Inhibition of methanogenesis leads to accumulation of methylated arsenic species and enhances arsenic volatilization from rice paddy soil

Microbial arsenic methylation in soil-water systems and its environmental significance

In this review, we have summarized the current knowledge about the environmental importance, relevance, and consequences of microbial arsenic (As) methylation in various ecosystems. In this regard, we have presented As biomethylation in terrestrial and aquatic ecosystems particularly in rice paddy soils and wetlands. The functions of As biomethylation by microbial consortia in anaerobic and aerobic conditions are extensively discussed. In addition, we have tried to explain the interconnections between As transformation and carbon (C), such as microbial degradation of organic compounds and methane (CH4) emission. These processes can cause As release because of the reduction of arsenate (As(V)) to the more mobile arsenite (As(III)) as well as As methylation and the formation of toxic trivalent methylated As species in anaerobic conditions. Furthermore, the sulfur (S) transformation can form highly toxic thiolated As species owing to its interference with As biomethylation. Besides, we have focused on many other mutual interlinks that remain elusive between As and C, including As biomethylation, thiolation, and CH4 emission, in the soil-water systems. Recent developments have clarified the significant and complex interactions between the coupled microbial process in anoxic and submerged soils. These processes, performed by little-known/unknown microbial taxa or well-known members of microbial communities with unrecognized metabolic pathways, conducted several concurrent reactions that contributed to global warming on our planet and have unfavorable impacts on water quality and human food resources. Finally, some environmental implications in rice production and arsenic removal from soil-water systems are discussed. Generally, our understanding of the ecological and metabolic evidence for the coupling and synchronous processes of As, C, and S are involved in environmental contamination-caused toxicity in human food, including high As content in rice grain, water resources, and global warming through methanogenesis elucidate combating global rice safety, drinking water, and climate changes.

Long-term paddy use influences response of methane production, arsenic mobility and speciation to future higher temperatures

Anaerobic microbial metabolisms make flooded paddy soils a major source of the greenhouse gas methane (CH4) and mobilize toxic arsenic (As), threatening rice production and consumption. Increasing temperatures due to climate change enhance these microbially mediated processes, increasing their related threats. Chronosequence studies show that long-term paddy use ("age") changes soil properties and redox biogeochemistry through soil organic carbon (SOC) accumulation, its association to amorphous iron (Fe) phases, and increased microbial activity. Using paddy and non-paddy soils from a chronosequence as proxies of soil development and incubating them at different temperatures, we show that paddy soil age influences the response of paddies to changes in temperature. Older paddies showed up to a 6-fold higher CH4 production with increasing temperature, compared to a 2-fold increase in young ones. Contrarily, changes in As mobility were higher in non-paddies and young paddies due to a lack of Fe-SOC-sorption sites. Temperature increased the formation of phytotoxic methylated As in all paddies, posing a risk for rice production. Mitigation strategies for future maintenance, abandonment, or management of paddy soils should include the consideration that history of use shapes the soils' biogeochemistry and microbiology and can influence the response of paddy soils to future temperature increases.

Antimony release and volatilization from organic-rich and iron-rich submerged soils

Antimony (Sb) is an poorly understood, increasingly common pollutant, especially in soils susceptible to waterlogging. We investigated the impact of waterlogging on Sb release, methylation, and volatilization from an organic-rich wetland soil and an iron (Fe)-rich floodplain soil in a 27-day microcosm experiment. The release of Sb into the porewaters of the organic-rich soil was environmentally relevant and immediate with waterlogging (3.2 to 3.5 mg L-1), and likely associated with a complex interplay of sulfide precipitation, sorption with organic matter and manganese (Mn) (oxyhydr)oxides in the soil. The release of Sb from the Fe-rich soil was likely associated with Fe-(oxyhydr)oxide reduction and immobilized due to co-precipitation with Fe-sulfides or as Sb-sulfides. Volatile Sb was produced from the soils after waterlogging. The organic-rich soil produced more volatile Sb (409 to 835 ng kgsoil-1), but the Fe-rich soil volatilized Sb more efficiently. The negligible association of Sb volatilization with soil parameters indicates a more complex underlying, potentially microbial, mechanism and that antimony volatilization could be ubiquitous and not dependent on specific soil properties. Future works should investigate the microbial and physiochemical drivers of Sb volatilization in soils as it may be an environmentally relevant part of the biogeochemical cycle.

