Effect of salinity on mature wastewater treatment biofilm microbial community assembly and metabolite characteristics

Biofilm application for anaerobic digestion: a systematic review and an industrial scale case

Biofilm is a syntrophic community of microorganisms enveloped by extracellular polymeric substances and displays remarkable adaptability to dynamic environments. Implementing biofilm in anaerobic digestion has been widely investigated and applied as it promotes microbial retention time and enhances the efficiency. Previous studies on anaerobic biofilm primarily focused on application in wastewater treatment, while its role has been significantly extended to accelerate the degradation of lignocellulosic biomass, improve gas-liquid mass transfer for biogas upgrading, or enhance resistance to inhibitors or toxic pollutants. This work comprehensively reviewed the current applications of biofilm in anaerobic digestion and focused on impacting factors, optimization strategies, reactor set-up, and microbial communities. Moreover, a full-scale biofilm reactor case from Norway is also reported. This review provides a state of-the- art insight on the role of biofilm in anaerobic digestion.

Influence of aeration modes and DO on simultaneous nitrification and denitrification in treatment of hypersaline high-strength nitrogen wastewater using sequencing batch biofilm reactor (SBBR)

Sequencing batch biofilm reactor (SBBR) has the potential to treat hypersaline high-strength nitrogen wastewater by simultaneous nitrification-denitrification (SND). Dissolved oxygen (DO) and aeration modes are major factors affecting pollutant removal. Low DO (0.35-3.5 mg/L) and alternative anoxic/aerobic (A/O) mode are commonly used for municipal wastewater treatment, however, the appropriate DO concentration and operation mode are still unknown under hypersaline environment because of the restricted oxygen transfer in denser extracellular polymeric substances (EPS) barrier and the decreased carbon source consumption during the anoxic phase. Herein, two SBBRs (R1, fully aerobic mode; R2, A/O mode) were used for the treatment of hypersaline high-strength nitrogen wastewater (200 mg/L NH4+-N, COD/N of 3 and 3% salinity). The results showed that the relatively low DO (2 mg/L) could not realize effective nitrification, while high DO (4.5 mg/L) evidently increased nitrification efficiency by enhancing oxygen transfer in denser biofilm that was stimulated by high salinity. A stable SND was reached 16 days faster with a ∼10% increase of TN removal under A/O mode. Mechanism analysis found that denser biofilm with coccus and bacillus were present in A/O mode instead of filamentous microorganisms, with the secretion of more EPS. Corynebacterium and Halomonas were the dominant genera in both SBBRs, and HN-AD process might assist partial nitrification-denitrification (PND) for highly efficient TN removal in biofilm systems. By using the appropriate operation mode and parameters, the average NH4+-N and TN removal efficiency could respectively reach 100% and 70.8% under the NLR of 0.2 kg N·m-3·d-1 (COD/N of 3), which was the highest among the published works using SND-based SBBRs in treatment of saline high-strength ammonia nitrogen (low COD/N) wastewater. This study provided new insights in biofilm under hypersaline stress and provided a solution for the treatment of hypersaline high-strength nitrogen (low COD/N) water.

Vallisneria natans decreased CH4 fluxes in wetlands: Interactions among plant physiological status, nutrients and epiphytic bacterial community

