Grandpa and I have dystrophinopathy?: approach to asymptomatic hyperCKemia

Further evidence for an attenuated phenotype of in-frame DMD deletions affecting the central rod domain of dystrophin around exon 48

Alterations in the X-linked recessive DMD gene cause dystrophinopathies with a broad clinical spectrum most commonly ranging from Duchenne muscular dystrophy (DMD) or Becker muscular dystrophy (BMD) to cardiomyopathy or intellectual disability. Carrier females are commonly unaffected but may show signs of dystrophinopathies. In addition, few asymptomatic male carriers with elevated creatine kinase levels have been described possibly related to deletions around exon 48. We now further support this assumed genotype-phenotype correlation by reporting an attenuated phenotype in a three-generation family with a deletion of exon 48 of the DMD gene with clinically unaffected carrier males and females. We confirmed deep intronic breakpoints in this family by genome sequencing, but such data are not available for published cases. Therefore, further observations are needed to clarify genotype-phenotype correlation in this region, since few reports also describe predicted in-frame copy number changes affecting this region in association with classical signs of dystrophinopathies.

DMD deletions underlining mild dystrophinopathies: literature review highlights phenotype-related mutation clusters and provides insights about genetic mechanisms and prognosis

DMD gene pathogenic variations cause a spectrum of phenotypes, ranging from severe Duchenne muscular dystrophy, the Becker milder cases, the intermediate or very mild muscle phenotypes invariably characterized by high CK, and the ultrarare fully-asymptomatic cases. Besides these phenotypes, X-linked dilated cardiomyopathy is also caused by DMD mutations. Males carrying DMD deletions with absent or very mild phenotypes have been sparsely described. We performed a horizon scan on public datasets to enroll males with the above phenotypes and carrying DMD deletions to delineate myopathic genotype-phenotype relationships. We inventoried 81 males, who were divided into the following clinical categorization: fully-asymptomatic males aged >43 years (A, N = 22); isolated hyperCKemia (CK, N = 35); and mild weakness (any age) with or without high CK (WCK, N = 24). In all cases, deleted intervals were exons 2 to 55, and no downstream exons were ever involved, apart from an exon 78 deletion in a WCK patient. All deletions were in-frame apart from the known exception to the rule of exon 2 and exon 78. We correlated the mild phenotypes (A and CK) to deleted exons, intronic breakpoints, exon-exon junctions, 3' isoforms rule, and protein epitopes, and we found that some genetic profiles are exclusively/mainly occurring in A/CK phenotypes, suggesting they are compatible with a quasi-normal muscular performance. We discussed diverse pathogenic mechanisms that may contribute to mild dystrophinopathic phenotypes, and we tried to address some "critical" genetic configurations or exon content needed to preserve a semi-functional DMD gene.

Ethnicity-related DMD Genotype Landscapes in European and Non-European Countries

Objective

Genetic diagnosis and mutation identification are now compulsory for Duchenne (DMD) and Becker muscular dystrophies (BMD), which are due to dystrophin (DMD) gene mutations, either for disease prevention or personalized therapies. To evaluate the ethnic-related genetic assortments of DMD mutations, which may impact on DMD genetic diagnosis pipelines, we studied 328 patients with DMD and BMD from non-European countries.

Methods

We performed a full DMD mutation detection in 328 patients from 10 Eastern European countries (Poland, Hungary, Lithuania, Romania, Serbia, Croatia, Bosnia, Bulgaria, Ukraine, and Russia) and 2 non-European countries (Cyprus and Algeria). We used both conventional methods (multiplex ligation-dependent probe amplification [MLPA] followed by gene-specific sequencing) and whole-exome sequencing (WES) as a pivotal study ran in 28 patients where DMD mutations were already identified by standard techniques. WES output was also interrogated for DMD gene modifiers.

Results

We identified DMD gene mutations in 222 male patients. We identified a remarkable allele heterogeneity among different populations with a mutation landscape often country specific. We also showed that WES is effective for picking up all DMD deletions and small mutations and its adoption could allow a detection rate close to 90% of all occurring mutations. Gene modifiers haplotypes were identified with some ethnic-specific configurations.

