Iatrogenic Pelvic Pain: Surgical and Mesh Complications

Application and research progress in composite stem cell materials of pelvic floor reconstruction

As an important tool for the surgical treatment of pelvic floor dysfunction, the safety of mesh must be guaranteed. Although the short-term curative effect of most synthetic mesh is satisfactory, complications often occur due to its material. Planting stem cells on mesh through specific methods may resolve the problems of mesh with poor biocompatibility or an uncontrollable rate o degradation. Based on recent research, this paper summarizes the research progress of stem cells composited with common mesh materials, such as polypropylene, polylactic acid and acellular matrix.

Google searches for stress urinary incontinence treatment options: a worldwide trend analysis in the synthetic mesh controversy era

PURPOSE

To analyze trends in worldwide public interest in the treatment options for stress urinary incontinence around the latest FDA 2019 ban on vaginal mesh for prolapse.

METHODS

We used the web-based tool Google Trends to analyse online searches related to the following terms: 'pelvic floor muscle exercises', 'continence pessary', 'pubovaginal slings', 'Burch colposuspension', 'midurethral slings', 'injectable bulking agents'. Data were expressed as relative search volume on a scale of 0-100. Comparisons of annual relative search volume and average annual percentage change, were analyzed to assess loss or gain of interest. Finally, we assessed the impact of the last FDA alert.

RESULTS

The mean annual relative search volume for midurethral slings was 20% in 2006 and significantly decreased until 8% in 2022 (p < 0.01). A regular decrease interest was recorded for autologous surgeries but a regain of interest for pubovaginal slings was registered since 2020 (+ 2.8%; p < 0.01). Conversely, a steep interest was noted for injectable bulking agents (average annual percentage change: + 4.4%; p < 0.01) and conservative therapies (p < 0.01). When trends were compared before and after the FDA 2019 alert, a lower research volume was found for midurethral slings, while a higher research volume was observed all others treatments (all p < 0.05).

CONCLUSION

The online public researches about midurethral slings have considerably decreased following warnings on the use of transvaginal mesh. There seems to be a growing interest in conservative measures, bulking agents, and recently pubovaginal slings.

How is pain associated with pelvic mesh implants measured? Refinement of the construct and a scoping review of current assessment tools

BACKGROUND

Recommendations for the management of pain related to pelvic mesh implants are still under development. One limitation that has impeded progress in this area is that mesh-related pain has not been consistently defined or measured. Here, we reviewed the ways in which pain associated with pelvic mesh implants has been measured, and mapped the ways in which these existing measures capture the construct.

METHODS

First, we reviewed existing accounts of the pain associated with pelvic mesh implants to develop a multifaceted construct definition, which includes aspects related to pain intensity, timing, body location, phenomenological qualities, impact/interference with daily living, and patient expectations and beliefs. Next, we reviewed the ways that the construct has been measured in the extant literature.

RESULTS

Within 333 eligible studies, 28 different assessments of pain associated with pelvic mesh were identified, and 61% of studies reported using more than one measurement tool. Questionnaire measures included measures designed to assess urological and/or pelvic symptoms, generic measures and unvalidated measures. We did not identify any validated questionnaire measures designed to assess pain associated with pelvic mesh implants. The phenomenological, location, and expectation/belief components of the construct were not captured well by the identified questionnaire measures, and there is no evidence that any of the identified measures have appropriate psychometric properties for the assessment of pain related to pelvic mesh implants.

CONCLUSIONS

We recommend further qualitative research regarding women's experiences of pelvic mesh-related pain assessment, and the development of a condition-specific patient reported outcome measure.

Recurrent Incontinence After Transvaginal Partial Sling Excision in Patients with Prior Mid-Urethral Sling

Introduction

Patients may develop recurrent urinary tract infections, pain syndromes, dyspareunia, and voiding difficulty after mid-urethral sling placement that can be treated by partial sling excision.

Objective

The primary objective of this study was to evaluate the incidence of de novo incontinence and voiding difficulty after partial sling excision. A secondary objective was to assess risk factors associated with future incontinence surgery in this subset of patients.

Methods

From 2009 to 2017, 95 female patients with subjective complaints of pelvic pain, dyspareunia, or voiding difficulty following synthetic mid-urethral sling placement for stress urinary incontinence underwent partial sling excision at a single institution. The incidence of urinary incontinence was assessed 6 months after partial sling excision. Patients were also assessed for resolution of voiding difficulty and future incontinence surgery. Primary endpoints were examined by Pearson's Chi-square test and interval data by t-test. A p < 0.05 was significant.