Systematic evaluation of methods for iron-impregnation of biochar and effects on arsenic in flooded soils

There is a need for innovative strategies to decrease the mobility of metal(loids) including arsenic (As) and cadmium (Cd) in agricultural soils, including rice paddies, so as to minimize dietary exposure to these toxic elements. Iron (Fe)-modified biochars (FBCs) are used to immobilize As and Cd in soil-water systems, but there is a lack of clarity on optimal methods for preparing FBCs because there are only limited studies that directly compare BCs impregnated with Fe under different conditions. There is also a lack of information on the long-term performance of FBCs in flooded soil environments, where reductive dissolution of Fe (oxy)hydroxide phases loaded onto biochar surfaces may decrease the effectiveness of FBCs. This study uses material characterization methods including FTIR, SEM-EDX, BET, and adsorption isotherm experiments to investigate the effects of Fe-impregnation methods (pH, pyrolysis sequence, and sonication) on the morphology and mineralogy of Fe loaded onto the biochar surface, and to FBC adsorbent properties for arsenate (As(V)), arsenite (As(III)), and Cd. Acidic impregnation conditions favored the adsorption of As(III) onto amorphous Fe phases that were evenly distributed on the biochar surface, including within the biochar pore structure. The combination of sonication with acidic Fe-impregnation conditions led to the best adsorption capacities for As(V) and As(III) (4830 and 11,166 μg As g-1 biochar, respectively). Alkaline Fe-impregnation conditions led to the highest Cd adsorption capacity of 3054 μg Cd g-1 biochar, but had poor effectiveness as an As adsorbent. Amending soil with 5% (w/w) of an acid-impregnated and sonicated FBC was more effective than an alkaline-impregnated FBC or ferrihydrite in decreasing porewater As concentrations. The acid-impregnated FBC also had greater longevity, decreasing As by 54% and 56% in two flooded phases, probably due to the greater stability of Fe(III) within the biochar pore structure that may have a direct chemical bond to the biochar surface. This study demonstrates that FBCs can be designed with selectivity towards different As species or Cd and that they can maintain their effectiveness under anaerobic soil conditions. This is the first study to systematically test how impregnation conditions affect the stability of FBCs in soils under multiple drying-rewetting cycles.

Arsenic biogeochemical cycling association with basin-scale dynamics of microbial functionality and organic matter molecular composition

Geogenic arsenic (As)-contaminated groundwater is a sustaining global health concern that is tightly constrained by multiple interrelated biogeochemical processes. However, a complete spectrum of the biogeochemical network of high-As groundwater remains to be established, concurrently neglecting systematic zonation of groundwater biogeochemistry on the regional scale. We uncovered the geomicrobial interaction network governing As biogeochemical pathways by merging in-field hydrogeochemical monitoring, metagenomic analyses, and ultrahigh resolution mass spectrometry (FT-ICR MS) characterization of dissolved organic matter. In oxidizing to weakly reducing environments, the nitrate-reduction and sulfate-reduction encoding genes (narGHI, sat) inhibited the dissolution of As-bearing iron minerals, leading to lower As levels in groundwater. In settings from weakly to moderately reducing, high abundances of sulfate-reduction and iron-transport encoding genes boosted iron mineral dissolution and consequent As release. As it evolved to strongly reducing stage, elevated abundance of methane cycle-related genes (fae, fwd, fmd) further enhanced As mobilization in part by triggering the formation of gaseous methylarsenic. During redox cycling of N, S, Fe, C and As in groundwater, As migration to groundwater and immobilization in mineral particles are geochemically constrained by basin-scale dynamics of microbial functionality and DOM molecular composition. The study constructs a theoretical model to summarize new perspectives on the biogeochemical network of As cycling.

