Ten-year retrospective study of the effectiveness of quantitative percussion diagnostics as an indicator of the level of structural pathology in teeth

A Clinical Prediction Rule for Predicting the Health-related Quality of Life after 5 Months in Patients with Knee Osteoarthritis Undergoing Conservative Treatment

OBJECTIVE

This study aimed to derive a clinical prediction rule (CPR) that can predict changes in health-related quality of life at 5 months for patients with knee osteoarthritis (KOA) undergoing conservative treatment.

METHODS

Patients with KOA receiving physical therapy and exercise therapy at an outpatient clinic were included in this study. The basic characteristics, medical information, and motor function test results were recorded at baseline. The primary outcome measure was the change in the Japan Knee Osteoarthritis Measure (JKOM) 5 months after the baseline measurement. A decision tree analysis was performed with the basic characteristics, medical information, and the motor function test results as the independent variables and the changes in the JKOM after 5 months (≥8 in the improved groups) as the dependent variable.

RESULTS

Analyzed data from 87 patients. The variables included the visual analog scale score, bilateral KOA, 5-m walk test, JKOM, and body mass index. Six CPRs were obtained from the terminal nodes. Accuracy validation of the model for the entire decision tree revealed an area under the receiver operating characteristic curve of 0.87 (validation data: 0.83), a positive likelihood ratio of 2.6, and a negative likelihood ratio of 0.1.

CONCLUSION

This CPR is an inspection characteristic that can exclude the possibility of the occurrence of an event based on a negative result. However, since the results of this study represent the first process of utilizing the CPR in actual clinical practice, its application should be kept in mind.

Finite element modeling of an intact and cracked mandibular second molar under quantitative percussion diagnostics loading

STATEMENT OF PROBLEM

Quantitative percussion diagnostics (QPD) has been devised to nondestructively evaluate the mechanical integrity of human teeth and implants, the mechanical integrity of the underlying bone, and the presence of cracks, but the mechanism is not clearly understood.

PURPOSE

The purpose of this study is to better understand the dynamic behavior of a tooth under conditions consistent with QPD by focusing on physiologically accurate 3D finite element models of a human mandibular second molar with surrounding tissues.

MATERIAL AND METHODS

Finite element analysis (FEA) was used to study the force response of dental structures measured by the sensor in a QPD handpiece. A defect-free (intact) and a cracked tooth model containing a vertical crack involving enamel, dentin, periodontal ligament, bone, and the QPD percussion rod were used for this purpose. Different crack gap spaces were studied for comparison. The FEA model was validated with clinical QPD data for a second mandibular molar containing a vertical crack that subsequently had to be extracted. The location and size of the vertical crack was determined once the tooth was extracted.

RESULTS

The present FEA results exhibited features consistent with those of corresponding clinical data, thus verifying the model. An examination of the relative acceleration of the crack faces with respect to each other revealed that an oscillation between the crack surfaces results in secondary peaks in the QPD energy return response compared with that of an intact tooth.

CONCLUSIONS

The present FEA modeling can generate simulated QPD results that exhibit established distinguishing characteristics in clinical QPD data for intact and cracked second mandibular molars. The model results also give insight into how QPD detects the presence of cracks and show that the oscillation of crack surfaces can produce the multipeak QPD results for a cracked molar observed clinically.

An evaluation of quantitative percussion diagnostics for determining the probability of a microgap defect in restored and unrestored teeth: A prospective clinical study

STATEMENT OF PROBLEM

Current dental diagnostics are image based and cannot detect a structural microgap defect such as a crack in a tooth. Whether percussion diagnostics can effectively diagnose a microgap defect is unclear.

PURPOSE

The purpose of the present study was to determine from a large multicenter prospective clinical study whether quantitative percussion diagnostics (QPD) could detect structural damage in teeth and whether a probability of its presence could be provided.

MATERIAL AND METHODS

A nonrandomized prospective and multicenter clinical validation study with 224 participants was performed in 5 centers with 6 independent investigators. The study used QPD and the normal fit error to determine whether a microgap defect was present in a natural tooth. Teams 1 and 2 were blinded. Team 1 tested teeth scheduled for restoration with QPD, and Team 2 disassembled the teeth aided by a clinical microscope, transillumination, and a penetrant dye. Microgap defects were documented in written and video formats. Controls were participants without damaged teeth. The percussion response from each tooth was stored on a computer and analyzed. A total of 243 teeth were tested to provide approximately 95% power to test the performance goal of 70%, based on an assumed population overall agreement of 80%.

