Observer variability in the evaluation of dual-isotope Tl-201/Tc-99m sestamibi rest/stress myocardial perfusion SPECT in men and women with known or suspected stable angina pectoris

Site qualification and clinical interpretation standards for 99mTc-SPECT perfusion imaging in a multi-center study of MITNEC (Medical Imaging Trials Network of Canada)

BACKGROUND

Qualification and interpretation standards are essential for establishing 99mTc-SPECT MPI accuracy vs. alternative modalities.

METHODS

Rest-stress 99mTc-SPECT phantom scans were acquired on 35 cameras. LV defects were quantified with summed stress (SSS) and difference scores (SDS) at 2 core labs. SDS ≥ 2 in the right coronary artery (RCA) was the qualifying standard. Twenty rest (R)-stress (S) patient images were acquired on qualified cameras and interpreted by core labs. Global scoring differences > 3 between labs or discordant clinical interpretations underwent review. Scoring, interpretation, image quality, and diagnostic parameter agreement were assessed.

RESULTS

Phantom scans: visual scoring confirmed RCA-ischemia on all cameras. Regional SSS, SDS agreement was moderate to very good: ICC-r = 0.57, 0.84. Patient scans: 90% of global SSS, 85% of SDS differences were ≤ 3. Regional SSS, SDS agreement: ICC-r = 0.87, 0.86, and global abnormal (SSS ≥ 4) and ischemic (SDS ≥ 2) interpretation: ICC-r = 0.90 were excellent. Clinical interpretation agreement was 100% following review. Image quality agreement was 70%. Automated metrics also agreed: ischemic total perfusion deficit ICC-r = 0.75, reversible perfusion defect, transient ischemic dilation, and S-R LV ejection fraction ICC-r ≥ 0.90.

CONCLUSION

Quantitative scoring and interpretation of scans were highly repeatable with site qualification and clinical interpretation standardization, indicating that dual-core lab interpretation is appropriate to determine 99mTc-SPECT MPI accuracy.

Lack of Concordance Between Local Investigators, Angiographic Core Laboratory, and Clinical Event Committee in the Assessment of Stent Thrombosis: Results From the TRACER Angiographic Substudy

BACKGROUND

Stent thrombosis (ST) is an important end point in cardiovascular clinical trials. Adjudication is traditionally based on clinical event committee (CEC) review of case report forms and source documentation rather than angiograms. However, the degree to which this method of adjudication is concordant with the review of independent angiographic core laboratories (ACLs) has not been studied. This report represents the first assessment of variability between local investigators (LIs), a CEC, and an ACL.

METHODS AND RESULTS

Serial angiograms of 329 patients with acute coronary syndrome without ST-segment-elevation who underwent percutaneous coronary intervention at entry in the Trial to Assess the Effects of Vorapaxar in Preventing Heart Attack and Stroke in Particpants With Acute Coronary Syndrome (TRACER) and who met criteria for possible ST subsequent to the index event were reviewed by an ACL. The ACL was blinded to the assessment by both LIs and the CEC regarding the presence or absence of ST. CEC adjudication was based on Academic Research Consortium definitions of ST, using case report form data and source documents, including catheterization laboratory reports. The ACL, CEC, and LIs agreed on the presence or absence of ST in 52.9% events (κ=0.32; 95% confidence interval, 0.26-0.39). The ACL and CEC agreed on 82.7% of events (κ=0.57; 95% confidence interval, 0.47-0.67); the ACL and LIs agreed on 61.1% of events (κ=0.25; 95% confidence interval, 0.16-0.34); and the CEC and LIs agreed on 62% of events (κ=0.28; 95% confidence interval, 0.21-0.36).

CONCLUSIONS

ST reporting by an ACL, a CEC, and LIs is discordant. The assessment of ST is more often detected by direct review of angiograms by an ACL.

CLINICAL TRIAL REGISTRATION

URL: http://www.clinicaltrials.gov. Unique identifier: NCT00527943.

