Tackling child neglect: a role for pediatricians

Interventions to Support Children's Recovery From Neglect-A Systematic Review

Earlier reviews to discover research on interventions for children after neglect have concluded little was available, despite the well-documented prevalence and harmful effects of neglect on children. We revisited this question through a systematic literature review to discover the state of research on interventions for children who have experienced neglect. We searched MEDLINE, PsycINFO, ERIC, Sociological Abstracts and EMBASE for studies published between 2003 and 2021. Studies were included if neglect could be distinguished, and child outcomes reported. Eight reports describing six studies about six interventions were identified. These studies differed in interventions, age-groups, definitions of neglect, and outcomes. Four studies reported positive child outcomes though with varying degree of quality. More research is needed to inform a coherent theory of change following neglect. There remains an urgent need for research on interventions to help children recover from neglect.

"All you need is compassion?" a latent profile analysis of neglect and self-compassion on child mental health

BACKGROUND

Neglect is a common form of child maltreatment and profoundly affects children's mental health globally. Self-compassion may help children cope with neglect but the role of self-compassion in neglect context has been understudied. This study identifies distinct patterns of self-compassion and child neglect and explores how neglect and self-compassion profiles correlate with child mental health.

METHODS

The sample includes 3342 children aged 8-16 (49.6 % female) from a national survey of 29 provinces in China using a multistage sampling method. We used latent profile analysis to identify distinct profiles of self-compassion and neglect and examine their combined effects on child mental health, including both positive indicators (hope, resilience) and negative indicators (anxiety, depression, academic burnout, and peer problems).

RESULTS

We identified four neglect/self-compassion profiles: Adaptable Self-Carers (average neglect/high self-compassion), Vulnerable Languishers (high neglect/low self-compassion), Stable Self-Soothers (low neglect/average self-compassion), and Opportune Thrivers (low neglect/high self-compassion). The Vulnerable Languishers group exhibited the poorest mental health outcomes, whereas the Opportune Thrivers showed the best outcomes. Adaptable Self-Carers, although experiencing more neglect than Stable Self-Soothers, had better mental health than the latter, possibly due to their greater self-compassion.

LIMITATIONS

The cross-sectional design limits our ability to determine causality, and the use of self-reported measures increases response bias risk.

CONCLUSIONS

More self-compassion and less neglect are associated with more positive mental health outcomes. Moreover, self-compassion is a potential protective factor against the adverse effects of neglect on child mental health. Fostering self-compassion may boost positive adjustment in children who have experienced neglect.

Subjective Experiences of At-Risk Children Living in a Foster-Care Village Who Participated in an Open Studio

The open studio art therapy model offers a space for free creation; in this space, the art therapist supports the participants’ art process. According to this model, the creative process is the central component of the therapeutic work. This qualitative study seeks to learn, through an analysis of interviews and artwork, about the subjective experiences of at-risk children living in a foster-care village who participated in an open studio. In addition, it seeks to identify changes in the artwork over time. This study involves a qualitative thematic analysis, while the analysis of visual data is based on the phenomenological approach to art therapy. The data include interviews and 82 artworks of five participants, aged 7–10 years. Five main themes emerged from the analysis of the visual and verbal data: (a) engaging in relationships; (b) moving along the continuum from basic, primary, art expressions (e.g., smearing, scribbling, etc.) to controlled expressions; (c) visibility, on a range between disclosure and concealment; (d) holding versus falling/instability; and (e) experiencing and expressions of change. The discussion expands on the themes in relation to key concepts in the field of psychodynamic psychotherapy and art therapy. It also examines the unique characteristics of this population in reference to empirical studies on developmental trauma and challenges of out-of-home placement. Finally, it discusses the study’s limitations and presents recommendations for further research.

Factors related to medical neglect recurrence and foster care and adoption services

BACKGROUND

Medical neglect is defined as the failure of a caretaker to heed obvious signs of serious illness, to seek medical care in a timely fashion, or to follow instructions once medical advice is obtained. It is reportable as a form of child maltreatment.

OBJECTIVES

(1) identify factors associated with referrals after medical neglect to adoption and foster care services; (2) describe a cohort of children with first-time cases; and (3) assess whether there were factors associated with recurrence.

