Speech Outcome of Supracricoid Partial Laryngectomy: Comparison with Total Laryngectomy and Anatomic Considerations

Analysis of swallowing and voice-related quality of life in patients after supracricoid partial laryngectomy

OBJECTIVE

This study evaluated the swallowing and voice function of laryngeal cancer patients after Supracricoid Partial Laryngectomy(SCPL), and its influence on quality of life to provide a reference for the selection of surgical methods for laryngeal cancer patients.

METHODS

Twenty-one patients who received SCPL between April 2015 and November 2021 were included. Each patient's swallowing function and quality of life were assessed through fiberoptic endoscopic examination of swallowing (FEES) and the M.D. Anderson Dysphagia Inventory (MDADI). Fundamental, jitter, shimmer, maximum phonation time (MPT), and voice handicap index-10 (VHI-10) were performed to assess voice function and voice-related quality of life.

RESULTS

The results of the FEES of the 21 patients were as follows: the rates of pharyngeal residue after swallowing solid, semiliquid, and liquid food were 0%, 28.57%, and 38.09%, respectively; the rates of laryngeal infiltration after swallowing solid, semiliquid, and liquid food were 0%, 28.57%, and 4.76%, respectively; and aspiration did not occur in any of the patients. In the evaluation of swallowing quality of life, the mean total MDADI score was 92.6 ± 6.32. The voice function evaluation showed that the mean F0, jitter, shimmer, and MPT values were 156.01 ± 120.87 (HZ), 11.57 ± 6.21 (%), 35.37 ± 14.16 (%) and 7.85 ± 6.08 (s), respectively. The mean total VHI-10 score was 7.14 ± 4.84.

CONCLUSION

SCPL provides patients with satisfactory swallowing and voice function. The patients in this study were satisfied with their quality of life in terms of swallowing and voice. SCPL can be used as a surgical method to preserve laryngeal function in patients with laryngeal cancer.

Longitudinal Voice Outcomes and Neoglottic Function After Supracricoid Partial Laryngectomy: The Development of a New Scale

OBJECTIVES

Supracricoid partial laryngectomy (SCPL) is an oncologically sound alternative to total laryngectomy that results in long-term alterations in vocal function. Little is known about long-term improvements in dysphonia and the mechanism of vocal recovery is unclear due to the lack of a standardized rating tool: The Pattern, Degree, and Vibration (PDV) Scale.

METHODS

Data from 24 individuals were compared over 3 post-operative timepoints after SCPL: 3 to 11, 12 to 35, and over 35 months. Voice outcomes were assessed using the Voice Handicap Index (VHI) and the GRBAS scale. Laryngeal exams were deidentified and rated using a novel rating scheme developed using literature review and consensus panel discussions.

RESULTS

There were significant improvements in VHI scores, Grade, and Strain over time. There was an increase in the Degree of Closure and a decline in Mucosal Vibration across timepoints. Pattern of Movement (P) was associated with dysphonia Grade. Better Degree of Closure (D) was associated with lower VHI scores and better Grade and Roughness. Mucosal Vibration (V) was associated with reduced Breathiness and Strain but variable Roughness. Age, T-stage, radiation treatment, surgery type, and time to feeding-tube removal were also associated with voicing characteristics.

CONCLUSIONS

There is evidence of improvement in several voice parameters over time after the first post-operative year. Various subcomponents of the new PDV rating scale were associated with voice outcomes. Its utility for research and clinical practice merits further investigation.

Long-term voice outcomes and quality of life after open partial horizontal laryngectomy type II vs. total laryngectomy: A cross-sectional study

OBJECTIVES

We aim to analyse long-term voice outcomes and quality of life (QoL) in patients undergoing open partial horizontal laryngectomy type II (OPHL type II) and to compare them to those obtained by patients undergoing total laryngectomy (TL) with voice prosthesis (VP).

DESIGN

Cross-sectional cohort study.

SETTING

Patients undergoing surgery for advanced laryngeal cancer, assessed during the usual follow-up consultations at the Phoniatric Unit (February 2020-December 2020).

PARTICIPANTS

Forty-five patients were enrolled and divided into two groups: OPHL group and TL group.

MAIN OUTCOMES MEASURES

Acoustic analysis, maximum phonation time, INFV₀  scale, I-SECEL, UW-QoL-V4 and MDADI questionnaires were used to assess the long-term outcomes.

RESULTS

Voices of patients undergoing OPHL Type II were worse than those of laryngectomised patients with VP. Nevertheless, scores in voice and dysphagia-related QoL were comparable and scores in the social domain of QoL were higher in OPHL group.

CONCLUSIONS

Open partial horizontal laryngectomy Type II allows an acceptable voice recovery and a satisfactory QoL.