Biochar mitigates the adverse effects of antimony on methanogenic activity: role as methane production-enhancer

Antimony, extensively used in energy applications, poses toxicity and contamination concerns, especially in anaerobic environments where its impact on microbial activity is poorly understood. Emerging remedies, like biochar, show promise in soil and water treatment. This study investigates biochar's influence on methanogenic activity under Sb(V) and Sb(III) stress using anaerobic sludge as inoculum and lactate as the carbon source. Sb(III) and Sb(V) were introduced at varied concentrations (5-80 mg/L), with or without biochar, monitoring changes in biogas production, pH, Sb, and lactate levels over time. Experiments with Sb(V) also involved calculating mass balance and electron distribution. Results showcased the following significant enhancements: biochar notably improved COD removal and biogas production in Sb(III) spiked conditions, up to 5-fold and 2-fold increases, respectively. Sb(III) removal reached up to 99% with biochar, while in high Sb(V) concentrations, biochar reduced the adverse effect on biogas production by 96%. Adsorption capacities favored biomass (60.96 mg Sb(III)/gVSS, and 22.4 mg Sb(V)/gVSS) over biochar (3.33 mg Sb(III)/g, and 1.61 mg Sb(V)/g) for both Sb species. This study underscores biochar's potential to mitigate metalloid impact on methanogenic activity while aiding Sb removal from liquid phase, suggesting promising implications for remediation and methane production enhancement strategies.

Effects of alternate wetting and drying on oxyanion-forming and cationic trace elements in rice paddy soils: impacts on arsenic, cadmium, and micronutrients in rice

Rice is a global dietary staple and its traditional cultivation under flooded soil conditions leads to accumulation of arsenic (As) in rice grains. Alternate wetting and drying (AWD) is a widely advocated water management practice to achieve lower As concentrations in rice, water savings, and decreased methane emissions. It is not yet clear whether AWD leads to tradeoffs between concentrations of As and micronutrient elements (e.g., zinc, manganese, molybdenum) in rice grain. We analyzed pore water chemistry and rice grain composition data from a field experiment conducted in Arkansas, USA, in 2017 and 2018 to test the hypothesis that AWD will have diverging effects on oxyanion-forming (arsenic, molybdenum) vs. cationic (cadmium, zinc, manganese, copper) trace elements. This was hypothesized to occur via decreases in soil pH and/or precipitation of iron oxide minerals during oxidizing conditions under AWD. Solubility of all trace elements, except zinc, increased in more reducing conditions. Consistent with our hypothesis, AWD tended to increase grain concentrations of cationic elements while decreasing grain concentrations of oxyanionic elements. Decreases in total As in rice grains under AWD were mainly driven by changes in dimethylarsinic concentrations, with negligible changes in inorganic As. Linear mixed-effects modeling showed that effects of AWD on grain composition were more significant in 2017 compared to 2018. These differences may be related to the timing of dry-downs in the developmental stage of rice plants, with dry-downs during the heading stage of rice development leading to larger impacts on grain composition of certain elements. We also observed significant interannual variability in grain elemental composition from continuously-flooded fields and postulate the warmer temperatures in 2018 may have played a role in these differences.

Chemical-microbial effects of acetic acid, oxalic acid and citric acid on arsenic transformation and migration in the rhizosphere of paddy soil

Low-molecular-weight organic acids (LMWOAs) are essential components of rice roots exudates and an important source of soil organic carbon. The chemical-microbial pathway by which LMWOA affects arsenic (As) cycling in the rhizosphere of paddy soils is still unclear. In this study, three typical LMWOAs (acetic acid (AA), oxalic acid (OA), and citric acid (CA)) in rice root exudates were added to As-contaminated soil at a concentration of 10 mM, mimicking the rhizosphere environment. The results showed that the addition of AA and OA inhibited the mobilization of As in the rhizosphere soil. After 14 days of incubation, the content of As in the porewater of AA and OA decreased by 40% and 22%, respectively, compared with the control. AA hindered the mobilization of As in soil via promoting the formation of secondary minerals. The addition of OA inhibits the mobilization of As via increasing the proportion of As (V) in porewater and promoting the formation of secondary minerals in soil. In addition, OA addition not only significantly increased the aioA gene abundance but also notably enriched the microorganisms containing As (III) methylation functional genes (arsM). The addition of CA greatly expedited the release of As from the soil solid phase through the solubilization of Fe/Mn minerals via the effects of both soil chemistry and microbial action. Furthermore, linear discriminant analysis effect size (LEfSe) revealed the possibility that bacteria such as Burkholderia, Magnetospirillum, and Mycobacterium were involved in the reduction or methylation of As in the rhizosphere of paddy soil. This study revealed the internal causes of LMWOAs regulating As transformation and mobilization in flooded paddy soil and provided theoretical support for reducing As accumulation in rice by breeding rice varieties with high AA and OA secretions.