Submerged macrophytes provide niches for epiphytic microbes (including aerobic methanotrophs) growth. However, little is known about the impacts of submerged macrophytes growth status and nutrients loadings on methanotroph community and methane release in wetlands. In the present study, methane fluxes, bacterial and methanotroph community in epiphytic biofilm, and environmental parameters were investigated during Vallisneria natans senescence in wetlands under low (VnL) and high (VnH) nutrients for seven weeks. Relative conductivity and concentration of H₂O₂, total chlorophyll and malondialdehyde were higher in leaves of V. natans in VnH than VnL at the same sampling time. Nutrients loading increased methane fluxes in treatments with or without (Control) macrophytes, while healthy V. natans plants reduced the methane flux and nutrients concentration in water columns. CH₄ fluxes were positively correlated to temperature and COD (p < 0.05). Methane oxidation rates were 3.04-31.68 μmol methane mg^-1 fresh weight of V. natans leaves - epiphytic biofilm within 1 h. Proteobacteria, Cyanobacteria, Bacteroidetes, Verrucomicrobia, Planctomycetes, Actinobacteria and Acidobacteria were dominant phylum in all epiphytic biofilms. The mean abundances of pmoA/16S rRNA were higher in VnL than VnH. According to Illumina sequencing results of pmoA gene, γ-proteobacteria and α-proteobacteria were the dominant methanotroph class in epiphytic biofilm from VnH and VnL, respectively. Among seven detected methanotrophic genera, Methylomonas was significantly higher in VnH than VnL. Network analysis revealed that there were much closer relationships between the environmental parameters and epiphytic bacterial community in VnH than in VnL. COD and MDA were negatively correlated with Methyloglobulus, Methylosarcina, Methylobacter and Methylocystis, but positively correlated with Methylomonas and Methylosinus. This study highlights that methanotrophs in epiphytic biofilm play important roles in methane-oxidizing, which can be affected by plant physiological status and environmental parameters.

Treatment performance of multistage active biological process (MSABP) reactor for saline sauerkraut wastewater: acclimatization, optimization and improvement

The wastewater with a high concentration of organics and salt is a major contaminant in the production of sauerkraut. In this study, a multistage active biological process (MSABP) system was constructed to treat sauerkraut wastewater. The key process parameters of the MSABP system were analyzed and optimized by response surface methodology. The optimization results indicated that the most optimal removal efficiencies and removal loading rates of chemical oxygen demand (COD) and NH₄⁺-N were 87.9%, 95.5%, 2.11 kg·m^-3·d^-1 and 0.12 kg·m^-3·d^-1, respectively, with hydraulic retention time (HRT) of 2.5 d and pH of 7.3. Meanwhile, this system could also be improved for the further treatment of COD and total nitrogen by effluent recycle and ozone oxidation. The COD and total nitrogen removal efficiencies of the modified MSABP system were 99.9% and 60.2%, respectively. In addition, the modified system could also reduce the potential harm from high concentrations of NO₂^--N.

Flow Cytometric Investigation of Salinicola halophilus S28 Physiological Response Provides Solid Evidence for Its Uncommon and High Ability to Face Salt-Stress Conditions

In a previous work, some bacterial strains isolated from the Saline di Tarquinia marine salterns (Viterbo, Italy) showed very unusual growth profiles in relation to temperature and salinity variations when grown in solid media. In particular, Salinicola halophilus S28 showed optimal or suboptimal growth in a very wide range of NaCl concentrations, suggesting a great coping ability with salinity variations. These intriguing outcomes did not fit with the general Salinicola halophilus description as a moderately halophilic species. Therefore, this study profiles the actual physiological status of S28 cells subjected to different NaCl concentrations to provide evidence for the actual coping ability of strain S28 with broad salinity variations. Flow cytometry was selected as the evaluation method to study the physiological status of bacterial cells subjected to different salinity levels, monitoring the strain response at different growth phases over 72 h. Strain S28 showed maximal growth at 8% NaCl; however, it grew very well with no statistically significant differences at all salinity conditions (4–24% NaCl). Flow cytometric results provided clear evidence of its actual and strong ability to face increasing salinity, revealing a good physiological response up to 24% of NaCl. In addition, strain S28 showed very similar cell physiological status at all salinity levels, as also indicated by the flat growth profile revealed in the range of 4–24% NaCl. This is the first study regarding the physiological response during the growth of halophilic bacteria under different conditions of salinity via flow cytometry. This technique represents an effective tool for the investigation of the physiological status of each cell, even if it is somehow underrated and underused by microbiologists for this purpose.

