Mesenchymal hamartoma of the liver: A proliferative lesion of possible hepatic stellate cell (Ito cell) origin

Outcomes of Primary Tumor Excision do not Differ from Non-Resection Methods in Pediatric Mesenchymal Hamartoma of the Liver: A Rapid Systematic Review

BACKGROUND

To conduct a rapid systematic review comparing the outcomes of primary tumor resection versus non-resection on patients with hepatic mesenchymal hamartoma.

METHODS

We searched the Ovid MEDLINE, EMBASE, Scopus, PubMed, Web of Science, and Google Scholar databases from January 1, 2000 to March 31, 2022. Studies that described cases of hepatic mesenchymal hamartoma, including management and outcomes, were included.

RESULTS

62 articles met inclusion criteria with 95 cases in total. Patients were assigned to the primary tumor resection (n = 85) or non-resection (n = 10) cohort based on the described management. Similar rates of morbidity (17% vs 20%) and mortality (6 vs 10%) were identified between cohorts. There were no differences in sex, liver lobe involvement, or tumor size among study groups.

CONCLUSIONS

Complete tumor resection should remain the gold standard for hepatic mesenchymal hamartomas when an adequate liver remnant exists. Reports of non-resected tumors demonstrating spontaneous regression or stability with watchful waiting have poor long term follow-up and have inadequate evidence of a true mesenchymal hamartoma diagnosis.

LEVEL OF EVIDENCE

Level I.

Pediatric Mesenchymal Hamartomas of the Liver can Show Both Foregut and Hindgut Phenotype

Cystic epithelium in mesenchymal hamartoma (MH) is typically biliary type. Mucinous differentiation of the epithelium and increased hepatocellular component may pose a diagnostic challenge. We studied MH in 7 children (6 M, 1 F; age 4 months to 8 years, median 1 year). Resected tumors varied from 3.0 to 17.0 cm. All tumors showed biliary epithelium in the cystic component with strong and diffuse reactivity for CK7 and CK19. Expression of CK20 and CDX2 was additionally seen in 2 tumors, rare/focal in 1, and diffuse with mucinous differentiation in the other. Strong and continuous nuclear reactivity for Sox9 was seen in the cyst epithelium in all 7 tumors including focal staining in mucinous areas. It was also positive in the hepatocellular component. CD56 and vimentin were variably positive in the cystic epithelium of all cases. Alpha-fetoprotein showed patchy weak staining in the hepatocellular component and was negative in the cystic epithelium. Hepar-1 showed focal staining in the cystic epithelium in 4/7 cases and diffuse in the hepatocellular component. Both patients showing CK20 and CDX2 expression had abnormal chromosomal analysis: one with balanced translocation between chromosomes 2 and 19 and other with loss of chromosome Y. Among others, one showed 46,XY,inv(9)(p11q12), one did not grow cells, and the remaining 3 had normal karyotype. Six patients underwent resection and one had liver transplantation. All were alive and well with a median follow-up of 1.5 years. In conclusion, mucinous epithelium can be seen in MH. Expression of Sox9 in the cyst epithelium and hepatocytes suggests a common origin for these components. Expression of vimentin indicates an overlapping epithelial-mesenchymal phenotype. Hepatic MH can show divergent epithelial differentiation including both foregut and hindgut phenotype, which may provide insights into the pathogenesis of this rare neoplasm but does not seem to affect the outcome in this limited series.

Mesenchymal Hamartoma of the Liver in Older Children: An Adult Variant or a Different Entity? Report of a Case With Review of the Literature

Mesenchymal hamartoma of the liver (MHL) is an uncommon benign hepatic tumor typically affecting children under 2 years of age. Only 5% of MHL occur after 5 years and are very rarely observed in adults. According to age, MHL may differ in their morphologic features. We report a case of an 11-year-old boy with MHL, resembling a malignant lesion from a clinical point of view, characterized by unusual histologic features: a prominent myxoid stroma, with a minimal ductular component, and absent cystic spaces. The present case and others reported in older children or adults demonstrate that these lesions may represent a potential diagnostic pitfall when occurring outside their classic clinical context especially because of their peculiar histologic findings. Moreover, it may be hypothesized that variation in morphology might be related to different evolutive stages of the cell of origin. To support this hypothesis, we therefore studied the presence of components of the Notch pathway inside and outside the lesion. Their absence inside the tumor and, in contrast, the expression of Notch2 and HES1 evident in overrepresented bile ducts present at the periphery might explain not only the lack of bile ducts, but also indicate a more adult phenotype compared with classic pediatric MHL, which show more bile ducts and liver trabeculae embedded in the mesenchymal matrix.

Mesenchymal hamartoma or embryonal sarcoma of the liver in childhood: a difficult diagnosis before complete surgical excision

BACKGROUND

Clinical experience shows that the primary diagnosis of mesenchymal hamartoma (MHL) and embryonal sarcoma of the liver (ESL) recurrently is mistaken, leading to inadequate managements. We evaluated the accuracy of the primary diagnosis of those liver tumors, compared with the final histological diagnosis.

METHODS

Records of 25 children (0-16 years, treated 01/1989-01/2013) with final diagnosis of MHL or ESL were analyzed.

RESULTS

Final diagnosis was MHL in 18/25 children (10 solid-cystic, 2 cystic, 6 solid) and ESL in 7/25 (4 solid-cystic, 1 cystic, 2 solid). Only 3/7 ESL patients and 15/18 MHL patients fell into the "typical" age group. In 13/25 children primary diagnosis was based on imaging only. Overall, primary diagnosis was concordant with the final diagnosis in 17/25 patients. Of 99/25 biopsied cases, 4/9 biopsy results exposed the wrong final diagnosis; of cystic-solid masses 4/14 were mistaken, of cystic masses 1/3, of solid masses 3/8.

CONCLUSION

Preoperative diagnosis of MHL and ESL is challenging because of atypical clinical presentation, misleading "typical" radiological findings, and difficult interpretation of biopsies. If feasible, complete surgical resection of, in particular, solid-cystic liver masses in the pediatric age group must be aimed for, to get a definitive, final diagnosis, followed by an adequate treatment strategy.

Hepatic mesenchymal hamartoma in a neonate with a Bochdalek diaphragmatic hernia: a case report

The Bochdalek diaphragmatic hernia (BDH) is a common birth defect that is associated with other congenital malformations. Hepatic mesenchymal hamartoma (HMH) is the second most common benign hepatic tumor in children. The association between BDH and HMH or ectopic hepatic tissue is uncommon. We report a case of a female newborn with a left BDH that at surgery was incidentally found to have a tumor of 3.5 cm in maximum dimension with a serous muscular membrane. The histopathological study revealed vascular-mesenchymal stroma with bile ducts entrapped and peripheral normal hepatic tissue. These findings correlate with the diagnosis of hepatic mesenchymal hamartoma (HMH) in ectopic hepatic tissue. Our objective is to report a case of a rare association between HMH and BDH as well as discuss its differential diagnosis.