Luces y sombras en el diagnóstico genético de la miocardiopatía hipertrófica

Application of next generation sequencing in cardiology: current and future precision medicine implications

Inherited cardiovascular diseases are highly heterogeneous conditions with multiple genetic loci involved. The application of advanced molecular tools, such as Next Generation Sequencing, has facilitated the genetic analysis of these disorders. Accurate analysis and variant identification are required to maximize the quality of the sequencing data. Therefore, the application of NGS for clinical purposes should be limited to laboratories with a high level of technological expertise and resources. In addition, appropriate gene selection and variant interpretation can result in the highest possible diagnostic yield. Implementation of genetics in cardiology is imperative for the accurate diagnosis, prognosis and management of several inherited disorders and could eventually lead to the realization of precision medicine in this field. However, genetic testing should also be accompanied by an appropriate genetic counseling procedure that clarifies the significance of the genetic analysis results for the proband and his family. In this regard, a multidisciplinary collaboration among physicians, geneticists, and bioinformaticians is imperative. In the present review, we address the current state of knowledge regarding genetic analysis strategies employed in the field of cardiogenetics. Variant interpretation and reporting guidelines are explored. Additionally, gene selection procedures are accessed, with a particular emphasis on information concerning gene-disease associations collected from international alliances such as the Gene Curation Coalition (GenCC). In this context, a novel approach to gene categorization is proposed. Moreover, a sub-analysis is conducted on the 1,502,769 variation records with submitted interpretations in the Clinical Variation (ClinVar) database, focusing on cardiology-related genes. Finally, the most recent information on genetic analysis's clinical utility is reviewed.

Shared Molecular Mechanisms of Hypertrophic Cardiomyopathy and Its Clinical Presentations: Automated Molecular Mechanisms Extraction Approach

Hypertrophic cardiomyopathy (HCM) is the most common inherited cardiovascular disease with a prevalence of 1 in 500 people and varying clinical presentations. Although there is much research on HCM, underlying molecular mechanisms are poorly understood, and research on the molecular mechanisms of its specific clinical presentations is scarce. Our aim was to explore the molecular mechanisms shared by HCM and its clinical presentations through the automated extraction of molecular mechanisms. Molecular mechanisms were congregated by a query of the INDRA database, which aggregates knowledge from pathway databases and combines it with molecular mechanisms extracted from abstracts and open-access full articles by multiple machine-reading systems. The molecular mechanisms were extracted from 230,072 articles on HCM and 19 HCM clinical presentations, and their intersections were found. Shared molecular mechanisms of HCM and its clinical presentations were represented as networks; the most important elements in the intersections’ networks were found, centrality scores for each element of each network calculated, networks with reduced level of noise generated, and cooperatively working elements detected in each intersection network. The identified shared molecular mechanisms represent possible mechanisms underlying different HCM clinical presentations. Applied methodology produced results consistent with the information in the scientific literature.

Trabeculated Myocardium in Hypertrophic Cardiomyopathy: Clinical Consequences

Aims: Hypertrophic cardiomyopathy (HCM) is often accompanied by increased trabeculated myocardium (TM)—which clinical relevance is unknown. We aim to measure the left ventricular (LV) mass and proportion of trabeculation in an HCM population and to analyze its clinical implication. Methods and Results: We evaluated 211 patients with HCM (mean age 47.8 ± 16.3 years, 73.0% males) with cardiac magnetic resonance (CMR) studies. LV trabecular and compacted mass were measured using dedicated software for automatic delineation of borders. Mean compacted myocardium (CM) was 160.0 ± 62.0 g and trabecular myocardium (TM) 55.5 ± 18.7 g. The percentage of trabeculated myocardium (TM%) was 26.7% ± 6.4%. Females had significantly increased TM% compared to males (29.7 ± 7.2 vs. 25.6 ± 5.8, p < 0.0001). Patients with LVEF < 50% had significantly higher values of TM% (30.2% ± 6.0% vs. 26.6% ± 6.4%, p = 0.02). Multivariable analysis showed that female gender and neutral pattern of hypertrophy were directly associated with TM%, while dynamic obstruction, maximal wall thickness and LVEF% were inversely associated with TM%. There was no association between TM% with arterial hypertension, physical activity, or symptoms. Atrial fibrillation and severity of hypertrophy were the only variables associated with cardiovascular death. Multivariable analysis failed to demonstrate any correlation between TM% and arrhythmias. Conclusions: Approximately 25% of myocardium appears non-compacted and can automatically be measured in HCM series. Proportion of non-compacted myocardium is increased in female, non-obstructives, and in those with lower contractility. The amount of trabeculation might help to identify HCM patients prone to systolic heart failure.