The use of pre-test and post-test probability values as criteria before selecting patients to undergo coronary angiography in patients who have ischemic findings on myocardial perfusion scintigraphy

Objective:

Myocardial perfusion scintigraphy (MPS) is a diagnostic test which is frequently used in the diagnosis of coronary heart disease (CHD). MPS is generally interpreted as ischemia present or absent; however, it has a power in predicting the disease, similar to other diagnostic tests. In this study, we aimed to assist in directing the high-risk patients to undergo coronary angiography (CA) primarily by evaluating patients without prior CHD history with pre-test and post-test probabilities.

Methods:

The study was designed as a retrospective study. Between January 2008 and July 2011, 139 patients with positive MPS results and followed by CA recently (<6 months) were evaluated from patient files. Patients’ pre-test probabilities based on the Diamond and Forrester method and the likelihood ratios that were obtained from the literature were used to calculate the patients’ post-exercise and post-MPS probabilities. Patients were evaluated in risk groups as low, intermediate, and high, and an ROC curve analysis was performed for the post-MPS probabilities.

Results:

Coronary artery stenosis (CAS) was determined in 59 patients (42.4%). A significant difference was determined between the risk groups according to CAS, both for the pre-test and post-test probabilities (p<0.001, p=0.024). The ROC analysis provided a cut-off value of 80.4% for post-MPS probability in predicting CAS with 67.9% sensitivity and 77.8% specificity.

Conclusion:

When the post-MPS probability is ≥80% in patients who have reversible perfusion defects on MPS, we suggest interpreting the MPS as “high probability positive” to improve the selection of true-positive patients to undergo CA, and these patients should be primarily recommended CA.

Clinical interpretation standards and quality assurance for the multicenter PET/CT trial rubidium-ARMI

Rubidium-ARMI ((82)Rb as an Alternative Radiopharmaceutical for Myocardial Imaging) is a multicenter trial to evaluate the accuracy, outcomes, and cost-effectiveness of low-dose (82)Rb perfusion imaging using 3-dimensional (3D) PET/CT technology. Standardized imaging protocols are essential to ensure consistent interpretation.

METHODS

Cardiac phantom qualifying scans were obtained at 7 recruiting centers. Low-dose (10 MBq/kg) rest and pharmacologic stress (82)Rb PET scans were obtained in 25 patients at each site. Summed stress scores, summed rest scores, and summed difference scores (SSS, SRS, and SDS [respectively] = SSS-SRS) were evaluated using 17-segment visual interpretation with a discretized color map. All scans were coread at the core lab (University of Ottawa Heart Institute) to assess agreement of scoring, clinical diagnosis, and image quality. Scoring differences greater than 3 underwent a third review to improve consensus. Scoring agreement was evaluated with intraclass correlation coefficient (ICC-r), concordance of clinical interpretation, and image quality using κ coefficient and percentage agreement. Patient (99m)Tc and (201)Tl SPECT scans (n = 25) from 2 centers were analyzed similarly for comparison to (82)Rb.

RESULTS

Qualifying scores of SSS = 2, SDS = 2, were achieved uniformly at all imaging sites on 9 different 3D PET/CT scanners. Patient scores showed good agreement between core and recruiting sites: ICC-r = 0.92, 0.77 for SSS, SDS. Eighty-five and eighty-seven percent of SSS and SDS scores, respectively, had site-core differences of 3 or less. After consensus review, scoring agreement improved to ICC-r = 0.97, 0.96 for SSS, SDS (P < 0.05). The agreement of normal versus abnormal (SSS ≥ 4) and nonischemic versus ischemic (SDS ≥ 2) studies was excellent: ICC-r = 0.90 and 0.88. Overall interpretation showed excellent agreement, with a κ = 0.94. Image quality was perceived differently by the site versus core reviewers (90% vs. 76% good or better; P < 0.05). By comparison, scoring agreement of the SPECT scans was ICC-r = 0.82, 0.72 for SSS, SDS. Seventy-six and eighty-eight percent of SSS and SDS scores, respectively, had site-core differences of 3 or less. Consensus review again improved scoring agreement to ICC-r = 0.97, 0.90 for SSS, SDS (P < 0.05).

CONCLUSION

(82)Rb myocardial perfusion imaging protocols were implemented with highly repeatable interpretation in centers using 3D PET/CT technology, through an effective standardization and quality assurance program. Site scoring of (82)Rb PET myocardial perfusion imaging scans was found to be in good agreement with core lab standards, suggesting that the data from these centers may be combined for analysis of the rubidium-ARMI endpoints.