Results

About 72% of patients were more likely to be continent after partial sling excision irrespective of initial symptoms prior to surgery. No difference was seen in voiding difficulty between the continent and incontinent patients after partial sling excision (p=0.09). Patients with a retropubic mid-urethral sling were more likely to be continent after partial sling excision (p=0.03). Preoperative maximum flow rate >16 mL/sec was associated as an independent variable to develop incontinence surgery after partial sling excision (p=0.009).

Conclusion

In conclusion, partial sling excision poses a low risk for de novo urinary incontinence regardless of preoperative symptoms. Stress urinary incontinence may be less likely to reoccur in those patients having a retropubic approach. A preoperative maximum flow rate of >16 mL/sec is a risk factor for future incontinence surgery after partial sling excision and should be taken into consideration when formulating a treatment plan.

Single-Incision Mini-Sling for the Treatment of Female Stress Urinary Incontinence: Is it Actually Inferior to Transobturator Vaginal Tape and Tension-Free Vaginal Tape?

Objectives:

The aim of the study was to report the extended long-term results of the use of single-incision mini-sling (SIMS), tension-free vaginal tape (TVT), and transobturator tape (TOT) for the treatment of female stress urinary incontinence (SUI) at the Department of Gynecology and Obstetrics of the University Medical Center Ljubljana.

Materials and Methods:

Enrolled women were evaluated by Patient Global Impression of Severity (PGI-S), Patient Global Impression of Improvement (PGI-I), Sandvik severity scale, Urogenital Distress Inventory (UDI-6), Incontinence Impact Questionnaire (IIQ-7), and Incontinence Questionnaire-Urinary Incontinence (ICIQ-UI) Short Form and data about diagnosis, procedures, complications, reoperations, postoperative results, and satisfaction with procedure were recorded.

Results:

In analyzed group of patients (n = 357), 116 (32%) underwent SIMS procedure, 189 (53%) TOT, and 52 (15%) TVT. The SIMS, TOT, and TVT groups did not differ significantly from each other in PGI-S, PGI-I, Sandvik severity scale, UDI-6, IIQ-7, and ICIQ-UI Short Form or in postoperative complication rate. Repeat surgery was needed in 9.5% after SIMS, in 13.2% of TOT patients and in 23.1% of TVT patients (P = 0.194). Urinary retention occurred in 9.5% of the SIMS patients, in 9.5% of the TOT patients, and in 13.5% of the TVT patients (P = 0.682). Mesh erosion/inflammation occurred in 3.4% of the SIMS patients, in 6.3% of the TOT patients, and in 3.8% of the TVT patients (P = 0.485).

Conclusion:

The efficacy and safety of SIMS, TOT, and TVT in the surgical treatment of SUI are comparable. The choice of the technique should be based on the relative pros and cons of techniques and the surgeon's experience.

T regulatory cells and TGF-β1: Predictors of the host response in mesh complications

Polypropylene mesh is frequently used in urogynecology procedures; however, pain and mesh exposure into the vagina occur in ~10% of cases. Mesh-induced pain, which occurs with or without exposure, persists after removal in 50% of cases. Chronic pain history predicts poor response to mesh removal but only a fraction have this diagnosis. We hypothesize that mesh induced pain is correlated with fibrosis and failure to improve with a heightened inflammatory and fibrotic host response. Women undergoing mesh removal were offered participation in a mesh biorepository. Standardized questionnaires including visual analog scale (VAS) pelvic pain scores were completed at enrollment and 6 months after removal. Responders were considered those with ≥13 mm VAS improvement. 30 mesh-tissue explants were randomly selected for analysis. Samples were labeled for CD8, CD4 (T_h) and FoxP3 (T_regs). Peri-fiber collagen deposition (fibrosis) was measured using a customized semi-quantitative assay. Concentrations of TGF-b1, bFGF, MCP-1, PDGF-BB, and IGFBP-1 in tissue were determined by immunoassay and compared to vaginal control biopsies with pathway analysis. VAS pain scores were correlated with degree of histologic fibrosis. Responders had more T_regs (7.8 vs 0.3 per mm², p = 0.036) and patients were 1.6 times as likely to be a responder for every additional T_reg/mm² (p = 0.05). Pro-fibrotic TGF-β1 was doubled in nonresponders (p = 0.032). On pathway analysis, decreased bFGF and increased PDGF-BB provide a possible mechanism for upregulation of TGF-β1. In conclusion, fibrosis is a plausible mechanism of pain complications and the adaptive immune response likely contributes to mitigation/prevention of complications and recovery in affected patients. STATEMENT OF SIGNIFICANCE: Polypropylene mesh improves anatomical outcomes in urogynecologic procedures, but is associated with complications, including pain and exposure through the vaginal epithelium. Mesh-induced pain is difficult to treat, and it is unclear why only half of women experience pain improvement after mesh removal. In this study, patient pain correlated with the presence of fibrosis and women with more T regulatory cells and lower TGF-β1 were more likely to have pain improvement following mesh removal. These findings implicate fibrosis as a mechanism of pain complications and suggest that the adaptive immune response may be responsible for prevention of complication and recovery. This improved understanding of how mesh can lead to pain moves us closer to the ultimate goal of preventing mesh complications.