Managing uncertainty in inherited cardiac pathologies-an international multidisciplinary survey

Multi-gene testing is useful in genetically heterogeneous conditions, including inherited cardiac pathologies. Increasing the number of genes analysed increases diagnostic yield of variants of certain, likely, or uncertain pathogenicity. Concerns exist regarding management of variants of uncertain/likely pathogenicity in conditions of oligogenic inheritance or variable expressivity. We surveyed a sample of colleagues across different specialties and departments internationally to compare management of patients with class 3 or class 4 variants in genes associated with non-syndromic cardiomyopathy or arrhythmia. An electronic survey regarding clinical management of variants ( www.surveymonkey.com/r/cardiacvariants ) was designed and distributed to colleagues internationally via professional bodies and direct email. 150 respondents (88 centres, 27 countries) completed the survey, most of whom were Clinical Geneticists or Genetic Counsellors. Most respondents offer pre-symptomatic testing to asymptomatic relatives of an individual with class 4 or class 5 variants. A minority of respondents offer pre-symptomatic testing for class 3 variants. Considering class 4 variants, 22 (15%) are fully reassuring that the patient with a negative predictive test would not develop the familial phenotype, while 123 (82%) counselled patients about the possibility of variant reclassification. Variability existed between and within centres and specialties. Multiple "free text" comments were provided. Recurring themes including need for multidisciplinary input, technical concerns, and concern regarding duty to review variants of uncertain significance. This study demonstrates that variability in management of likely pathogenic/uncertain variants exists. Close multi-disciplinary input is essential. The development of disorder or gene-specific evidence-based guidelines might ameliorate uncertainty in management.

The HCM-causing Y235S cMyBPC mutation accelerates contractile function by altering C1 domain structure

Mutations in cardiac myosin binding protein C (cMyBPC) are a major cause of hypertrophic cardiomyopathy (HCM). In particular, a single amino acid substitution of tyrosine to serine at residue 237 in humans (residue 235 in mice) has been linked to HCM with strong disease association. Although cMyBPC truncations, deletions and insertions, and frame shift mutations have been studied, relatively little is known about the functional consequences of missense mutations in cMyBPC. In this study, we characterized the functional and structural effects of the HCM-causing Y235S mutation by performing mechanical experiments and molecular dynamics simulations (MDS). cMyBPC null mouse myocardium was virally transfected with wild-type (WT) or Y235S cMyBPC (KO^Y235S). We found that Y235S cMyBPC was properly expressed and incorporated into the cardiac sarcomere, suggesting that the mechanism of disease of the Y235S mutation is not haploinsufficiency or poison peptides. Mechanical experiments in detergent-skinned myocardium isolated from KO^Y235S hearts revealed hypercontractile behavior compared to KO^WT hearts, evidenced by accelerated cross-bridge kinetics and increased Ca²⁺ sensitivity of force generation. In addition, MDS revealed that the Y235S mutation causes alterations in important intramolecular interactions, surface conformations, and electrostatic potential of the C1 domain of cMyBPC. Our combined in vitro and in silico data suggest that the Y235S mutation directly disrupts internal and surface properties of the C1 domain of cMyBPC, which potentially alters its ligand-binding interactions. These molecular changes may underlie the mechanism for hypercontractile cross-bridge behavior, which ultimately results in the development of cardiac hypertrophy and in vivo cardiac dysfunction.

[Genetic tests in hypertrophic cardiomyopathy: Benefits, limitations, and applications in clinical practice]

Hypertrophic cardiomyopathy is the most common monogenic heart disease. Its phenotypic expression is quite variable. In up to 60% of the cases, mutations are described in the genes coding for cardiac sarcomer proteins. Massive sequencing of deoxyribonucleic acid makes it possible to discover new genes responsible for the disease, but it has the disadvantage of discovering numerous variants of uncertain significance in these patients. The strategy used, especially when they do not segregate with the disease, is one of the challenges of genetics. Pathogenicity criteria may help to catalogue this variant. The genetic tests on the index case a diagnosis to be made, and the possibility of cascading to first degree relatives. The presence or not of a positive genotype in the relatives will determine the subsequent follow-up guidelines. The appearance of a positive genotype is a poor prognosis regardless of the type of mutation.

