A survey of coarse-grained methods for modeling protein conformational transitions

Riemannian geometry for efficient analysis of protein dynamics data

An increasingly common viewpoint is that protein dynamics datasets reside in a nonlinear subspace of low conformational energy. Ideal data analysis tools should therefore account for such nonlinear geometry. The Riemannian geometry setting can be suitable for a variety of reasons. First, it comes with a rich mathematical structure to account for a wide range of geometries that can be modeled after an energy landscape. Second, many standard data analysis tools developed for data in Euclidean space can be generalized to Riemannian manifolds. In the context of protein dynamics, a conceptual challenge comes from the lack of guidelines for constructing a smooth Riemannian structure based on an energy landscape. In addition, computational feasibility in computing geodesics and related mappings poses a major challenge. This work considers these challenges. The first part of the paper develops a local approximation technique for computing geodesics and related mappings on Riemannian manifolds in a computationally feasible manner. The second part constructs a smooth manifold and a Riemannian structure that is based on an energy landscape for protein conformations. The resulting Riemannian geometry is tested on several data analysis tasks relevant for protein dynamics data. In particular, the geodesics with given start- and end-points approximately recover corresponding molecular dynamics trajectories for proteins that undergo relatively ordered transitions with medium-sized deformations. The Riemannian protein geometry also gives physically realistic summary statistics and retrieves the underlying dimension even for large-sized deformations within seconds on a laptop.

MinActionPath2: path generation between different conformations of large macromolecular assemblies by action minimization

Recent progress in solving macromolecular structures and assemblies by cryogenic electron microscopy techniques enables sampling of their conformations in different states that are relevant to their biological function. Knowing the transition path between these conformations would provide new avenues for drug discovery. While the experimental study of transition paths is intrinsically difficult, in-silico methods can be used to generate an initial guess for those paths. The Elastic Network Model (ENM), along with a coarse-grained representation (CG) of the structures are among the most popular models to explore such possible paths. Here we propose an update to our software platform MinActionPath that generates non-linear transition paths based on ENM and CG models, using action minimization to solve the equations of motion. The new website enables the study of large structures such as ribosomes or entire virus envelopes. It provides direct visualization of the trajectories along with quantitative analyses of their behaviors at http://dynstr.pasteur.fr/servers/minactionpath/minactionpath2_submission.

Modeling and Simulation of the NMDA Receptor at Coarse-Grained and Atomistic Levels

N-Methyl-D-aspartate (NMDA) receptors are glutamate-gated excitatory channels that play essential roles in brain functions. While high-resolution structures were solved for an allosterically inhibited form of functional NMDA receptor, other key functional states (particularly the active open-channel state) have not yet been resolved at atomic resolutions. To decrypt the molecular mechanism of the NMDA receptor activation, structural modeling and simulation are instrumental in providing detailed information about the dynamics and energetics of the receptor in various functional states. In this chapter, we describe coarse-grained modeling of the NMDA receptor using an elastic network model and related modeling/analysis tools (e.g., normal mode analysis, flexibility and hotspot analysis, cryo-EM flexible fitting, and transition pathway modeling) based on available structures. Additionally, we show how to build an atomistic model of the active-state receptor with targeted molecular dynamics (MD) simulation and explore its energetics and dynamics with conventional MD simulation. Taken together, these modeling and simulation can offer rich structural and dynamic information which will guide experimental studies of the activation of this key receptor.

Predicting allosteric sites using fast conformational sampling as guided by coarse-grained normal modes

To computationally identify cryptic binding sites for allosteric modulators, we have developed a fast and simple conformational sampling scheme guided by coarse-grained normal modes solved from the elastic network models followed by atomistic backbone and sidechain reconstruction. Despite the complexity of conformational changes associated with ligand binding, we previously showed that simply sampling along each of the lowest 30 modes can adequately restructure cryptic sites so they are detectable by pocket finding programs like Concavity. Here, we applied this method to study four classical examples of allosteric regulation (GluR2 receptor, GroEL chaperonin, GPCR, and myosin). Our method along with alternative methods has been utilized to locate known allosteric sites and predict new promising allosteric sites. Compared with other sampling methods based on extensive molecular dynamics simulation, our method is both faster (1-2 h for an average-size protein of ∼400 residues) and more flexible (it can be easily integrated with any structure-based pocket finding methods), so it is suitable for high-throughput screening of large datasets of protein structures at the genome scale.

