Comparison of screw versus locked plate fixation for Scarf osteotomy treatment of hallux valgus

Additional Akin Proximal Phalanx Procedure Has a Limited Effect on the Outcome of Scarf Osteotomy for Hallux Valgus Surgery

BACKGROUND

One of the most common supplementary techniques for hallux valgus (HV) surgery is proximal phalanx correction proposed by Akin. This study aims to determine the influence of the Akin procedure on the outcome of scarf osteotomy for HV correction.

METHODS

This prospective randomized study on 145 patients diagnosed with moderate to severe HV who underwent a scarf corrective osteotomy was carried out between 2011 and 2016. Patients were divided into two groups based on the additional Akin correction of the proximal phalanx. Postoperative follow-up was 2 years. The patients underwent an examination performed by two orthopedic surgeons twice-at the primary visit (qualification for the surgery and the study) and at the final follow-up. In between, the patients remained under the care of one of the physicians. Data collected included biometric records, radiographs (eg, hallux valgus angle [HVA]), intermetatarsal angle, American Orthopaedic Foot & Ankle Society Hallux Metatarsophalangeal Index, and visual analog scale score for pain and satisfaction.

RESULTS

There was a significant difference in comparison of the HVA between the groups at the final follow-up. Other collected parameters were similar (American Orthopaedic Foot & Ankle Society Hallux Metatarsophalangeal Index, level of pain, and satisfaction). The complication rate was also similar between the groups. We observed comparable rates of reconsent to the treatment and foot appearance satisfaction in both groups.

CONCLUSIONS

Regardless of additional Akin correction, the outcome was comparable. Despite a significant difference in HVA score, pain and satisfaction level were similar. Based on our results, the Akin procedure may not provide substantial benefit as an adjunct to the scarf procedure.

Does screwless scarf osteotomy for hallux valgus increase the risk of transfer metatarsalgia?

INTRODUCTION

The scarf osteotomy is a reliable surgical technique for treating hallux valgus. The aim of our study was to analyze the occurrence of transfer metatarsalgia after surgery on the first ray using a screwless Scarf osteotomy technique that we have been using in our department since 1995, which consists of stabilization by axial impaction without internal fixation. We hypothesized that the alleged shortening of the first metatarsal produced by this technique may be at the origin of postoperative metatarsalgia.

PATIENTS AND METHODS

This was a case series of first ray metatarsal screwless Scarf osteotomies reviewed in the medium term. We did a clinical and radiological review of all patients operated using this technique between 2012 and 2017 who did not meet the following exclusion criteria: procedure on the other lateral metatarsals, concurrent hindfoot pathology, incomplete medical records.

RESULTS

Of 114 feet, 96 were included in the study and 18 were excluded. The mean follow-up was 1 year and 8 months [1-4years]. The mean AOFAS score was 90.3 and 96% of patients were either satisfied or very satisfied with the outcome. All the parameters improved significantly: shoe wearing, pain, function, alignment. Fourteen feet had transfer metatarsalgia, which appeared during the first year postoperative (AOFAS 75/100). Ten other complications occurred: two Morton's neuromas, three cases of complex regional pain syndrome, one superficial infection, one paresthesia, two recurrences with surgical revision, one nonunion. No general complications were found. Based on radiographs, the mean M1 shortening was 3.3mm (6.3mm in metatarsalgia group versus 3.0 mm in the non-metatarsalgia group, P=0.2) and the mean angular correction was 16.2° (±6°).

DISCUSSION

The overall results of screwless Scarf osteotomy are comparable and satisfactory, allowing large deformities to be corrected (28°±8° preoperatively in our cohort). M1 shortening and the transfer metatarsalgia rate appear to be higher than with other techniques.

CONCLUSION

Screwless scarf osteotomy of M1 yields good functional and radiological outcomes in the medium term. However, it appears to cause more shortening and transfer metatarsalgia.

LEVEL OF EVIDENCE

IV Retrospective, non-interventional in current practice (Recommendation grade C, low level of scientific proof).