Efficient pollutants removal and microbial flexibility under high-salt gradient of an oilfield wastewater treatment system

The treatment of hypersaline oilfield wastewater (HSOW) is a challenge due to its complex composition and low biodegradability, especially in coastal areas. In this study, an HSOW treatment system of gas flotation and biochemistry technology combined with constructed wetland (CW) was investigated. The combined treatment system could efficiently remove COD, NH₄⁺-N and oil under high salinity (1.36-2.21 × 10⁴ mg/L), with average removal rates of 98.5%, 99.9% and 96%, respectively. Meanwhile, different salinity shaped particular community structures and functions. The abundance of Marivita, Parvibaculum, etc. was highly correlated with salinity. Co-occurrence network resulted that the microorganisms were highly interconnected, and formed a functional group of petroleum degrading. Pseudomonas, Rosevarius, Alternaria, etc. were the key genera. Moreover, functional prospected revealed that high salinity reduced the energy metabolism activity. This study will optimize the combined process and provide the basis for further extraction of high-efficiency degradation strains for HSOW enhanced treatment.

Metagenomic insights into the "window" effect of static magnetic field on nitrous oxide emission from biological nitrogen removal process at low temperature

This study aimed to explore whether the "window" effect of static magnetic field (SMF) on nitrous oxide (N₂O) emission from the biological nitrogen removal process at low temperature existed and reveal its biological mechanism at the gene level. Four sequencing batch reactors (SBRs) with SMFs of 0, 10, 45, and 75 mT were operated continuously for 110 days at 10 °C and the lowest N₂O-Gas cumulative emission (5.50 mg N/day) and N₂O conversion rate (4.28 %) in 45 mT SMF-SBR verified the existence of the "window" effect. In 45 mT SMF-SBR, nearly all enzymatic activities related to N₂O reduction and corresponding functional gene abundances improved significantly. Metagenomic high-throughput sequencing analysis revealed that Alicycliphilus denitricans, Paracoccus denitrificans, Rhodopseudomonas palustris, Pseudomonas stutzeri, and Dechloromonas aromatica, as species related to N₂O reduction, could be separately enriched by applying suitable SMF intensity. Gene functions annotation based on KEGG and CAZy databases indicated that SMF not only accelerated the rate of free ammonia into ammonia-oxidizing bacteria and electrons delivered to the corresponding denitrification reductases, but also enhanced the degradation of complex organic matter into smaller molecules, and thus reducing the production of N₂O via nitrifier denitrification and incomplete denitrification pathways at 10 °C. These findings provided a guideline and presented a blueprint of ecophysiology for the future application of magnetic field to the reduction of N₂O emission in wastewater treatment plants in the cold region.

Increasing salinity concentrations determine the long-term participation of methanogenesis and sulfidogenesis in the biodigestion of sulfate-rich wastewater

The competition between sulfate-reducing bacteria (SRB) and methanogenic archaea (MA) depends on several factors, such as the COD/SO₄^2- ratio, sensitivity to inhibitors and even the length of the operating period in reactors. Among the inhibitors, salinity, a characteristic common to diverse types of industrial effluents, can act as an important factor. This work aimed to evaluate the long-term participation of sulfidogenesis and methanogenesis in the sulfate-rich wastewater process (COD/SO₄^2- = 1.6) in an anaerobic structured-bed reactor (AnSTBR) using sludge not adapted to salinity. The AnSTBR was operated for 580 d under mesophilic temperature (30 °C). Salinity levels were gradually increased from 1.7 to 50 g-NaCl L^-1. Up to 35 g-NaCl L^-1, MA and SRB equally participated in COD conversion, with a slight predominance of the latter (53 ± 11%). A decrease in COD removal efficiency associated with acetate accumulation was further observed when applying 50 g-NaCl L^-1. The sulfidogenic pathway corresponded to 62 ± 17% in this case, indicating the inhibition of MA. Overall, sulfidogenic activity was less sensitive (25%-inhibition) to high salinity levels compared to methanogenesis (100%-inhibition considering the methane yield). The wide spectrum of SRB populations at different salinity levels, namely, the prevalence of Desulfovibrio sp. up to 35 g-NaCl L^-1 and the additional participation of the genera Desulfobacca, Desulfatirhabdium, and Desulfotomaculum at 50 g-NaCl^-1 explain such patterns. Conversely, the persistence of Methanosaeta genus was not sufficient to sustain methane production. Hence, exploiting SRB populations is imperative to anaerobically remediating saline wastewaters.

