Fetal exposure to isotretinoin—An international problem

A new perspective on isotretinoin in pregnancy: Pregnancy outcomes, evaluation of complex phenotypes, and importance of teratological counselling

OBJECTIVES

Teratogens are responsible for 5% of all known causes of congenital anomalies. Isotretinoin, a retinoic acid-derived agent, leads to congenital anomalies in 21-52% of cases when exposure occurs during pregnancy according to studies conducted before 2006. However, rates of congenital anomalies were much lower in later studies. The purpose of this study was to investigate the rates of congenital anomalies in isotretinoin exposure during pregnancy, isotretinoin exposure before pregnancy, and a control group unexposed to any teratogenic agents.

STUDY DESIGN

In this cohort study, we divided pregnant women admitted to our center between 2009 and 2020 into two groups: isotretinoin exposure before and during the pregnancy (n = 77) and isotretinoin exposure before the pregnancy (n = 75). We selected the control group from among the non-teratogen exposed pregnant women with a simple random sampling method. Obstetricians calculated the ages of all pregnancies via ultrasound (USG) (crown-rump diameter for the first trimester; biparietal diameter and femur length for the second trimester). After birth, a pediatric genetics specialist examined all babies. Whole-exome sequencing (WES) was conducted on the babies who displayed complex phenotypes.

RESULTS

Among the isotretinoin exposure before and during the pregnancy, isotretinoin exposure before the pregnancy, and the control groups, there were statistically significant differences in live births (respectively, 64.3 %, 88 %, 93.3 %), congenital anomalies (respectively, 28.6 %, 6.1 %, 1.4 %), miscarriages (respectively, 13 %, 2.7 %, 4 %), terminations (respectively, 32.5 %, 9.3 %, 2.7 %), and premature births (11.9 %, 16.7 %, 2.9 %) (respectively, p < 0.001, p < 0.001, p = 0.014, p < 0.001). We detected novel phenotypical features in five patients.

CONCLUSIONS

Our study demonstrated that study design, long-term follow-up, teratological counseling, and implementation of advanced molecular analysis in complex phenotypes with novel phenotypical features are beneficial for understanding the association of congenital anomalies with isotretinoin exposure. While evaluating congenital anomalies, we detected statistically significant differences between isotretinoin exposure before and during the pregnancy vs control, but we did not detect any statistically significant differences between isotretinoin exposure before the pregnancy and controls. Another finding of the study is that WES might be an efficient way to evaluate complex phenotypes in isotretinoin-exposed babies; however, further research is required.

The rates of major malformations after gestational exposure to isotretinoin: a systematic review and meta-analysis

Objective

Isotretinoin is among the most notorious human teratogens, documented originally as causing up to 30% of malformations. This systematic review and meta-analysis aimed to evaluate the rates of major malformation (MM) among isotretinoin-exposed pregnant women over the years through a systematic review and meta-analysis.

Methods

Eligible studies were searched and identified using various databases. Single-arm meta-analysis and meta-analysis of odd ratios among controlled studies were performed using Review Manager version 5.3.

Results

Ten eligible studies that combined 2,783 isotretinoin-exposed women were included in our study. The rate of MM weighted for the sample size was 15%. Three studies that included an unexposed comparison group were eligible for the meta-analysis. The pooled odds ratio of MM for isotretinoin-exposed women was 3.76. After 2006, the pooled odds ratio of MM for isotretinoin exposure was significantly lower at 1.04.

Conclusion

The current rate of MM in isotretinoin-exposed women was substantially lower after 2006.

Non-compliance with pregnancy prevention recommendations for isotretinoin in Korea between 2019-2020

Objective

Isotretinoin is commonly prescribed worldwide despite its notorious teratogenicity. A risk management program (RMP) was introduced in Korea to prevent isotretinoin use during pregnancy. Here, we evaluate the compliance of Korean women with the recommendations of the RMP.

Methods

This prospective cohort study was conducted between April 2019 and June 2020. Thirty-six and 82 patients received the prescription before and after the introduction of RMP, respectively.

Results

There was a significant difference in the total number of days for which isotretinoin was prescribed before and after the RMP was introduced (68.8±100.9 and 28.0±26.1 days, respectively). However, 1.43% (120/8,394) of the total patients contacted by the teratology information services were exposed to isotretinoin on an average.