The HCM-linked W792R mutation in cardiac myosin-binding protein C reduces C6 FnIII domain stability

Cardiac myosin-binding protein C (cMyBP-C) is a functional sarcomeric protein that regulates contractility in response to contractile demand, and many mutations in cMyBP-C lead to hypertrophic cardiomyopathy (HCM). To gain insight into the effects of disease-causing cMyBP-C missense mutations on contractile function, we expressed the pathogenic W792R mutation (substitution of a highly conserved tryptophan residue by an arginine residue at position 792) in mouse cardiomyocytes lacking endogenous cMyBP-C and studied the functional effects using three-dimensional engineered cardiac tissue constructs (mECTs). Based on complete conservation of tryptophan at this location in fibronectin type II (FnIII) domains, we hypothesized that the W792R mutation affects folding of the C6 FnIII domain, destabilizing the mutant protein. Adenoviral transduction of wild-type (WT) and W792R cDNA achieved equivalent mRNA transcript abundance, but not equivalent protein levels, with W792R compared with WT controls. mECTs expressing W792R demonstrated abnormal contractile kinetics compared with WT mECTs that were nearly identical to cMyBP-C-deficient mECTs. We studied whether common pathways of protein degradation were responsible for the rapid degradation of W792R cMyBP-C. Inhibition of both ubiquitin-proteasome and lysosomal degradation pathways failed to increase full-length mutant protein abundance to WT equivalence, suggesting rapid cytosolic degradation. Bacterial expression of WT and W792R protein fragments demonstrated decreased mutant stability with altered thermal denaturation and increased susceptibility to trypsin digestion. These data suggest that the W792R mutation destabilizes the C6 FnIII domain of cMyBP-C, resulting in decreased full-length protein expression. This study highlights the vulnerability of FnIII-like domains to mutations that alter domain stability and further indicates that missense mutations in cMyBP-C can cause disease through a mechanism of haploinsufficiency. NEW & NOTEWORTHY This study is one of the first to describe a disease mechanism for a missense mutation in cardiac myosin-binding protein C linked to hypertrophic cardiomyopathy. The mutation decreases stability of the fibronectin type III domain and results in substantially reduced mutant protein expression dissonant to transcript abundance.

Exploring evidence of positive selection signatures in cattle breeds selected for different traits

Since domestication, the genome landscape of cattle has been changing due to natural and artificial selection forces resulting in several general and specialized cattle breeds of the world. Identifying genomic regions affected due to these forces in livestock gives an insight into the history of selection for economically important traits and genetic adaptation to specific environments of the populations under consideration. This study explores the genes/genomic regions under selection in relation to the phenotypes of Holstein, Hanwoo, and N'Dama cattle breeds using Tajima's D, XP-CLR, and XP-EHH population statistical methods. The whole genomes of 10 Holstein (South Korea), 11 Hanwoo (South Korea), and 10 N'Dama (West Africa-Guinea) cattle breeds re-sequenced to ~11x coverage and retained 37 million SNPs were used for the study. Selection signature analysis revealed 441, 512, and 461 genes under selection from Holstein, Hanwoo, and N'Dama cattle breeds, respectively. Among all these, seven genes including ARFGAP3, SNORA70, and other RNA genes were common between the breeds. From each of the gene lists, significant functional annotation cluster terms including milk protein and thyroid hormone signaling pathway (Holstein), histone acetyltransferase activity (Hanwoo), and renin secretion (N'Dama) were enriched. Genes that are related to the phenotypes of the respective breeds were also identified. Moreover, significant breed-specific missense variants were identified in CSN3, PAPPA2 (Holstein), C1orf116 (Hanwoo), and COMMD1 (N'Dama) genes. The genes identified from this study provide an insight into the biological mechanisms and pathways that are important in cattle breeds selected for different traits of economic significance.

