X-ray crystallography, an essential tool for the determination of thermodynamic relationships between crystalline polymorphs

An unexpected high-pressure stability domain for a lower density polymorph of benzophenone

For over a century, it was thought that the crystalline polymorph II of benzophenone does not possess a stable domain in the pressure-temperature phase diagram. With a combination of new experimental results and literature data, this case of crystalline dimorphism has finally been solved and it is shown that form II possesses a stable domain at high pressure and high temperature, even though its density is lower than that of form I, the stable form under ordinary pressure and temperature conditions. The phase diagram of benzophenone is a clear demonstration of the fact that to understand the phase behaviour of a chemical substance both the exchange of heat (due to the change in intermolecular interactions) and work (due to the change of volume at a given pressure) need to be taken into account.

The Phase Diagram of the API Benzocaine and Its Highly Persistent, Metastable Crystalline Polymorphs

The availability of sufficient amounts of form I of benzocaine has led to the investigation of its phase relationships with the other two existing forms, II and III, using adiabatic calorimetry, powder X-ray diffraction, and high-pressure differential thermal analysis. The latter two forms were known to have an enantiotropic phase relationship in which form III is stable at low-temperatures and high-pressures, while form II is stable at room temperature with respect to form III. Using adiabatic calorimetry data, it can be concluded, that form I is the stable low-temperature, high-pressure form, which also happens to be the most stable form at room temperature; however, due to its persistence at room temperature, form II is still the most convenient polymorph to use in formulations. Form III presents a case of overall monotropy and does not possess any stability domain in the pressure-temperature phase diagram. Heat capacity data for benzocaine have been obtained by adiabatic calorimetry from 11 K to 369 K above its melting point, which can be used to compare to results from in silico crystal structure prediction.

Polymorphism of benzylthiouracil, an active pharmaceutical ingredient against hyperthyroidism

The crystal structures of dimorphic benzylthiouracil, a drug against hyperthyroidism, have been redetermined and the atom coordinates of the two independent molecules of form I have been obtained for the first time. The dimorphism convincingly demonstrates the conformational versatility of the benzylthiouracil molecule. It has been established through calorimetric studies that the low-temperature form II transforms endothermically (Δ_II→IH = 5.6(1.5) J g^-1) into form I at 405.4(1.0) K. The high-temperature form I melts at 496.8(1.0) K (Δ_I→LH = 152.6(4.0) J g^-1). Crystallographic and thermal expansion studies show that form II is denser than form I, leading to the conclusion that the slope of the II-I equilibrium curve in the pressure-temperature phase diagram is positive. It follows that this dimorphism corresponds to a case of overall enantiotropic behaviour, which implies that both solid phases possess their own stable phase region irrespective of the pressure. Moreover, form II is clearly the stable polymorph under ambient conditions.

On the dimorphism and the pressure-temperature state diagram of gestodene, a steroidal progestogen contraceptive

The pressure-temperature phase diagram of the dimorphism of the contraceptive drug gestodene is constructed using the temperature and enthalpy of fusion of form I (469.5K, 107Jg^-1), and those of the endothermic transition from form II to form I (311K, 8.52Jg^-1). At ordinary pressure, the sign of the enthalpy of this transition indicates that these polymorphs are enantiotropically related and that form II, whose melting temperature is calculated to be about 452K, is the stable form at room temperature. Considering the inequality in the specific volumes of the two polymorphs, it is shown that the two forms remain enantiotropically related on increasing pressure, because the I-II equilibrium and the melting equilibria I-L and II-L diverge as a consequence of the negative slope dP/dT of the solid-solid equilibrium. In addition, it is demonstrated that the heats of dissolution, inferred from solubility measurements, lead to virtually the same value of the heat of transition from II to I as for the differential scanning calorimetry measurements.

On the dimorphism and the pressure-temperature state diagram of racemic m-nisoldipine, a dihydropyridine calcium ion antagonist

The pressure-temperature phase diagram of the dimorphism of racemic m-nisoldipine is constructed using temperatures and enthalpies of fusion of forms A and B. At ordinary pressure, the transition from form B to form A is found to occur around 192K, which indicates that these polymorphs are enantiotropically related and that form A is stable at room temperature. Nevertheless, the phase relationship turns to be monotropic when pressures become greater than about 100MPa, which indicates that form B becomes the sole stable phase.

Pressure-temperature phase diagram of the dimorphism of the anti-inflammatory drug nimesulide

Understanding the phase behavior of active pharmaceutical ingredients is important for formulations of dosage forms and regulatory reasons. Nimesulide is an anti-inflammatory drug that is known to exhibit dimorphism; however up to now its stability behavior was not clear, as few thermodynamic data were available. Therefore, calorimetric melting data have been obtained, which were found to be T_I-L=422.4±1.0K, Δ_I→LH=117.5±5.2Jg^-1,T_II-L=419.8±1.0K and Δ_II→LH=108.6±3.3Jg^-1. In addition, vapor-pressure data, high-pressure melting data, and specific volumes have been obtained. It is demonstrated that form II is intrinsically monotropic in relation to form I and the latter would thus be the best polymorph to use for drug formulations. This result has been obtained by experimental means, involving high-pressure measurements. Furthermore, it has been shown that with very limited experimental and statistical data, the same conclusion can be obtained, demonstrating that in first instance topological pressure-temperature phase diagrams can be obtained without necessarily measuring any high-pressure data. It provides a quick method to verify the phase behavior of the known phases of an active pharmaceutical ingredient under different pressure and temperature conditions.

Solid state stability and solubility of triethylenetetramine dihydrochloride

The API triethylenetetramine dihydrochloride used as an alternative treatment of Wilson's disease is sensitive to water and it exhibits polymorphism. As this may become an issue for the drug formulation, the physical stability has been studied by differential scanning calorimetry, high-pressure thermal analysis, dynamic vapor sorption, and X-ray diffraction as a function of temperature. In addition, high-pressure liquid chromatography and mass spectrometry have been used to study the purity and chemical stability of the API. A pressure-temperature phase diagram of the pure compound has been constructed and it can be concluded that form II is monotropic in relation to form I, which is the only stable solid. The solubilities of the different solid forms have been determined with the help of a temperature - composition phase diagram. The API is very soluble, at 20° C about 10% of the saturated solution with respect to the dihydrate consists of API and the solubility of the pure form I is twice as high. Moreover, it has been shown that at 20°C, a relative humidity above 40% induces the formation of the dihydrate and at 70% a saturated solution appears. At higher temperatures, the formation of the dihydrate appears at lower relative humidity values. A clear link has been established between the API's chemical stability, its physical stability and the relative humidity in the air. Humidity levels above 40% are detrimental to the quality of the API.