PARTICIPANTS AND SETTING

Data from the National Child Abuse and Neglect Data System for 36 U.S. states.

METHODS

A cohort of children was constructed with first confirmed reports of medical neglect in 2012 with matched confirmed reports during 2012-2017 to describe child, family, offender, and report factors associated with recurrence. These factors were then used in multivariate models, including logistic regression and Cox proportional hazard models, to assess their effects on recurrence and with referral to foster care and adoption services.

RESULTS

Complex family problems were associated with referral for foster care and adoption services, and 8.1% had recurrence within 5 years. Older children with medical problems, Black race, or who were reported by medical or legal personnel had increased risk for recurrence. Only referral to mental health care services was found to decrease this risk.

CONCLUSIONS

Medical neglect recurs within 5 years despite referrals to most services. Those trying to stop its recurrence should focus on mental health needs and families with children who are older, Black, or have complex medical problems.

When Medical Care and Parents Collide-Parents Who Refuse Testing and or Treatment for Children

Medical Neglect is a challenging diagnosis. Physicians and parents may clash over what they both perceive to be in the best interest of the child. Cultural, religious, financial, or philosophical differences between the health care providers and families can be difficult to negotiate. This paper reviews the definition of medical neglect and describes barriers that can prevent families from following medical recommendations for their child. Involvement of statutory authorities to intervene in cases of medical neglect may be helpful, but also may result in increased friction between parents and the health system, often without a satisfactory outcome for the child. Recognizing and then overcoming such barriers, as well as improving communication can help the family to begin to cooperate with medical recommendations. The paper will present an approach to families, parameters for reporting when all other options have failed, and the child remains at risk for harm due to the failure of the parent or caregiver to follow medical advice. The ultimate goal of any intervention is to ensure that children can achieve their full potential, in a nurturing and caring environment.

Medical Neglect Allegations in the Context of Conflicted Divorce/Separation Child Custody: What Should the Health Care Provider Do?

Pediatricians and child health providers face with situation in which families disagree about recommended treatments. Managing these disagreements is more challenging during periods of divorce or separation particularly when parents are in dispute over custody or medical decision-making. Parental disagreement exists along a continuum. General principles apply 1) the worse the conflict, the worse the outcome for children, 2) when conflict is combined with other factors such as separation, the outcome is often worse, and 3) the pediatrician/primary health care provider can mitigate this. This manuscript provides a review of the subject and suggestions for the practicing provider.

Maltreatment experiences and psychopathology in children and adolescents: The intervening role of domain-specific self-representations moderated by age

BACKGROUND

Associations between maltreatment experiences and psychopathology symptoms in children and adolescents are well established. However, the role of domain-specific self-representations (SR) in those associations remains unexplored.

OBJECTIVE

This multi-informant study aimed to explore the indirect associations between maltreatment experiences and children's and adolescents' psychopathology symptoms (i.e., internalizing and externalizing problems), through domain-specific self-representations, and the moderating role of age in those indirect associations.

PARTICIPANTS AND SETTING

Participants were 203 children/adolescents (52.7 % boys), aged 8-16 years old (M = 12.64; SD = 2.47), referred to child/youth protection commissions, their parents, and case workers.

METHOD

Case workers reported on child/adolescent maltreatment, children/adolescents reported on SR, and parents reported on psychopathology symptoms.

RESULTS

Controlling for chronicity of maltreatment and child/adolescent sex effects, multiple mediation path analysis revealed that: 1) higher levels of physical and psychological abuse were associated with less externalizing problems through more negative social SR; 2) higher levels of physical neglect were associated with more externalizing problems through more positive opposition SR; 3) higher levels of psychological neglect were associated with less externalizing problems through more negative physical appearance SR, and 4) associated with more externalizing problems through more negative opposition SR. Moreover, the indirect effects of physical and psychological abuse on internalizing and externalizing problems through instrumental SR were conditional on child/adolescent age.

CONCLUSION

Findings signal the relevance of preventing child/adolescent maltreatment and promoting the construction of positive and, foremost, realistic and adaptive self-representations as protection against maladjustment.