The dawn of interoperating spatial models in cell biology

Spatial simulations are becoming an increasingly ubiquitous component in the cycle of discovery, experimentation, and communication across the sciences. In cell biology, many researchers share a vision of developing multiscale models that recapitulate observable behaviors spanning from atoms to cells to tissues. For this dream to become a reality, however, simulation technologies must provide a means for integration and interoperability as they advance. Already, the field has developed numerous methods that span scales of length, time, and complexity to create an extensive body of effective simulation approaches, and although these approaches rarely interoperate, they collectively cover a large spectrum of knowledge that future models may handle in a more unified manner. Here, we discuss the importance of making the data, workflows, and outputs of spatial simulations shareable and interoperable; and how democratization could encourage diverse biologists to participate more easily in developing models to advance our understanding of biological systems.

Why are large conformational changes well described by harmonic normal modes?

Low-frequency normal modes generated by elastic network models tend to correlate strongly with large conformational changes of proteins, despite their reliance on the harmonic approximation, which is only valid in close proximity of the native structure. We consider 12 variants of the torsional network model (TNM), an elastic network model in torsion angle space, that adopt different sets of torsion angles as degrees of freedom and reproduce with similar quality the thermal fluctuations of proteins but present drastic differences in their agreement with conformational changes. We show that these differences are related to the extent of the deviations from the harmonic approximation, assessed through an anharmonic energy function whose harmonic approximation coincides with the TNM. Our results indicate that mode anharmonicity is more strongly related to its collectivity, i.e., the number of atoms displaced by the mode, than to its amplitude; low-frequency modes can remain harmonic even at large amplitudes, provided they are sufficiently collective. Finally, we assess the potential benefits of different strategies to minimize the impact of anharmonicity. The reduction of the number of degrees of freedom or their regularization by a torsional harmonic potential significantly improves the collectivity and harmonicity of normal modes and the agreement with conformational changes. In contrast, the correction of normal mode frequencies to partially account for anharmonicity does not yield substantial benefits. The TNM program is freely available at https://github.com/ugobas/tnm.

The functional motions and related key residues behind the uncoating of coxsackievirus A16

The coxsackievirus A16 (CVA16) is a highly contagious virus that causes the hand, foot, and mouth disease, which seriously threatens the health of children. At present, there are still no available antiviral drugs or effective treatments against the infection of CVA16, and thus it is of great significance to develop anti-CVA16 vaccines. However, the intrinsic uncoating property of the capsid may destroy the neutralizing epitopes and influence its immunogenicity, which hinders the vaccine developments. In the present work, the functional-quantity-based elastic network model analysis method developed by our group was extended to combine with group theory to investigate the uncoating motions of the CVA16 capsid, and then the functionally key residues controlling the uncoating motions were identified by our functional-quantity-based perturbation method. Several motion modes encoded in the topological structure of the capsid were revealed to be responsible for the uncoating of CVA16 particle. These modes predominantly contribute to the fluctuation of the gyration radius of the capsid. Then, by using the perturbation method, four clusters of key sites involved in the uncoating motions were identified, whose perturbations induce significant changes in the fluctuation of the gyration radius. These key residues are mainly located at the 2-fold channels, the quasi 3-fold channels, the bottom of the canyons, and the inter-subunit interfaces around the 3-fold axes. Our studies are helpful for better understanding the uncoating mechanism of the CVA16 capsid and provide potential target sites to prevent the uncoating motions, which is valuable for the vaccine design against CVA16.