Methanogens-Driven Arsenic Methylation Preceding Formation of Methylated Thioarsenates in Sulfide-Rich Hot Springs

Hot springs represent a major source of arsenic release into the environment. Speciation is typically reported to be dominated by arsenite, arsenate, and inorganic thiolated arsenates. Much less is known about the relevance and formation of methylated thioarsenates, a group with species of high mobility and toxicity. In hot spring samples taken from the Tengchong volcanic region in China, methylated thioarsenates contributed up to 13% to total arsenic. Enrichment cultures were obtained from the corresponding sediment samples and incubated to assess their capability to convert arsenite into methylated thioarsenates over time and in the presence of different microbial inhibitors. In contrast to observations in other environmental systems (e.g., paddy soils), there was no solid evidence, supporting that the sulfate-reducing bacteria contributed to the arsenic methylation. Methanosarcina, the sole genus of methanogens detected in the enrichment cultures, as well as Methanosarcina thermophila TM-1, a pure strain within the genus, did methylate arsenic. We propose that methylated thioarsenates in a typical sulfide-rich hot spring environment like Tengchong form via a combination of biotic arsenic methylation driven by thermophilic methanogens and arsenic thiolation with either geogenic sulfide or sulfide produced by sulfate-reducing bacteria.

Synchronous response of arsenic methylation and methanogenesis in paddy soils with rice straw amendment

Rice straw (RS) amendment promotes arsenic (As) methylation and methane (CH₄) emissions from paddy soils, which can cause straighthead disease and climate warming. Although methanogens have been identified as critical regulators of methylated As concentrations in flooded soils, the mechanism of these microbial groups on As methylation in paddy soils with RS amendment remains unknown. In this study, paddy soil was incubated to test the response in As methylation and methanogenesis in flooded soil with RS amendment. Our results showed that RS amendment increased the accumulation of monomethylarsonic acid (MMA) and dimethylarsinic acid (DMA) whether methanogenesis was inhibited or not. The methanogens in the genera of Methanocella probably played critical role in promoting As methylation in flooded soil with RS amendment. With the RS amendment, inhibition of methanogenesis led to the accumulation MMA and DMA by suppressing DMA demethylation. The demethylation of DMA was driven by methanogens possibly belonging to the genera of Methanobacterium. This study revealed a wealth of methanogens that dominate As methylation with RS amendment. It will provide guidance to RS amendment in As contaminated paddy soil and has important implications for rice quality and global climate change.

Effects of organic sulfur and arsenite/dissolved organic matter ratios on arsenite complexation with dissolved organic matter

The speciation and fate of arsenic (As) in soil-water systems is a topic of great interest, in part due to growing awareness of As uptake into rice as an important human exposure pathway to As. Rice paddy and other wetland soils are rich in dissolved organic matter (DOM), leading to As/DOM ratios that are typically lower than those in groundwater aquifers or that have been used in many laboratory studies of As-DOM interactions. In this contribution, we evaluate arsenite (As(III)) binding to seven different DOM samples at As/DOM ratios relevant for wetland pore waters, and explore the chemical properties of the DOM samples associated with high levels of As(III)-DOM complexation. We integrate data from wet chemical analysis of DOM chemical properties, dialysis equilibrium experiments, and two-site ligand binding models to show that in some DOM samples, 15-60% of As(III) can be bound to DOM at environmentally-relevant As/DOM ratios of 0.0032-0.016 μmol As/mmol C. Binding decreases as the As(III)/DOM ratio increases. The organic sulfur (S_org) content of the DOM samples was strongly correlated with levels of As(III)-DOM complexation and "strong" binding site densities, consistent with theories that thiols are strong binding ligands for As(III) in natural organic matter. Finally, a whole-cell E. coli biosensor assay was used to show that DOM samples most effective at complexing As(III) also led to decreased microbial As(III) uptake at low As/DOC ratios. This work demonstrates that naturally-occurring variations in the S_org content of DOM has a significant impact on As(III) binding to DOM, and has implications for As(III) availability to microorganisms.

