Impact of focal spot size on radiologic image quality: A visual grading analysis

[Physical Properties of Small Focal Spot Imaging with Deep Learning Reconstruction in Chest-abdominal Plain CT]

PURPOSE

The aim of this study was to compare the physical properties of small focal spot imaging with deep learning reconstruction (DLR) and small or large focal spot imaging with hybrid iterative reconstruction (IR) in chest-abdominal plain computed tomography.

METHOD

In small focal spot imaging using DLR and hybrid IR, tube currents were set at 350 mA. For the large focal spot imaging using hybrid IR, the tube current was set at 360, 400, 450, and 500 mA. The spatial frequencies with 50% task transfer function (TTF) for delrin and acrylic were calculated to compare spatial resolution properties for lung and soft tissue in the chest. Additionally, the low-contrast object-specific contrast-to-noise ratio (CNRLO) was measured as noise property was measured for a 7-mm module with a CT value contrast of 10 HU in the abdomen.

RESULT

Spatial frequencies with 50% TTF for delrin and acrylic were found to be greater in small focal spot imaging using DLR compared to those in small and large focal spot imaging using hybrid IR. Moreover, the CNRLO obtained from small focal spot imaging with DLR was also nearly equivalent to that of large focal spot imaging with hybrid IR at tube currents of 450 and 500 mA.

CONCLUSION

In chest-abdominal plain computed tomography, small focal spot imaging with DLR has been demonstrated to exhibit greater spatial resolution properties compared to small and large focal spot imaging with hybrid IR, with equivalent or better noise performance.

Optimisation of exposure parameters using a phantom for thoracic spine radiographs in antero-posterior and lateral views

INTRODUCTION

To investigate the exposure parameters for thoracic spine/(TS) radiography that allows the image acquisition at the lowest dose possible, while maintaining an adequate image quality/(IQ) to identify all relevant anatomical criteria.

METHODS

An experimental phantom study was conducted, and 48 different radiographs of TS (24 AP/24 lateral) were acquired. The Automatic Exposure Control/(AEC) with the central sensor was used to select the beam intensity, while Source-to-Detector-Distance/(SDD) (AP:115/125 cm; Lateral:115/150 cm), tube potential (AP:70/81/90 kVp; Lateral: 81/90/102 kVp), use of grid/no grid and focal spot (fine/broad) were manipulated. IQ was assessed by observers with ViewDEX. Effective Dose (ED) was estimated using PCXMC2.0 software. Descriptive statistics paired with intraclass correlation coefficient (ICC) were applied to analyse data.

RESULTS

The ED increased with a greater SDD for lateral-view, presenting a significant difference (p = 0.038), however IQ was not affected. For both AP and lateral, the use of grid had a significant effect on ED (p < 0.001). Despite the images acquired without grid had lower IQ scores, the observers considered the IQ adequate for clinical use. A 20% reduction in ED (0.042mSv-0.033 mSv) was observed when increasing the beam energy from 70 to 90 kVp for AP grid in. The observers ICC ranged from moderate to good (0.5-0.75) in lateral and good to excellent (0.75-0.9) for AP views.

CONCLUSIONS

The optimised parameters in this context were 115 cm SDD, 90 kVp with grid for the best IQ and lowest ED. Further studies in clinical setting are necessary to enlarge the context and cover different body habitus and equipment.

IMPLICATIONS FOR PRACTICE

The SDD impacts on dose for TS; Higher kVp and grid are necessary to better image quality.

Improving small animal cone beam CT resolution by mitigating x-ray focal spot induced blurring via deconvolution

Objective. Modern preclinical small animal radiation platforms utilize cone beam computerized tomography (CBCT) for image guidance and experiment planning purposes. The resolution of CBCT images is of particular importance for visualizing fine animal anatomical structures. One major cause of spatial resolution reduction is the finite size of the x-ray focal spot. In this work, we proposed a simple method to measure x-ray focal spot intensity map and a CBCT image domain deblurring model to mitigate the effect of focal spot-induced image blurring. Approach. We measured a projection image of a tungsten ball bearing using the flat panel detector of the CBCT platform. We built a forward blurring model of the projection image and derived the spot intensity map by deconvolving the measured projection image. Based on the measured spot intensity map, we derived a CBCT image domain blurring model for images reconstructed by the filtered backprojection algorithm. Based on this model, we computed image domain blurring kernel and improved the CBCT image resolution by deconvolving the CBCT image. Main results. We successfully measured the x-ray focal spot intensity map. The spot size characterized by full width at half maximum was ∼0.75 × 0.55 mm2 at 40 kVp. We computed image domain convolution kernels caused by the x-ray focal spot. A simulation study on noiseless projections was performed to evaluate the spatial resolution improvement exclusively by the focal spot kernel, and the modulation transfer function (MTF) at 50% was increased from 1.40 to 1.65 mm−1 for in-plane images and 1.05–1.32 mm−1 for cross-plane images. Experimental studies on a CT insert phantom and a plastinated mouse phantom demonstrated improved spatial resolution after image domain deconvolution, as indicated by visually improved resolution of fine structures. MTF at 50% was improved from 1.00 to 1.12 mm−1 for in-plane direction and from 0.72 to 0.84 mm−1 for cross-plane direction. Significance. The proposed method to mitigate blurring caused by finite x-ray spot size and improve CBCT image resolution is simple and effective.