Human Missense Mutations in Regulator of G Protein Signaling 2 Affect the Protein Function Through Multiple Mechanisms

Regulator of G protein signaling 2 (RGS2) plays a significant role in alleviating vascular contraction and promoting vascular relaxation due to its GTPase accelerating protein activity toward Gαq. Mice lacking RGS2 display a hypertensive phenotype, and several RGS2 missense mutations have been found predominantly in hypertensive human subjects. However, the mechanisms whereby these mutations could impact blood pressure is unknown. Here, we selected 16 rare, missense mutations in RGS2 identified in various human exome sequencing projects and evaluated their ability to inhibit intracellular calcium release mediated by angiotensin II receptor type 1 (AT1R). Four of them had reduced function and were further investigated to elucidate underlying mechanisms. Low protein expression, protein mislocalization, and reduced G protein binding were identified as likely mechanisms of the malfunctioning mutants. The Q2L mutant had 50% lower RGS2 than wild-type (WT) protein detected by Western blot. Confocal microscopy demonstrated that R44H and D40Y had impaired plasma membrane targeting; only 46% and 35% of those proteins translocated to the plasma membrane when coexpressed with Gα_q Q209L compared with 67% for WT RGS2. The R188H mutant had a significant reduction in Gα_q binding affinity (10-fold increase in K_i compared with WT RGS2 in a flow cytometry competition binding assay). This study provides functional data for 16 human RGS2 missense variants on their effects on AT1R-mediated calcium mobilization and provides molecular understanding of those variants with functional loss in vitro. These molecular behaviors can provide insight to inform antihypertensive therapeutics in individuals with variants having reduced function.

Factors Influencing the Phenotypic Expression of Hypertrophic Cardiomyopathy in Genetic Carriers

INTRODUCTION AND OBJECTIVES

Hypertrophic cardiomyopathy (HCM) is a disorder with variable expression. It is mainly caused by mutations in sarcomeric genes but the phenotype could be modulated by other factors. The aim of this study was to determine whether factors such as sex, systemic hypertension, or physical activity are modifiers of disease severity and to establish their role in age-related penetrance of HCM.

METHODS

We evaluated 272 individuals (mean age 49 ± 17 years, 57% males) from 72 families with causative mutations. The relationship between sex, hypertension, physical activity, and left ventricular hypertrophy was studied.

RESULTS

The proportion of affected individuals increased with age. Men developed the disease 12.5 years earlier than women (adjusted median, 95%CI, -17.52 to -6.48; P < .001). Hypertensive patients were diagnosed with HCM later (10.8 years of delay) than normotensive patients (adjusted median, 95%CI, 6.28-17.09; P < .001). Individuals who performed physical activity were diagnosed with HCM significantly earlier (7.3 years, adjusted median, 95%CI, -14.49 to -1.51; P = .016). Sex, hypertension, and the degree of physical activity were not significantly associated with the severity of left ventricular hypertrophy. Adjusted survival both free from sudden death and from the combined event were not influenced by any of the exploratory variables.

CONCLUSIONS

Men and athletes who are carriers of sarcomeric mutations are diagnosed earlier than women and sedentary individuals. Hypertensive carriers of sarcomeric mutations have a delayed diagnosis. Sex, hypertension, and physical activity are not associated with disease severity in carriers of HCM causative mutations.

Spectrum of Mutations in Hypertrophic Cardiomyopathy Genes Among Tunisian Patients

BACKGROUND

Hypertrophic cardiomyopathy (HCM) is a common cardiac genetic disorder associated with heart failure and sudden death. Mutations in the cardiac sarcomere genes are found in approximately half of HCM patients and are more common among cases with a family history of the disease. Data about the mutational spectrum of the sarcomeric genes in HCM patients from Northern Africa are limited. The population of Tunisia is particularly interesting due to its Berber genetic background. As founder mutations have been reported in other disorders.

METHODS

We performed semiconductor chip (Ion Torrent PGM) next generation sequencing of the nine main sarcomeric genes (MYH7, MYBPC3, TNNT2, TNNI3, ACTC1, TNNC1, MYL2, MYL3, TPM1) as well as the recently identified as an HCM gene, FLNC, in 45 Tunisian HCM patients.

RESULTS

We found sarcomere gene polymorphisms in 12 patients (27%), with MYBPC3 and MYH7 representing 83% (10/12) of the mutations. One patient was homozygous for a new MYL3 mutation and two were double MYBPC3 + MYH7 mutation carriers. Screening of the FLNC gene identified three new mutations, which points to FLNC mutations as an important cause of HCM among Tunisians.

CONCLUSION

The mutational background of HCM in Tunisia is heterogeneous. Unlike other Mendelian disorders, there were no highly prevalent mutations that could explain most of the cases. Our study also suggested that FLNC mutations may play a role on the risk for HCM among Tunisians.