To patent or not to patent? Consideration of the societal aspects of patenting across pharma-nutrition industries

Science and claims of the arena of food bioactives: comparison of drugs, nutrients, supplements, and nutraceuticals

The scientific community and lay press are participating in a heated debate over the usefulness of food bioactives when used as dietary supplements. This debate often ignores hard scientific evidence and the outcomes of proper research in either direction. Some propose that health claims should be awarded based on classic pharmacological parameters of efficacy and safety. Others suggest that a botanical history of their safe use and basic biological evidence in support of their effects should suffice to allow their marketing. The current regulatory impasse does not help solve this conundrum. It is time for scientists, regulators, and legislators to open an epistemological debate on the appropriateness of using classic pharmacological methods for substances that do not share the usual drug profiles and which are, consequently, difficult to study in humans.

Innovations in the veterinary intestinal health field: A patent landscape analysis

In recent years it has become evident that a healthy intestinal microbiome is beneficial for the overall health of an individual. A healthy microbiome is diverse, increasing stability and resilience and strengthening the immune system. In addition, healthy intestinal metabolisms have a beneficial effect on many physiological processes such as the brain function.

Looking from the One Health perspective, which recognizes that health of humans is closely connected to the health of animals and environment, it is inherently beneficial to stimulate the health of animals for the well-being of humans. However, the intensive administration of antibiotics to livestock for prevention and cure of disease, and even stimulation of growth, disrupts a healthy microbiome. With the rapid increase of emerging zoonotic diseases, alternatives to the use of antimicrobial compounds are urgently necessary. This research analyses the development of alternatives for antibiotic use contributing to veterinary intestinal health through an in-depth patent analysis of inventions for fodder additives. In the period 1999–2020, 1269 unique patent families describing the use of probiotics, enzymes and prebiotics for swine, poultry and ruminants were identified. Innovation trends, geography, key applicants, and classification of patents were analysed.

Asian industrial applicants applied for the majority of patents comprising the largest share of patents for probiotics and enzymes in combination with fodder for swine. Followed by North American and European industrial applications, applying for patents for probiotics in combination with fodder for poultry, swine, and ruminants. Overall, our results do not show a clear increase in innovations, suggesting that innovations in the use of probiotics and enzymes in animal feed appear to be stalling. While in the near future a combination of the use of antibiotics and alternatives is most likely to be implemented, the use of probiotics stands a good chance of replacing antibiotics in animal husbandry and limiting the adverse effects of antibiotic abuse.

•

Alternatives for antibiotic use contributing to veterinary intestinal health are slowly coming to the market.

•

Patent applications for probiotics, prebiotics, enzymes supporting a healthy veterinary intestine are stabilizing.

•

China, as largest applicant for patents targeting the VIH,vcombines probiotics and enzymes with fodder for swine and poultry.

Therapeutic potential of broccoli-derived extracellular vesicles as nanocarriers of exogenous miRNAs

MicroRNAs (miRNAs) are small noncoding RNAs that regulate gene expression. The wide-ranging biological activities of microRNAs stimulated research on disease mechanisms and is suggesting appealing therapeutic applications. When unprotected, miRNAs suffer from rapid degradation and appropriate strategies need to be developed to improve their therapeutic potential. Since the first observation of miRNAs being naturally transported by extracellular vesicles (EVs), the latter have been proposed as specific transport means for drug delivery, conferring stability and increasing resistance against RNase degradation. However, a standard, reproducible, and cost-effective protocol for EV isolation is lacking. Here, the use of broccoli-derived EVs as a therapeutic vehicle for extracellular RNA drug delivery was assessed. EVs were isolated from broccoli, combining ultracentrifugation and size exclusion chromatography methodology. Caco-2 cells were exposed to isolated EVs loaded with exogenous miRNAs and cellular viability was tested. The miRNAs were taken up by this intestinal cell line. Our results show that broccoli EVs can be efficiently isolated, characterized, and loaded with exogenous miRNAs, leading to toxicity in caco-2 cells. Because the pharmaceutical industry is searching for novel drug delivery nanovesicles with intrinsic properties such as low immunogenicity, stability to the gastrointestinal tract, ability to overcome biological barriers, large-scale production, cost-effectiveness, etc., broccoli-isolated nanovesicles might be suitable candidates for future pharmacological applications. We propose broccoli as a natural source of EVs, which are capable of transporting exogenous miRNAs with potential therapeutic effects and suggest that appropriate toxicological and randomized controlled trials as well as patent applications are warranted.