Can preoperative myocardial perfusion scintigraphy predict changes in left ventricular perfusion and function after coronary artery bypass graft surgery?

OBJECTIVES We wanted to evaluate whether preoperative myocardial perfusion scintigraphy (MPS) could predict changes in cardiac symptoms and postoperative myocardial perfusion and left ventricular function after coronary artery bypass grafting (CABG). METHODS Ninety-two patients with stable angina pectoris (and at least one occluded coronary artery) underwent MPS before, and 6 months after, undergoing CABG. The result of the MPS was kept secret from the surgeons. RESULTS Before CABG, 90% of the patients had angina. After CABG, 97% of the patients were without symptoms. Overall graft patency was 84%. Before CABG, one patient had normal perfusion; in the rest of them the defects were classified as follows: reversible (60%), partly reversible (27%) and irreversible (12%). Following CABG, 33% had normal perfusion; in the rest the defects were reversible in 29%, partly reversible in 12% and irreversible in 26%. Left ventricular ejection fraction (LVEF), which was normal before operation in 45%, improved in 40% of all patients. The increase in LVEF was not related to the preoperative pattern of perfusion defects. Of 30 patients with normalized perfusion after CABG, 29 (97%) had reversible defects and one patient had partly reversible defects. Of 83 perfusion defects, which were normalized after CABG, 67 were reversible (81%) or partly reversible (12%). Seventy-five percent of all reversible coronary artery territories before CABG were normalized after operation. CONCLUSIONS Our results indicate that reversible or partly reversible perfusion defects at a preoperative MPS have a high chance of normalized myocardial perfusion assessed by MPS 6 months after operation. Normal perfusion is obtained almost exclusively in territories with reversible ischaemia. Symptoms improved in nearly all patients and LVEF in a significant fraction of the patients, not related to preoperative MPS.

Significant association of female gender with lower degree of pathological 99mTc-sestamibi scintigraphy results as well as higher cardiac-related deaths free survival in elderly patients

BACKGROUND

The aim of the present study was to assess the impact of female gender on the extent of myocardial perfusion defects as revealed by (99m)Tc-sestamibi myocardial perfusion scintigraphy (MPS) and on emerging cardiac events (CE) in patients aged ≥ 70 years.

PATIENTS AND METHODS

86 patients aged ≥ 70 years with known or suspected CAD undergoing MPS (74.4 ± 3.2 years; women: n = 46; 53.5%) were included in this study. Semiquantitative analysis of MPS was performed and summed stress (SSS), summed difference (SDS), and summed rest scores (SRS) were calculated. Emerging CE comprised myocardial revascularization and -infarction and cardiac-related death. Multivariate regression analysis was performed to assess the independent prognostic impact of several patient related variables on MPS results. Kaplan-Meier- and log rank analyses were calculated for assessment of CE free survival as related to gender.

RESULTS

Normal SSS (87.0% vs. 27.5%; p < 0.0001), SDS (80.4% vs. 27.5%; p < 0.0001), and SRS (97.8% vs. 82.5%; p = 0.023) were significantly more often found in women, whereas incidence of mildly and severely impaired SSS (6.5% vs. 35%; p = 0.001 and 2.2% vs. 25%; p = 0.002, respectively) and SDS (15.2% vs. 52.5%; p < 0.0001 and 2.2% vs. 17.5%; p = 0.023, respectively) were significantly higher in men. Multivariate logistic regression analysis revealed female gender as an independent predictor of normal SSS (odds ratio/OR: 17.6) and SDS (OR: 53.3). Female gender was associated with a significant higher cardiac-death free survival compared to male patients (p = 0.031).

CONCLUSION

Female gender is independently associated with a significantly lower degree of pathological MPS results and a higher cardiac-death free survival in elderly patients.

