Common rostrocaudal gradient of output from human intercostal motoneurones during voluntary and automatic breathing

Analysis and applications of respiratory surface EMG: report of a round table meeting

Surface electromyography (sEMG) can be used to measure the electrical activity of the respiratory muscles. The possible applications of sEMG span from patients suffering from acute respiratory failure to patients receiving chronic home mechanical ventilation, to evaluate muscle function, titrate ventilatory support and guide treatment. However, sEMG is mainly used as a monitoring tool for research and its use in clinical practice is still limited-in part due to a lack of standardization and transparent reporting. During this round table meeting, recommendations on data acquisition, processing, interpretation, and potential clinical applications of respiratory sEMG were discussed. This paper informs the clinical researcher interested in respiratory muscle monitoring about the current state of the art on sEMG, knowledge gaps and potential future applications for patients with respiratory failure.

Semi-automated Detection of the Timing of Respiratory Muscle Activity: Validation and First Application

Background: Respiratory muscle electromyography (EMG) can identify whether a muscle is activated, its activation amplitude, and timing. Most studies have focused on the activation amplitude, while differences in timing and duration of activity have been less investigated. Detection of the timing of respiratory muscle activity is typically based on the visual inspection of the EMG signal. This method is time-consuming and prone to subjective interpretation.

Aims: Our main objective was to develop and validate a method to assess the respective timing of different respiratory muscle activity in an objective and semi-automated manner.

Method: Seven healthy adults performed an inspiratory threshold loading (ITL) test at 50% of their maximum inspiratory pressure until task failure. Surface EMG recordings of the costal diaphragm/intercostals, scalene, parasternal intercostals, and sternocleidomastoid were obtained during ITL. We developed a semi-automated algorithm to detect the onset (EMG, onset) and offset (EMG, offset) of each muscle’s EMG activity breath-by-breath with millisecond accuracy and compared its performance with manual evaluations from two independent assessors. For each muscle, the Intraclass Coefficient correlation (ICC) of the EMG, onset detection was determined between the two assessors and between the algorithm and each assessor. Additionally, we explored muscle differences in the EMG, onset, and EMG, offset timing, and duration of activity throughout the ITL.

Results: More than 2000 EMG, onset s were analyzed for algorithm validation. ICCs ranged from 0.75–0.90 between assessor 1 and 2, 0.68–0.96 between assessor 1 and the algorithm, and 0.75–0.91 between assessor 2 and the algorithm (p < 0.01 for all). The lowest ICC was shown for the diaphragm/intercostal and the highest for the parasternal intercostal (0.68 and 0.96, respectively). During ITL, diaphragm/intercostal EMG, onset occurred later during the inspiratory cycle and its activity duration was shorter than the scalene, parasternal intercostal, and sternocleidomastoid (p < 0.01). EMG, offset occurred synchronously across all muscles (p ≥ 0.98). EMG, onset, and EMG, offset timing, and activity duration was consistent throughout the ITL for all muscles (p > 0.63).

Conclusion: We developed an algorithm to detect EMG, onset of several respiratory muscles with millisecond accuracy that is time-efficient and validated against manual measures. Compared to the inherent bias of manual measures, the algorithm enhances objectivity and provides a strong standard for determining the respiratory muscle EMG, onset.

Motoneurone synchronization for intercostal and abdominal muscles: interneurone influences in two different species