Conclusions

Our data provide unreported mutation landscapes in different countries, suggesting that ethnicity may orient genetic diagnosis flowchart, which can be adjusted depending on the mutation type frequency, with impact in drug eligibility.

EMQN best practice guidelines for genetic testing in dystrophinopathies

Dystrophinopathies are X-linked diseases, including Duchenne muscular dystrophy and Becker muscular dystrophy, due to DMD gene variants. In recent years, the application of new genetic technologies and the availability of new personalised drugs have influenced diagnostic genetic testing for dystrophinopathies. Therefore, these European best practice guidelines for genetic testing in dystrophinopathies have been produced to update previous guidelines published in 2010.These guidelines summarise current recommended technologies and methodologies for analysis of the DMD gene, including testing for deletions and duplications of one or more exons, small variant detection and RNA analysis. Genetic testing strategies for diagnosis, carrier testing and prenatal diagnosis (including non-invasive prenatal diagnosis) are then outlined. Guidelines for sequence variant annotation and interpretation are provided, followed by recommendations for reporting results of all categories of testing. Finally, atypical findings (such as non-contiguous deletions and dual DMD variants), implications for personalised medicine and clinical trials and incidental findings (identification of DMD gene variants in patients where a clinical diagnosis of dystrophinopathy has not been considered or suspected) are discussed.

How to use: creatine kinase

Creatine kinase (CK) remains an essential tool for assessment of muscular weakness and pain in children despite the advent of advanced diagnostic tests in this field. It is also useful in diagnosing and monitoring various other conditions. This article will explore the physiology of CK and clinical situations where the estimation of CK can help the clinicians' decision-making process with the diagnosis and management of these conditions. Some clinical scenarios are used to highlight how the tests can be used in different clinical situations. The role of CK as a biomarker of myocardial injury has been purposefully omitted in this article.

A rare subclinical or mild type of Becker muscular dystrophy caused by a single exon 48 deletion of the dystrophin gene

In the material of 227 families with Becker muscular dystrophy (BMD), we found nine non-consanguineous families with 17 male individuals carrying a rare mutation—a single exon 48 deletion of the dystrophin gene—who were affected with a very mild or subclinical form of BMD. They were usually detected thanks to accidental findings of elevated serum creatine phosphokinase (sCPK). A thorough clinical analysis of the carriers, both children (12) and adults (5), revealed in some of them muscle hypotonia (10/17) and/or very mild muscle weakness (9/17), as well as decreased tendon reflexes (6/17). Adults, apart from very mild muscle weakness and calf hypertrophy in some, had no significant abnormalities on neurological assessments and had good exercise tolerance. Parents of the children carriers of the exon 48 deletion are usually unaware of their children being affected, and possibly at risk of developing life-threatening cardiomyopathy. The same concerns the adult male carriers. Therefore, the authors postulate undertaking preventive measures such as cascade screening of the relatives of the probands. Newborn screening programmes of Duchenne muscular dystrophy (DMD)/BMD based on sCPK marked increase may be considered.

Manifesting pediatric carrier of isolated dystrophinopathy with initial presentation of myalgia and persistent hyperCKemia

Dystrophinopathy is caused by mutations in the dystrophin gene at Xp21. Although manifesting carriers of dystrophinopathy have been documented in adults, symptomatic dystrophinopathy in female children is rare. We report on a 13-year-old girl with initial presentation of myalgia at age 7 years and an incidental finding of increased transaminases and creatine kinase at regular health check at age 12 years. At age 13 years, manual muscle testing revealed asymmetric bilateral proximal weakness of extremities. Slight calf hypertrophy and winged scapulae were found. Muscle biopsy revealed a mosaic pattern in dystrophin immunostaining. Mutation analysis of the dystrophin gene revealed a novel de novo c.1150-2delA mutation. Accordingly, the patient was found to be an isolated dystrophinopathy carrier, manifesting limb-girdle pattern of muscle weakness in her childhood. This report suggests that dystrophinopathy should always be considered in female patients with sporadic myopathy. Dystrophin immunostaining and mutation analysis for the dystrophin gene are necessary for final diagnosis, subsequent genetic counseling, and long-term care.

