Incidence and Indications for Ancillary Testing in the Determination of Death by Neurological Criteria in Children

Adverse Events During Apnea Testing for the Determination of Death by Neurologic Criteria: A Single-Center, Retrospective Pediatric Cohort

OBJECTIVES

To report the prevalence of adverse events in children undergoing apnea testing as part of the determination of death by neurologic criteria (DNC).

DESIGN

Single-center, retrospective study.

SETTING

Academic children's hospital that is a Level I Trauma Center.

PATIENTS

All children who underwent apnea testing to determine DNC from July 2013 to June 2020.

INTERVENTIONS

None.

MEASUREMENTS AND MAIN RESULTS

We abstracted the medical history, blood gases, ventilator settings, blood pressures, vasoactive infusions, intracranial pressures, chest radiographs, and echocardiograms for all apnea tests as well as any ancillary test. Adverse events were defined as hypotension, hypoxia, pneumothorax, arrhythmia, intracranial hypertension, and cardiac arrest. Fifty-eight patients had 105 apnea tests. Adverse events occurred in 21 of 105 apnea tests (20%), the most common being hypotension (15/105 [14%]) and hypoxia (4/105 [4%]). Five of 21 apnea tests (24%) with adverse events were terminated prematurely (three for hypoxia, one for hypotension, and one for both hypoxia and hypotension) but the patients did not require persistent escalation in care. In the other 16 of 21 apnea tests (76%) with adverse events, clinical changes were transient and managed by titrating vasoactive infusions or completing the apnea test.

CONCLUSIONS

In our center, 20% of all apnea tests were associated with adverse events. Only 5% of all apnea tests required premature termination and the remaining 15% were completed and the adverse events resolved with medical care.

Ancillary Tests for Death by Neurologic Criteria in Children

Investigators from Children's Hospital of Pennsylvania reported on the usage of ancillary studies in the declaration of brain death in children in a single-center retrospective descriptive study.

A review of current controversies in determining death by neurologic criteria in children

PURPOSE OF REVIEW

Death by neurologic criteria (DNC) is the irreversible cessation of all functions of the entire brain, including the brainstem. It is legally recognized as equivalent to cardiopulmonary death. Legal and ethical controversies surrounding DNC have emerged as a result of several highly publicized cases that have eroded public trust in our ability to declare DNC accurately. In this review, we focus on recently published primary data about DNC and address some of these controversies.

RECENT FINDINGS

Approximately 21% of children who die in pediatric intensive care units (PICU) are declared DNC. Although 60% of physicians report that they have been asked to maintain organ support after DNC declaration, less than 1% of patients remain physically present in the PICU more than 5 days after DNC declaration. We discuss strategies for safely conducting the apnea test, indications and prevalence of ancillary testing, and objections to DNC, including issues of consent and requests for ongoing organ support.

SUMMARY

In order to maintain public trust, published guidelines must be followed to accurately and consistently diagnose DNC. We must develop strategies to respond to objections to DNC determination. Ongoing research is needed to improve the safety of apnea testing and indications for and interpretation of ancillary testing.