The contribution of branched-axon monosynaptic inputs in the generation of short-term synchronization of motoneurones remains uncertain. Here, synchronization was measured for intercostal and abdominal motoneurones supplying the lower thorax and upper abdomen, mostly showing expiratory discharges. Synchronization in the anaesthetized cat, where the motoneurones receive a strong direct descending drive, is compared with that in anaesthetized or decerebrate rats, where the direct descending drive is much weaker. In the cat, some examples could be explained by branched-axon monosynaptic inputs, but many others could not, by virtue of peaks in cross-correlation histograms whose widths (relatively wide) and timing indicated common inputs with more complex linkages, e.g., disynaptic excitatory. In contrast, in the rat, correlations for pairs of internal intercostal nerves were dominated by very narrow peaks, indicative of branched-axon monosynaptic inputs. However, the presence of activity in both inspiration and expiration in many of the nerves allowed additional synchronization measurements between internal and external intercostal nerves. Time courses of synchronization for these often consisted of combinations of peaks and troughs, which have never been previously described for motoneurone synchronization and which we interpret as indicating combinations of inputs, excitation of one group of motoneurones being common with either excitation or inhibition of the other. Significant species differences in the circuits controlling the motoneurones are indicated, but in both cases, the roles of spinal interneurones are emphasised. The results demonstrate the potential of motoneurone synchronization for investigating inhibition and have important general implications for the interpretation of neural connectivity measurements by cross-correlation.

Differential activation of the human costal and crural diaphragm during voluntary and involuntary breaths

Simultaneous electromyographic recordings from the human costal and crural diaphragm during voluntary augmented breathing and involuntary rebreathing show that the increase in inspiratory crural diaphragm activity was ~60% of the increase in costal diaphragm activity. However costal to crural diaphragm activation did not differ between the two tasks. The dissociation in the amplitude of activation of the costal and crural diaphragm becomes apparent only as the drive to breathe increases above tidal breathing.

Respiratory muscle activity in voluntary breathing tracking tasks: Implications for the assessment of respiratory motor control

How the involuntary (bulbospinal) and voluntary (corticospinal) pathways interact in respiratory muscle control is not established. To determine the role of excitatory corticobulbar pathways in humans, studies typically compare electromyographic activity (EMG) or evoked responses in respiratory muscles during hypercapnic and voluntary tasks. Although ventilation is matched between tasks by having participants track signals of ventilation, these tasks may not result in matched respiratory muscle activity. The aim of this study was to describe respiratory muscle activity and ribcage and abdominal excursions during two different voluntary conditions, compared to hypercapnic hyperventilation. Ventilation was matched in the voluntary conditions via (i) a simple target of lung volume ('volume tracking') or (ii) targets of both ribcage and abdominal excursions, adjusted to end-expiratory lung volume in hypercapnic hyperventilation ('bands tracking'). Compared to hypercapnic hyperventilation, respiratory parameters such as tidal volume were similar, but the ratio of ribcage to abdominal excursion was higher for both voluntary tasks. Inspiratory scalene and parasternal intercostal muscle activity was higher in volume tracking, but diaphragm and abdominal muscle activity showed little to no change. There were no differences in muscle activity in bands tracking for any muscle, compared to hypercapnic hyperventilation. An elevated ratio of ribcage to abdominal excursion in the bands tracking task indicates that participants could not accurately match the targets in this condition. Inspiratory muscle activity is altered in some muscles in some voluntary tasks, compared to hypercapnia. Therefore, differences in muscle activity should be considered in interpretation of studies that use these protocols to investigate respiratory muscle control.

Muscles of Breathing: Development, Function, and Patterns of Activation

This review is a comprehensive description of all muscles that assist lung inflation or deflation in any way. The developmental origin, anatomical orientation, mechanical action, innervation, and pattern of activation are described for each respiratory muscle fulfilling this broad definition. In addition, the circumstances in which each muscle is called upon to assist ventilation are discussed. The number of "respiratory" muscles is large, and the coordination of respiratory muscles with "nonrespiratory" muscles and in nonrespiratory activities is complex-commensurate with the diversity of activities that humans pursue, including sleep (8.27). The capacity for speech and adoption of the bipedal posture in human evolution has resulted in patterns of respiratory muscle activation that differ significantly from most other animals. A disproportionate number of respiratory muscles affect the nose, mouth, pharynx, and larynx, reflecting the vital importance of coordinated muscle activity to control upper airway patency during both wakefulness and sleep. The upright posture has freed the hands from locomotor functions, but the evolutionary history and ontogeny of forelimb muscles pervades the patterns of activation and the forces generated by these muscles during breathing. The distinction between respiratory and nonrespiratory muscles is artificial, as many "nonrespiratory" muscles can augment breathing under conditions of high ventilator demand. Understanding the ontogeny, innervation, activation patterns, and functions of respiratory muscles is clinically useful, particularly in sleep medicine. Detailed explorations of how the nervous system controls the multiple muscles required for successful completion of respiratory behaviors will continue to be a fruitful area of investigation. © 2019 American Physiological Society. Compr Physiol 9:1025-1080, 2019.

