Comparison of land use regression models for NO2 based on routine and campaign monitoring data from an urban area of Japan

Intra-urban variability of long-term exposure to PM2.5 and NO2 in five cities in Colombia

Rapidly urbanizing cities in Latin America experience high levels of air pollution which are known risk factors for population health. However, the estimates of long-term exposure to air pollution are scarce in the region. We developed intraurban land use regression (LUR) models to map long-term exposure to fine particulate matter (PM2.5) and nitrogen dioxide (NO2) in the five largest cities in Colombia. We conducted air pollution measurement campaigns using gravimetric PM2.5 and passive NO2 sensors for 2 weeks during both the dry and rainy seasons in 2021 in the cities of Barranquilla, Bucaramanga, Bogotá, Cali, and Medellín, and combined these data with geospatial and meteorological variables. Annual models were developed using multivariable spatial regression models. The city annual PM2.5 mean concentrations measured ranged between 12.32 and 15.99 µg/m3 while NO2 concentrations ranged between 24.92 and 49.15 µg/m3. The PM2.5 annual models explained 82% of the variance (R2) in Medellín, 77% in Bucaramanga, 73% in Barranquilla, 70% in Cali, and 44% in Bogotá. The NO2 models explained 65% of the variance in Bucaramanga, 57% in Medellín, 44% in Cali, 40% in Bogotá, and 30% in Barranquilla. Most of the predictor variables included in the models were a combination of specific land use characteristics and roadway variables. Cross-validation suggests that PM2.5 outperformed NO2 models. The developed models can be used as exposure estimate in epidemiological studies, as input in hybrid models to improve personal exposure assessment, and for policy evaluation.

Land use regression modelling of NO2 in São Paulo, Brazil

BACKGROUND

Air pollution is a major global public health problem. The situation is most severe in low- and middle-income countries, where pollution control measures and monitoring systems are largely lacking. Data to quantify the exposure to air pollution in low-income settings are scarce.

METHODS

In this study, land use regression models (LUR) were developed to predict the outdoor nitrogen dioxide (NO₂) concentration in the study area of the Western Region Birth Cohort in São Paulo. NO₂ measurements were performed for one week in winter and summer at eighty locations. Additionally, weekly measurements at one regional background location were performed over a full one-year period to create an annual prediction.

RESULTS

Three LUR models were developed (annual, summer, winter) by using a supervised stepwise linear regression method. The winter, summer and annual models explained 52 %, 75 % and 66 % of the variance (R²) respectively. Cross-holdout validation tests suggest robust models. NO₂ levels ranged from 43.2 μg/m³ to 93.4 μg/m³ in the winter and between 28.1 μg/m³ and 72.8 μg/m³ in summer. Based on our annual prediction, about 67 % of the population living in the study area is exposed to NO₂ values over the WHO suggested annual guideline of 40 μg/m³ annual average.

CONCLUSION

In this study we were able to develop robust models to predict NO₂ residential exposure. We could show that average measures, and therefore the predictions of NO_2, in such a complex urban area are substantially high and that a major variability within the area and especially within the season is present. These findings also suggest that in general a high proportion of the population is exposed to high NO₂ levels.

Assessing the intra-urban variability of nitrogen oxides and ozone across a highly heterogeneous urban area

High-resolution air quality maps are critical towards assessing and understanding exposures to elevated air pollution in dense urban areas. However, these surfaces are rarely available in low- and middle-income countries that suffer from some of the highest air pollution levels worldwide. In this study, we make use of land use regressions (LURs) to generate annual and seasonal, high-resolution nitrogen dioxide (NO₂), nitrogen oxides (NO_x), and ozone (O₃) exposure surfaces for the Greater Beirut Area (GBA) in Lebanon. NO₂, NO_x and O₃ concentrations were monitored using passive samplers that were deployed at 55 pre-defined monitoring locations. The average annual concentrations of NO₂, NO_x, and O₃ across the GBA were 36.0, 89.7, and 26.9 ppb, respectively. Overall, the performance of the generated models was appropriate, with low biases, high model robustness, and acceptable R² values that ranged between 0.66 and 0.73 for NO₂, 0.56 and 0.60 for NO_x, and 0.54 and 0.65 for O₃. Traffic-related emissions as well as the operation of a fossil-fuel power plant were found to be the main contributors to the measured NO₂ and NO_x levels in the GBA, whereas they acted as sinks for O₃ concentrations. No seasonally significant differences were found for the NO₂ and NO_x pollution surfaces; as their seasonal and annual models were largely similar (Pearson's r > 0.85 for both pollutants). On the other hand, seasonal O₃ pollution surfaces were significantly different. The model results showed that around 99% of the population of the GBA were exposed to NO₂ levels that exceeded the World Health Organization defined annual standard.