Comparison between dobutamine echocardiography and single-photon emission computed tomography for interpretive reproducibility

Interpretive variability of dobutamine stress echocardiography (DSE) and stress single-photon emission computed tomography (SPECT) has been previously investigated. However, no study has directly compared the variability of these techniques in the same patient population. We directly compared the interpretive reproducibility of DSE and stress SPECT in patients undergoing both types of pharmacologic stress imaging. Before discharge, simultaneous DSE and SPECT was performed in 56 patients early after a first acute myocardial infarction. Intra- and interobserver concordances were evaluated by exact agreement and kappa statistic. Intraclass coefficient of correlation was used to assess intra- and interobserver reproducibilities of segmental score analysis. Intraobserver agreement percentages in the identification of patients with ischemia were 98% for SPECT and 91% for DSE (p = NS) and kappa values were excellent (>0.80) for both techniques. Interobserver agreement was higher (p <0.01) for SPECT (96%) than for DSE (79%). Similarly, kappa value was excellent for SPECT (0.92) and only moderate for DSE (0.56). Finally, the intraclass coefficients of correlation for intra- and interobserver reproducibilities were higher for SPECT (0.98 and 0.97, respectively) than for DSE (0.80 and 0.71, respectively; p <0.001 for both). In conclusion, after uncomplicated acute myocardial infarction, stress SPECT imaging has a better interpretive reproducibility than DSE.

High probability of disease in angina pectoris patients: is clinical estimation reliable?

BACKGROUND

According to most current guidelines, stable angina pectoris patients with a high probability of having coronary artery disease can be reliably identified clinically.

OBJECTIVES

To examine the reliability of clinical evaluation with or without an at-rest electrocardiogram (ECG) in patients with a high probability of coronary artery disease.

PATIENTS AND METHODS

A prospective series of 357 patients referred for coronary angiography (CA) for suspected stable angina pectoris were examined by a trained physician who judged their type of pain and Canadian Cardiovascular Society grade of pain. Pretest likelihood of disease was estimated, and all patients underwent myocardial perfusion scintigraphy (MPS) followed by CA an average of 78 days later. For analysis, the investigators focused on the approximate groups of patients with more severe disease, ie, typical angina (n=187), Canadian Cardiovascular Society grade 2 pain or higher (n=176) or high (higher than 85%) estimated pretest likelihood of disease (n=142).

RESULTS

In the three groups, 34% to 39% of male patients and 65% to 69% of female patients had normal MPS, while 37% to 38% and 60% to 71%, respectively, had insignificant findings on CA. Of the patients who had also an abnormal at-rest ECG, 14% to 21% of men and 42% to 57% of women had normal MPS. Sex-related differences were statistically significant.

CONCLUSIONS

Clinical prediction appears to be unreliable. Addition of at-rest ECG data results in some improvement, particularly in male patients, but it makes the high probability groups so small that the addition appears to be of limited clinical relevance.

Frequency and significance of troponin T elevation in acute ischemic stroke

Elevated levels of troponin have been reported in patients with acute ischemic stroke. In this prospective study, the prevalence and characteristics of troponin elevation were examined in 244 patients with acute ischemic stroke but without overt ischemic heart disease. Troponin T (TnT) and creatine kinase-MB (CK-MB) concentrations were measured and 12-lead electrocardiograms obtained daily during the first 5 days of admission. Myocardial perfusion scintigraphy was performed in patients with TnT levels of 0.10 micro g/L and in comparable controls without elevation of TnT. Patients were followed for a mean of 19 +/- 7 months, with all-cause mortality as the clinical end point. Elevated levels of TnT (>0.03 micro g/L) and creatine kinase-MB (> or =10 micro g/L) were observed in 10% and 9% of patients, respectively. Patients with elevated TnT had higher frequencies of heart and/or renal failure. Perfusion abnormalities on myocardial perfusion scintigraphy at rest were not more frequent or pronounced in patients with TnT levels of > or =0.10 micro g/L than in the control group. Only 7 patients (3%) had elevations of TnT or creatine kinase-MB and electrocardiographic changes suggesting acute myocardial infarctions. According to univariate and multivariate analyses, elevation of TnT was significantly associated with mortality. In conclusion, elevated levels of TnT are rare in patients presenting with ischemic stroke but without overt ischemic heart disease. Heart and renal failure rather than myocardial infarction are the most likely causes. When present, elevation of TnT seems to be useful in identifying patients who are at increased risk of dying within the following 2 years.