Quality of life after Supracricoid Partial Laryngectomy

BACKGROUND

Supracricoid partial laryngectomy has good oncologic results in the treatment of advanced laryngeal cancer with the advantage of preserving larynx phonatory function when compared with total laryngectomy. However the rehabilitation could be a challenge, especially regarding swallowing function. Is supracricoid partial laryngectomy associated with better quality of life than total laryngectomy?

METHODS

Survey study that included 33 patients (16 total laryngectomy and 17 supracricoid partial laryngectomy) with advanced larynx cancer surgically treated and fully rehabilitated. The quality of life were evaluated with EORTC QLQ C30 and H&N 35 instrument.

RESULTS

Patients who underwent supracricoid partial laryngectomy obtained better scores in global health status-quality of life and general activities and had lower levels of sensory and speech-related symptoms.

CONCLUSION

SPL was associated with better quality of life when compared with TL.

Substitution Voice Rehabilitation After Open Partial Horizontal Laryngectomy Through the Proprioceptive Elastic Method (PROEL): A Preliminary Study

OBJECTIVE

The aim was to investigate the efficacy of the Proprioceptive Elastic Method (PROEL) in the rehabilitation of the substitution voice after open partial horizontal laryngectomy (OPHL).

STUDY DESIGN

Prospective outcome study.

METHODS

Fifteen patients surgically treated by OPHL type II or type III for laryngeal cancer were recruited (experimental group). Each patient underwent a specific program of voice rehabilitation based on the PROEL method with the same speech and language pathologist. Acoustic-aerodynamic analysis: maximum phonation time (MPT); spectrographic classification (Titze's modified classification), perceptual analysis (INFVo rating scale) and self-assessments (SECEL questionnaire) were performed before the treatment (T0), after 3 months of rehabilitation (T1), and at the end of the 6-month rehabilitation program (T2). A control sample of other 15 patients who underwent OPHL type II or type III and who underwent a standard perioperative rehabilitation was randomly extracted from an historical database and compared to the experimental group.

RESULTS

Significative voice improvements between T0-T1 and T2 were found for acoustic, aerodynamic, perceptual, and self-assessments analysis in the experimental group. Significative differences were found between the experimental group at T2 and the control sample for aerodynamic, self-assessment, and perceptual analysis.

CONCLUSIONS

The results of the present study support PROEL method as an effective approach for substitution voice rehabilitation after OPHL type II and III. Randomized controlled trials on larger groups of patients are needed in future in order to compare PROEL with other rehabilitative approaches.

Supracricoid Laryngectomy: The Function of the Remaining Arytenoid in Voice and Swallowing

Introduction  Supracricoid laryngectomy still has selected indications; there are few studies in the literature, and the case series are limited, a fact that stimulates the development of new studies to further elucidate the structural and functional aspects of the procedure.

Objective  To assess voice and deglutition parameters according to the number of preserved arytenoids.

Methods  Eleven patients who underwent subtotal laryngectomy with cricohyoidoepiglottopexy were evaluated by laryngeal nasofibroscopy, videofluoroscopy, and auditory-perceptual, acoustic, and voice pleasantness analyses, after resuming oral feeding.

Results  Functional abnormalities were detected in two out of the three patients who underwent arytenoidectomy, and in six patients from the remainder of the sample. Almost half of the sample presented silent laryngeal penetration and/or vallecular/hypopharyngeal stasis on the videofluoroscopy. The mean voice analysis scores indicated moderate vocal deviation, roughness and breathiness; severe strain and loudness deviation; shorter maximum phonation time; the presence of noise; and high third and fourth formant values. The voices were rated as unpleasant. There was no difference in the number and functionality of the remaining arytenoids as prognostic factors for deglutition; however, in the qualitative analysis, favorable voice and deglutition outcomes were more common among patients who did not undergo arytenoidectomy and had normal functional conditions.

Conclusion  The number and functionality of the preserved arytenoids were not found to be prognostic factors for favorable deglutition efficiency outcomes. However, the qualitative analysis showed that the preservation of both arytenoids and the absence of functional abnormalities were associated with more satisfactory voice and deglutition patterns.

Telephonic voice intelligibility after laryngeal cancer treatment: is therapeutic approach significant?

The aim was to investigate telephonic voice intelligibility in patients treated for laryngeal cancer using different approaches. In total, 90 patients treated for laryngeal cancer using different approaches and 12 healthy volunteers were recruited. Each patient and each healthy control read a list of words and sentences during a telephone call. Six auditors listened to each telephonic recording and transcribed the words and sentences they understood. Mean intelligibility rates for each treatment were assessed and compared. Regarding words, the poorest intelligibility was noted for type II open partial horizontal laryngectomies, followed by total laryngectomies. The best intelligibility was found for transoral laser microsurgery, followed by radiotherapy alone. For sentences, the poorest intelligibility was noted for type II open partial horizontal laryngectomies, followed by chemoradiotherapy. The best intelligibility was found for radiotherapy alone and transoral laser microsurgery. More aggressive surgery as well as chemoradiotherapy correlated with significantly poorer outcomes. Transoral laser microsurgery or radiotherapy alone ensured the best telephonic voice intelligibility. Intermediate-advanced T stages at diagnosis also showed significantly poorer intelligibility outcomes, suggesting that T stage represents an independent negative prognostic factor for voice intelligibility after treatment.

