From improved knowledge to certain technical revolutions: Many advances in foot and ankle surgery

Clinical and functional outcomes of 405 Achilles tendon ruptures after a minimum follow-up of 1 year

OBJECTIVE

The results of surgical versus conservative treatment of acute Achilles tendon ruptures are still controversial. The objective of this study was to compare surgical and conservative treatment at a minimum follow-up of 1 year in terms of the complications, functional outcomes and clinical results.

HYPOTHESES

There is no difference in the complications, clinical results and functional outcomes between the two treatment groups. There is no difference in the occurrence of complications or the clinical results due to the immobilization or rehabilitation protocols.

METHODS

This was a retrospective comparative, multicenter, non-randomized study of acute Achilles tendon ruptures treated between 01/01/2018 and 31/12/2019 at 21 study sites in France. All patients who received surgical or conservative treatment were included. The demographics, sports participation, nature of treatment, immobilization parameters (type, duration, position) and rehabilitation protocol were collected. Rerupture, general and specific complications, clinical results (heel-rise test, single-leg hop, calf circumference, ankle dorsiflexion) and the functional outcomes (ATRS, VISA-A, EFAS, SF-12) were collected at the final review.

RESULTS

Four hundred five patients were reviewed at a mean follow-up of 24 (±7) months. Surgical treatment was done in 372 patients (92%) and conservative treatment in 33 patients (8%), with these two sets of patients having comparable preoperative characteristics. There was a similar number of reruptures in the conservative group (3 cases, 9%) as in the surgical group (15 cases, 4%) (p=0.176). There were more general complications in the conservative group (24%) than in the surgical group (11%) (p=0.04). There was a 9% rate of surgery-related complications (infection, nerve damage, anesthesia after-effects). The ATRS (p=0.017), EFAS Total (p=0.013), EFAS daily living (p=0.008), and SF-12 physical (p=0.01) were better in the surgical group. Strict then relative immobilization provided the best balance between functional recovery (EFAS total of 33, p<0.01) and tendon lengthening (0°, p=0.01) without increasing the occurrence of rerupture (2%, p=0.18). Early weightbearing accompanied by immobilization and rehabilitation within 30 days did not lead to more reruptures than if it was started beyond 30 days (p=0.082 and p=0.07).

CONCLUSIONS

This study found no differences in the number of reruptures between surgical treatment and conservative treatment of acute Achilles tendon ruptures. Surgical treatment led to better clinical results but had a variable effect on improving the functional scores. No matter which treatment is used, in the ideal case, 3 weeks of strict immobilization in equinus should be followed by progressive reduction over the next 3 weeks. Early weightbearing and mobilization within 30 days did not increase the risk of rerupture; it actually optimized the clinical and functional outcomes.

LEVEL OF EVIDENCE

III; retrospective comparative, non-randomized.

Portable device for measuring isometric plantar-flexion force after open Achilles repair: Retrospective cohort of 30 recreational athletes with one-year minimum follow-up

BACKGROUND

Plantar flexion force in recreational athletes after repair of Achilles tendon tears has rarely been reported, due to the lack of a widely available and fast measurement method. Knowledge of this parameter would allow optimisation of muscular and sports recovery. The main objective of this study was to measure the isometric force of the triceps surae at least 1 year after unilateral Achilles-tendon repair, comparatively to the unaffected side, using a portable device. The secondary objectives were to compare Achilles tendon and calf-muscle trophicity, dorsiflexion, and the single-leg heel-rise test versus the normal side and to assess functional scores at last follow-up.

HYPOTHESES

(i) Plantar flexion force does not differ significantly between the operated and contralateral sides. (ii) Calf-muscle trophicity, dorsiflexion, and the single-leg heel-rise test do not differ significantly between the operated and contralateral sides.

PATIENTS AND METHODS

This single-centre retrospective study included patients aged 18 to 65 years with a history of open repair of an acute unilateral Achilles tear at least 1 year earlier. Plantar flexion force, calf-muscle trophicity, dorsiflexion, and the heel-to-floor distance were measured on both sides and compared. The ATRS, VISA-A score, and EFAS score were determined. All complications were recorded.

RESULTS

The study included 30 patients with a mean follow-up of 20.3 months (range, 12-28 months). The operated side had significantly lower values for isometric triceps surae force, calf circumference, and heel-to-floor distance compared to the contralateral side (p<0.0001). Tendon width was significantly greater on the operated side (p<0.0001). Dorsiflexion did not differ significantly between sides (p=0.106). Mean functional score values were 91.5±6 for the ATRS (maximum, 100), 85±12 for the VISA-A score (maximum, 100), and 19.5±4 for the EFAS score (maximum, 24).

DISCUSSION

Isometric triceps-surae force measured using a portable device at least 1 year after open surgical Achilles-tendon repair was significantly decreased compared to the contralateral side. Calf circumference and heel-to-floor distance were also significantly lower. These data indicate a need for improved monitoring of triceps surae recovery to optimise rehabilitation and sports resumption.

LEVEL OF EVIDENCE

IV, retrospective comparative cohort study.