion spanning 19 exons of the canine dystrophin (DMD) gene. This pathogenic loss-of-function variant most likely explains the observed disease phenotype. The X-chromosomal variant was absent in seven controls of the same breed. Most likely, this partial deletion of the DMD gene was either transmitted on the maternal path within the family of the affected dog or arose de novo. This study revealed a spontaneous partial deletion in DMD gene in a Jack Russell Terrier showing a Duchenne-type muscular dystrophy due to non-functional dystrophin.

Pathogenic deep intronic MTM1 variant activates a pseudo-exon encoding a nonsense codon resulting in severe X-linked myotubular myopathy

X-linked myotubular myopathy (XLMTM) is a severe congenital myopathy characterised by generalised weakness and respiratory insufficiency. XLMTM is associated with pathogenic variants in MTM1; a gene encoding the lipid phosphatase myotubularin. Whole genome sequencing (WGS) of an exome-negative male proband with severe hypotonia, respiratory insufficiency and centralised nuclei on muscle biopsy identified a deep intronic MTM1 variant NG_008199.1(NM_000252.2):c.1468-577A>G, which strengthened a cryptic 5' splice site (A>G substitution at the +5 position). Muscle RNA sequencing was non-diagnostic due to low read depth. Reverse transcription PCR (RT-PCR) of muscle RNA confirmed the c.1468-577A>G variant activates inclusion of a pseudo-exon encoding a premature stop codon into all detected MTM1 transcripts. Western blot analysis establishes deficiency of myotubularin protein, consistent with the severe XLMTM phenotype. We expand the genotypic spectrum of XLMTM and highlight benefits of screening non-coding regions of MTM1 in male probands with phenotypically concordant XLMTM who remain undiagnosed following exome sequencing.