RESULTS

Regardless of the collection method, tooth geometry, restoration material used, or restoration type, the data on detecting a microgap defect in a tooth were accurate. The data also reflected good sensitivity and specificity consistent with previously published clinical studies. The combined study data showed an overall agreement of 87.5% with a 95% confidence interval (84.2 to 90.3), beyond the 70% predetermined performance goal. The combined study data determined whether it was possible to predict the probability of a microgap defect.

CONCLUSIONS

The results showed that the data on detecting microgap defects in a tooth site were consistently accurate and confirmed that QPD provided information to aid the clinician in treatment planning and early preventative treatment. QPD can also alert the clinician of probable diagnosed and undiagnosed structural problems via the use of a probability curve.

Treatment of cracked teeth: A comprehensive narrative review

OBJECTIVES

The term "cracked tooth" is used to describe an incomplete fracture initiated from the crown and progressing towards a subgingival direction. Despite the high prevalence of cracked teeth and their frequent association with symptoms and pulpal or periapical pathoses, there is still no consensus in the literature with regard to their restorative and endodontic management. Therefore, the aim of this narrative review was to evaluate the most relevant research and provide an up-to-date comprehensive overview regarding the treatment of cracked teeth.

MATERIALS AND METHODS

An electronic literature search was carried out in MEDLINE (via Ovid), Embase (via Ovid), Scopus, and Web of Science as well as several "Grey literature" sources up to February 22nd 2022 using a combination of pre-specified 'free-text' terms (keywords) and "subject headings." The search process was supplemented by handsearching in relevant dental journals and reference lists. This narrative review focused on clinical follow-up studies (observational or interventional studies, case series/reports), laboratory studies and systematic reviews written in English language that reported data on treatment of permanent cracked teeth. The selection of relevant studies was carried out by two reviewers (AK and DG) working independently in two consecutive stages: title/abstract screening and full-text retrieval. Any discrepancies in the study selection were resolved by discussion between the reviewers.

RESULTS

In total, 64 articles were selected for inclusion in this narrative review.

CONCLUSIONS

Cracked teeth with normal pulp or reversible pulpitis have exhibited high pulp and tooth survival rates by the provision of direct or indirect composite restorations. Besides, recent data favour monitoring, especially in the absence of symptoms or compromised tooth structure. When endodontic intervention is required, current evidence suggests that along with appropriate restorative management, outcomes of cracked teeth may be comparable to those of non-cracked root filled teeth.

Finite Element Study of Periodontal Ligament Properties for a Maxillary Central Incisor and a Mandibular Second Molar Under Percussion Conditions

Purpose

The quantitative percussion diagnostics (QPD) response of a mandibular second molar and a maxillary central incisor including their supporting ligament/bone structure was simulated using dynamic 3D finite element analysis (FEA). The focus of the work was on the role of the periodontal ligament (PDL) which acts as a damper in the dental structure and dissipates occlusal forces transmitted from the tooth surface to the surrounding bone.

Methods

Several FEA models were developed to examine the effects of mechanical characteristics that have been reported for the PDL. Specifically, the effects of changing the PDL’s quasi-static elastic modulus and Rayleigh damping properties were predicted.

Results

The present FEA simulations indicate that the PDL can significantly reduce forces for both the incisor and the molar compared to when there is no PDL (i.e. ankylosed tooth) as long as the quasi-static elastic modulus of the PDL is among the lowest reported (~ 0.1 MPa). In addition, the FEA simulations for both the incisor and molar with this lower value of the PDL quasi-static elastic modulus are also in reasonably good agreement with experimental percussion data. A simple approximation for partitioning Rayleigh damping properties between the hard and soft tissues was also found to provide reasonable values of overall damping that are consistent with experimental data.

Conclusion

The overall findings indicate that using a quasi-static elastic modulus of approximately 0.1 MPa for the PDL in combination with Rayleigh damping gives realistic predictions of the mechanical response of a tooth under QPD loading conditions.