High-frequency spinal cord stimulation in a subacute animal model of spinal cord injury

High-frequency spinal cord stimulation (HF-SCS) applied at the T2 spinal level results in physiologic activation of the inspiratory muscles in C2 spinal-sectioned dogs. Although the bulbo-spinal fibers were cut, they likely survived the duration of acute experiments, and inspiratory muscle activation may have involved stimulation of these fibers. In two anesthetized, C2 paralyzed, intubated, and mechanically ventilated dogs, HF-SCS (300 Hz) was applied at the T2 level. The effectiveness of HF-SCS in generating inspired volume (V) and negative airway pressures (P) was evaluated over a period of 5 days during which time the bulbo-spinal fibers would have degenerated. Because the effectiveness of HF-SCS may be adversely affected by deterioration of these fibers and/or the condition of the animal, low-frequency (50 Hz) SCS (LF-SCS) was also performed and served as a control. All vital signs, oxygen saturation, and end-tidal Pco₂ remained stable over the 5-day period. V and P also remained stable over the study period. For example, mean V and P were 771 ± 25 ml and 64 ± 1 cmH₂O with HF-SCS (3 mA) during the initial and 674 ± 59 ml and 63 ± 5 cmH₂O on the final day. Comparable values during LF-SCS (8 mA) were 467 ± 12 ml and 48 ± 1 cmH₂O during the initial and 397 ± 20 ml and 42 ± 2 cmH₂O on the final day. Because V and P in response to HF-SCS remained stable over a 5-day period following which the bulbo-spinal fibers would have degenerated, the mechanism of HF-SCS does not depend upon the viability of these tracts. HF-SCS therefore may be a useful method to restore ventilation in chronic ventilator dependent tetraplegics. NEW & NOTEWORTHY This study indicates that the respiratory responses to high-frequency spinal cord stimulation applied at the T2 level results in activation of the inspiratory motoneuron pools via interneuronal circuits and/or the inspiratory motoneurons directly and does not depend upon activation of long descending inspiratory bulbo-spinal fibers. This method therefore, may provide an alternative method to restore ventilation in ventilator dependent spinal cord injured patients.

Task-dependent output of human parasternal intercostal motor units across spinal levels

KEY POINTS

During breathing, there is differential activity in the human parasternal intercostal muscles and the activity is tightly coupled to the known mechanical advantages for inspiration of the same regions of muscles. It is not known whether differential activity is preserved for the non-respiratory task of ipsilateral trunk rotation. In the present study, we compared single motor units during resting breathing and axial rotation of the trunk during apnoea. We not only confirmed non-uniform recruitment of motor units across parasternal intercostal muscles in breathing, but also demonstrated that the same motor units show an altered pattern of recruitment in the non-respiratory task of trunk rotation. The output of parasternal intercostal motoneurones is modulated differently across spinal levels depending on the task and these results help us understand the mechanisms that may govern task-dependent differences in motoneurone output.

ABSTRACT

During inspiration, there is differential activity in the human parasternal intercostal muscles across interspaces. We investigated whether the earlier recruitment of motor units in the rostral interspaces compared to more caudal spaces during inspiration is preserved for the non-respiratory task of ipsilateral trunk rotation. Single motor unit activity (SMU) was recorded from the first, second and fourth parasternal interspaces on the right side in five participants in two tasks: resting breathing and 'isometric' axial rotation of the trunk during apnoea. Recruitment of the same SMUs was compared between tasks (n = 123). During resting breathing, differential activity was indicated by earlier recruitment of SMUs in the first and second interspaces compared to the fourth space in inspiration (P < 0.01). By contrast, during trunk rotation, the same motor units showed an altered pattern of recruitment because SMUs in the first interspace were recruited later and at a higher rotation torque than those in the second and fourth interspaces (P < 0.05). Tested for a subset of SMUs, the reliability of the breathing and rotation tasks, as well as the SMU recruitment measures, was good-excellent [intraclass correlation (2,1): 0.69-0.91]. Thus, the output of parasternal intercostal motoneurones is modulated differently across spinal levels depending on the task. Given that the differential inspiratory output of parasternal intercostal muscles is linked to their relative mechanical effectiveness for inspiration and also that this output is altered in trunk rotation, we speculate that a mechanism matching neural drive to muscle mechanics underlies the task-dependent differences in output of axial motoneurone pools.