Conclusion

The proportion of patients exposed to isotretinoin did not change, and there was no significant change in compliance, with the implementation of the RMP during the study period. Further studies are needed to evaluate the effectiveness of the RMP in the long term.

Isotretinoin: Still the cause of anxiety for teratogenicity

Isotretinoin is known as a potent teratogenic agent. Pregnancy should be ruled out before isotretinoin is prescribed. In this study, we evaluated the fetal outcomes of pregnant women who had inadvertently been exposed to isotretinoin during or before pregnancy. We collected data of pregnant women who had admitted to the Teratology Information Service due to isotretinoin exposure. Data regarding medications and comorbidities were documented. Outcomes were grouped as: live births, stillbirths, live births with congenital malformations, induced abortions (due to fetal abnormalities), spontaneous abortions, and elective abortions. We found that three women had gone to elective abortions. Three babies were live born without birth defects, of which, maternal exposure periods were between 0 and 3 weeks, 9 and 10 weeks before last menstrual period. One woman, exposed to isotretinoin up to the fourth week of gestation, decided ongoing her pregnancy with no current drug-related complications. Although many risk management programs worldwide have been used to prevent isotretinoin-related teratogenicity, the results of the present study showed that women became pregnant during isotretinoin intake and opted for pregnancy termination. Attention should be paid to the risk management programs mandating effective contraceptions, in order to lessen the drug-related terminations.

Knowledge of community pharmacists about the risks of medication use during pregnancy in central region of Saudi Arabia

Background

Community pharmacists (CPs) are the most accessible health care provider to the public, and they have huge duties to improve medication use especially among the pregnant women in their community. The objective of this study was to evaluate knowledge of CPs about the medication safety during pregnancy.

Methods

A prospective cross-sectional survey was carried out over practicing community pharmacists in a capital of Saudi Arabia (SA). Pharmacists were asked about the safety of each medicine during pregnancy. It involved both prescription-only medications (POM) and over-the-counter (OTC) medications. Both descriptive and analytic statistics were utilized. For descriptive analysis, results were expressed as numbers, percentages and mean (±SD and 95% CI).

Results

The response rate was (71.1%). Most of the respondents (69.6%) believed that alprazolam is not safe while 22% of respondents believed that it is used on basis of risk-benefit assessment. Also, most of CPs (65.2%) said that amoxicillin is safe, but a very few of CPs (11.7%) knew that tetracycline should be used only if potential benefits may outweigh the risk. Among non-prescribed analgesics, majority of CPs (92.6%) knew that acetaminophen is safe. About dietary supplements, 48.4% of CPs reported that Vitamin A supplements are not safe. There was significant difference observed between age groups of CPs in scores of knowledge test (P = 0.001).

Conclusion

Community Pharmacists are the most accessible health care providers who can help pregnant women with their medications use there are still gaps in knowledge where educational interventions are needed.

Occurrence of pregnancy and pregnancy outcomes during isotretinoin therapy

BACKGROUND

Isotretinoin, a teratogen, is widely used to treat cystic acne. Although the risks of pregnancy during isotretinoin therapy are well recognized, there are doubts about the level of adherence with the pregnancy prevention program in Canada. Our objective was to evaluate the effectiveness of the Canadian pregnancy prevention program in 4 provinces: British Columbia, Saskatchewan, Manitoba and Ontario.

METHODS

Using administrative data, we identified 4 historical cohorts of female users of isotretinoin (aged 12-48 yr) for the period 1996 to 2011. We defined pregnancy using International Statistical Classification of Diseases and billing codes. One definition included only cases with documented pregnancy outcomes (high-specificity definition); the other definition also included individuals recorded as receiving prenatal care (high-sensitivity definition). We studied new courses of isotretinoin and detected pregnancies in 2 time windows: during isotretinoin treatment only and up to 42 weeks after treatment. Live births were followed for 1 year to identify congenital malformations.

RESULTS

A total of 59 271 female patients received 102 308 courses of isotretinoin. Between 24.3% and 32.9% of participants received prescriptions for oral contraceptives while they were taking isotretinoin, compared with 28.3% to 35.9% in the 12 months before isotretinoin was started. According to the high-specificity definition of pregnancy, there were 186 pregnancies during isotretinoin treatment (3.1/1000 isotretinoin users), compared with 367 (6.2/1000 users) according to the high-sensitivity definition. By 42 weeks after treatment, there were 1473 pregnancies (24.9/1000 users), according to the high-specificity definition. Of these, 1331 (90.4%) terminated spontaneously or were terminated by medical intervention. Among the 118 live births were 11 (9.3%) cases of congenital malformation. Pregnancy rates during isotretinoin treatment remained constant between 1996 and 2011.