Laringectomias supracricóides: revisão de literatura em protocolos de qualidade de vida

RESUMO: A Laringectomia Parcial Supracricóide (LPSC) é indicada para tratamento de tumores com estadiamento1 e 2 e certos casos de tumores avançados. É considerada pela literatura como apresentando resultados satisfatórios em ambas situações, preservação da laringe e funcionalidade. Este estudo tem como objetivo rever de forma sistemática a literatura voltada para qualidade de vida em voz de pacientes submetidos a LPSC, identificando-se os protocolos de qualidade de vida em câncer de cabeça e pescoço. Para a revisão de literatura sistemática exploratória foram considerados os seguintes bancos de dados: MEDLINE, SciELO, LILACS; PubMed. Utilizados descritores em português, inglês e espanhol. A seleção dos artigos seguiu critérios de inclusão, para aplicação de teste de Relevância. Esta revisão de literatura revelou que os protocolos específicos para pacientes oncológicos de cabeça e pescoço mais utilizados são o EORTC-C30/H&N35, UW-QOL e HNQOL. A LPSC embora seja considerada uma cirurgia que vise à preservação das funções de deglutição e fonação é apontada como tendo possibilidade de permanência de queixas em tais funções. A literatura afirma que os pacientes se declaram satisfeitos com a própria voz, tendo pouca dificuldade para se comunicar de forma inteligível. Estudos relacionam pacientes com dificuldades respiratórias após LPSC, inclusive com apneia obstrutiva do sono. Conclui-se que há necessidade de mais pesquisas que visem pontuar as dificuldades resultantes da LPSC e que utilizem protocolos específicos em cabeça e pescoço, para melhor mostrar o impacto da LPSC na qualidade de vida.

Structured review of papers reporting specific functions in patients with cancer of the head and neck: 2006 - 2013

Health-related quality of life (HRQoL) focuses on 4 core domains: physical and psychological function, social interaction, disease, and treatment-related symptoms, and is a key outcome in patients with cancer of the head and neck. We reviewed papers published between 2006 and 2013 that used validated questionnaires to report functional outcome in this group. A total of 572 papers were identified and 118 of them concerned function. Specific outcomes included anxiety, chewing, maxillectomy, mucositis, pain, shoulder function, and trismus. The specific functions most often identified were xerostomia, speech or voice, and swallowing or dysphagia. A considerable body of evidence has now accumulated on HRQoL and functional outomes although the precise role of HRQoL during the planning of treatment remains controversial. Over time, the emphasis of the studies included has tended to move away from the reporting of outcomes in general to more hypothesis-driven and group-specific work.

Long-term functional results after open partial horizontal laryngectomy type IIa and type IIIa: A comparison study

BACKGROUND

The purpose of this study was to compare long-term swallowing, voice results, and quality of life (QOL) after open partial horizontal laryngectomy (OPHL) type IIa and type IIIa.

METHODS

Twenty-three patients after OPHL type IIa and 18 patients after OPHL type IIIa were involved. Swallowing skills and neoglottis' motility and vibrations were videoendoscopically assessed. Aerodynamic measures, spectrogram analysis, aspiration pneumonia, body weight variations, and voice perceptual assessment were performed. Generic voice-related and swallowing-related QOL were assessed. Data were statistically compared using Mann-Whitney U test or Fisher exact tests, as appropriate.

RESULTS

Significant differences were found only for the residue with solids and for the intelligibility (I) parameter of the overall quality impression and intelligibility, additive and unnecessary noise, speech fluency, and presence of voiced segments scale with patients of the OPHL type IIIa group showing worse performances than the OPHL type IIa group.

CONCLUSION

Patients who underwent OPHL type IIa and type IIIa show comparable long-term functional outcomes. OPHL type IIIa represents a valid surgical alternative to OPHL type IIa. © 2015 Wiley Periodicals, Inc. Head Neck 38: E1427-E1435, 2016.