Electrical activation to the parasternal intercostal muscles during high-frequency spinal cord stimulation in dogs

High-frequency spinal cord stimulation (HF-SCS) is a novel technique of inspiratory muscle activation involving stimulation of spinal cord pathways, which may have application as a method to provide inspiratory muscle pacing in ventilator-dependent patients with spinal cord injury. The purpose of the present study was to compare the spatial distribution of motor drive to the parasternal intercostal muscles during spontaneous breathing with that occurring during HF-SCS. In nine anesthetized dogs, HF-SCS was applied at the T2 spinal level. Fine-wire recording electrodes were used to assess single motor unit (SMU) pattern of activation in the medial bundles of the 2nd and 4th and lateral bundles of the 2nd interspaces during spontaneous breathing and HF-SCS following C1 spinal section. Stimulus amplitude during HF-SCS was adjusted such that inspired volumes matched that occurring during spontaneous breathing (protocol 1). During HF-SCS mean peak SMU firing frequency was highest in the medial bundles of the 2nd interspace (17.1 ± 0.6 Hz) and significantly lower in the lateral bundles of the 2nd interspace (13.5 ± 0.5 Hz) and medial bundles of the 4th (15.2 ± 0.7 Hz) (P < 0.05 for each comparison). Similar rostrocaudal and mediolateral gradients of activity were observed during spontaneous breathing prior to C1 section. Since rib cage movement was greater and peak discharge frequencies of the SMUs higher during HF-SCS compared with spontaneous breathing, stimulus amplitude during HF-SCS was adjusted such that rib cage movement matched that occurring during spontaneous breathing (protocol 2). Under this protocol, mean peak SMU frequencies and rostrocaudal and mediolateral gradients of activity during HF-SCS were not significantly different compared with spontaneous breathing. This study demonstrates that 1) the topographic pattern of electrical activation of the parasternal intercostal muscles during HF-SCS is similar to that occurring during spontaneous breathing, and 2) differential spatial distribution of parasternal intercostal activation does not depend upon differential descending synaptic input from supraspinal centers.

Does breathing type influence electromyographic activity of obligatory and accessory respiratory muscles?

Craniomandibular electromyographic (EMG) studies frequently include several parameters, e.g. resting, chewing and tooth-clenching. EMG activity during these parameters has been recorded in the elevator muscles, but little is known about the respiratory muscles. The aim of this study was to compare EMG activity in obligatory and accessory respiratory muscles between subjects with different breathing types. Forty male subjects were classified according to their breathing type into two groups of 20 each: costo-diaphragmatic breathing type and upper costal breathing type. Bipolar surface electrodes were placed on the sternocleidomastoid, diaphragm, external intercostal and latissimus dorsi muscles. EMG activity was recorded during the following tasks: (i) normal quiet breathing, (ii) maximal voluntary clenching in intercuspal position, (iii) natural rate chewing until swallowing threshold, (iv) short-time chewing. Diaphragm EMG activity was significantly higher in the upper costal breathing type than in the costo-diaphragmatic breathing type in all tasks (P < 0·05). External intercostal EMG activity was significantly higher in the upper costal breathing type than in the costo-diaphragmatic breathing type in tasks 3 and 4 (P < 0·05). Sternocleidomastoid and latissimus dorsi EMG activity did not show significant differences between breathing types in the tasks studied (P > 0·05). The significantly higher EMG activity observed in subjects with upper costal breathing than in the costo-diaphragmatic breathing type suggests that there could be differences in motor unit recruitment strategies depending on the breathing type. This may be an expression of the adaptive capability of muscle chains in subjects who clinically have a different thoraco-abdominal expansion during inspiration at rest.