INTERPRETATION

Adherence to the isotretinoin pregnancy prevention program in Canada was poor during the 15-year period of this study.

Pregnancy and dermatologic therapy

Dermatologists should be familiar with medication safety in pregnancy to be able to prescribe safely and confidently to pregnant women or women who may become pregnant during the course of treatment for dermatologic conditions. Topical medications should be considered first-line therapy for pregnant women, but certain systemic medications are safe to use in pregnancy and may be prescribed if necessary. Dermatologic surgery may be performed during the second trimester of pregnancy with proper positioning, but elective procedures should be delayed until the postpartum period.

Pregnancy outcomes and factors associated with voluntary pregnancy termination in women who had been treated for acne with isotretinoin

OBJECTIVE

We aimed to study the pregnancy outcomes of women exposed to isotretinoin and to identify the factors influencing their decision to request an abortion.

METHODS

The study prospectively identified 79 women who had been treated for acne with isotretinoin during the periconceptional period, and who were followed up until completion of their pregnancy. Characteristics of exposure and doses were self-reported by participants.

RESULTS

Of the 56 participants who decided to continue their pregnancy, there were 11 spontaneous abortions and 44 women who delivered healthy full-term babies of which 19 had been exposed to isotretinoin <1 month before conception or during pregnancy. In a nominal logistic regression analysis including 68 patients who provided adequate information for analysis, exposure to isotretinoin >2 weeks post-conception and pregnancy termination recommended by the first-contact physician were found to be significantly associated with patients' decision to undergo elective abortion: adjusted OR = 9.87 (95% CI 1.18-82.34) and 12.51 (95% CI 2.36-66.29), respectively.

CONCLUSIONS

Our study reports an elevated rate of babies born without evidence of gross malformation or neurofunctional abnormality even tough exposure occurred during the teratogenic risk period. However, caution is recommended since a substantial risk of congenital malformations has been reported with low doses of isotretinoin and at exposures limited to early pregnancy. We also found that primary-care physicians may influence patients' decision to request pregnancy termination independently of their timing of exposure to isotretinoin.

Development of canal cholesteatoma in a patient with prenatal isotretinoin exposure

PURPOSE

To describe the clinical and radiologic findings in a case of isotretinoin embryopathy-like syndrome and discuss management of hearing loss, congenital external auditory canal (EAC) stenosis, and EAC cholesteatoma.

METHODS

Review of medical, audiological, and radiological records.

RESULTS

An 8 year old female presented with bilateral moderate conductive hearing loss, bilateral microtia, left EAC stenosis, and right EAC atresia, secondary to prenatal isotretinoin exposure. Comorbidities included developmental delay, ventricular septal defect, hypotonia, and retinal maldevelopment. The left EAC was sharply upsloping with a 2mm-diameter meatus. Computed tomography (CT) scan of the temporal bone demonstrated normal middle and inner ears bilaterally; serial CT scans over 6 years demonstrated progressive development of left canal cholesteatoma. Implantation of a right BAHA system was performed, followed by left canalplasty and excision of cholesteatoma with facial nerve monitoring. An endaural incision was utilized to avoid compromising future microtia repair. Postoperative left-sided hearing improved to mild low-frequency conductive hearing loss rising to normal at 2000 Hz and above.

CONCLUSIONS

Despite extensive precautions for its use, isotretinoin remains a cause of major birth defects, including sensorineural, conductive or mixed hearing loss. Congenital EAC stenosis is much less common than congenital atresia or acquired stenosis; optimal surgical approaches vary depending on hearing status and facial nerve anatomy. Close monitoring for development of canal cholesteatoma is necessary.