Medical neglect at a tertiary paediatric hospital

Medical neglect is under-researched and the extent of the problem in Australia is unknown. We conducted a review of the referrals for medical neglect to the Child Protection Unit (CPU) at a tertiary children's hospital in Sydney over a 5 years period, from 2011 to 2016, to determine what medical conditions are being referred, the reason for the medical neglect concern and whether cases are managed in line with American Academy of Pediatrics (AAP) guideline on medical neglect. 61 cases of medical neglect were identified, constituting 4.1% of all referrals to the Child Protection Unit for physical abuse and neglect. There was a wide variety of medical conditions. Most were chronic medical conditions (87%). The top two medical conditions were chronic and complex multi-system disorders (37.7%) and endocrine disorders (18%). The majority of medical neglect were related to concerns that the caregivers were unwilling to follow medical advice (45.9%) or unable to provide necessary medical care (26.2%). In line with the AAP guideline on medical neglect, all cases were managed by addressing communication difficulties (100%) and resource issues were addressed in 80% of cases. A report to statutory child protection agencies was made in 50% of cases. Directly observed therapy and medical contracts were used in 30% and 26% of cases. We conclude that children with chronic medical conditions may be at risk of medical neglect. Communication difficulties were a factor in all cases. Statutory agency intervention is often required.

The Identification of Psychosocial Risk Factors Associated With Child Neglect Using the WE-CARE Screening Tool in a High-Risk Population

INTRODUCTION

Neglect accounts for over 70% of child maltreatment and carries significant sequelae. Identification of psychosocial determinants of health may allow pediatric providers to ameliorate precursors of child neglect.

METHODS

Data were collected 1 month before and after implementation of the Well-Child Care Visit, Evaluation, Community Resources, Advocacy, Referral, Education (i.e., WE-CARE) screen at all well-child visits. Social workers recorded number and types of referrals, and providers completed surveys.

RESULTS

Analysis of 602 completed screens (75% capture rate) showed 377 families (63%) with at least one need and 198 (33% overall, 53% of those with positive results) indicating a desire to discuss. Of families requesting assistance, 122 (62%) connected with a social worker, and total referrals increased after implementation. Provider surveys supported an increased frequency of and comfort with assessing families for certain risk factors, and screening was not perceived to interrupt clinic flow.

CONCLUSION

Standardized screening identifies families at risk for neglect, improves provider comfort, and minimally affects flow. Identification of psychosocial needs should be part of routine preventive care.

Child Abuse and Neglect in India

India is home to the largest child population in the world, with almost 41 % of the total population under 18 y of age. The health and security of the country's children is integral to any vision for its progress and development. Doctors and health care professionals are often the first point of contact for abused and neglected children. They play a key role in detecting child abuse and neglect, provide immediate and longer term care and support to children. Despite being important stakeholders, often physicians have a limited understanding on how to protect these vulnerable groups. There is an urgent need for systematic training for physicians to prevent, detect and respond to cases of child abuse and neglect in the clinical setting. The purpose of the present article is to provide an overview of child abuse and neglect from a medical assessment to a socio-legal perspective in India, in order to ensure a prompt and comprehensive multidisciplinary response to victims of child abuse and neglect. During their busy clinical practice, medical professionals can also use the telephone help line (CHILDLINE telephone 1098) to refer cases of child abuse, thus connecting them to socio-legal services. The physicians should be aware of the new legislation, Protection of Children from Sexual Offences (POCSO) Act, 2012, which requires mandatory reporting of cases of child sexual abuse, failing which they can be penalized. Moreover, doctors and allied medical professionals can help prevent child sexual abuse by delivering the message of personal space and privacy to their young patients and parents.