A robust approach to deriving long-term daily surface NO2 levels across China: Correction to substantial estimation bias in back-extrapolation

BACKGROUND

Long-term surface NO₂ data are essential for retrospective policy evaluation and chronic human exposure assessment. In the absence of NO₂ observations for Mainland China before 2013, training a model with 2013-2018 data to make predictions for 2005-2012 (back-extrapolation) could cause substantial estimation bias due to concept drift.

OBJECTIVE

This study aims to correct the estimation bias in order to reconstruct the spatiotemporal distribution of daily surface NO₂ levels across China during 2005-2018.

METHODS

On the basis of ground- and satellite-based data, we proposed the robust back-extrapolation with a random forest (RBE-RF) to simulate the surface NO₂ through intermediate modeling of the scaling factors. For comparison purposes, we also employed a random forest (Base-RF), as a representative of the commonly used approach, to directly model the surface NO₂ levels.

RESULTS

The validation against Taiwan's NO₂ observations during 2005-2012 showed that RBE-RF adequately corrected the substantial underestimation by Base-RF. The RMSE decreased from 10.1 to 8.2 µg/m³, 7.1 to 4.3 µg/m³, and 6.1 to 2.9 µg/m³ in predicting daily, monthly, and annual levels, respectively. For North China with the most severe pollution, the population-weighted NO₂ ([NO₂]_pw) during 2005-2012 was estimated as 40.2 and 50.9 µg/m³ by Base-RF and RBE-RF, respectively, i.e., 21.0% difference. While both models predicted that the national annual [NO₂]_pw increased during 2005-2011 and then decreased, the interannual trends were underestimated by >50.2% by Base-RF relative to RBE-RF. During 2005-2018, the nationwide population that lived in the areas with NO₂ > 40 µg/m³ were estimated as 259 and 460 million by Base-RF and RBE-RF, respectively.

CONCLUSION

With RBE-RF, we corrected the estimation bias in back-extrapolation and obtained a full-coverage dataset of daily surface NO₂ across China during 2005-2018, which is valuable for environmental management and epidemiological research.

Land use regression modelling of PM2.5 spatial variations in different seasons in urban areas

As one of the principal components of haze, fine particulate matter (PM_2.5) has potential negative health effects, causing widespread concern. Identification of the pollutant spatial variation is a prerequisite of understanding ambient air pollution exposure and further improving air quality. Seven urban built-up areas in Liaoning central urban agglomeration (LCUA) were used for land use regression (LUR) modelling of PM_2.5 concentrations using small amounts of spatially aggregated data and to assess the model's seasonal consistency. LUR models explained 52-61% of the variation in the PM_2.5 concentrations at urban scales. The average building floor area was the key predictor in each model, and the percent water area was predictor with a negative coefficient. Good seasonal consistency was observed between the heating-seasonal model and annual average model, showing that the annual average PM_2.5 pollution in the LCUA was mainly influenced by pollution during the heating season. Extending the linear LUR model with regression kriging improved the model's explanatory ability and predictive performance. The predicted PM_2.5 concentrations in Shenyang and Anshan were the highest and that in Yingkou was the lowest. The building three-dimensional variables played important roles in the urban spatial modelling of air pollution.

Long-term exposure to nitrogen dioxide and natural-cause and cause-specific mortality in Japan

BACKGROUND

Long-term exposure to air pollution is linked with increased risk of adverse health outcomes, but the evidence for the association between nitrogen dioxide (NO₂) and mortality is weak because of the inadequate adjustment of potential confounders and limited spatial resolution of the exposure assessment. Moreover, there are concerns about the independent effects of NO₂. Therefore, we examined the association between NO₂ long-term exposure and all-cause and cause-specific mortality.