Dystrophin quantification and clinical correlations in Becker muscular dystrophy: implications for clinical trials

Duchenne muscular dystrophy is caused by mutations in the DMD gene that disrupt the open reading frame and prevent the full translation of its protein product, dystrophin. Restoration of the open reading frame and dystrophin production can be achieved by exon skipping using antisense oligonucleotides targeted to splicing elements. This approach aims to transform the Duchenne muscular dystrophy phenotype to that of the milder disorder, Becker muscular dystrophy, typically caused by in-frame dystrophin deletions that allow the production of an internally deleted but partially functional dystrophin. There is ongoing debate regarding the functional properties of the different internally deleted dystrophins produced by exon skipping for different mutations; more insight would be valuable to improve and better predict the outcome of exon skipping clinical trials. To this end, we have characterized the clinical phenotype of 17 patients with Becker muscular dystrophy harbouring in-frame deletions relevant to on-going or planned exon skipping clinical trials for Duchenne muscular dystrophy and correlated it to the levels of dystrophin, and dystrophin-associated protein expression. The cohort of 17 patients, selected exclusively on the basis of their genotype, included 4 asymptomatic, 12 mild and 1 severe patient. All patients had dystrophin levels of >40% of control and significantly higher dystrophin (P = 0.013), β-dystroglycan (P = 0.025) and neuronal nitric oxide synthase (P = 0.034) expression was observed in asymptomatic individuals versus symptomatic patients with Becker muscular dystrophy. Furthermore, grouping the patients by deletion, patients with Becker muscular dystrophy with deletions with an end-point of exon 51 (the skipping of which could rescue the largest group of Duchenne muscular dystrophy deletions) showed significantly higher dystrophin levels (P = 0.034) than those with deletions ending with exon 53. This is the first quantitative study on both dystrophin and dystrophin-associated protein expression in patients with Becker muscular dystrophy with deletions relevant for on-going exon skipping trials in Duchenne muscular dystrophy. Taken together, our results indicate that all varieties of internally deleted dystrophin assessed in this study have the functional capability to provide a substantial clinical benefit to patients with Duchenne muscular dystrophy.

Exon skipping and dystrophin restoration in patients with Duchenne muscular dystrophy after systemic phosphorodiamidate morpholino oligomer treatment: an open-label, phase 2, dose-escalation study

BACKGROUND

We report clinical safety and biochemical efficacy from a dose-ranging study of intravenously administered AVI-4658 phosphorodiamidate morpholino oligomer (PMO) in patients with Duchenne muscular dystrophy.

METHOD

We undertook an open-label, phase 2, dose-escalation study (0·5, 1·0, 2·0, 4·0, 10·0, and 20·0 mg/kg bodyweight) in ambulant patients with Duchenne muscular dystrophy aged 5-15 years with amenable deletions in DMD. Participants had a muscle biopsy before starting treatment and after 12 weekly intravenous infusions of AVI-4658. The primary study objective was to assess safety and tolerability of AVI-4658. The secondary objectives were pharmacokinetic properties and the ability of AVI-4658 to induce exon 51 skipping and dystrophin restoration by RT-PCR, immunohistochemistry, and immunoblotting. The study is registered, number NCT00844597.

FINDINGS

19 patients took part in the study. AVI-4658 was well tolerated with no drug-related serious adverse events. AVI-4658 induced exon 51 skipping in all cohorts and new dystrophin protein expression in a significant dose-dependent (p=0·0203), but variable, manner in boys from cohort 3 (dose 2 mg/kg) onwards. Seven patients responded to treatment, in whom mean dystrophin fluorescence intensity increased from 8·9% (95% CI 7·1-10·6) to 16·4% (10·8-22·0) of normal control after treatment (p=0·0287). The three patients with the greatest responses to treatment had 21%, 15%, and 55% dystrophin-positive fibres after treatment and these findings were confirmed with western blot, which showed an increase after treatment of protein levels from 2% to 18%, from 0·9% to 17%, and from 0% to 7·7% of normal muscle, respectively. The dystrophin-associated proteins α-sarcoglycan and neuronal nitric oxide synthase were also restored at the sarcolemma. Analysis of the inflammatory infiltrate indicated a reduction of cytotoxic T cells in the post-treatment muscle biopsies in the two high-dose cohorts.