Effect of upper costal and costo-diaphragmatic breathing types on electromyographic activity of respiratory muscles

AIM

To compare electromyographic (EMG) activity in young-adult subjects with different breathing types.

METHODOLOGY

This study included 50 healthy male subjects with complete natural dentition, and no history of orofacial pain or craniomandibular-cervical-spinal disorders. Subjects were classified into two groups: upper costal breathing type, and costo-diaphragmatic breathing. Bipolar surface electrodes were located on sternocleidomastoid, diaphragm, external intercostal, and latissimus dorsi muscles. Electromyographic activity was recorded during the following tasks: (1) normal quiet breathing; (2) speaking the word 'Mississippi'; (3) swallowing saliva; and (4) forced deep breathing.

RESULTS

Sternocleidomastoid and latissimus dorsi EMG activity was not significantly different between breathing types, whereas diaphragm and external intercostal EMG activity was significantly higher in the upper costal than costo-diaphragmatic breathing type in all tasks (P<0·05; Wilcoxon signed rank-sum test).

CONCLUSION

Diaphragm and external intercostal EMG activity suggests that there could be differences in motor unit recruitment strategies depending on the breathing type.

CO2 homeostasis is maintained in conscious humans by regulation of tidal volume, but not of respiratory rhythm

Automatic regulation of tidal volume (VT) maintains CO2 homeostasis when spontaneous respiratory rhythm is replaced with a cortically triggered rhythm. We examined whether automatic regulation of respiratory frequency (fR) could maintain CO2 homeostasis at rest if the VT is cortically designated in experiments performed in 21 conscious humans. First, volitionally controlled fR at levels lower than baseline resulted in a larger VT, maintaining end-tidal CO2 fraction constant at eupneic levels. However, when fR was volitionally controlled at levels higher than baseline, end-tidal CO2 fraction decreased unexpectedly. Next, when the VT was volitionally constrained but fr was freely chosen, end-tidal CO2 fraction decreased. The present study revealed some limitations in the control of CO2 homeostasis by automatic regulation of fR, probably because respiratory rhythm is susceptible to non-metabolic factors. This study also showed the importance of automatic regulation of VT in maintaining CO2 homeostasis at rest. Nevertheless, automatic regulation of VT was incomplete when fR was volitionally imposed at high levels.

Recruitment of motor units in two fascicles of the semispinalis cervicis muscle

This study investigated the behavior of motor units in the semispinalis cervicis muscle. Intramuscular EMG recordings were obtained unilaterally at levels C2 and C5 in 15 healthy volunteers (8 men, 7 women) who performed isometric neck extensions at 5%, 10%, and 20% of the maximal force [maximum voluntary contraction (MVC)] for 2 min each and linearly increasing force contractions from 0 to 30% MVC over 3 s. Individual motor unit action potentials were identified. The discharge rate and interspike interval variability of the motor units in the two locations did not differ. However, the recruitment threshold of motor units detected at C2 (n = 16, mean ± SD: 10.3 ± 6.0% MVC) was greater than that of motor units detected at C5 (n = 92, 6.9 ± 4.3% MVC) (P < 0.01). A significant level of short-term synchronization was identified in 246 of 307 motor unit pairs when computed within one spinal level but only in 28 of 110 pairs of motor units between the two levels. The common input strength, which quantifies motor unit synchronization, was greater for pairs within one level (0.47 ± 0.32) compared with pairs between levels (0.09 ± 0.07) (P < 0.05). In a second experiment on eight healthy subjects, interference EMG was recorded from the same locations during a linearly increasing force contraction from 0 to 40% MVC and showed significantly greater EMG amplitude at C5 than at C2. In conclusion, synaptic input is distributed partly independently and nonuniformly to different fascicles of the semispinalis cervicis muscle.