METHODS

We included participants who were enrolled in health checkups in Okayama City, Japan, in 2006 or 2007 and were followed until 2016. We used a land-use regression model to estimate the average NO₂ concentrations from 2006 to 2007 and allocated them to the participants. We estimated hazard ratios (HRs) for a 10-μg/m³ increase in NO₂ levels for all-cause or cause-specific mortality using Cox proportional hazard models.

RESULTS

After excluding the participants who were assigned with outlier exposures, a total of 73,970 participants were included in the analyses. NO₂ exposure was associated with increased risk of mortality and the HRs and their confidence intervals were 1.06 (95% CI: 1.02, 1.11) for all-cause, 1.02 (0.96, 1.09) for cardiopulmonary, and 1.36 (1.14, 1.63) for lung cancer mortality. However, the elevated risks became equivocal after the adjustment for fine particulate matter except lung cancer.

CONCLUSION

Long-term exposure to NO₂ was associated with increased risk of all-cause, cardiopulmonary, and lung cancer mortality. The elevated risk for lung cancer was still observable even after adjustment for fine particulate matter.

Assessing NO2 Concentration and Model Uncertainty with High Spatiotemporal Resolution across the Contiguous United States Using Ensemble Model Averaging

NO₂ is a combustion byproduct that has been associated with multiple adverse health outcomes. To assess NO₂ levels with high accuracy, we propose the use of an ensemble model to integrate multiple machine learning algorithms, including neural network, random forest, and gradient boosting, with a variety of predictor variables, including chemical transport models. This NO₂ model covers the entire contiguous U.S. with daily predictions on 1-km-level grid cells from 2000 to 2016. The ensemble produced a cross-validated R² of 0.788 overall, a spatial R² of 0.844, and a temporal R² of 0.729. The relationship between daily monitored and predicted NO₂ is almost linear. We also estimated the associated monthly uncertainty level for the predictions and address-specific NO₂ levels. This NO₂ estimation has a very high spatiotemporal resolution and allows the examination of the health effects of NO₂ in unmonitored areas. We found the highest NO₂ levels along highways and in cities. We also observed that nationwide NO₂ levels declined in early years and stagnated after 2007, in contrast to the trend at monitoring sites in urban areas, where the decline continued. Our research indicates that the integration of different predictor variables and fitting algorithms can achieve an improved air pollution modeling framework.

Land use regression for spatial distribution of urban particulate matter (PM10) and sulfur dioxide (SO2) in a heavily polluted city in Northeast China

Particulate material 10 μm (PM₁₀) and sulfur dioxide (SO₂) are representative air pollutants in Northeast China and may contribute more to the morbidity of respiratory and cardiovascular disease than may other pollutants. Up to now, there have been few studies on the relation between health effect and air pollution by PM₁₀ and SO₂ in Northeast China, which may be due to the lack of a model for determination of air pollution exposure. For the first time, we used daily concentration data and influencing factors (different type of land use, road length and population density, and weather conditions as well) to develop land use regression models for spatial distribution of PM₁₀ and SO₂ in a central city in Northeast China in both heating and non-heating months. The final models of SO₂ and PM₁₀ estimation showed good performance (heating months: R² = 0.88 for SO₂, R² = 0.88 for PM₁₀; non-heating months: R² = 0.79 for SO₂; R² = 0.87 for PM₁₀). Estimated concentrations of air pollutants were more affected by population density in heating seasons and land use area in non-heating seasons. We used the land use regression (LUR) models developed to predict pollutant levels in nine districts in Shenyang and conducted a correlation analysis between air pollutant levels and hospital admission rates for childhood asthma. There were high associations between asthma hospital admission rates and air pollution levels of SO₂ and PM₁₀, which indicated the usability of the LUR models and the need for more concern about the health effects of SO₂ and PM₁₀ in Northeast China. This study may contribute to epidemiological research on the relation between air pollutant exposure and typical chronic disease in Northeast China as well as providing the government with more scientific recommendations for air pollution prevention.