Is performing sacrospinous fixation with vaginal hysterectomy and McCall's culdoplasty for advanced uterovaginal prolapse preferable over McCall's culdoplasty alone?

Purpose of study

Advanced uterovaginal prolapse can significantly affect the quality of life in women and usually requires surgical management. McCall's culdoplasty (M) or sacrospinous fixation (SSF) are done at the time of vaginal hysterectomy with pelvic floor repair (VHPFR) to reduce recurrence, but recurrence rates of 15% and 33% have been reported with these procedures respectively. We hypothesize that combining VH-PFR with both McCall's culdoplasty and sacrospinous fixation (VH-PFR-M-SSF) may decrease recurrence rates compared to VH-PFR-M without significantly affecting other perioperative outcomes.

Methods

All patients with advanced uterovaginal prolapse and willing for VH-PFR at our institute from January 2015 to March 2018 were included after informed consent, except for medically unfit women and those preferring alternative management. We conducted a case control study comparing VH-PFR-M and VH-PFR-M-SSF with a follow-up period of 24 months. Qualitative and quantitative data were statistically analysed and Odds ratio and 95% Confidence interval was calculated. Kaplan Meier Curve was drawn and Log Rank test was used to compare recurrence.

Results

Out of 174 patients who underwent surgery in the study period, 131 patients (75.28%) underwent VH-PFR-M and 43 patients (24.71%) underwent VH-PFR-M-SSF. Both groups were comparable for age, body mass index, parity, postmenopausal status, comorbidities and aggravating factors. Patients with higher stage of prolapse were more in group 2 (p < 0.001). There were no intraoperative complications or postoperative surgical interventions in either group. The duration of surgery was not significantly different. Change in haematocrit was more in group 2 but no patient required blood transfusion. There was no statistically significant difference in recurrence rates between the 2 groups.

Conclusion

The procedure (VH PFR M-SSF) is safe and affordable with good results in Stage 3 with advanced bulge and stage 4 prolapse.

A Novel Approach to Managing Post Retropubic Vaginal Sling Pain

OBJECTIVE

To describe a novel technique of using peripheral nerve neuromodulation (PNNM) for the treatment of refractory, mesh-induced chronic pelvic pain. Chronic pelvic pain associated with mesh can be a debilitating complication and there is currently no consensus on treatment. PNNM has been shown to be successful in the treatment of post-traumatic neuralgias but has yet to be studied in mesh complications.

MATERIALS AND METHODS

We present a case of a 50-year-old woman who had unrelenting pelvic pain after retropubic sling placement. She failed multiple therapies including medications, mesh removal, pelvic floor physical therapy, pudendal neuromodulation, and pelvic floor onabotulinumtoxinA trigger point injections.

RESULTS

The only treatment that provided temporary relief of this patient's pain was transvaginal trigger point injections along with a right pudendal nerve block using 40 mg triamcinolone and 0.5% ropivacaine. To help define if treatment at the site of her pain would provide relief, a series of blocks were done by advancing a needle retropubically to her area of pain and injecting triamcinolone and 0.5% ropivacaine. This injection, which corresponded to the previous tract of her retropubic sling, provided temporary, but profound, relief. PNNM was then done with placement of the electrode in the retropubic space at the site of her pain. This provided instantaneous relief of almost all of her pain symptoms. Twelve months postoperatively, the patient continued to have >90% improvement in her pain.

CONCLUSION

Focused PNNM is a simple procedure and can provide symptomatic relief for refractory postvaginal mesh pain.

Obturator nerve injury and repair during laparoscopic lymphadenectomy. Case report and review of the literature

Objective

To report a case of obturator nerve injury during laparoscopic lymphadenectomy and repair through the same approach during the same surgical procedure; and to present a review of the literature on this type of injury, techniques used, timing of the repair, and rehabilitation outcomes.

Materials and Methods

Case presentation of a 29-year-old woman seen at the National Cancer Institute (Instituto Nacional de Cancerología) in Bogotá, Colombia. The patient had a clinical diagnosis of stage Ib1 squamous cell carcinoma of the cervix and was taken to radical trachelectomy plus bilateral pelvic lymphadenectomy because of her wish to preserve fertility. During the procedure, a complete dissection of the obturator nerve was recognized and repaired immediately through the laparoscopic approach. A literature search was conducted in the Medline database via PubMed. The terms used for the search were "Obturator Nerve," "Lymph Node Excision," "Trauma," "Nervous System". The search was limited to publications in Spanish and English and included case series and reports, cohorts and review articles published between 1968 and September 2018.

