An extremely rare case of primary malignancy in giant cell tumor of bone, arising in the right femur and harboring H3F3A mutation

Reliability and Role of Mutation-specific H3F3A (Histone 3-3) G34W Immunohistochemistry to Differentiate Giant Cell Tumor of Bone From its Clinicoradiologic and Histologic Mimics: An Institutional Study

Giant cell tumor of bone (GCTB) is a benign neoplasm, which can sometimes be a diagnostic challenge, especially in small biopsies, due to its histologic benign and malignant mimics. We evaluated the role of H3.3 G34W immunohistochemistry (IHC) antibody in diagnosing GCTB and its role in differentiating it from its close histologic mimics. A total of 120 cases (80 cases of GCTB and 40 cases of histologic mimics) were retrieved and subjected to IHC. Of 80 cases of GCTB, 72 cases showed a positive nuclear immunoexpression, while all 40 cases of histologic mimics of GCTB showed a negative staining for H3.3 G34W IHC. Sensitivity and specificity of this mutation-specific antibody for diagnosis of GCTB was 90% and 100%, respectively, while, the positive predictive value and the negative predictive value were 100% and 83.3%, respectively. A positive expression of H3.3 G34W was seen in all 5 cases of GCTB, postdenosumab therapy, as well as, in all 3 cases of malignant giant cell tumor. The presented study showed that H3.3 G34W mutation-specific IHC is a reliable and specific marker for GCTB and can help distinguish it from the histologic mimics due to distinct therapeutic implications.

Malignancy in giant cell tumor of bone in the extremities

Background

Malignancy in giant cell tumor of bone (GCTB) is a rare tumor with relevant literature being sparse. In primary malignant GCTB, distinct areas of benign GCTB are juxtaposed with high-grade sarcoma, while in secondary malignant GCTB sarcoma occurs at the site of previously managed GCTB. This study assesses the distinguishing characteristics of patients with this condition, the time interval for development of secondary malignant GCTB, the outcome of treatment, and explores factors associated with oncologic outcomes.

Methods

This is a retrospective case series of patients from a prospectively collected institutional musculoskeletal oncology database. From January 1998 to December 2016, 1365 patients were managed for extremity GCTBs. 32 (2.3%) patients had malignant GCTB, including 12 with primary malignant GCTB and 20 with secondary malignant GCTB. The study population comprised 18 males and 14 females presenting at a mean age of 33.7 years (±13.0) and followed for a mean of 9.5 years (±7.4). Data were collected on patient and treatment-related factors, and the occurrence of local recurrence, metastasis, and death. The time from the diagnosis of GCTB to the secondary malignant GCTB was defined as the latent period.

Results

Malignant GCTB most commonly presents in the distal femur and proximal tibia with pain and swelling. Radiologically, they are aggressive Campanacci Grade III tumors with prominent bony destruction and soft tissue extension. In the 20 patients with secondary malignant GCTB, the tumors were osteosarcoma in 15, undifferentiated pleomorphic sarcoma in 4 patients and fibrosarcoma in one patient. The mean latent period in patients with secondary malignant GCTB was 7.9 year (±7.3). The median recurrence-free survival (RFS) of secondary malignant GCTB (latent period) and benign GCTB were 61.5 and 19 months respectively (p < 0.001), receiver operating curve analysis found 49.5 months to be the critical threshold, with a longer interval to recurrence being seen in malignant recurrence. The 5 and 10-year overall survival rate of malignant GCTB were 45.8% and 36.1% respectively. The 5-year survival rates of primary malignant GCTB and secondary malignant GCTB were 56.2% and 40.0% respectively (p = 0.188). Adequate surgical margins decreased the local recurrence (LR) rate (P = 0.006). Pulmonary metastasis developed in 69% of patients. The median distant metastasis-free survival between malignant GCTB and benign GCTB were 9 and 21 months (p = 0.002). Chemotherapy was associated with a longer pulmonary metastasis free survival (13 months Vs 6 months, P = 0.002), but not with increased overall survival (57.0% Vs 33.3%, P = 0.167).

Conclusions

Malignant GCTB carries a poor prognosis. Accurate diagnosis is critical to avoid inadequate surgical margins when treating primary malignant GCTB. Aggressive tumors and pulmonary metastasis should raise suspicion for malignant GCTB. Secondary malignant transformation should be suspected in patients presenting with recurrence especially after 4 years. Adjuvant chemotherapy use did not benefit survival, but was associated with increased pulmonary progression-free survival.

Absence of H3F3A mutation in a subset of malignant giant cell tumor of bone

Giant cell tumor of bone typically involves the epiphysis of the long bones of skeletally mature patients. It is genetically characterized by highly recurrent and specific mutations of the H3F3A gene, which encodes histone H3.3. The most common mutation H3F3A G34W can readily be detected by a recently developed mutation-specific antibody. Giant cell tumor of bone rarely transforms to a sarcoma (malignant giant cell tumor of bone), which has not been genetically characterized in detail. We studied seven clinicopathologically defined malignant giant cell tumors, as well as two H3F3A-mutant bone sarcomas without giant cell tumor histology using a combination of clinicopathological, immunohistochemical, and molecular methods (Sanger sequencing + pyrosequencing or next generation sequencing). The cases included five men and four women, with a median age at initial diagnosis of 27 years. The two H3F3A G34W-positive sarcomas without giant cell tumor histology involved the subarticular epiphyseal sites, suggesting relatedness with giant cell tumor of bone. In two of the seven clinicopathologically defined malignant giant cell tumor cases, the sarcoma tissue showed the H3F3A G34W mutation. However, in the remaining five cases, in contrast to their associated H3F3A G34W-mutant giant cell tumor, the sarcoma lacked the H3F3A G34W mutation, either entirely or sub-clonally in the samples tested. This discordant mutation status was confirmed in all instances by immunohistochemistry and sequencing. A FISH analysis suggested that the absence of the H3F3A G34W mutation may be related to deletion of the H3F3A gene. Therefore, we have demonstrated that H3F3A G34W mutation, a critical driver in giant cell tumor, is absent in a subset of malignant giant cell tumor of bone. This novel recurrent phenomenon has potential biological and diagnostic implications, and further study is required to better characterize this progression pathway and understand its mechanism.

Histone H3.3 mutation in giant cell tumor of bone: an update in pathology

Giant cell tumor of bone (GCTB) is a locally aggressive bone tumor that frequently shows local recurrence and occasionally shows malignant transformation to high-grade sarcoma. Histologically, conventional GCTB is composed mainly of three types of cells: mononuclear neoplastic cells with an osteoblastic precursor phenotype, mononuclear histiocytic cells, and osteoclast-like multinucleated giant cells. These cells interact with each other via the RANKL-RANK axis and other mechanisms for tumor formation. The vast majority of GCTBs were recently revealed to harbor H3F3A p.G34W mutation, and a minor subset have H3F3A p.G34L, p.G34M, p.G34R, or p.G34V mutation. H3.3 G34W mutant-specific immunohistochemistry is a highly sensitive and specific surrogate marker for H3F3A p.G34W mutation in GCTB and thus useful for differential diagnoses of histological mimics. H3.3 mutant-specific immunohistochemistry has also contributed to the understanding of the bone-forming ability of neoplastic cells of GCTB and the remarkable new bone formation after treatment with denosumab, an inhibitor of RANKL. In primary and secondary malignant GCTBs, the H3F3A gene allele can be preserved or lost with malignant transformation.