HOPMA: Boosting Protein Functional Dynamics with Colored Contact Maps

In light of the recent very rapid progress in protein structure prediction, accessing the multitude of functional protein states is becoming more central than ever before. Indeed, proteins are flexible macromolecules, and they often perform their function by switching between different conformations. However, high-resolution experimental techniques such as X-ray crystallography and cryogenic electron microscopy can catch relatively few protein functional states. Many others are only accessible under physiological conditions in solution. Therefore, there is a pressing need to fill this gap with computational approaches. We present HOPMA, a novel method to predict protein functional states and transitions by using a modified elastic network model. The method exploits patterns in a protein contact map, taking its 3D structure as input, and excludes some disconnected patches from the elastic network. Combined with nonlinear normal mode analysis, this strategy boosts the protein conformational space exploration, especially when the input structure is highly constrained, as we demonstrate on a set of more than 400 transitions. Our results let us envision the discovery of new functional conformations, which were unreachable previously, starting from the experimentally known protein structures. The method is computationally efficient and available at https://github.com/elolaine/HOPMA and https://team.inria.fr/nano-d/software/nolb-normal-modes.

Equally Weighted Multiscale Elastic Network Model and Its Comparison with Traditional and Parameter-Free Models

Dynamical properties of proteins play an essential role in their function exertion. The elastic network model (ENM) is an effective and efficient tool in characterizing the intrinsic dynamical properties encoded in biomacromolecule structures. The Gaussian network model (GNM) and anisotropic network model (ANM) are the two often-used ENM models. Here, we introduce an equally weighted multiscale ENM (equally weighted mENM) based on the original mENM (denoted as mENM), in which fitting weights of Kirchhoff/Hessian matrixes in mENM are removed since they neglect the details of pairwise interactions. Then, we perform its comparison with the mENM, traditional ENM, and parameter-free ENM (pfENM) in reproducing dynamical properties for the six representative proteins whose molecular dynamics (MD) trajectories are available in http://mmb.pcb.ub.es/MoDEL/. In the results, for B-factor prediction, mENM performs best, while the equally weighted mENM performs also well, better than the traditional ENM and pfENM models. As to the dynamical cross-correlation map calculation, mENM performs worst, while the results produced from the equally weighted mENM and pfENM models are close to those from MD trajectories with the latter a little better than the former. Furthermore, encouragingly, the equally weighted mANM displays the best performance in capturing the functional motional modes, followed by pfANM and traditional ANM models, while the mANM fails in all the cases. This work is helpful for strengthening the understanding of the elastic network model and provides a valuable guide for researchers to utilize the model to explore protein dynamics.

Exploring Conformational Space with Thermal Fluctuations Obtained by Normal-Mode Analysis

Proteins in their native states can be represented as ensembles of conformers in dynamical equilibrium. Thermal fluctuations are responsible for transitions between these conformers. Normal-modes analysis (NMA) using elastic network models (ENMs) provides an efficient procedure to explore global dynamics of proteins commonly associated with conformational transitions. In the present work, we present an iterative approach to explore protein conformational spaces by introducing structural distortions according to their equilibrium dynamics at room temperature. The approach can be used either to perform unbiased explorations of conformational space or to explore guided pathways connecting two different conformations, e.g., apo and holo forms. In order to test its performance, four proteins with different magnitudes of structural distortions upon ligand binding have been tested. In all cases, the conformational selection model has been confirmed and the conformational space between apo and holo forms has been encompassed. Different strategies have been tested that impact on the efficiency either to achieve a desired conformational change or to achieve a balanced exploration of the protein conformational multiplicity.

eBDIMS server: protein transition pathways with ensemble analysis in 2D-motion spaces

SUMMARY

Understanding how proteins transition between different conformers, and how conformers relate to each other in terms of structure and function, is not trivial. Here, we present an online tool for transition pathway generation between two protein conformations using Elastic Network Driven Brownian Dynamics Importance Sampling, a coarse-grained simulation algorithm, which spontaneously predicts transition intermediates trapped experimentally. In addition to path-generation, the server provides an interactive 2D-motion landscape graphical representation of the transitions or any additional conformers to explore their structural relationships.

AVAILABILITY AND IMPLEMENTATION

eBDIMS is available online: http://ebdims.biophysics.se/ or as standalone software: https://github.com/laura-orellana/eBDIMS, https://github.com/cabergh/eBDIMS.