Time-Dependent Biosensor Fluorescence as a Measure of Bacterial Arsenic Uptake Kinetics and Its Inhibition by Dissolved Organic Matter

Microbe-mediated transformations of arsenic (As) often require As to be taken up into cells prior to enzymatic reaction. Despite the importance of these microbial reactions for As speciation and toxicity, understanding of how As bioavailability and uptake are regulated by aspects of extracellular water chemistry, notably dissolved organic matter (DOM), remains limited. Whole-cell biosensors utilizing fluorescent proteins are increasingly used for high-throughput quantification of the bioavailable fraction of As in water. Here, we present a mathematical framework for interpreting the time series of biosensor fluorescence as a measure of As uptake kinetics, which we used to evaluate the effects of different forms of DOM on uptake of trivalent arsenite. We found that thiol-containing organic compounds significantly inhibited uptake of arsenite into cells, possibly through the formation of aqueous complexes between arsenite and thiol ligands. While there was no evidence for competitive interactions between arsenite and low-molecular-weight neutral molecules (urea, glycine, and glyceraldehyde) for uptake through the aquaglyceroporin channel GlpF, which mediates transport of arsenite across cell membranes, there was evidence that labile DOM fractions may inhibit arsenite uptake through a catabolite repression-like mechanism. The observation of significant inhibition of arsenite uptake at DOM/As ratios commonly encountered in wetland pore waters suggests that DOM may be an important control on the microbial uptake of arsenite in the environment, with aspects of DOM quality playing an important role in the extent of inhibition. IMPORTANCE The speciation and toxicity of arsenic in environments like rice paddy soils and groundwater aquifers are controlled by microbe-mediated reactions. These reactions often require As to be taken up into cells prior to enzymatic reaction, but there is limited understanding of how microbial arsenic uptake is affected by variations in water chemistry. In this study, we explored the effect of dissolved organic matter (DOM) quantity and quality on microbial As uptake, with a focus on the role of thiol functional groups that are well known to form aqueous complexes with arsenic. We developed a quantitative framework for interpreting fluorescence time series from whole-cell biosensors and used this technique to evaluate effects of DOM on the rates of microbial arsenic uptake. We show that thiol-containing compounds significantly decrease rates of As uptake into microbial cells at environmentally relevant DOM/As ratios, revealing the importance of DOM quality in regulating arsenic uptake, and subsequent biotransformation, in the environment.

Microbial mediated reaction of dimethylarsinic acid in wetland water and sediments

The biogeochemical reactions of dimethylarsinic acid (DMAs(V)) were investigated using simulated wetland systems in a laboratory. DMAs(V) was injected into the wetland water, and the As concentrations in the water, plants, and sediments were monitored. Aqueous and solid-phase As speciation was evaluated, and the results revealed that the DMAs(V) was completely transported to the sediments and plants. X-ray absorption spectroscopic measurement of the As in the sediment revealed that approximately 85-95% of As existed as inorganic As species, demonstrating the important role of microorganisms in the biogeochemical reaction of DMAs(V). The influences of microbes were further investigated in smaller batches under aerobic and anaerobic conditions. The microbial batch results showed that DMAs(V) demethylation reduced the total aqueous As concentration, demonstrating that As(V) has higher affinity to wetland sediment than DMAs(V). The redox conditions were also revealed as an important controlling factor of the As reaction and, under anaerobic conditions, we observed the presence of the most toxic form of inorganic As(III) in the aqueous phase. Although this study reports one example from a specific wetland, the important roles of the redox conditions and microbial influences were identified from the comprehensive analysis of As speciation and mass balance.