Isotretinoin use and compliance with the Dutch Pregnancy Prevention Programme: a retrospective cohort study in females of reproductive age using pharmacy dispensing data

BACKGROUND

Isotretinoin is very effective in the treatment of severe acne. However, because of the teratogenic properties of this agent an isotretinoin Pregnancy Prevention Programme (PPP) was implemented in the Netherlands to guarantee that treatment is contraindicated in women of reproductive age unless at least one effective method of contraception is used. Furthermore, the PPP stipulates that isotretinoin treatment should be managed by physicians or specialists experienced in treatment with this drug and that only monthly prescriptions are issued.

OBJECTIVE

To assess compliance with the Dutch isotretinoin PPP in women of reproductive age during the study period of 1 January 2005 to 31 December 2008.

METHODS

Detailed information on dispensed medication and co-medication was available from the Dutch Foundation of Pharmaceutical Statistics. Four types of outcome were studied: concomitant dispensing of hormonal contraceptive with isotretinoin; the proportion of specialist prescribing of isotretinoin; prescribing of conventional acne therapy prior to isotretinoin initiation; and isotretinoin dispensing exceeding the maximum amount. The use of contraceptives in women aged between 15 and 45 years was defined as concomitant if the period of systemic contraceptive use overlapped the period of isotretinoin dispensing for at least 10 days, or if any dispensing of an intrauterine or intravaginal contraceptive was recorded since the year 2000. Dispensings were separated into those prescribed by either specialists or general practitioners (GPs). The use of antibacterials, antiandrogens or topical agents against acne was checked 4 months prior to an isotretinoin dispensing, and a possible excess of the maximum amount of isotretinoin was defined as prescriptions of more than 100 defined daily doses.

RESULTS

During the study period, data were available for 442 Dutch pharmacies encompassing 4881 women of reproductive age using isotretinoin at least once during study period. Among women of reproductive age, the use of isotretinoin increased during the study period. The proportion of isotretinoin initiation with concomitant oral hormonal or intrauterine contraceptives was low (59.3% [95% CI 57.6, 61.0]). Initiation of isotretinoin by a specialist increased the chance for concomitant contraception by 26% (95% CI 6.0, 49.0); in 78.2% (95% CI 76.8, 79.6) of women, isotretinoin was initiated by a specialist. Conventional acne therapy up to 16 months prior to isotretinoin initiation was found in 70% of the women (70.3% [95% CI 66.0, 74.6]). In 1.4% (95% CI 1.0, 1.8) of cases of treatment initiation, the amount of isotretinoin dispensed on one prescription seemed too high.

CONCLUSION

Attention should be paid to improving the implementation of the isotretinoin PPP. Despite clear guidelines and warnings in the product information, our study strongly suggests that concomitant use of isotretinoin and contraceptives is too low. Even though we will have missed non-pharmacological forms of contraception, these results raise doubts about the safe use of isotretinoin in women of reproductive age in the Netherlands. Furthermore, isotretinoin does not seem to be used in cases of severe acne only. Reserving isotretinoin prescribing to specialists may improve adherence to the PPP.

Perspectives of primary care clinicians on teratogenic risk counseling

BACKGROUND

Women of childbearing age are commonly prescribed medications by primary care providers (PCPs) that may cause birth defects if used during pregnancy.

METHODS

To identify what PCPs perceive as barriers to and potential facilitators of providing counseling to women of childbearing age when teratogenic medications are prescribed, we conducted eight focus groups with 48 PCPs recruited from four clinical settings in Pittsburgh, Pennsylvania. We explored PCPs' experiences counseling women about teratogenic medications. Each focus group was audio-recorded, transcribed, and coded using a grounded theory approach by three independent coders.

RESULTS

PCPs feel responsible for counseling women when they prescribe medications that may cause birth defects, but note difficulties identifying clinically relevant sources of information on teratogenicity. Other barriers to providing counseling include limited visit times and lack of reimbursement for preconception or teratogenic risk counseling. PCPs find it challenging to identify patients who may become pregnant and who therefore need contraceptive and/or teratogenic risk counseling. PCPs expressed a desire for online resources that could be used when explaining medication risks to patients. PCPs feel that the development of patient information materials, electronic decision support tools, clinical care systems that routinely assess patients' pregnancy risk, and changes in the reimbursement structure may facilitate counseling patients about teratogenic risks.

CONCLUSIONS

PCPs perceive themselves as playing an important role in providing their patients information on risk of medication-induced birth defects. To ensure safe prescription of teratogenic medications, PCPs suggest interventions at both the clinic and healthcare system levels.