Spinal vascular malformations: Angiographic evaluation and endovascular management

Spinal vascular malformations (SVM) are classified based on their location (intramedullary, perimedullary, radicular, extradural) and flow pattern (high-flow, low-flow, no arteriovenous shunt). High-flow SVMs are generally congenital lesions diagnosed in children and young patients without gender predominance. They present with hemodynamic disturbances, mass effect, or hemorrhages, but may also be discovered incidentally. Low-flow SVMs tend to be acquired lesions presenting in older men with progressive myelopathy caused by spinal venous hypertension. They are rarely associated with vascular syndromes but may accompany prothrombotic conditions. The sensitivity and specificity of conventional MRI are excellent for high-flow SVMs but poor for low-flow lesions, which are frequently diagnosed with extensive delays reducing the potential for favorable outcomes. The sensitivity of advanced MRI techniques remains unclear, notably for the detection of low-flow shunts without flow voids on conventional MRI. Catheter angiography remains the gold standard modality for the evaluation of the spinal vasculature and its disorders. SVMs can be treated by surgical or endovascular means. Initially plagued by high recurrence rates due to inadequate embolization material, endovascular techniques represent nowadays a valid alternative to surgery, thanks notably to the introduction of liquid embolic agents.

Introduction to Diagnostic and Therapeutic Spinal Angiography

This article describes the basic principles of diagnostic and therapeutic spinal angiography as practiced by the author, including catheterization and radioprotection techniques, the selection of endovascular devices and embolization agents, and procedural complications.

Efficacy of fine focal spot technique in CT angiography of neck

OBJECTIVES

Focal spot size partially defines spatial resolution of a CT system. Many CT tubes have two focal spot sizes, with the finer one allowing more detailed imaging at the cost of photon intensity and increased heat production. Improved X-ray technology and advancement of various generations of iterative reconstruction allow the use of fine focal spot technique in CT angiography. CT neck angiography (CTNA) has been commonly performed as part of stroke imaging or in the trauma setting. This prospective study aimed to assess the efficacy of fine focal spot scanning in vessel clarity improvement, vessel calcification and arterial pulsation artefact reduction on CTNA.

METHODS AND MATERIALS

Consecutive adult patients of all ages and genders who presented for CTNA were included. All CTNA were scanned with standard focal spot size (SFSS) of 1 × 1 mm in first 4 months while the CTNA in the following 4 months with fine focal spot size (FFSS) of 0.5 × 1 mm. Vessel clarity, calcification and arterial pulsation artefact of arch of aorta, brachiocephalic, subclavian, common carotid, carotid bifurcation, internal carotid, external carotid and vertebral arteries were assessed randomly using a 5-point scale by two blinded radiologists. Results were compared.

RESULTS

There were 43 patients (mean age 60) with 97 calcified arterial segments in SFSS and 48 patients (mean age 62) with 113 calcified arterial segments in FFSS. 30 % of patients had > 50% carotid artery stenosis. No occlusion or dissection was found in the remaining arteries. Mann-Whitney test showed FFSS performed significantly better for vessel clarity (U: 48238.50, p < .001,r: 0.556) and calcification artefact reduction (U: 2040.50, p < .001,r: 0.564). There was no significant reduction for arterial pulsation artefact.

CONCLUSION

Fine focal spot technique improves vessel clarity and reduces calcification blooming artefact in CTNA. These benefits may potentially improve the assessment of arterial luminal stenosis and vessel wall pathology, including plaque morphology.

ADVANCES IN KNOWLEDGE

Beam hardening artefact from calcification particularly in the vessel wall can often reduce the clarity of vessel lumen thus affect accurate assessment of luminal stenosis. Fine focal spot technique has the advantages of reducing beam-hardening artefact of vessel wall calcifications and improving vessel wall clarity, thus it may potentially improve the assessment of arterial luminal stenosis and vessel wall pathology, including plaque morphology. It may become an important CT imaging technique in near future.