Prognostic value of myocardial perfusion imaging in patients with known or suspected stable angina pectoris: Evaluation in a setting in which myocardial perfusion imaging did not influence the choice of treatment

OBJECTIVE

Previous investigations on the prognostic value of myocardial perfusion imaging (MPI) were performed under circumstances in which the test result was known to the patient's physician. We wanted to examine the prognostic value of MPI in patients with known or suspected stable angina in a setting in which MPI could not influence the diagnostic and therapeutic strategy.

DESIGN

A prospective series of 507 patients referred to coronary angiography for this condition were examined by MPI before angiography. Management was based on symptoms and angiographic findings, as the results of MPI were not communicated. Patients were followed for a mean of 45.3 +/- 7.7 months.

RESULTS

During follow-up, 20 patients (3.9%) suffered from myocardial infarction, 19 (3.8%) died and eight (1.6%) were revascularized >1 year after MPI resulting in a combined annual event rate of 2.5%. Patients with normal MPI had a low annual event rate of 1.6% (or 1.1% with regard to myocardial infarction or death only). In contrast, event rates in patients with reversible or mixed ischaemia were 4.0% per year. MPI added independent prognostic value to standard clinical data in a multivariate Cox model.

CONCLUSION

We could confirm that in patients with known or suspected stable angina, MPI is a valuable risk stratifying tool.

To what degree is amelioration of angina following coronary revascularization associated with improvement in myocardial perfusion?

OBJECTIVE

To examine the association between changes in chest pain and changes in perfusion following revascularization as assessed by clinical evaluation and myocardial perfusion imaging (MPI) in patients with stable angina.

DESIGN

In a prospective series of 380 patients (58.8 +/- 8.8 years) referred to angiography because of known or suspected stable angina, changes in chest discomfort and changes in perfusion after 2 years were assessed in 144 patients, who underwent revascularization, and 236, who did not. The decision to treat invasively was made without knowledge of the result of MPI.

RESULTS

In revascularized patients, the presence of typical/atypical angina was reduced from 93% to 36% and the improvement was associated with improvement in perfusion. A small improvement in perfusion induced a high frequency of change from angina to no pain, whereas a further reduction caused little extra change. In non-revascularized patients the change in chest discomfort was not related to changes in perfusion, which were rarely present.

CONCLUSION

Alleviation of chest discomfort 2 years after revascularization is associated with improvements in perfusion. This association appeared to be an all-or-nothing phenomenon. Non-revascularized patients also exhibited improvements in chest discomfort despite insignificant changes in perfusion.

Redefinition of the Q wave -- is there a clinical problem?

This study evaluated the potential consequences of the redefined joint European/American electrocardiographic criteria for an established myocardial infarction (MI). New and previous diagnostic Q-wave criteria were used in patients with stable angina pectoris. Seventy-nine patients with and 77 patients without a documented previous MI were compared using the results of myocardial perfusion imaging at rest as a reference. With the new Q-wave criteria, 71% of the former group and 40% of the latter had evidence of established MI compared with 33% and 3% when using the previous criteria (p <0.0001). Sensitivity, specificity, and positive and negative predictive values were 71%, 60%, 64%, and 67% for the new criteria versus 33%, 97%, 93%, and 59% with the previous criteria. These data suggest that that the new Q-wave criteria may be too nonspecific, resulting in an inappropriately high number of false-positive results.

Diagnostic accuracy of myocardial perfusion imaging in a study population without post-test referral bias

BACKGROUND

Most previous studies on the accuracy of myocardial perfusion imaging (MPI) are hampered by post-test referral bias, in that referral for coronary angiography was influenced by the MPI result. In this way, patients with a normal MPI result less frequently underwent catheterization, a tendency supposed to cause an underestimation of test specificity and an overestimation of test sensitivity.

METHODS AND RESULTS

MPI by use of a gated dual-isotope protocol was undertaken before angiography in 357 patients referred for angiography for suspected stable angina pectoris. The MPI reports were kept secret to prevent post-test referral bias. The MPI study was normal in 215 patients (60%) and showed reversible perfusion abnormalities in 118 (33%) and fixed defects in 24 (7%). Angiography was normal in 231 patients (65%) and revealed 1 or more significant stenoses in 126 (35%). With angiography as the reference, the sensitivity and specificity of MPI for detecting significant coronary artery stenosis were 75% and 79%, respectively.