Results

Eight studies were included, all of them case reports. In six cases, complete sectioning of the nerve was recognized during surgery. In four cases, end-to-end anastomosis was used for repair; three cases were reconstructed using sural nerve grafting; and one case was managed with neurolysis and end-to-end anastomosis. All cases were approached laparoscopically. Over a nine-month follow-up period, three patients recovered full nerve function.

Conclusion

The studies retrieved were all case reports, the most frequent injury being complete nerve sectioning. Several nerve repair techniques were used. Recovery after one year was not complete in a significant number of the cases reported.

Proximal location of explanted midurethral slings is associated with urinary storage symptoms

AIM

To examine the location of midurethral slings (MUS) at the time of excision to determine associations between presenting symptoms and sling location at explant.

METHODS

We performed an IRB approved, retrospective review of MUS explants between January 2011 and March 2016. Symptoms and physical examination findings were compared between women with slings explanted from the mid-urethra (MU) and women with slings explanted from the proximal urethra/bladder neck (PU/BN).

RESULTS

We included 95 consecutive women who underwent MUS explant in the analysis. Presenting symptoms included pain in 69 women (72.6%), urinary urgency in 66 (66.5%), voiding dysfunction in 55 (57.9%), urge urinary incontinence (UUI) in 41 (43.2%), stress urinary incontinence in 34 (35.8%), and recurrent urinary tract infections in 22 (23.2%). At sling explant, 2 (2.1%) slings were found at the distal urethra, 33 (34.7%) at the MU and 60 (63.2%) at the PU/BN. Women with slings explanted from the PU/BN were more likely to present with urgency (78.3% vs 54.5%; P = 0.017) and UUI (53.3% vs 27.3%; P = 0.015) and less likely to present with pain on examination (48.3% vs 75.8%; P = 0.01).

CONCLUSIONS

The majority of MUS requiring explant in this cohort were found at the PU/BN. The most common presenting symptom before MUS explant was pain, followed by urgency and voiding dysfunction. PU/BN location of MUS is likely a factor in the development of urgency and UUI in women who ultimately undergo explant.

Gentle cyclic straining of human fibroblasts on electrospun scaffolds enhances their regenerative potential

The extracellular matrix of fascia-like tissues is a resilient network of collagenous fibers that withstand the forces of daily life. When overstretched, the matrix may tear, with serious consequences like pelvic organ prolapse (POP). Synthetic implants can provide mechanical support and evoke a host response that induces new matrix production, thus reinforcing the fascia. However, there is considerable risk of scar formation and tissue contraction which result in severe complications. Matrix producing fibroblasts are both mechanosensitive and contractile; their behavior depends on the implant's surface texture and mechanical straining. Here we investigate the effect of both in a newly-designed experimental setting. Electrospun scaffolds of Nylon and PLGA/PCL and a non-porous PLGA/PCL film were clamped like a drumhead and seeded with fibroblasts of POP patients. Upon confluency, scaffolds were cyclically strained for 24 or 72 h at 10% and 0.2 Hz, mimicking gentle breathing. Non-loading condition was control. Strained fibroblasts loosened their actin-fibers, thereby preventing myofibroblastic differentiation. Mechanical loading upregulated genes involved in matrix synthesis (collagen I, III, V and elastin), matrix remodeling (α-SMA, TGF-β1, MMP-2) and inflammation (COX-2, TNF-α, IL8, IL1-β). Collagen genes were expressed earlier under mechanical loading and the ratio of I/III collagen increased. Matrix synthesis and remodeling were stronger on the electrospun scaffolds, while inflammation was more prominent on the non-porous film. Our findings indicate that mechanical straining enhances the regenerative potential of fibroblasts for the regeneration of fascia-type tissues and limit the risk of scar tissue formation. These effects are stronger on an electrospun texture. STATEMENT OF SIGNIFICANCE: Pelvic organ prolapsed is a dysfunctional disease in female pelvic floor that can reduce the quality of life women. Currently, trans-vaginal knitted meshes are used to anatomically correct the dysfunctional tissues. However, the meshes can create sever adverse complications in some patients (e.g. chronic pain) in longer-term. As an alternative, we developed nanofibrous matrices by electrospinning based on different materials. We designed an in-vitro culture system and subjected cell-seeded matrices to cyclic mechanical loading. Results revealed that gentle straining of POP-cells on electrospun matrices, advances their regenerative potential at morphological and gene expression levels. Our findings, provide a proof-of-concept for using electrospun matrices as an alternative implant for pelvic floor repair, given that the parameters are designed efficiently and safely.