Child protection decisions to substantiate hospital child protection teams' reports of suspected maltreatment

The present study focuses on the way child protection officers (CPOs) in Israel assess suspected abuse and neglect (SCAN) reports made by hospital child protection teams (CPTs), to determine whether the alleged maltreatment is substantiated. The study was conducted in six medical centers and included 358 reports investigated by CPOs for SCAN. A structured questionnaire was completed by hospital CPTs to capture all relevant information on each child referred to the CPTs. Structured phone interviews were conducted with each of the CPOs who received a CPT report. Bivariate associations and multivariate logistic regressions were conducted to estimate the substantiation rate of cases reported by CPTs and the types of maltreatment substantiated, as well as to identify case characteristics of the child and the family that were associated with the CPOs' substantiation decision. CPO follow-up investigations revealed a substantiation rate of 53.5%. The maltreatment type most commonly substantiated was neglect. The case characteristics associated with substantiation included socio-demographic background, parents' health and functioning, previous contact with social services, characteristics of the hospital referral, medical findings and an assessment of the parents' behaviors. The findings of the study highlighted the importance of cooperation between the health and welfare services and the policy makers. This cooperation is essential for identifying early signs of maltreatment. Enhanced cooperation and effective information transfer between various professionals would help prevent or at least reduce the recurrence of maltreatment and would ensure that the children and their families are treated appropriately.

Child neglect: assessment and intervention

Neglect is often a neglected form of child maltreatment even though it is the most common and deadliest form of child maltreatment. Pediatric nurse practitioners (PNPs) will most likely encounter neglected children in their practice. It is crucial that PNPs recognize child neglect in a timely manner and intervene appropriately. This continuing education article will help PNPs understand and respond to child neglect. Neglect will be defined and risk factors will be discussed. Children who are neglected can experience serious and lifelong consequences. The medical assessment and plan of care for children with concerns of suspected neglect will be discussed.

Community perceptions of the social determinants of child health in Western Cape, South Africa: neglect as a major indicator of child health and wellness

BACKGROUND

Worldwide, neglect is the most common form of child maltreatment. Data on neglect are scarce in low- and middle-income countries, and almost no qualitative research includes the voices of children.

OBJECTIVES

The main objective was to understand community perceptions of the social determinants of child health. The study was also intended to test the feasibility of health professionals undertaking qualitative studies of the social determinants of child health which can be used to inform clinical care and policy.

METHODS

The target population was people living in deprived circumstances in rural South Africa. Data collected included focus group discussions with children and adults, children's drawings, semi-structured in-depth interviews, documentary review and transect drives. Purposive sampling of poorer households was done. Recurring themes were explored using a continuous repetitive process. Data were examined using framework analysis.

RESULTS

The main finding was that neglect owing to substance abuse was a major predictor of poor child health and wellness. This sensitive topic was introduced by children, who created a platform for discussion with and among adult participants. Adults attributed neglect to a breakdown in family structure and changing norms regarding the responsibilities of parents. Community programmes were cited by children as a source of support, while some adults felt they undermined parental responsibility.

CONCLUSION

Understanding social arrangements and community support structures is best achieved at community level through a participatory, qualitative approach. These methods also enable the views of children to inform the findings. Children's input will help uncover neglect and other hidden predictors of challenges to child health, and promote a rights-based approach to care and research.

Child abuse and neglect: a worldwide concern

PURPOSE OF REVIEW

As knowledge about child abuse and neglect increases worldwide, so does the literature on abuse and neglect. The authors explore many studies published this year, with attention to the advances in understanding which are guiding prevention efforts as well as diagnosis and treatment of abuse and neglect.

RECENT FINDINGS

The evidence base for many forms of child abuse continues to grow. Controversy around the diagnosis of child abuse still continues, with current debate focused on the diagnosis of abusive head injury and whether children with vitamin D deficiency are misdiagnosed with abusive fractures. As clinicians begin to understand the factors which may increase child vulnerability to abuse, more sophisticated and focused prevention efforts are being implemented, and researchers are evaluating these efforts with an eye to whether or not they really contribute to prevention.

SUMMARY

The short-term and long-term impact of child maltreatment is significant not only for individuals but for families and communities in which abuse is taking place. General pediatricians have an important role to play with families and in the community as advocates for the protection of children. However, it is clear that specialists in child abuse should also play a role in order for diagnosis and management of abuse to adhere to a high standard of care. This has been validated this year by the creation of Child Abuse Pediatrics as a board certified specialty in the United States. As knowledge about abuse and neglect grows, clinicians are focusing on prevention as well as diagnosis and treatment.