CONCLUSIONS

In this prospective study without post-test referral bias, we found a lower sensitivity and slightly higher specificity than in studies with post-test referral bias. The imperfect accuracy may reflect differences between anatomic and physiologic imaging.

Potential impact of myocardial perfusion scintigraphy as gatekeeper for invasive examination and treatment in patients with stable angina pectoris: observational study without post-test referral bias

AIMS

To evaluate the impact of using myocardial perfusion scintigraphy (MPS) as gatekeeper for coronary angiography and revascularization in stable angina pectoris.

METHODS AND RESULTS

A prospective series of 507 out of 972 adult patients referred to coronary angiography for known or suspected stable angina pectoris underwent clinical examination followed immediately by MPS, the result of which was not communicated. MPS showed normal perfusion in 258/507 (51%) patients, reversible defects in 201/507 (40%), and fixed defects in 48/507 (9%). Of 168 revascularized patients, 27 (16%) had normal perfusion and 13 (8%) had fixed defects. Coronary angiography was undertaken in 476 patients of whom 252 (53%) had normal findings or insignificant stenoses. The same was the case in 361 (41%) out of the 883 of the 972 consecutive patients, who had this examination. Assuming that the true rate of normal perfusion in the entire series was correspondingly lower, 48% of catheterizations and 19% of revascularizations were superfluous.

CONCLUSION

The use of MPS as gatekeeper appears to make about half of catheterizations and almost one-fifth of revascularizations redundant. Even in high-risk groups, substantial savings are possible, and the risk of overlooking patients with severe disease seems negligible.

Use of myocardial perfusion imaging to predict the effectiveness of coronary revascularisation in patients with stable angina pectoris

PURPOSE

Coronary revascularisation is the treatment of choice in patients with stable angina who have significant stenoses. From a pathophysiological point of view, however, mitigation of angina is to be expected only in the presence of reversible ischaemia. Therefore it was the aim of this study to examine the effect of revascularisation on stable angina in relation to the myocardial perfusion imaging (MPI) pattern prior to intervention.

METHODS

Three hundred and eighty-four patients (58.0+/-8.8 years) referred for angiography underwent MPI. Prior to MPI and at 2-year follow-up, patients were classified as having typical angina, atypical angina, non-cardiac chest pain or no pain, and the severity of chest pain was graded according to the Canadian Cardiovascular Society (CCS) criteria. The patients themselves estimated their pain on a visual analogue scale. Management was based on symptoms and angiographic findings, since the results of MPI were not communicated.

RESULTS

Among the 240 patients who were not revascularised, 79% had typical or atypical angina at study entrance versus 40% at follow-up. In comparison, 93% of the 144 revascularised patients had typical or atypical angina before intervention versus only 36% at follow-up. This additional advantage of invasive therapy was present only in patients with reversible defects; revascularisation had no additional effect in patients with normal perfusion or irreversible defects. Similarly, additional, significant reductions in CCS class and visual analogue score were observed exclusively in patients with reversible defects.

CONCLUSION

In patients referred for coronary angiography owing to known or suspected stable angina, revascularisation was significantly more effective than medical treatment exclusively in patients with reversible ischaemia.

Usefulness of the exercise electrocardiogram in diagnosing ischemic or coronary heart disease in patients with chest pain

We compared exercise electrocardiograms with myocardial perfusion images and coronary angiograms in 186 patients who had been referred to coronary angiography for stable angina pectoris. All had normal electrocardiographic findings at rest, and none had undergone coronary revascularization. Sensitivity, specificity, and positive and negative predictive values with the exercise electrocardiogram for prediction of reversible and/or irreversible hypoperfusion were 58%, 89%, 76%, and 77% and 70%, 88%, 72%, and 87%, respectively, for prediction of reversibility only. Corresponding values for comparison with coronary angiography were 65%, 89%, 74%, and 83%, respectively. Sensitivities were considerably lower in women than in men. Exercise electrocardiographic findings were normal in 50% of women and 25% of men who had reversible perfusion defects.