INTERPRETATION

The safety and biochemical efficacy that we present show the potential of AVI-4658 to become a disease-modifying drug for Duchenne muscular dystrophy.

FUNDING

UK Medical Research Council; AVI BioPharma.

Targeting RNA to treat neuromuscular disease

The development of effective therapies for neuromuscular disorders such as Duchenne muscular dystrophy (DMD) is hampered by considerable challenges: skeletal muscle is the most abundant tissue in the body, and many neuromuscular disorders are multisystemic conditions. However, despite these barriers there has recently been substantial progress in the search for novel treatments. In particular, the use of antisense oligonucleotides, which are designed to target RNA and modulate pre-mRNA splicing to restore functional protein isoforms or directly inhibit the toxic effects of pathogenic RNAs, offers great promise and these approaches are now being tested in the clinic. Here, we review recent advances in the development of such antisense oligonucleotides and other promising novel approaches, including the induction of readthrough nonsense mutations.

The status of exon skipping as a therapeutic approach to duchenne muscular dystrophy

Duchenne muscular dystrophy (DMD) is associated with mutations in the dystrophin gene that disrupt the open reading frame whereas the milder Becker's form is associated with mutations which leave an in-frame mRNA transcript that can be translated into a protein that includes the N- and C- terminal functional domains. It has been shown that by excluding specific exons at, or adjacent to, frame-shifting mutations, open reading frame can be restored to an out-of-frame mRNA, leading to the production of a partially functional Becker-like dystrophin protein. Such targeted exclusion can be achieved by administration of oligonucleotides that are complementary to sequences that are crucial to normal splicing of the exon into the transcript. This principle has been validated in mouse and canine models of DMD with a number of variants of oligonucleotide analogue chemistries and by transduction with adeno-associated virus (AAV)-small nuclear RNA (snRNA) reagents encoding the antisense sequence. Two different oligonucleotide agents are now being investigated in human trials for splicing out of exon 51 with some early indications of success at the biochemical level.

Becker muscular dystrophy patients with deletions around exon 51; a promising outlook for exon skipping therapy in Duchenne patients

Theoretically, 13% of patients with Duchenne muscular dystrophy may benefit from antisense-mediated skipping of exon 51 to restore the reading frame, which results in the production of a shortened dystrophin protein. We give a detailed description with longitudinal follow up of three patients with Becker muscular dystrophy with in-frame deletions in the DMD gene encompassing exon 51. Their internally deleted, but essentially functional, dystrophins are identical to those that are expected as end products in DMD patients treated with the exon 51 skipping therapy. The mild phenotype encourages further development of exon 51 skipping therapy.

DMD Trp3X nonsense mutation associated with a founder effect in North American families with mild Becker muscular dystrophy

A recurrent exon 1 nonsense mutation in the DMD gene, p.Trp3X (c.9G>A), was first ascertained in a proband with no symptoms until age 20 and who walked until the age of 62. Six other unrelated kindreds carrying a p.Trp3X mutation were subsequently ascertained, five from North America and one from Italy. In six of the seven kindreds, the proband presented in childhood incidental to elevated creatine kinase levels detected in the context of other illnesses, or in the setting of cramps with or without rhabdomyolysis. Genetic analysis by high density SNP genotyping demonstrates that the six North American families share a 3.7 Mbp haplotype surrounding the p.Trp3X allele, signifying that this is a founder mutation in these individuals. The size of the founder haplotype and the structure of shared genome-wide segments suggests that the minimal age of this mutation is >6 generations. The discovery of the first DMD founder mutation, associated with a mild Becker phenotype, suggests that the prevalence of hypomorphic dystrophin mutations should be re-examined with the use of improved genomic analysis.