Biotreatment efficiency, hydrolytic potential and bacterial community dynamics in an immobilized cell bioreactor treating caper processing wastewater under highly saline conditions

Although caper processing wastewaters (CPW) are characterized by high organic content and salt concentration, no attempt has been made to treat these effluents. In this study, an immobilized cell bioreactor efficiently treated CPW even at hypersaline conditions (100 g/L salinity). Nitrogen was mainly assimilated during biotreatment, as nitrification was inhibited at elevated salinities. The hydrolytic potential was assessed by determining glucanase, xylanase, glucosidase, lipase and protease activities, which were negatively affected above 20 g/L salinity as the consequence of the inhibition of non-halotolerant microbiota. Succession of non-halotolerant taxa by the slightly halotolerant bacteria Defluviimonas, Amaricoccus, Arenibacter, Formosa and Muricauda, and then by the moderately/extremely halotolerant genera Halomonas, Roseovarius and Idiomarina occurred over salinity increase. Diversity indices were reduced during transition from moderately saline to hypersaline conditions. A distinct network was formed at hypersaline conditions, consisting of the halotolerant genera Halomonas, Idiomarina, Saliterribacillus and Gracilibacillus.

Comparison of Myriophyllum Spicatum and artificial plants on nutrients removal and microbial community in constructed wetlands receiving WWTPs effluents

The impacts of WWTPs effluents on nutrients removal and epiphytic microbial community in constructed wetlands dominated by submersed macrophytes remain to be fully illustrated. In this study, compared to M. Spicatum, artificial submersed macrophytes (control) generally had higher NH₄⁺-N (78.35% vs 80.52%) and TN (73.35% vs 90.25%) removal rates and similar COD (70.64% vs 70.80%) and TP (59.86% vs 60.82%) removal rates in wetlands receiving simulated effluents of WWTPs (GB18918-2002). Microbial population richness was higher in epiphytic biofilms on M. Spicatum than artificial ones, and substrates played the most decisive role in determining the microbial diversities. Network analysis revealed that there were more complex interactions among environmental parameters, bacteria and eukaryotes in M. Spicatum systems than in artificial ones. Nutrients in effluents could cause damage to M. Spicatum. The results highlight that artificial plants have better performance on effluents deep treatments than submerged plants.

Comparison of the effects of salinity on microbial community structures and functions in sequencing batch reactors with and without carriers

This study investigated and compared the microbial communities between a sequencing batch reactor (SBR) without carriers and a hybrid SBR with addition of carriers for the treatment of saline wastewater. The two systems were operated over 292 days with alternating aerobic/anoxic mode (temperature: 28℃, salinity: 0.0-3.0%). High removal efficiency of chemical oxygen demand (COD) and total inorganic nitrogen (TIN) was achieved in both the SBR (above 86.7 and 95.4% respectively) and hybrid SBR (above 84.4 and 94.0%) at 0.0-2.5% salinity. Further increasing salinity to 3.0% decreased TIN removal efficiency to 78.4% in the hybrid SBR. Steep decline of biodiversity and relative abundance of ammonia-oxidizing bacteria (AOB) contributed to the worse performance. More genera related to sulfide-oxidizing and sulfate-reducing bacteria were detected in the hybrid SBR than the SBR at 3.0% salinity. The abundance of halotolerant bacteria increased with the salinity increase for both reactors, summing up to 25.5% in the suspended sludge (S-sludge) from the SBR, 28.9 and 22.9% in the S-sludge and biofilm taken from the hybrid SBR, respectively. Nitrification and denitrification via nitrate was the main nitrogen removal pathway in the SBR and hybrid SBR at 0.0 and 0.5% salinity, while partial nitrification and denitrification via nitrite became the key process for nitrogen removal in the two reactors when the salinity was increased to 1.0-3.0%. Higher abundance of anaerobic ammonium-oxidizing (ANAMMOX) and sulfide-oxidizing autotrophic denitrification (SOAD) bacteria were found in the hybrid SBR at 3.0% salinity.