Assessing the Effect of Packing the Sulcus on Image Quality in Equine Digital Radiography

The requirement to pack the sulcus of the equine foot as an aid to diagnostic interpretation before acquisition of dorsoproximal-palmarodistal oblique projections is debatable. The purpose of this study was to investigate the benefit of packing the sulcus in the assessment of normal anatomy. 23 cadaver limbs were radiographed in a podoblock (https://www.podoblock.com/products-page/podoblock/podoblock/) A non-packed image (NP) and a packed image (P) of the same foot were acquired. The image quality of P was graded against the reference NP by five observers, where -1=P was superior, 0=no difference between P and NP, and +1=NP was superior. Four anatomical criteria were used: the distal solar margin of the distal phalanx (DP), the vascular channels of DP, the palmar aspect of the distal interphalangeal joint and the articulation of the navicular bone with DP. A total Visual Grading Analysis Score of 0.28 indicates a preference for NP images. Packing was of benefit in only 10.8 per cent of cases. While judicious high-quality packing may be of benefit in a minority of cases, the routine packing of the sulcus in equine radiography was not found to be of benefit in the assessment of anatomical features in this study.

RELATIONSHIP BETWEEN RADIATION DOSE AND IMAGE QUALITY IN DIGITAL BREAST TOMOSYNTHESIS

This phantom-based study aimed to examine radiation dose from digital breast tomosynthesis (DBT) and digital mammography (DM) and to assess the potential for dose reductions for each modality. Images were acquired at 10-60 mm thicknesses and four dose levels and mean glandular dose was determined using a solid-state dosemeter. Eleven readers assessed image quality and compared simulated lesions with those on a reference image, and the data produced was analysed with the Friedman and Wilcoxon signed-rank tests. For a phantom thickness of 50 mm (typical breast thickness), DBT dose was 13 % higher than DM, but this differential is highly dependent on thickness. Visibility of masses was equal to a reference image (produced at 100 % dose) when dose was reduced by 75 and 50 % for DBT and DM. For microcalcifications, visibility was comparable with the reference image for both modalities at 50 % dose. This study highlighted the potential for reducing dose with DBT.

Methods for the analysis of ordinal response data in medical image quality assessment

The assessment of image quality in medical imaging often requires observers to rate images for some metric or detectability task. These subjective results are used in optimization, radiation dose reduction or system comparison studies and may be compared to objective measures from a computer vision algorithm performing the same task. One popular scoring approach is to use a Likert scale, then assign consecutive numbers to the categories. The mean of these response values is then taken and used for comparison with the objective or second subjective response. Agreement is often assessed using correlation coefficients. We highlight a number of weaknesses in this common approach, including inappropriate analyses of ordinal data and the inability to properly account for correlations caused by repeated images or observers. We suggest alternative data collection and analysis techniques such as amendments to the scale and multilevel proportional odds models. We detail the suitability of each approach depending upon the data structure and demonstrate each method using a medical imaging example. Whilst others have raised some of these issues, we evaluated the entire study from data collection to analysis, suggested sources for software and further reading, and provided a checklist plus flowchart for use with any ordinal data. We hope that raised awareness of the limitations of the current approaches will encourage greater method consideration and the utilization of a more appropriate analysis. More accurate comparisons between measures in medical imaging will lead to a more robust contribution to the imaging literature and ultimately improved patient care.

THORACIC SPINE IMAGING: A COMPARISON BETWEEN RADIOGRAPHY AND TOMOSYNTHESIS USING VISUAL GRADING CHARACTERISTICS

The aim of the present study was to evaluate digital tomosynthesis (DTS) in thoracic spine imaging, comparing the reproduction of anatomical structures with that achieved using digital radiography (DR). In a prospective visual grading study, 23 patients referred in 2014 for elective radiographic examination of the thoracic spine were examined using lateral DR and DTS. The DR image and the DTS section images were read in random order by four radiologists, evaluating the ability of the modalities to present a clear reproduction of nine specific relevant structures of the thoracic vertebrae 3, 6 and 9 (T3, T6 and T9). The data were analysed using visual grading characteristics (VGC) analysis. The VGC analysis revealed a statistically significant difference in favour of DTS for all evaluated structures, except for the anterior vertebral edges and lower end plate surfaces of T6 and T9 and the cancellous bone of T9. The difference was most striking in T3 and for posterior structures. For no structure in any vertebra was the reproduction rated significantly better for DR. In conclusion, DTS of the thoracic spine appears to be a promising alternative to DR, especially in areas where the problem of overlaying anatomy is accentuated, such as posterior and upper thoracic structures.