Perceptions of heart attack risk amongst individuals with diabetes

Awareness of heart disease and associated health behaviours in a developing country: a qualitative study

AIM

The aim of this study was to explore awareness of heart disease and associated health behaviours.

DESIGN

A qualitative study was conducted using in-depth interviews.

METHODS

The study participants were patients with hypertension. Data analysis was guided by Braun and Clarke's steps of thematic analysis and using NVivo12 software.

RESULTS

A total of 18 patients with hypertension were interviewed. The patients had poor understanding of heart disease and were not concerned about developing heart disease in the future. Barriers to fruit and vegetable consumption were poor access, cost and sociocultural factors, whereas being busy, poor physical health and lack of access to an exercise facility were barriers to physical activity.

Perceptions of risks for diabetes-related complications in Type 2 diabetes populations: a systematic review

AIM

In Type 2 diabetes, there is no clear understanding of how people perceive their risk of experiencing diabetes-related complications. To address this issue, we undertook an evidence-based synthesis of how people with Type 2 diabetes perceive their risk of complications.

METHODS

We performed a systematic search of nine electronic databases for peer-reviewed articles published on or before 1 March 2016. Data from 18 studies reporting lay perceptions of risks for complications in Type 2 diabetes populations were included. Publication year ranged between 2002 and 2014.

RESULTS

Methods used to assess risk perceptions were heterogeneous, ranging from questionnaires measuring the accuracy of perceived risks to semi-structured and focus group interviews. We found evidence of low risk awareness in most dimensions of risk perceptions measured and the existence of optimistic bias.

CONCLUSIONS

Perceptions were generally biased and varied according to the dimension of risk measured, the subpopulation concerned and the type of complications considered. Future work is needed to identify the best practical ways of correcting for biased risk perceptions so as to encourage self-care behaviours and treatment adherence.

Patients' responses to the communication of vascular risk in primary care: a qualitative study

AIM

To examine the perspectives of patients identified as being at 'high risk' of cardiovascular events, with particular reference to the potential responses to risk messages.

BACKGROUND

Systematic population screening for cardiovascular disease (CVD) aims to identify those at high risk and provide medication and lifestyle support. In the United Kingdom, this takes the form of the National Health Service Health Check.

METHODS

We conducted a qualitative interview study. In 2011 we interviewed 37 patients, from seven UK primary care practices, who were at high risk of developing CVD.

FINDINGS

Risk messages were delivered via face-to-face consultations or by letter and were relayed in either a 'downplaying' or 'serious warning' style. Patients' accounts of receiving information about risk revealed two broad response styles: 'committed' (active resistance; commitment to change) and 'non-committed' (procrastination; downplaying and fatalism). Responses to risk messages are usually assumed to be due to individual characteristics but they may be explained by an interaction between the way risk is communicated and the patient's response style.

Educating health consumers about cardio-metabolic health risk: what can we learn from lay mental models of risk?

OBJECTIVE

To study lay conceptions of cardio-metabolic risk and compare them with those of experts, in order to formulate focal points for better educational risk information.

METHODS

40 Dutch lay people were interviewed about the risks of developing cardio-metabolic diseases. Following a 'mental models approach', their conceptions were qualitatively analyzed and compared to an expert model.

RESULTS

We identified four key themes representing lay conceptions: (1) "same factors, different value" (e.g. the dominance of certain factors, such as stress); (2) "superficiality and incoherence" (e.g. a focus on health and illness in general); (3) "misjudged elevated risk concept" (e.g. either being sick or not); and (4) "no concept of a link between cardio-metabolic diseases" (e.g. separate links between causes and diseases).

CONCLUSION

Potential mismatches between lay and expert conceptions do not seem to indicate a lack of basic knowledge among consumers, but rather that certain risk factors are not effectively translated into a coherent risk picture.

PRACTICE IMPLICATIONS

In improving educational materials, we could more explicitly take into account factors that lay people find important. Additionally, effort should be made to produce a more coherent risk understanding among consumers, for example through an alternative information structure.

Patients' perspectives on depression case management in general practice - a qualitative study

OBJECTIVE

General practice-based case management is effective in improving symptoms, adherence, and the perceived process of care of patients living with major depression. The aim was to explore the patients' perceptions of practice-based depression case management, their satisfaction with it and how living with depression contextualizes case management.

METHODS

This qualitative study was nested in a large cluster-randomized controlled trial on the effectiveness of case management for patients living with major depression. Case management was provided over 12 months by practice-based health care assistants, who monitored symptoms. We undertook semi-structured interviews with 41 patients, then transcribed and analysed them using qualitative content analysis.

RESULTS

Patients described depression as the unfortunate situation, where loneliness and lack of energy lead to being unable to actively seek help. Case management was appreciated because of regular, proactive contact and support by health care assistants. It was crucial to patients that they could trust the health care assistant. Some patients complained that case management was undertaken too mechanically and lacked empathy.

CONCLUSION

Patients living with depression may perceive practice-based case management as beneficial if carried out in a trustworthy and empathetic manner.

PRACTICE IMPLICATIONS

General practices should ensure that depression case management is patient-centered and non-mechanical.

Digging deeper: the role of qualitative research in behavioral diabetes

Qualitative research methodology is more recognized and valued in diabetes behavioral research in recent years. Qualitative methods help clinicians answer questions that quantitative research may not be able to answer, such as exploring patients' motivations, perceptions, and expectations. This paper reviews recent (2005-present) rigorous qualitative studies of children, adolescents, and adult patients with type 1 and type 2 diabetes with the aim of answering the following research question: How has qualitative research contributed to our understanding of behavioral diabetes care? We focus on studies exploring patients', health care providers', and families' interpersonal experiences of diabetes as well as patients' psychosocial experiences of diagnosis and treatment, self-care, complications, and cultural factors. After reviewing the research in each area, we conclude by discussing how qualitative research contributes to our increased understanding of behavioral diabetes.