Quality of Life After Conservation Surgery for Laryngeal Cancer

Quality of life preservation has become an essential goal of treatment in the management of laryngeal carcinoma. Although established treatments of reference such as total laryngectomy and chemoradiation protocols have focused on survival and anatomic preservation of the larynx, they still generate considerable functional morbidity with detrimental effects on quality of life. Transoral and transcervical partial laryngectomy techniques can offer significant advantages when used prudently after proper patient selection. The growing relevance of those techniques in the management of advanced and recurrent laryngeal carcinoma deserves particular attention, with potential for improved quality of life without compromising oncologic outcomes.

Swallowing, voice, and quality of life after supratracheal laryngectomy: preliminary long-term results

BACKGROUND

The purpose of this study was to report preliminary long-term outcomes after supratracheal laryngectomy (STL).

METHODS

Twenty-two male patients who underwent STL were involved in this study. Swallowing skills, neoglottis motility, and vibrations were videoendoscopically assessed. Aerodynamic measures, spectrogram analysis, aspiration pneumonia, body weight variations, and voice perceptual assessment were performed. Generic, voice-related, and swallowing-related quality of life (QOL) were assessed.

RESULTS

Aspiration was found in 10, 2, and 5 patients, respectively, for liquids, semisolids, and solids. Neoglottis motility was generally preserved, whereas vibration was impaired. Aerodynamic measures showed a poor performance. Perceptual assessment revealed highly dysphonic voices. In only 8 patients, a harmonic structure was visible in the spectrograms. Aspiration pneumonia occurred in 2 patients. Preoperative weight was maintained in 16 patients. Generic, voice-related, and swallowing-related QOL revealed satisfied patients.

CONCLUSION

After STL, swallowing was sufficiently restored and QOL was satisfactory, whereas the voice was severely impaired even if oral communication was well preserved.

Multidimensional evaluation of vocal function after supracricoid laryngectomy with cricohyoidopexy

OBJECTIVES

The aim of this study was to assess the vocal outcome and the impact of arytenoid resection on vocal function following supracricoid laryngectomy with cricohyoidopexy.

METHODS

Twenty-eight male patients who had undergone supracricoid laryngectomy with cricohyoidopexy were included in the study. In 7 patients, one arytenoid cartilage had been totally resected; in 11, both arytenoid cartilages had been preserved; and in 10, one arytenoid cartilage had been partially resected. The maximum phonation time, fundamental frequency, jitter, shimmer, and noise-to-harmonics ratio were assessed and analyzed. Perceptual analysis was performed with the grade, roughness, breathiness, asthenia, and strain (GRBAS) scale. Abduction-adduction and anteroposterior squeezing actions were analyzed from videoendoscopic records. The Voice Handicap Index-10 (VHI-10) was used for self-assessment.

RESULTS

The acoustic and aerodynamic parameters and GRBAS score showed severe impairment. The self-assessment revealed that patients were relatively satisfied with their voice quality. There were no statistically significant differences in the acoustic and aerodynamic parameters, the GRBAS score, or the VHI-10 score according to the level of arytenoid resection.

CONCLUSIONS

Supracricoid laryngectomy with cricohyoidopexy caused deterioration of acoustic and aerodynamic voice parameters and the GRBAS score. Statistically, the level of arytenoid resection had no apparent effect on the objective, perceptual, or subjective voice parameters.

Quality of voice evaluation in patients treated by supracricoid laryngectomy and modified supracricoid laryngectomy

OBJECTIVE

To compare quality of voice in patients treated by supracricoid laryngectomy and patients treated by modified supracricoid laryngectomy using the sternohyoid muscle for neoglottis reconstruction.

STUDY DESIGN

Case series. Setting. Teaching hospital.

SUBJECTS AND METHODS

This study was performed between 2004 and 2008 on 28 consecutive patients affected by T1b-T2 laryngeal carcinoma. Eleven patients were treated by supracricoid laryngectomy, and 17 patients were treated by modified supracricoid laryngectomy. For each patient, postoperative parameters such as decannulation time, nasogastric feeding tube, and length of hospitalization were noted. Vocal function, Voice Handicap Index scores, and perceptual voice analysis scores on intelligibility, noise, fluency, and voice scale were evaluated.

RESULTS

The postoperative course of the patients treated by modified supracricoid laryngectomy was similar to patients treated by supracricoid laryngectomy. No delay in the length of hospitalization was detected in patients undergoing surgery with the new technique. A significant difference was detected in the nasogastric tube removal time and decannulation time. The data from intelligibility, noise, fluency, and voice scale analyses revealed a better quality of voice in patients treated by modified supracricoid partial laryngectomy with a significant difference in intelligibility, fluency, and voicing. The Voice Handicap Index mean value of physical, functional, and emotional subscales confirmed patients' perceptions of a minor voice handicap in patients treated by modified supracricoid laryngectomy, with a significant difference on the physical subscale.

CONCLUSION

Modified supracricoid laryngectomy seems to be a good way to improve quality of voice and quality of life in patients with early laryngeal cancer.