SUPPLEMENTARY INFORMATION

Supplementary data are available at Bioinformatics online.

Large-Scale Conformational Changes and Protein Function: Breaking the in silico Barrier

Large-scale conformational changes are essential to link protein structures with their function at the cell and organism scale, but have been elusive both experimentally and computationally. Over the past few years developments in cryo-electron microscopy and crystallography techniques have started to reveal multiple snapshots of increasingly large and flexible systems, deemed impossible only short time ago. As structural information accumulates, theoretical methods become central to understand how different conformers interconvert to mediate biological function. Here we briefly survey current in silico methods to tackle large conformational changes, reviewing recent examples of cross-validation of experiments and computational predictions, which show how the integration of different scale simulations with biological information is already starting to break the barriers between the in silico, in vitro, and in vivo worlds, shedding new light onto complex biological problems inaccessible so far.

Can Conformational Changes of Proteins Be Represented in Torsion Angle Space? A Study with Rescaled Ridge Regression

Torsion angles are the natural degrees of freedom of protein structures. The ability to determine torsional variations corresponding to observed changes in Cartesian coordinates is highly valuable, notably to investigate the mechanisms of functional conformational changes or to develop computational models of protein dynamics. This issue is far from trivial in practice since the impact of modifying one torsion angle strongly depends on all other angles, and the compounding effects of small variations in bond lengths and valence angles can completely disrupt a protein fold. We demonstrate that naive strategies, such as directly comparing torsion angles between structures without correcting for variations in bond lengths and valence angles or fitting torsional variations without a proper regularization scheme, fail at producing an adequate representation of conformational changes in internal coordinates. In contrast, rescaled ridge regression, a method recently introduced to regularize multidimensional regressions with correlated explanatory variables, is shown to consistently identify a minimal set of torsion angles variations that closely reproduce changes in Cartesian coordinates. This torsional representation of conformational changes is shown to be robust to the choice of experimental structures. It also provides a better agreement with theoretical models of protein dynamics than the Cartesian representation, regarding notably the predominance of low-frequency normal modes in functional motions and the presence, in predicted equilibrium dynamics, of hints of natural selection for specific functional motions. The software is available at https://github.com/ugobas/tnm .

Identification of key sites controlling protein functional motions by using elastic network model combined with internal coordinates

The elastic network model (ENM) is an effective method to extract the intrinsic dynamical properties encoded in protein tertiary structures. We have proposed a new ENM-based analysis method to reveal the motion modes directly responsible for a specific protein function, in which an internal coordinate related to the specific function was introduced to construct the internal/Cartesian hybrid coordinate space. In the present work, the function-related internal coordinates combined with a linear perturbation method were applied to identify the key sites controlling specific protein functional motions. The change in the fluctuations of the internal coordinate in response to residue perturbation was calculated in the hybrid coordinate space by using the linear response theory. The residues with the large fluctuation changes were identified to be the key sites that allosterically control the specific protein function. Two proteins, i.e., human DNA polymerase β and the chaperonin from Methanococcus maripaludis, were investigated as case studies, in which several collective and local internal coordinates were applied to identify the functionally key residues of these two studied proteins. The calculation results are consistent with the experimental observations. It is found that different collective internal coordinates lead to similar results, where the predicted functionally key sites are located at similar positions in the protein structure. While for the local internal coordinates, the predicted key sites tend to be situated at the region near to the coordinate-involving residues. Our studies provide a starting point for further exploring other function-related internal coordinates for other interesting proteins.

Coarse-grain simulations on NMR conformational ensembles highlight functional residues in proteins

Dynamics are a key feature of protein function, and this is especially true of gating residues, which occupy cavity or tunnel lining positions in the protein structure, and will reversibly switch between open and closed conformations in order to control the diffusion of small molecules within a protein's internal matrix. Earlier work on globins and hydrogenases have shown that these gating residues can be detected using a multiscale scheme combining all-atom classic molecular dynamics simulations and coarse-grain calculations of the resulting conformational ensemble mechanical properties. Here, we show that the structural variations observed in the conformational ensembles produced by NMR spectroscopy experiments are sufficient to induce noticeable mechanical changes in a protein, which in turn can be used to identify residues important for function and forming a mechanical nucleus in the protein core. This new approach, which combines experimental data and rapid coarse-grain calculations and no longer needs to resort to time-consuming all-atom simulations, was successfully applied to five different protein families.

Advances in coarse-grained modeling of macromolecular complexes

Recent progress in coarse-grained (CG) molecular modeling and simulation has facilitated an influx of computational studies on biological macromolecules and their complexes. Given the large separation of length-scales and time-scales that dictate macromolecular biophysics, CG modeling and simulation are well-suited to bridge the microscopic and mesoscopic or macroscopic details observed from all-atom molecular simulations and experiments, respectively. In this review, we first summarize recent innovations in the development of CG models, which broadly include structure-based, knowledge-based, and dynamics-based approaches. We then discuss recent applications of different classes of CG models to explore various macromolecular complexes. Finally, we conclude with an outlook for the future in this ever-growing field of biomolecular modeling.

Coarse-grained dynamics of supramolecules: Conformational changes in outer shells of Dengue viruses

While structural data on viruses are more and more common, information on their dynamics is much harder to obtain as those viruses form very large molecular complexes. In this paper, we propose a new method for computing the coarse-grained normal modes of such supra-molecules, NormalGo. A new formalism is developed to represent the Hessian of a quadratic potential using tensor products. This formalism is applied to the Tirion elastic potential, as well as to a Gō like potential. When combined with a fast method for computing a select set of eigenpairs of the Hessian, this new formalism enables the computation of thousands of normal modes of a full viral shell with more than one hundred thousand atoms in less than 2 h on a standard desktop computer. We then compare the two coarse-grained potentials. We show that, despite significant differences in their formulations, the Tirion and the Gō like potentials capture very similar dynamics characteristics of the molecule under study. However, we find that the Gō like potential should be preferred as it leads to less local deformations in the structure of the molecule during normal mode dynamics. Finally, we use NormalGo to characterize the structural transitions that occur when FAB fragments bind to the icosahedral outer shell of serotype 3 of the Dengue virus. We have identified residues at the surface of the outer shell that are important for the transition between the FAB-free and FAB-bound conformations, and therefore potentially useful for the design of antibodies to Dengue viruses.

Molecular simulations of cellular processes

It is, nowadays, possible to simulate biological processes in conditions that mimic the different cellular compartments. Several groups have performed these calculations using molecular models that vary in performance and accuracy. In many cases, the atomistic degrees of freedom have been eliminated, sacrificing both structural complexity and chemical specificity to be able to explore slow processes. In this review, we will discuss the insights gained from computer simulations on macromolecule diffusion, nuclear body formation, and processes involving the genetic material inside cell-mimicking spaces. We will also discuss the challenges to generate new models suitable for the simulations of biological processes on a cell scale and for cell-cycle-long times, including non-equilibrium events such as the co-translational folding, misfolding, and aggregation of proteins. A prominent role will be played by the wise choice of the structural simplifications and, simultaneously, of a relatively complex energetic description. These challenging tasks will rely on the integration of experimental and computational methods, achieved through the application of efficient algorithms. Graphical abstract.

Multi-scale simulations of biological systems using the OPEP coarse-grained model

Biomolecules are complex machines that are optimized by evolution to properly fulfill or contribute to a variety of biochemical tasks in the cellular environment. Computer simulations based on quantum mechanics and atomistic force fields have been proven to be a powerful microscope for obtaining valuable insights into many biological, physical, and chemical processes. Many interesting phenomena involve, however, a time scale and a number of degrees of freedom, notably if crowding is considered, that cannot be explored at an atomistic resolution. To bridge the gap between reality and simulation, many different advanced computational techniques and coarse-grained (CG) models have been developed. Here, we report some applications of the CG OPEP protein model to amyloid fibril formation, the response of catch-bond proteins to two types of fluid flow, and interactive simulations to fold peptides with well-defined 3D structures or with intrinsic disorder.